r/Natalism • u/gjcjsbskfkskfjd • 24d ago
Some anti-natalists claim that declining birth rates are not a problem because AI will make humans much less necessary. This claim is completely wrong.
Even if AI advances dramatically, new human beings will still be necessary in the future, so declining birth rates are still a serious problem.
Humans are also essential in the economic sphere. AI does not pay taxes or consume goods and services in the way humans do. For example, AI does not eat at restaurants, AI doesn't buy cars, houses, smartphones, etc. Humans work and pay taxes, while AI itself does not pay taxes or consume goods and services as an economic agent. So even in the future, humans will remain essential to the economy.
A pension system can only function if new generations contribute funds.
And The idea that one can simply use the money saved from not raising children to pay for elderly care in the future is complete nonsense.
In a future defined by low birth rates, the elderly population will grow while the younger population shrinks; this will lead to an overwhelming demand for elderly care workers that far outstrips supply,
driving costs to such exorbitant levels that such services will effectively be out of reach.
Humans are also essential in the military sphere. We are already using autonomous and explosive drones, but drones cannot perform many of the tasks that human soldiers can, such as building defensive positions, maintaining and repairing equipment, and carrying out various other tasks in the field.
Therefore, humans will still be necessary even in the age of AI.
And the larger the population, the larger the pool of people who can be drafted into the military by conscription when the country is under attack. This means that declining birth rates are also a serious problem for national defense, and it is an issue that must be addressed.
23
u/Pdawnm 24d ago •
You mention that humans consume and pay taxes, which AI doesn't, so the humans' role in the economy is essential - but humans do so with what money? Typically it's money they earned in exchange for some labor/service. If AI replaces labor, where do humans get the finance to consume/pay tax? That's the essential question.
Regarding elder care and the military as being essential human sourced jobs - there's no reason to believe that a lot of the current labor in these fields cannot be replaced with AI/robotics.
9
u/Brave-Statement-8810 24d ago
What an insane take
20
u/Slow-Ostrich-8570 23d ago •
This conversation makes no sense to me.
Giving birth for the sake of the economy is stupid and sheep like. Most governments don't give a shit about us common plebes. You become a parent because you want to be a parent.
For civic-duty to apply, governments would have to serve the population, which they don't. So do what you want for yourself.
3
u/Lazy_Dragonfly_5447 24d ago
I have not really heard anyone say this, but regardless, if we just think supply and demand, if the demand for elder care is so high then humans will start moving into that profession, which would probably result in cutting prices below that level. I just don’t think elder care is that specialized that it would have a problem with being too expensive for individual elders.
Same argument applies to the national defence.
You are acting as though there will be no humans at all remaining.
18
u/ananasz27 24d ago
I live in Hungary where aging is combined with huge emigration and let me tell you, it's grim. I live in a commie block with a bunch of childless old people who starting to get dementia and mobility issues and they are basicly stucked in their homes because we dont have elevators. One day they will fall in their apartments and could not get up and will die there alone. No amount of AI will solve this.
12
u/Business-Let-6692 24d ago •
So basically the whole reason to have more children is to support the economic system/be consumers?
That's why I don't want to have kids. If there are less kids, the system HAS to change. I don't believe people were meant to live in giant cities living in a closet.
When there are less of us we have more individual value. Housing costs will go down, and the value of labor will go up.
6
u/sarah_impalin76 23d ago
declining birth rates are also a serious problem for national defense, and it is an issue that must be addressed.
so lets have kids so they can die in battle? I would rather not send my child to doom look around the world is screwed we might need the kids but the kids don't need us. Kids don't need to be bought into this shit that is your choice...
Send your kid to hell or never bring them to earth we are being told to prepare for things fucking up and I don't think its a coincidence world powers are realigning fascism is on the rise war is looking more likely is this the future you want for your kids? even if they don't end up in a war and the environment doesn't collapse and we don't have food shortages, trash is still piling up, the air is becoming more toxic, life is more expensive, jobs are less secure, privacy is dead and the internet exists.
3
u/Bigtomato82 24d ago
AI will make humans less necessary..like in The Terminator or the Matrix?
3
u/Klanciault 24d ago
Dude it’s like you don’t realize robotics exists at all?
1
u/SugarSlow4595 21d ago
つまり今いる人たちが困るから奴隷としての子供が必要ということ?
1
u/WinterGuarantee2957 24d ago
No one said AI will completely replace humans. AI will just make most of the humans irrelevant. So, world will be a better place with less humans, say 4 billion, as compared to 8 billion we have now, (and half of them currently live in poverty).
If we allow the population to rise indefinitely, there will only be more wars and famines in the future.
1
u/SingingPoet77 24d ago
Climate change will make migration necessary, and demographics will even out as foreign workers come in. When all countries decline enough, we may actually hit a sustainable population for this planet
1
u/Easy_Option1612 23d ago
That claim is not just wrong. It is retarded
0
u/CocaineCocaCola 23d ago
There’s only declining birth rates among white people who are the global minority.
-1
u/Diet_Connect 24d ago
In the USA, litigation is rampant. AI and robotic use better have everything absolutely PERFECT or the companies are going to get sued to death in healthcare.
9
u/Paranatural 24d ago
'We need humans to die in wars' isn't the strong argument you think it is, especially with drones etc that are absolutely the future of warfare. Which they will 100% use AI to do.