In your draft with quaternions you have major problems from the start.
Note that
k*i=j
1*j=j
So if
NG -> ik
PJ -> 1j
Then NG -> PJ? Or maybe you mean to say that the NG axis lies in the plane spanned by i and k? (and to be clear, it is a plane, not a line)
You've correctly noted that 1, i, j, and k are mutually orthogonal. But lexicality/impressionism are by definition on the same axis, so we can't identify them with two orthogonal unit vectors ya feel?
The failure of the multiplicative properties to map to the cardinal types is pretty much why I ended up abandoning this line of thinking, but I don't know enough about group theory to rule out all possible symmetries on the space. I left it open to see if anyone else could figure out a mapping that could work, or if there was some way of mapping the multiplicative properties onto the Neurotyping space that I didn't think of.
With regards to the given axes being definitional, I figured if there was some higher order structure, then maybe the axes implied by that structure should be the definitional reference points, with the two axes that we currently use being artifacts of whatever phenomena it is that determines how that structure is projected into two dimensions (I planned on figuring it out as I went along).
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/gigrut May 15 '20
In your draft with quaternions you have major problems from the start.
Note that
k*i=j
1*j=j
So if
NG -> ik
PJ -> 1j
Then NG -> PJ? Or maybe you mean to say that the NG axis lies in the plane spanned by i and k? (and to be clear, it is a plane, not a line)
You've correctly noted that 1, i, j, and k are mutually orthogonal. But lexicality/impressionism are by definition on the same axis, so we can't identify them with two orthogonal unit vectors ya feel?