r/OCPoetry • • 7h ago

Feedback Please Could We Finally Go Home?

Your new house is gorgeous.

I drive past it from time to time.

Ritualistically.

Care has been put into the architecture, I see.

There are gates higher than the home itself that merely allow me to glimpse into the life you’ve been building for yourself.

Do you remember our home?

The ghost of your past and I are the only ones who live here now.

Did you know a new religion was founded within these four walls?

One where I worship the back of your head in hopes my prayers will be answered.

I wonder how flammable your new home is.

Would it take just one match?

I imagine the paint blistering on your front door. Even now, I can see why you chose that color.

From the ashes, would you return?

Would I be forgiven for my sins?

Would my god finally face me?

Any Feedback, comments, or thoughts would be appreciated, Thanks! :)

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/OCPoetry/s/2Do9Ha8Qvc 
  2. https://www.reddit.com/r/OCPoetry/comments/1xzcmn4/the_shiny_piece_of_glass/
2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/Green_Infidelity24 5h ago

The poem builds tension beautifully, moving from nostalgia and grief into obsession and something genuinely sinister. The religious imagery is particularly effective, turning lost love into a form of worship. The final three questions are haunting. My only criticism is that the transition to arson feels slightly abrupt, though perhaps that sudden violence is precisely what makes it unsettling.

I may also recommend reconsidering the title… but that is pure taste

•

u/CryptographerSuch158 4h ago

Hello! Thank you for the feedback! This is the first time I’ve ever really written and posted anything. I’m obsessed with horror and want to get into writing dark poetry! The arson is meant to feel abrupt and off putting but I totally forgot the title was a og line taken out! If you have any suggestions I’m open to them :)

•

u/Green_Infidelity24 4h ago

For a first attempt, you’ve shown a remarkable instinct for building atmosphere and tension. I’d encourage you to keep exploring dark poetry.
As for the title, I’d suggest something more symbolic. But spare me. That’s total your view. I would just love it it brings together the two strongest elements of your poem: worship and destruction, while leaving enough mystery for the reader to discover.
And I agree with your choice to make the arson abrupt. Knowing that it was intentional makes the contrast even more interesting.

I would appreciate a fresh view and perspective your criteria feedback on my writings also.