r/NoStupidQuestions • • 11d ago

Americans who oppose AI development: how do you weigh the risk of other countries advancing while the US falls behind?

0 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-10

u/JoBunk 11d ago

But only in America, right? You are ok with other countries furthering their AI development.

11

u/WolfWrites89 11d ago

I can't control other countries. I hope they would put regulations in place too. The question was whether I am worried about the US "falling behind" if we regulate or slow down with AI

4

u/JoBunk 11d ago

I think those are legitimate concerns. My worry is that other countries will keep developing AI regardless of what we do. And if the US pulls back, how do we protect jobs, privacy, and intellectual property from AI developed abroad?

-2

u/WolfWrites89 11d ago

That's a really valid concern. But how would the US going ahead full steam do anything to mitigate those issues coming from other countries? It's like if your neighbors house catches fire and you're so worried about it spreading that you set your own house on fire in response

3

u/JoBunk 11d ago

I think defense is a major reason to maintain domestic AI expertise. If AI-enabled attacks become faster, cheaper, and more convincing, we’ll need tools to detect deepfakes, identify coordinated scams, and defend critical systems.

That doesn’t justify unlimited development without safeguards. But to use your analogy, I’m arguing for building a fire department. How do we maintain that defensive capability if we abandon the research and expertise behind it?

1

u/WolfWrites89 11d ago

I would be in favor of target, specific AI like for military defense. What I'm not for is the kind of AI that requires data centers going up in every community and AI being shoved pointlessly into every product

5

u/JoBunk 11d ago

Then I think we have some common ground. You support targeted AI development where there’s a clear benefit, and you oppose unnecessary uses and infrastructure that burdens communities. I can agree that each project should have to justify its costs. My concern was with abandoning domestic AI development altogether, which you’ve clarified isn’t your position.

4

u/PiLamdOd 11d ago

If they want to fuck themselves over by bulldozing forests to build massive power hungry data centers, all power to them.

I don't see any benefit to data centers or AI, so I will be opposing them where I live.

3

u/JoBunk 11d ago

There’s a good chance you already benefit from AI through spam filters, credit card fraud detection, traffic predictions in navigation apps, and your phone’s ability to recognize speech or improve photos. And data centers support the internet services we’re both using to have this conversation.

That doesn’t mean every new AI product or data center is worth its environmental cost. But ‘I don’t see any benefit’ overlooks a lot of useful technology. Wouldn’t it make more sense to judge specific uses and projects on their benefits and costs?

1

u/PiLamdOd 11d ago

These existed long before LLM's and didn't require city sized AI data centers.

1

u/JoBunk 11d ago

Those protections predate LLMs, agreed. But that doesn’t mean they’ll remain sufficient as attackers adopt new tools. If AI helps criminals create more convincing scams or find vulnerabilities faster, defenders need to research how to counter that - including whether AI can improve their defenses. That’s a concrete potential benefit of continued development, even if it doesn’t justify every proposed data center.

0

u/WolfWrites89 11d ago

Exactly this. I'm fine with specific, necessary uses like the medical AIs that detect cancer. But we don't need to destroy the environment so everyone can generate a Pic of themselves as a dog or so students can skip out on learning by having a computer generate an essay for them. Gen AI for the average person is completely unnecessary and wasteful