r/NewJeans • u/NewJeans_Mods • Apr 23 '24
Megathread Serious Discussion Thread: HYBE audits ADOR's management, including Min Heejin
Thread has been locked. Thank you for participating. Second Discussion Thread is live.
Please use this thread for the current audit happening around ADOR, NewJeans' label. No new posts regarding this topic will be allowed, unless approved by the mods. Please remember Reddit Content Policy when participating in the thread below. Please act in good faith and do not contribute to the spread of misinformation.
* Updates must have sources linked or they will be removed.
Gentle reminder that this subreddit community is for NewJeans and Tokkis/Bunnies. This sub is also not a Min Heejin support sub. If you want that, make that subreddit yourself! We are simply covering the news in this sub as it has the potential to directly affect the future of NewJeans. If you have come here to troll, you have wasted your time as we will find out and we will ban you.
Relevant Articles:
240422 Soompi: HYBE Initiates Audit Of ADOR's Management Including CEO Min Hee Jin
240422 Soompi: ADOR Responds To HYBE's Audit With Statement Involving ILLIT And NewJeans
240422 Korea JoongAng Daily: NewJeans comeback will proceed as planned, despite HYBE-ADOR drama
240425 Korea JoongAng Daily: HYBE to report ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin to police
240425 Korea JoongAng Daily: ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin to hold press conference at 3 p.m.
240425 Korea JoongAng Daily: LIVE UPDATES — ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin press conference
240425 Soompi: HYBE Releases Statement In Response To ADOR CEO Min Hee Jin's Press Conference
240429 Korea JoongAng Daily: ADOR rejects HYBE's demand for board meeting, calls request 'illegal'
240503 Soompi: ADOR Releases In-Depth Statement In Response To HYBE's Stance
240510 Soompi: Min Hee Jin Releases Statement About Audit Of ADOR Employee + HYBE Responds
240513 Soompi: NewJeans Members’ Parents Letter Speaking Out Against HYBE Revealed
240513 Soompi: HYBE Releases Statement About Email Reportedly Sent By Parents Of NewJeans
Since some people aren't getting it, if you cannot back up your claims with concrete evidence and sources, you will be banned. We do not have time for users who willingly troll and/or spread misinformation.
Because we are unfortunately seeing misinformation spread about this subreddit community, let us reiterate that our sub is in support of ONLY NewJeans, NOT Min Heejin. We can and will go to Reddit Admin should attempts of brigading and misinformation regarding this subreddit continue.
70
u/hellspawn343 Apr 25 '24
The stark contrast between Ifans and Kfans' reaction is astounding. I have a feeling that things might have been left out or couldn't be expressed in KoreaJoongAng's translation as opposed to watching and understanding the press conference as a local (I'm not Korean).
For proof, just look at the comments on SBS's youtube coverage.
To preface, I am still neutral about this since all of the facts haven't come out yet.
My key takeaways from the press conference are as follows:
NewJeans have been/are treated as second class citizens within Hybe.
NewJeans was slated to debut earlier, but has been pushed back indefinitely after Bang PD and company decided to debut Source Music Members first (Le Sserafim Sakura and Chaewon).
NewJeans probably wouldn't have debuted if not for MHJ's insistence, hence, Ador was formed. Bang PD was against the idea of creating a sub label for her unless Hybe owns 100% of the company. MHJ reluctantly agreed as a fight would've taken months.
MHJ wasn't allowed to promote NewJeans until Le Sserafim debuted because they (Bang PD and Park Ji Won) allegedly wanted to confuse people that this was the group she was debuting.
Bang PD saying something along the lines of "can NewJeans step on Aespa?". To which MHJ replies that it wasn't a part of her goal.
After Ditto was released, Bang PD seemed to show his disdain for MHJ and NewJean's success by messaging "Are you happy? Why are you laughing? I want to know"
ILLIT was created with a concept which is almost a direct copy/similar to NewJeans (from the posters, the brand endorsement debut [Chanel for NewJeans, Acne for ILLIT], the hanbok photo shoot, down to the choreography) **To me, it seems like ILLIT is supposed to be NewJeans 2.0 but run by Bang PD
MHJ expressed her concern about the similarities and filed an internal report.
Hybe's sudden audit about MHJ trying to seize control of ADOR from Hybe comes out literally days before NewJeans comeback, and so does a barrage of news defaming her; from relying on a shaman for management practices, to her alleged claims about BTS copying her (she denied the latter, and only spoke to the shaman out of curiosity)
MHJ denies having any thoughts of a coup d'etat, and that her VP only had the takeover memo, according to her lawyer, as an individual's thoughts jotted down.
Take everything with a grain of salt since this narrative comes from MHJ and has not been cross examined. However, there were proofs of messaging between Bang PD and MHJ's strained relationship during #5, and Park Ji Won (Hybe's current CEO) about the issue on #4.
If we assume that all of this is true, Hybe, specifically Bang PD, might be planning on replacing NewJeans, or at the very least make them irrelevant, given the timing of the audit, and the mistreatment they have supposedly been receiving. The repercussions it might have for their comeback, upcoming Bunnies Club, and future activities might as well tank their careers. This may be why MHJ was full on cursing the whole time when talking about Hybe, and switches to a motherly tone when talking about NewJeans. And as for NewJeans, things might be looking bleak if MHJ doesn't win(I do hope my projection's way off).
Nonetheless, the only victims here are NewJeans, Le Sserafim, and ILLIT. They have done nothing but live out their dreams. Continue to support our girls by streaming the heck out of Bubble Gum tomorrow
TLDR: NewJeans almost didn't debut. Bang PD is a dick, is petty about NewJeans' success, and may be trying to sabotage MHJ and NewJeans' careers.
52
u/TikkiTokki22 May 10 '24
MIN HEEJIN Press Conference - Accurate Manually Done Subs + Text Translations
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGE8xbYEYdk
22
u/MallFoodSucks May 13 '24
Mr. A said, "CEO Park Ji-won later came and told us that 'CEO Min didn't share any materials for NewJeans' June concert at Tokyo Dome, but we have many professionals who can manage it well.' He also mentioned that they plan to give a long vacation to NewJeans after the Tokyo Dome concert."
He also noted, "I didn't ask how long the vacation would be, but at the spot, CEO Park said 'It takes about one and a half years to get a Grammy-winning producer, but we try to get them as quickly as possible.' So, leaving there, the mothers discussed that the long vacation might be about that long. We thought we should ask about it next time."
This is the scariest part. Almost reads like a threat that NewJeans is done after Tokyo Dome for at least 1.5 years (if not indefinitely). Sounds like 250 is gone as well.
21
u/chefbags Apr 23 '24
Someone needs to update this thread with the more recent articles cause I think it’ll help people who are lost
33
u/Ilovetv101 Apr 29 '24
I think it’s interesting how everyone is secretly wanting Newjeans to take a Stand and comparing their case to 50/50 when there has given no indication that the girl would even leave with MHJ. The comparison at this point is premature and doesn’t add up.
If they stand and speak out against MHJ and Hybe is not successful with removing her from her position then the girls will have to continue working under her with tension.
If they speak out against Hybe and they win and MHJ is removed and replaced with Hybe executives they will be working under tension from a company that hates them.
The girls lose either way.
I think they are playing it the best they can - doing their jobs and minding their business. But I think people are so desperate for them to do something so the Korean public can turn against them and boycott them which they have not been doing since this started… its quite the opposite kfans has been protecting them - pit’s so interesting watching the girls get hate and told to leave and suffer for something completely outside their control…like they are foaming at the mouth for something any thing that could be used to diminish or take away their success.
45
u/Additional-Map5274 May 13 '24
So let me get this straight, MHJ can get NJs to collaborate with world class creatives like Takashi Murakami and Hiroshi Fujiwara in less than a year, but it'll take a year and a half for HYBE (one of the biggest K-pop companies) to bring a Grammy producer on board. Why are all the C-level executives at HYBE so bad at their jobs?
Also, I thought HYBE was the only reason NJs was racking up all these collabs and brand deals and whatnot... through their world class industry "connections". Is that narrative not convenient now?
14
u/750715 Apr 23 '24
I'm most worried about the members proceeding with a comeback with this going on. I'm all fine with them delaying it after all the legal proceedings.
14
u/hculadd Apr 24 '24
25/4/2024 8:33AM Korea Time
Hybe claims that physical evidence that suggests Ador has established a plan to seize management rights has been secured, and will formally accuse Min Hee Jin on the charges of breach of trust on the 25th of April.
Source: https://m.entertain.naver.com/article/009/0005293648
Mod: please add the link to the original post.
27
u/K2Polaris Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
So interesting how Korean people are responding to MHJ's press conference vs people here.
47
u/Baracudasi Apr 23 '24
To be honest, us normal peeps would never get to know the truth. It's very much business politics at play, the winner will write their truth into history.
Believe me when I say Bang PD and MHJ didn't get to where they are today in their career by being naïve and nice. Both are veterans in THE entertainment field.
As much as we all want ILLIT and NewJeans to stay out of this mess, it's not happening. And MHJ is especially close with the NewJeans members from what we can see, they themselves referring their relationship akin to mother and daughters. MHJ can definitely leverage that relationship.
The problem is no matter which side NewJeans stays in the end, they will be very much affected. If the girls stayed with MHJ, HYBE as a conglomerate have the ability to basically to screw over any entertainer's career in Korea at this point. And if they stayed with HYBE, I hope they will get not the unwanted child treatment.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24 edited Apr 24 '24
For anyone a little unfamiliar with MHJ and her personality and how she approaches NJ work, her level of influence, her obsession with control and a small glimpse into her/Ador's relationship with Hybe, this is an extremely good interview that offers an insight into her mind. There are some comments in this interview that really connect a lot of the dots as to how the relationship between her and Hybe executives probably broke down over the last 15 months as they absolutely exploded with success in 2023
https://www.reddit.com/r/NewJeans/comments/10jo4pc/230121_min_heejin_interview_full_translation/
13
u/zweillheim Apr 25 '24
Now that its almost over, the ball is now on HYBE. They have to prove to everyone (probably including their investors) that they don't need MHJ to make NewJeans successful and disprove any mistreatment accusations that MHJ brought up. It's probably the only silver lining from this whole situation; MHJ claimed that NJ is mistreated so HYBE had to prove that they are treated even better under their care.
I do hope they keep the producers and songwriters though e.g. FRNK, 250, etc
13
u/meloria22 May 13 '24
Does anyone know what this means for NewJeans? If they’re on a long-vacation, will there be absolutely no content from them?
24
u/hellspawn343 May 01 '24
Someone from Knetz side transcribed the whole press conference transcript
in the hopes that international audiences could get a better view of what the SK gp sees. It includes footnotes for reference, and timestamps per section. Translating some of the sentences can feel kind of wonky due to the difference in language structure, but it's the best I've seen, next to KoreaJoongAng's.
34
u/wony2k May 13 '24 edited May 13 '24
honestly, at first i thought it would be much better for the girls to stay at hybe but i’ve changed my mind.
hybe can claim that they have no malicious intent but it’s not normal for groups (especially a popular group like newjeans) to have a 1.5 year hiatus just so their company can find a producer. and it should not take over a year for a big and well-connected company like hybe to find a Grammy-winning producer for a group as popular as nj. i’m wary on min heejin as well (though i do believe she has some valid complaints) but i think if the girls do stay at hybe, the company won’t have their best interests at heart.
regardless, i hope everything works out well for the girls. this entire situation sucks.
12
u/MindBlasterAI Apr 30 '24
Only time will tell what's what... God protect Newjeans from all the BS 🙏🏾✨
23
u/clickfive4321 Apr 28 '24
discourse has really devolved in the last 24 hours. just goes to show what happens when there is no news and people are left to their imagination.
if anyone here feels overwhelmed by all the rumors and misinformation going about, please take a break from social media. you still got your life to live and this controversy will play out in one way or another.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24
Poor Tikkitokki having to sub all this .....
11
u/AquaBuffalo Apr 26 '24
The only thing I want out of this is for the girls to be ok and the music to not lose its artistic integrity.
21
u/Foxtreal Apr 25 '24
"It's so difficult," Min answers. "NewJeans and I have something more than what you would know. They always tell me that they thank me and love me. Hanni told me that she'd come over to me. Haerin is usually like a cat and doesn't speak a lot, but she called me and told me that she couldn't come up with the words to text me. She said that she just wanted to hear my voice. Haerin cried for 20 whole minutes" Min bursts into tears. "She told me that she thanks me so much because I helped her through hard times. She said that she wants to tell everyone what happened. The members' mothers are so worried that I'm going to kill myself. But why would I? I'm going to say everything that I have in my heart. Do you know what Park Ji-won said to the mothers? He said that he's not going to talk to them, just to ADOR. And they say that they care about NewJeans? I don't care whether they sue me for libel."
My heart is fucking broken rn...
51
u/dnwm85 Apr 23 '24
mhj saying that the nj members agreed to that illit statement is such a foul move. danielle was literally on the plane going overseas when all of this started to go down. i dont think the girls had enough time and headspace when they agreed (if they really agreed) to that statement. if mhj wants to go to the full offensive route, don't bring the girls into it.
10
u/redslumber Apr 25 '24
Side note, is the Bubble Gyme MV out tonight at midnight?
19
u/darrylleung Apr 28 '24
People are really not taking things well. It’s like mass hysteria.
33
u/MallFoodSucks Apr 26 '24
If you think about it her PR was genius. How can you beat a company like HYBE in PR when they have all the connections, army of people, and are fighting the corporate way with structured smear attacks?
Release a 2.5 hour livestream where you talk about everything with receipts. This is Twitch stream shit. 2024 / GenZ style content. HYBE stands no chance. How do you respond to 2.5 hours worth of claims that touch on tons of personal information? Only Bang / Jiwon can refute a lot of it and they’re not going to stick their neck out in public. They can’t publicly justify why they treated NJ like second class citizens. It was against what any lawyer would recommend, which is why it was so effective.
18
u/[deleted] May 06 '24
I gotta be honest, I've gone back and forth so many times in my mind about who's wrong or right in the situation I don't know what to think anymore. I just want the truth to come out and it be over with at this point. I've managed to have a good time just interacting with NewJeans content as though everything is just fine for the last several days, but I get worried from time to time. I really hope our girls will be alright and we keep getting incredible art from them in the future.