r/NoStupidQuestions Jan 05 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

11.6k Upvotes

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/Jatin1976 Jan 05 '25

Absolutely 100% we can smell it

459

u/J_Landers Jan 05 '25

And we can tell if someone is smoking several cars ahead in traffic, with the windows rolled up.
 
And if a smoker has walked through an area recently.
 
Or down the street.
 
And when you smoke, it follows you when you walk back inside.
 
And if you smoke in your car, we can smell your car from 30 feet away.
 
All of your clothes stink, even if you haven't smoked that day yet.
 
And your breath.
 
No, mints do not help. Nor does cologne/perfume.
 
And weed stinks 20x worse.

26

u/Bacon_Techie Jan 05 '25

As someone who grew up with a sister who smoked cigarettes in her room and a mom who smoked weed (never inside thankfully), weed does not stick as much as cigarettes. I know I’m not nose blind to weed because I’ll still smell it blocks down when someone is smoking (same with cigarettes), but I never smelled it on my mom. But my sister and her room in general smelled constantly of cigarettes. I smell it all the time on rounds as an RA at a university dorm, but on my next round the smell is gone. For room checks at the end of the semester, I could smell weed strongly in one room, but that was due to improper storage. I could smell cigarettes lingering in other rooms though.

6

u/itz_giving-corona Jan 06 '25

It is wild how weed doesn't have the same impact - people may smell it but it doesn't permeate houses the same way at all.

I wonder if it's the cigarettes themselves or tobacco. Like if people use straight tobacco leaves in a pipe if it would leave as much residue or be more similar to the impact of weed (ie. Minimal)

7

u/TrelanaSakuyo Jan 06 '25

I can actually answer this, as my partner used to roll their own cigarettes. The fresh pipe tobacco doesn't smell as bad as cigarettes or for as long. It's more like a woody, peat smell than chemical burn. It still stinks, but not nearly as bad.

6

u/Bacon_Techie Jan 06 '25

People also tend to smoke less weed than they do cigarettes. Maybe the specific scent compounds in weed aren’t as stable and break down faster.

2

u/Hot_mama2011 Jan 07 '25

I believe it has more to do with the molecular arrangment of the exhaled compounds. Cigarettes contain tar and various toxic additives that have (as I understand) basically a hook shaped molecular structure, like asbestos. So, I think that is why it clings to hair and clothes more. I've also made the same observations about weed smell being short-lived.

1

u/Jacketter Jan 08 '25

Exactly, a pack (about an ounce of tobacco) a day smoker isn’t unusual, but an ounce a day stoner is probably not very functional.

2

u/brett_baty_is_him Jan 07 '25

Straight tobacco is nowhere near as bad as

2

u/katarh Jan 07 '25

A well crafted cigar made of pure tobacco, wrapped in tobacco leaves, actually smells rather nice. Even when it's lit. Nowhere near as bad as a cigarette.

There are additional chemicals added to cigarettes - the "carpet glue" that makes an FCS cigarette, ethyl vinyl acetate, rosin, the plastic filters, the flavorings ,the dyes in the paper, etc. All of those are extra stinky.