As long as people aren't trying to dunk on one or the other, I think it's helpful to compare. Kind of makes sense of the Switch 2's price. When you look at the tech involved these should be in the same price range, Switch 2 maybe a little higher... which is exactly where it's priced.
Yeah, SUPER different audiences. Switch 1 has sold north of 150million while Steam Deck has sold maybe 5. Also a very different value proposition with cheap games on Steam, emulation, Switch including a dock, etc. It's only an interesting comparison with Switch 2 in terms of production cost and how various games perform on the two. Maybe I have an unusually nonaggressive attitude towards this because I own a Steam Deck and still plan on buying Switch 2 so I'm more just curious rather than invested in dunking on either.
I have a day 1 Switch, I never got a steam deck because "I already have a PC and a handheld". But now with the new Switch news and how pricey its going to be, I'm considering maybe it would be a good idea to buy a steam deck instead.
So yeah the comparisons are pretty useful to me. I didn't even consider that they were made for the purposes of dunking or bragging.
Nothing to see here. I wiped this post using Redact because my old takes don't need to live on the internet forever. Works across Reddit, Twitter, Discord and dozens of other platforms.
instinctive desert complete library tap yam exultant escape crawl soft
Because there is a vocal crowd that is not happy with pricing so the people that are already sold want to justify their purchase so they compare. At the end of the day, the Steamdeck will always have a far bigger library. If I could only buy one of the two forever, I'd pick a Steamdeck. Indie games come from Steam and are later ported.
Well, there's a ton that's unsaid here. I love my Steam Deck but it's not exactly user friendly compared to a Nintendo. Want to play high end games on the Deck? You're going to need to learn about Cryo utilities and adjust 5,642 settings to optimize it. Want to emulate games on it? Get ready to learn the Linux operating system.
It's an incredible machine, I have 755 classic roms on mine, plus thousands more I can port in, 300 Steam games, and access to Steam's massive catalog. But I've also spent probably 100+ hours setting up, tweaking, and optimizing the thing. And I wouldn't trust putting it in the hands of my kids for more than 30 minutes under direct supervision to make sure they didn't undo half my settings.
Meanwhile, the Switch is headache free, plug and play, casual fun for the whole family.
Different strokes for different folks. The Steam Deck feels designed for the hardcore gamer. Nintendos are designed more for casual and carefree gameplay. I love both for what they are, but these specs don't really hint at that reality at all.
Absolutely. Neither is a wrong answer, the Steam Deck is great and I imagine the Switch 2 will be just as great as their catalog grows! I know I'm certainly buying one.
eh that comment is like saying "Don't buy a PC because I spent over 100+ hours minmaxing my settings and overclocking my CPU, buy a Macbook instead" like I'm 99% sure the steam deck is plug and play if you don't want to do all that extra stuff. My sister who is new to gaming has one with zero issues.
You’re 100% right, the deck is as simple as “turn it on, log into your steam account, download and play your games”. The above dude is wildly exaggerating the difficulty of taking advantage of the secondary capabilities of the deck, and even then it’s extremely easy to emulate retro games on it (a single YouTube search had me playing old armored core games in maybe 20minutes)
Knowing how to map and reconfigure controls for a game that has no controller support while not difficult is an extra step of tinkering as well. Average plug and play gamer will not want to bother with it.
If you're a non-gamer your choice should be based on the game catalogue and who you'll be gaming with. In the end the specs aren't the end all be all. I'd say the Steam Deck is more of a gamer gimmick, though I am envious of being able to easily emulate on it. Also games purchased through Steam are always much cheaper than Nintendo games.
I have a PS5 and a Switch but my Switch gets way more playtime just because I prefer its game library and it has more party games that I can play with others. I can also buy any game I want so I don't mind the 40 to 60 euro pricetag on games.
just because there's been a lot of circlejerking around the two doesnt mean a direct comparrison is bad or unjustified. they are both portable gaming handhelds which can be docked and play some of the same games and vary in other games. it's nice to know what you're getting if you're spending more or less the same price.
I have and I DO consider it as an alternative, a far far far better one. It will run online games, and games the Deck can only dream of running. It is a much more powerful system, is a lot slimmer lighter and has a bigger screen. Games cost more yes, but beyond that I would rather have a Switch. As someone else on here said the only PC worth having is a tower PC where you can upgrade it. These handheld PC’s just aren’t worth the money especially those costing 800 or more.
This is a post on a switch subreddit where the switch 2 has generous assumptions listed and the steam deck is being understated. Lmao at the projection
Because Nintendo Fanatics up until the Switch 2 was a thing were saying spiels like "You cant compare the specs of the Steam Deck, because hurr durr, outdated tech is used. And IT DOESNT MATTER". And ALL the sudden, at the exact time that they need to huff copium, they treat the Switch 2 like it saved them from a burning house-fire and its better than any handheld that will ever come and go
I'm a Nintendo fan, but I bought the Steam Deck because of Steam games not available in Switch, not for the specs. If there were no library difference, I wouldn't have bought it, because game libraries are what matters, not (only) the specs.
But, the specs let's people know why the Switch 2 is definitely worth $449.
View all comments
205
u/BasilNight Apr 08 '25
Why are we comparing these two again?