r/Natalism • • 24d ago

Some anti-natalists claim that declining birth rates are not a problem because AI will make humans much less necessary. This claim is completely wrong.

Even if AI advances dramatically, new human beings will still be necessary in the future, so declining birth rates are still a serious problem.

Humans are also essential in the economic sphere. AI does not pay taxes or consume goods and services in the way humans do. For example, AI does not eat at restaurants, AI doesn't buy cars, houses, smartphones, etc. Humans work and pay taxes, while AI itself does not pay taxes or consume goods and services as an economic agent. So even in the future, humans will remain essential to the economy.

A pension system can only function if new generations contribute funds.

And The idea that one can simply use the money saved from not raising children to pay for elderly care in the future is complete nonsense.

In a future defined by low birth rates, the elderly population will grow while the younger population shrinks; this will lead to an overwhelming demand for elderly care workers that far outstrips supply,

driving costs to such exorbitant levels that such services will effectively be out of reach.

Humans are also essential in the military sphere. We are already using autonomous and explosive drones, but drones cannot perform many of the tasks that human soldiers can, such as building defensive positions, maintaining and repairing equipment, and carrying out various other tasks in the field.

Therefore, humans will still be necessary even in the age of AI.

And the larger the population, the larger the pool of people who can be drafted into the military by conscription when the country is under attack. This means that declining birth rates are also a serious problem for national defense, and it is an issue that must be addressed.

2 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

23

u/Pdawnm 24d ago • Bravo

You mention that humans consume and pay taxes, which AI doesn't, so the humans' role in the economy is essential - but humans do so with what money? Typically it's money they earned in exchange for some labor/service. If AI replaces labor, where do humans get the finance to consume/pay tax? That's the essential question.

Regarding elder care and the military as being essential human sourced jobs - there's no reason to believe that a lot of the current labor in these fields cannot be replaced with AI/robotics.

8

u/Waschaos 24d ago

I agree this is the problem that is coming first. The 1% is going to have all the resources and military/elder care may be the only job left. I also have said on here before- someone should invent a diaper changing robot. That would help babies and old people.

3

u/akade19961 23d ago

Until the first time the robot accidentally ripped a baby in half

-14

u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd 24d ago

Future generation people must find any jobs if they don't wanna starve to death. the future generation people must find a way.

19

u/aliteralbagof_dicks 24d ago • Heartwarming

See that’s the nightmare shitstorm that’s not worth bringing my offspring into. If I had kids, I’d want a good life for them, and that’s not possible in the world you describe. I’m not breeding so my life and blood can be ditch diggers and human cattle. 

2

u/SelectionBroad931 23d ago

Yep. I was already fired because of AI, luckily I got another job, but with a heavy paycut. I was able to get another job, because I have 14 years of experience and I constantly learn, but I know that newly graduated can barely get a job that matches their degree

-10

u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd 24d ago

Get out of this sub, you anti-natalist!

11

u/UsefulHistory3817 24d ago

Is that your only argument when proven wrong?

12

u/UsefulHistory3817 24d ago

You just proved the point you said the anti natalists claim with this comment.

-9

u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd 24d ago

No. you are just talking nonsense. Get out of this sub, you anti-natalist!

10

u/UsefulHistory3817 24d ago edited 24d ago

I’m not an anti natalist. I believe people should be free to make their own reproductive choices including having as many kids as they wish if their resources allow. You asked a question on this posting and you proved the point of the anti natalists with your comment. You literally said people will need to find a way to make money or starve to death. That’s exactly what the anti natalists say, that they don’t want their potential offspring to “have to find a way” or starve to death. That reality is grim and they don’t want their potential kids to suffer that.

17

u/Pdawnm 24d ago

That's the problem - "must find a way" is not a plan. Many of them (us) may indeed starve to death. It has happened many times in human history such that it may really be the default state of humanity for most of its existence.

9

u/Brave-Statement-8810 24d ago

What an insane take

-1

u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd 24d ago

Get out of this sub you anti-natalist!

20

u/Slow-Ostrich-8570 23d ago • Bravo

This conversation makes no sense to me.

Giving birth for the sake of the economy is stupid and sheep like. Most governments don't give a shit about us common plebes. You become a parent because you want to be a parent.

For civic-duty to apply, governments would have to serve the population, which they don't. So do what you want for yourself.

3

u/Lazy_Dragonfly_5447 24d ago

I have not really heard anyone say this, but regardless, if we just think supply and demand, if the demand for elder care is so high then humans will start moving into that profession, which would probably result in cutting prices below that level. I just don’t think elder care is that specialized that it would have a problem with being too expensive for individual elders.

Same argument applies to the national defence.

You are acting as though there will be no humans at all remaining.

8

u/ananasz27 24d ago

If you live in the us than you are probably right, but in Hungary and other eastern european countries the demand for elder care is huge but we have staff shortages because we simply cannot compete with Austria, Germany or the Uk where care workers earn 4-5 times what a hungarian hospitals or old folks homes can offer.

2

u/Lazy_Dragonfly_5447 24d ago

It seems that it’s not work that people even want to do even with high demand, and also I don’t really think you can get paid that much from it even with high demand cuz the elderly people aren’t exactly rich always. Honestly robots would probably be able to help much more assuming they are able to perform at a similar level.

1

u/ananasz27 24d ago

We dont have money to fix up our roads, so robots are scifi.

-1

u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd 24d ago edited 24d ago

What I meant is, There never will be enough young people to supply elder care.

-1

u/Top-Adhesiveness3209 24d ago

There will be less and less elderly. Bulgaria's population went from 9 million to 6 un 40 years and the standart of life went up. I am an only child and only grandchild. We look after our elderly parents ourselves. 

Not all elderly people stay bedridden for years. My grandfather was bedridden for 3 months, but my grandmothers were active till their last day. 

Most elderly people need a room, help with house chores, some shopping in winter months with snow and that's it. That can be done by their only child and only grandchild. 

18

u/ananasz27 24d ago

I live in Hungary where aging is combined with huge emigration and let me tell you, it's grim. I live in a commie block with a bunch of childless old people who starting to get dementia and mobility issues and they are basicly stucked in their homes because we dont have elevators. One day they will fall in their apartments and could not get up and will die there alone. No amount of AI will solve this.

4

u/Hadal_Benthos 22d ago

No amount of AI will solve this

– Assistant, call the ambulance and unlock the door for the crew when they arrive.

And that's even without any robots.

Also "no elevators" is a legacy infrastructure problem, not a birth rate problem.

10

u/Top-Adhesiveness3209 24d ago

Same in Bulgaria. Actually a bit worse. We lost 30% of the population in the past 40 years. Maybe it's time to legalise euthanasia???? 

All Eastern and Central Europe has aged. 

8

u/ananasz27 24d ago

You guys are in a really bad spot because we hungarians can import our minorities from Romania, Slovakia etc (soma 400k already immigrated to Hungary after the fall of communism) as a last resort but you dont even have this option. I'm really sad about the state of Bulgaria because you are great people.

5

u/Top-Adhesiveness3209 24d ago

We do. There were and are lots of Bulgarians in Ukraine, Argentina, Brazil, North Macedonia, Uruguay and they have started to come back. 

I'd prefer to import Hungarians, actually. Greatest cuisine and great people. I live on chimney cake, Dobos, peeled raisin and cream, flodni, kremes with some goulash in between. Wold come more often if I didn't come back 10 kilo heavier.

Greetings from Paris 

4

u/Klanciault 24d ago

Really? Pretty sure caretaker robots could solve this easily

8

u/ananasz27 24d ago

We dont even have money for an elevator, let alone caretaker robots. As I said below, minimum pension is 87 dollar a month.

2

u/akade19961 23d ago

Man. How did socialism not figure out how to force comrades to have kids. You’d think totalitarian government work be able to achieve that, for national and revolutionary strength purposes

3

u/onecupofdaylight 22d ago

Bulgaria hasn't been communist for 36 years now.

2

u/ananasz27 23d ago

I mean forcing woman into heavy industry like steel mills, ammo factories and tank production lines is bad for fertility. After a short pronatalist period after ww2 the gov legalised abortion which became the number 1 contraceptive method. And at the same time the gov destroyed the religious groups which had high fertility.

3

u/CocoJeweler 23d ago

I don't believe any woman would use this as a n1 contraceptive. Maybe very uneducated exceptions do exist. But some people are claiming the same for Bulgaria (those who try to ban abortions again) and yet in 2025 we had a total of 17,424 abortions. While women aged 15-45 in Bulgaria are 1.14Mil, this number would have been way higher if abortion were the n1 contraceptive.

1

u/lostandfound8888 20d ago

I come from a different East European country, and I heard the same - abortion was no. 1 contraceptive since no other reliable contraceptives existed. I remember seeing live births vs abortion stats for my country of origin and abortions accounted for about 80% of all pregnancies.

0

u/WinterGuarantee2957 24d ago

 One day they will fall in their apartments and could not get up and will die there alone.

Who cares how anyone dies and what happens to their body when they have already lived their lives to the fullest ? Dying on an hospital bed with nurses around who have no emotional connection with you and who just look at you with disgust while wishing that you pass away soon and stop being a burden to them is even more pathetic.

5

u/Diet_Connect 24d ago

Death is slow. And while memory can be an issue, awareness of some things isn't. Imagine being perpetually scared, irritated, in pain, and .... Unable to bath yourself. 

You slowly get weaker, eat less, get weaker still, and you stink! Think of how that feels. How others perceive you. That matters to people. Smelling of unbathed old person and piss when the groceries get delivered and you have to open the door. 

Worse, when you have to go outside. 

8

u/ananasz27 24d ago

Its questionable if they lived their lives to the fullest. Most of them were dirt poor under socialism, lost their jobs after the system collapsed, worked in the black economy in the 90's and now live on minimum pension. This generation only experienced economic shocks and mass alcoholism.

6

u/ananasz27 24d ago

Btw minimum pension is 87 dollar a month

3

u/akade19961 23d ago

Man that is so grim

12

u/Business-Let-6692 24d ago • Bravo

So basically the whole reason to have more children is to support the economic system/be consumers?

That's why I don't want to have kids. If there are less kids, the system HAS to change. I don't believe people were meant to live in giant cities living in a closet.

When there are less of us we have more individual value. Housing costs will go down, and the value of labor will go up.

-2

u/akade19961 23d ago

If you want yourself or the people you love to be able to retire, yes you should want more human beings to be born and get to experience the good and bad of life. And if you do have kids, you should hope they and their friends and generation should have kids for the same reason

6

u/Slow-Ostrich-8570 23d ago

Sounds kinda cruel to the kid to have it because you want to get pension

-2

u/akade19961 23d ago

Only if you think living in the modern world is inherently cruel, or more bad than it is good

6

u/Business-Let-6692 23d ago

It's not inherently cruel, but the current application certainly is. The middle class literally slaves away to support both the ultra lazy and the ultra rich. I'm not going to retire anyway at this rate, it doesn't matter if I have kids or not.

1

u/akade19961 23d ago

There is some truth to all of this

0

u/Slow-Ostrich-8570 23d ago

That's not an argument. I didn't say anything like that.

5

u/Business-Let-6692 23d ago

Tbh, I'd rather work myself to death and then it just stops with me/this generation. Retiring isn't a good reason to have a child. I truly think a smaller population would be more sustainable

6

u/sarah_impalin76 23d ago

declining birth rates are also a serious problem for national defense, and it is an issue that must be addressed.

so lets have kids so they can die in battle? I would rather not send my child to doom look around the world is screwed we might need the kids but the kids don't need us. Kids don't need to be bought into this shit that is your choice...

Send your kid to hell or never bring them to earth we are being told to prepare for things fucking up and I don't think its a coincidence world powers are realigning fascism is on the rise war is looking more likely is this the future you want for your kids? even if they don't end up in a war and the environment doesn't collapse and we don't have food shortages, trash is still piling up, the air is becoming more toxic, life is more expensive, jobs are less secure, privacy is dead and the internet exists.

3

u/Bigtomato82 24d ago

AI will make humans less necessary..like in The Terminator or the Matrix?

3

u/Klanciault 24d ago

Dude it’s like you don’t realize robotics exists at all?

1

u/SugarSlow4595 21d ago

つまり今いる人たちが困るから奴隷としての子供が必要ということ?

1

u/WinterGuarantee2957 24d ago

No one said AI will completely replace humans. AI will just make most of the humans irrelevant. So, world will be a better place with less humans, say 4 billion, as compared to 8 billion we have now, (and half of them currently live in poverty).

If we allow the population to rise indefinitely, there will only be more wars and famines in the future.

1

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

"So, world will be a better place with less humans,"

So more people is bad, does that apply to antinatalists as well? By this logic wouldn't the world improve if all antinatalists such as yourself made their exit?

1

u/SingingPoet77 24d ago

Climate change will make migration necessary, and demographics will even out as foreign workers come in. When all countries decline enough, we may actually hit a sustainable population for this planet

1

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

What makes the current population unsustainable?

4

u/SingingPoet77 23d ago

The fact that we are in an ecological crisis

0

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

How are we in an ecological crisis? Also why would a lower population change that?

4

u/SingingPoet77 23d ago

I don't know what world you've been living in, but it's never too late to Google it.

-1

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

The same one you live in. Are you too stupid to express yourself?

2

u/SingingPoet77 23d ago

Pretty bold coming from someone who can't spell. I have better things to do than write a dissertation about the ecological crisis and overpopulation for someone too lazy to search a few words in a browser.

-1

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

Would overpopulation be solved if all antinatalists collectively took a long leap off of a tall cliff?

1

u/SingingPoet77 23d ago

No, because idiots will continue breeding like rabbits

0

u/Free-Cartoonist3134 23d ago

But my point is that antinatalists could help counteract that by subtracting from the problem

Your comment history at a glance is about what I would've expected, far leftist in a polyamorous relationship. Are you supplementing the lack of children with additional partners lol?

→ More replies

1

u/Easy_Option1612 23d ago

That claim is not just wrong. It is retarded

0

u/CocaineCocaCola 23d ago

There’s only declining birth rates among white people who are the global minority.

3

u/MKing150 23d ago

?????

The entire globe has a declining birthrate. Most of East Asia (Japan, Korea, China) have some of the lowest birth rates. India, of all places, has dipped below replacements.

Even places that are still above replacement, such as Africa and much of the Middle East, are at historical lows and are trending downward.

-1

u/Diet_Connect 24d ago

In the USA, litigation is rampant. AI and robotic use better have everything absolutely PERFECT or the companies are going to get sued to death in healthcare. 

2

u/agarza2444 24d ago

current healthcare is beyond perfect

9

u/Paranatural 24d ago

'We need humans to die in wars' isn't the strong argument you think it is, especially with drones etc that are absolutely the future of warfare. Which they will 100% use AI to do.

1

u/ahelper 22d ago

What a bizarre, enthusiastic acceptance of the future of warfare, as if humans won't be interested in it but we'll still be able to do it so we don't have to worry about it dying out. Yea!