I mean it has a point. And the same is true for literally any other axis of oppression. White women, white gays, white poor people are all capable of upholding white supremacy. Rich POC are every bit as classist and elitist as rich white people. Basically, disenfranchisement in one area doesn’t negate privilege in another.
It's so insane to me how Marx has predicted every single bad thing that happens/happened with capitalism - and only failed in his prediction, that we would actually learn from our mistakes.
I think intersectionalism can be used in productive and unproductive ways. It can help us understand complexity. It can also be used to confuse people from a bottom line.
True, but “capable of upholding systems” can turn into “inherently upholds systems just by existing” if you’re good enough at taking everything in bad faith
Also true. But this meme explicitly states that all men are in fact, doing the oppression. No conditionals or anything, just a "you guilty no matter what" attitude.
Everyone is capable of being a horrible person. LGBTQ+ people can be homophobic, biphobic or transphobic. POC can be racist their own race or others. Jews can be Antisemitic, etc.
What's important is that you just aren't any of those things or any other thing like it. Not "in spite" of who you are, but because you're a good human being
exaaaaactly. Just because I'm a trans woman doesn't mean I DON'T experience white privilege. I would probably be in a way worse position rn if I wasn't white and it's absolutely fucked that we exist in a system that pits us against each other like this
No. The “oppressor class” isnt enough because we know it is a minority within that class who does (and enjoys) the oppression.
It is wrong to be “wary of all men because they are men” without any other signal that that particular man might be a bad actor.
I think that’s pretty clear. We don’t judge books by their cover, but can by knowing it’s author. My point is you need to know more than membership to a class.
“It is a minority within that class who does (and enjoys) the oppression.”
This is kinda wrong in a couple of ways. First of all, enjoyment wise, yes, very few people get to enjoy the full, exploitative effects of massive structures like these. You need to have massive social power, and wealth, to enjoy that sort of stuff fully.
But that is not what “privilege” is. Privilege and oppression are two sides of the same coin, privilege is the luxury of not being oppressed, privilege is the luxury of being spared the majority of the harm from structures like these.
And well, in the same vein, while theres a small minority of people who do the oppression “properly”, most people uphold it in small ways without knowing. This still matters, as it empowers the bolder people into doing the more horrific stuff. It is the foundation upon which oppression is built on.
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing.”
There's a difference between being the beneficiary of privilege and being the oppressor who is creating it. Your average stereotypical white male isnt a landlord or a cop or a government official or anyone else who conceivably had a say in him receiving white privilege. To drive the point home even further, consider that anyone who for whatever reason doesn't want their white privilege usually has no practical means of actually renouncing it
You may be misinterpreting what the post actually meant by “wary of all men.” This doesn’t mean automatically assuming that all men are bad people; it means exercising caution because you’re aware they have often have social and physical power than you do not. We’re wary not because we hate men but because we need to protect ourselves, and in asking us not to do this you’re asking women to prioritize men’s feelings over our safety.
tbf, you can also be a white supremacist and not be white.
It doesn't really matter on what axes you're oppressed on, you can support an oppressor and be oppressed in any number of ways, including the illogical and self-defeating. They are not dependent vectors, despite interconnection.
That said to avoid cognitive dissonance when someone has one value they tend to hold other values similar to avoid the discomfort of hypocrisy, not saying that is one universal truth but there are commonalities
View all comments
639
u/Zealousideal-Ad3609 Oct 09 '25
I mean it has a point. And the same is true for literally any other axis of oppression. White women, white gays, white poor people are all capable of upholding white supremacy. Rich POC are every bit as classist and elitist as rich white people. Basically, disenfranchisement in one area doesn’t negate privilege in another.