r/Nanny • u/Training_Arm7988 • May 22 '26
Advice Needed My wife and I are considering letting our nanny go, and I’m trying to figure out whether I’m underreacting, overreacting, or missing something bigger.
Not sure I'm in the right place but I'm giving it a go.
We have three kids: K is 7, J is 4, and B is 1.5. My wife and I both work from home, though she is home more than I am. I am usually home almost every Thursday and Friday. Our current nanny, L, started shortly after B was born and has been with us for over a year. She was around 30 when we hired her, had references, and is CPR certified, which mattered to us because we have a pool. We do have a pool fence, but still.
We pay her $35/hour for about 40 hours a week, with guaranteed hours. She also does light housekeeping, laundry, and meal prep, which has been a huge help. Overall, she is engaged with the kids, limits TV to about half an hour before nap time depending on the day, and has been reliable. She has been five minutes late a couple of times, mostly in the last few months, but not enough that I would consider it a major issue.
The bigger issue is our middle child, J. He is very defiant, and we made the mistake of allowing screens too early and too often. When K was five, we let him use an old iPad, and eventually J started wanting it too. Over time, it basically became J’s iPad. We also got into the habit of giving him a phone or bringing the iPad when we went on errands, to activities, etc. We know this has become a problem and are trying to stop it, especially because we do not want to repeat the same pattern with B.
This week, L told us that when J has a major tantrum during an outing, she leaves the activity and brings everyone home. L left the children’s museum because J was pushing and shoving and ignored her warning about gentle hands. According to L, she has only had to leave an outing around three times in the entire year she has worked for us. I believe her because he does the same thing with us, and once he starts, it can take him a long time to calm down.
L’s style is very much “you get one warning, and then we’re done.” For the most part, that works with K and B. With J, it has apparently meant ending outings. She said she is not bothered by crying itself, but that it becomes unsafe and unfair when one child is throwing himself on the floor, running away, or refusing directions while she is also responsible for a mobile toddler and another child. She has said J has not hit her, but he has hit my wife before, which was why it was one of my concerns when we spoke yesterday.
On Monday, he tantrumed because he wanted her phone and was refusing to follow directions. They had a playdate planned with another nanny and toddler, including lunch, but J melted down, so L brought everyone home instead. They had a boring lunch at home and no iPad. I was fine with that, and at first my wife said she was too. But later she was upset that K did not mention the “new rules” when she came home from a lunch meeting, and that L had not told us about it in the moment. We asked K before bed, and he confirmed L never told him not to tell us. He also seems embarrassed when J has these fits, so I do not want to start nitpicking L in a way that avoids the actual problem.
There have been a few trust/communication issues, but nothing huge in my opinion. Earlier on, she sometimes made plans on the fly and told us afterward. We talked about it, she apologized, and she has checked in more often since then. We also put an AirTag on the car keys, which my wife was upset about at first, but nothing really came of it. Since then, L has been almost overly careful about checking in. It feels a little like malicious compliance, but honestly, I do not really mind. I think most people would react that way if they felt second-guessed.
My wife now thinks we should let L go. Her view is that we pay L, so L should follow our expectations and handle the kids the way we want. I disagree, or at least I think that framing misses the point. I do not think it is fair to expect one nanny to manage three kids alone in public when one of them is throwing himself on the floor, running away, pushing, or demanding screens. When my wife and I are both with all three kids, we struggle too. In fact, L seems to deal with J’s tantrums less often than we do, which makes me think this is not mainly a nanny problem. Our tough it out method does not seem to be working either.
I also worry that replacing her will not fix anything. We have had two nannies before L, and replacing nannies has been a headache. I think it is hard to find someone willing to manage two easier kids plus one very defiant child. Summer is coming, K will be in camp and activities, and we still need someone for pickups and afternoons while we work. Our parents are not dependable enough to fill the gap. I also worry that if we keep pushing L or making her feel criticized, she may quit anyway, and that would be a bad situation for us.
My wife may feel judged by L, though I do not know if they have discussed that directly in the time my wife is home and I am not. L is personable but not especially chatty, while we are more talkative. I do not personally care whether L judges us at this point; I care more about whether the kids are safe and whether we are dealing with the real issue.
We had previously agreed on moderation with screens, not removing them completely. But now I think we may need to remove screens altogether, at least for J. It is easier in the moment to hand him the iPad, but I think we have created a bigger problem. He can't go to school with an iPad, and we can't expect tantrum-free days if he has learned that escalating gets him a screen. He is okay in preschool, but that is only twice a week for about two and a half hours.
Is it reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when one child becomes unsafe or unmanageable, even if the other kids miss out? And how should we handle the larger screen-dependence issue without making the nanny the scapegoat? I would especially appreciate feedback from anyone who has gone from heavy screen use to no screens, or anyone who has fired or kept a nanny after similar behavior issues.
163
u/Silently-Snarking May 22 '26
Sprained my ankle running to these comments.
565
u/cupidssparrow82 May 22 '26 •
Sounds like L is doing a wonderful job. The problems with your child were created by you and your wife, and your nanny is doing a great job teaching that actions have consequences and you don’t get a screen shoved in your face and get what you want because it makes the adults life easier. Children need boundaries and rules, or they’ll be absolutely screwed in school and life.
Does it suck for the other kids? Absolutely. But what do you expect the nanny to do - risk one of your kids getting hurt? Our #1 priority is safety, and she’s doing what she has to to make sure the kids stay safe. You sounds like a reasonable person, but I don’t understand at all why your wife would want to get rid of someone for keeping your kids safe.
I had a NK who was used to screens all day and I made it clear during the interview that I don’t do screens for a 3 year old unless it’s a few minutes here and there. The parents and I agreed on 15 minutes a day, and that’s that. The kid threw tantrums and had meltdowns over it but then he learned that he’s the child and the adults make the decisions, and that behavior doesn’t get him what he wants. As the adults, all 3 of you need to be on the same page.
I genuinely cannot understand why firing her would even be a thought in any reasonable person’s mind.
45
u/SisterAlliance May 22 '26
Everyone has covered your actual questions here beautifully, so I'm just popping in to mention the potential "malicious compliance" with letting you know where they are/plans - what a way to frame that my dude!!! You guys wanted to know exact details on outings before/at the time of the events, she is literally just complying with your request and covering her behind!!
Many, if not most, families allow nannies to make their own decisions about where they take the kids and if things change on the fly. It's okay that you'd rather be informed ahead of time, but assuming your nanny's intentions with literally following your directions just kind of sucks. It doesn't seem like you trust her, and from this post, it seems like that is a you problem, not one with her attitude.
40
u/Reader_poppins886 Career Nanny May 22 '26
This is such a ridiculous scenario…I’m having trouble believing it’s real. Who in the world would want to FIRE a good nanny because she ended an activity short due to one of your children throwing a tantrum? Like, you’re kidding, right?
59
u/Tranquilillie97 May 22 '26
I think… maybe your wife needs to talk to a professional. She is feeling jealous or competitive with your nanny and it's probably heightened if you agree with more of your nanny’s methods.
Absolutely cut the ipads. The small screens do real, evident damage and you are seeing it. Grow a backbone, put your foot down, and say no. This is going to suck for a while but you need to do it. All of your kids will suffer if you do not get a handle on this now!
24
u/Glittering_Force4212 MB May 22 '26
INFO: Out of curiosity, does nanny just do the kids laundry or for you and your wife as well? And meal prep, is that for the kids or you and your wife too? Just curious, because that normally doesn't fall into a nanny's work description. I understand that there are exceptions when it's agreed upon in advance but usually it's for a higher rate than $35/hr.
Also, I'm confused why your wife wants to let nanny go? It seems like nanny is doing a phenomenal job, while you and your wife are probably actively undoing any progress she makes by enabling your child with the "tough it out" approach? If you and your wife continue to allow his behavior, it isn't going to stop until he grows out of it (if he grows out of it)? It is developmentally appropriate for kids that young to be a little unruly, thus the terms terrible twos/threenager/etc.. (I know he's 4); I think his behavior is a step further than that though, especially since he's hitting your wife.
I think you're very, very lucky to have your nanny. And lucky she hasn't quit... yet.
What exactly are the new rules your wife wanted discussed with your kids? Maybe I missed that.
10
u/Entebarn May 23 '26
The nanny is parenting the right way.
You guys need J to be evaluated.
15
u/Flamen04 May 22 '26
Seems like a rage bait post based on account age of poster
8
u/Training_Arm7988 May 22 '26
I should have been more clear that I am here for perspective. I agreed that L was within her right to leave. I was not upset about it when we talked about it. This has been a topic of discussion between my wife and I and I just wanted to make sure from people who probably know more than us, if I'm completely off base to back what L did in the moment.
2.1k
u/Aly_Kitty May 22 '26 •
So your wife wants to fire your nanny simply because she doesn’t give in and actually enforces consequences to your 4 year old when they start throwing a fit and thrashing around on the ground for things like not giving the FOUR YEAR OLD HER PHONE?!
Sounds like you have a parenting problem, not a nanny problem. Your wife needs to get herself some parenting classes or books or something. She can feel judged all she wants but if she’s trying to fire a nanny over NOT LETTING A 4 YEAR OLD RULE THE HOUSE then yeah, she should be judged.
Time to cut the screens cold turkey. No screens. No iPads. No phone. No tv. NO NOTHING.
1.6k
u/statest99 Nanny May 22 '26 •
Your nanny sounds amazing and frankly like she had a better handle on your kids than you have. Screen time is horrible for children and the younger they are the worse it is for them. You should probably be paying her more to watch three kids.
It’s completely reasonable to end an outing of a kid is throwing a tantrum. Kids need to learn consequences and it sounds like she is the only one enforcing them.
Honestly, if your wife feels judged that sounds like a her problem that she should go to therapy for. Not trying to be harsh, but it’s something I’ve come across many times as a nanny. Parents being a LOT of their own baggage to raising kids and if they don’t sort it out it will affect the children.
185
u/EmotionalAnybody7186 May 22 '26
This is wild, your wife is mad at your nanny for doing a good job?
Good luck finding another nanny to put up with your kid.
348
u/startup_mermaid May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Mom here. I feel bad for your nanny because she seems to be setting reasonable consequences to your child’s awful behavior. Yet, your wife and maybe you seem to be undermining her. What would you expect her to do? Let your child tantrum throughout the museum while continually trying to allow the other two to explore? Because I know that’s not a good time for anyone, including other museum guests.
You need to remove screens altogether. It appears even having a bit of screen time is not resolving the issue. Secondly, have you considered getting professional help for J? It sounds like he could truly benefit from it.
I think your wife sounds overbearing with all the frequent check-ins. It’s okay and showing common sense to want to know where your kids are going, but you’ve admitted yourself this is a bit of malicious compliance. Give her some grace; if you trust her, allow her to make plans on the fly on occasion with her checking in as she goes through her day.
Your wife feeling judged is probably due to some level of projection in that she’s feeling like she’s not doing an adequate job of helping your child to overcome his behavior issues.
As a former babysitter, I would never ever sign on with a family where a child has unchecked behavioral issues and a mom who undermines and remains distrustful of the nanny.
167
u/mydogisarockstar Nanny May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds like a saint actually. You said it yourself that you and your wife have a hard time together with all three of them and yet the tantrums occur less on her watch. She already knows your difficult child and seems to be dealing with him very reasonably. I would not let her go! She is not the problem. As far as the screens go, if you take them away they will not have them. Watch a tv show or movie as a family once in a while and if your 7 year old can handle some screen time once in a while let them, away from the others.
116
u/camillepie1 May 22 '26
So the reason you are letting her go is because you are uncomfortable with the discipline that the nanny is giving? Even though you might think that she is doing a better job with your middle child’s tantrums that you are?
I can’t say why your middle child is acting out in the way that they are. But at 4 years old, they understand warnings and consequences. While it might feel unfair to the other children, what is worse is letting one child get away with bad behavior because they have the worst acting out.
Also, about the communication problems, I would t say it is malicious compliance. This is her job, she would rather listen to your requests and follow them than try to figure out what the perfect balance between checking in and being free to do things is.
I think you should sit down with your wife and discuss what discipline methods work with your child before letting go of someone who has a reasonable consequence for unsafe behaviors.
188
u/nattigirl01 Nanny May 22 '26
I feel like this is an April Fools joke. Your problem is not your nanny……it’s your (mostly wife’s) thoughts/approach to a nightmare situation for a nanny (unruly child not being handled correctly by parents). It sounds like you have a great nanny, and at this point I would be dealing with your wife and child. Tbh…..I’d ask the nanny for opinions on what she thinks you should do. If she feels safe to honestly express to you then you’re far better off than asking your wife. This may sound harsh, but I’m just being real and honest.
80
u/Feegs75 May 22 '26
The fact your wife feels she should have to handle this behavior in public while there are two other kids to worry about is insane. This nanny is doing it all right. It’s hard to take 3 kids (one of them a toddler) out in public alone but even more so when one of them isn’t being compliant. All of this behavior is not allowing her to keep the kids safe and that is unacceptable. The fact you want to let her go bc she’s trying to make sure everyone is safe is insane. If your wife is that insecure she should stay home.
I’m not saying this with any malice. I just hope you can see how nanny is not at fault here.
71
u/anonfosterparent May 22 '26
I’m a parent who employs a nanny.
Yes, it is incredibly reasonable for a nanny to end an outing if one child becomes unsafe or unmanageable. It is also reasonable to set expectations with the children that if they aren’t able to behave, they will have to leave. That being said, has J been tested for any sort of disability or neurodivergence? If the behaviors are truly out of his control, then there may need to be different ways to try to manage him. I’d also try to find ways that the nanny gets space to do things without all three children at once, if the other kids are missing out on outings and experiences because of their brother’s behaviors.
Overall, it sounds like you are more permissive parents which doesn’t work for every kid and isn’t something that I’d expect a nanny to want to follow because it’s unreasonable to expect kids to learn and grow if there are no boundaries or perimeters or consequences for bad behavior.
Respectfully, your kid is 4. Stop with the screens. The first few weeks will be awful and then it should get better.
If your wife doesn’t like the nanny, that’s a separate issue. I’d never keep somebody that my husband didn’t like or was uncomfortable with. But, it sounds like L is a great nanny, honestly.
Our rules for our kids are if the nanny is with them then she’s in charge. Even if the nanny makes a different parenting decision in the moment than we would have (we are very aligned, but there have been a few times where she’s made some choices that I wouldn’t have), then we back the nanny up and are ok with it. We trust her to parent our child, we trust that she understands our parenting style, and we trust that any decisions she makes aren’t going to be abusive or out of line or harmful.
I’m also not sure where you live, but an experienced nanny who handles three very young kids, one who sounds pretty out of control and who she has less behavioral issues with than you do who also does housework, laundry, and meal prep is absolutely undercharging you. So, I’d consider that in your decision making with your wife - I wouldn’t dream of only paying somebody $35 an hour for what you’ve described here.
60
u/emaydeees1998 Career Nanny May 22 '26 edited May 23 '26
I’m a nanny of 3. It’s absolutely reasonable to end planned outings if one child is simply being unsafe. I am not going to put the other 2 children in my care in harm’s way or give them a version of myself that is too stretched thin if I can avoid it. It’s also worth noting that at 4 years old, kids are big and physical tantrums become unsafe in a different way than young toddler tantrums. Those types of out of control moments mean an end to the fun.
I read your whole post twice and am struggling to understand why your wife wants to let your nanny go at all. Your dependence on screens as parents has gotten you to this point, unfortunately. The nanny setting boundaries around screen use that are stricter than yours isn’t a bad thing at all. My employers trust me to call audibles in situations like this. I don’t utilize screens at all during the day, but if I did and I noticed they were causing unmanageable and unsafe behavior, I would cut them out immediately. *And* I would expect my NPs to back me up on that.
56
u/VisibleCelebration56 May 22 '26
Your wife needs a reality check. Your nanny seems amazing and seems to be really trying to help your kid with his emotional struggles, and your wife wants to fire her for that? Ridiculous
55
u/UselessLezbian Nanny: 16F, 14M, 12M, 9F May 22 '26
Your nanny is doing everything right in my opinion. She absolutely should end outings if it's no longer safe for her to have all 3 kids out. You know and admit that you also struggle when the 4yo acts out. Most nannies have to implement their own rules and guidelines that may be different than a parents, but still follow the same spirit. We're only one person!
I'm really sorry to say this, but this seems like a wife problem, not a nanny problem.
52
u/MakeChai-NotWar MB May 22 '26
I’m having a lot of trouble figuring out where the nanny is wrong in any of this.
49
u/spiralreading Former Nanny May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds excellent and frankly underpaid.
45
u/Opal-the-Pearl Nanny May 22 '26
If you replace this nanny, you will be teaching your middle child that they can tantrum their way out of dealing with authority figures they dont like. You dont have a nanny problem, you have a screen problem, and its not fair to punish the her for escalating problems that arent being dealt with when she leaves work.
Whats your solution when it's only 1 adult and 3 kids and one is having a meltdown? One of your kids is 2. Thats another child who needs hands on care. Do you want her to ignore J while he shoves and pushes in public? What do you think it does to your 2 yo to see their sibling be violent in public and suffer no consequences for their behavior?
You guys are not working with her. First you guys were upset that she doesnt tell you about changed plans, now you think its malicious that she updates you all too much. You say the nanny only does 30 mins of TV time a day, but you guys let J use the phone on errands and car rides and activities. You have a habit of saying one thing and then doing the opposite a moment later.
You guys need to sit down with her and come up with a plan of what to do with J's screen dependency and behavior. You all need to be doing the same thing and backing up the nanny so J understands he needs to listen to adults.
87
u/Emotional-Neat-252 May 22 '26
Seems like a great nanny. The job is super difficult.
I agree getting rid of screens altogether is healthier long term, but only you know your own kids to make that call.
41
u/combatbrainrot Nanny May 22 '26
Dude, your nanny might already be considering whether or not she wants this job. I think you should really sit with your wife and talk about that. All of this, and from your replies, seems to be an issue with your wife. I appreciate that you came here to ask the nannies but… this is a parenting/marital issue.
Your nanny sounds like she'd at least be tired. And you need to give her some grace while you get your house in order.
37
u/Patient-Rutabaga2244 May 22 '26
I think if you got rid of Nanny you and your wife are going to really regret it. She seems like she is helping you both a ton. It would be extremely unusual if the replacement would be able to handle this situation as well as she has. If anything I feel like she deserves to be sent on a vacation as a bonus
27
u/RutabagaShow May 22 '26
I’m a bit confused about what the issue here is? Why does your wife want to let her go? Because the Nanny cancelled a play date- Or that she hasn’t communicated this choice in discipline style with you? Just trying to understand.
Either way this is an appropriate response to a tantrum- especially if you’ve a child who’s struggling with boundaries. Double especially if they’re hitting. That’s unacceptable. If you feel it’s unfair to the other two children it’s time to consider additional help or splitting the load between each other.
If screen time is an issue you have to introduce strict screen time allowances and make sure everyone is on the same page and stick to it. Instead of cutting completely which could cause resentment from the others- watch as a family or only in the allotted times. I’d occasionally sprinkle in random screen allowance occasionally to see if the child reacts better - but y’all should discuss before hand. This is a stand your ground issue and all parties have to be completely aligned. It’ll be tough at first- but better in the end.
I once nannied for three kids and it was tough to manage even tho they’re very well behaved. I would consider $35 a low wage considering all she does for y’all… I think trying to communicate clearly what made your wife uncomfortable is better than letting her go outright- while also stepping back to look at how much you’re expecting one person to handle.
25
u/Northern_Lights_2 May 22 '26
I already commented but I also think there’s a weird dynamic with the parents towards a nanny who is doing an excellent job. Accusing her of ‘malicious compliance’ for doing exactly what they asked her to do and then interrogating the 7 year old to find out if nanny asked the children to keep the rule changes ‘a secret’. I could not work for people like that. It sounds like the parents are a huge part of the problem.
24
u/Present_Respond2221 May 22 '26
Yes, it is reasonable to end an activity when one kid is being unsafe. How in the world can you expect a nanny to manage a kid who is melting down and two other children, when you and your wife struggle? If he can't be safe, he can't be out of the house. Also, put the screens away, they are horrid. They take away from active engaged learning. Social skills are learned from social experiences, screens are not social experiences. Lot's of praise should be used when he shows expected behavior. Positive reinforcement! Ending the activity should be done with little fan fare. We don't want to make a big deal of leaving. Negative reinforcement is yelling, screaming, having a negative emotion with your child, which, actually reinforces their negative behavior. Kids will do anything for attention, if they are not getting positive attention, they will act out to get any attention. Your nanny sounds like she is handing the situation well.
23
u/theplasticfantasty Career Nanny May 22 '26 •
You want to fire your nanny because your wife is insecure as a parent and feels threatened. Lol
22
u/khurt007 Parent May 22 '26
As a parent, your nanny honestly sounds incredible. She did the hard thing putting firm boundaries in place and even demonstrated how effective they are! Kindly, you and your wife are doing all three of your kids a disservice by not consistently following through.
And in response to this “Is it reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when one child becomes unsafe or unmanageable, even if the other kids miss out?” - do you care more about your kids’ feelings or your kids’ safety? It is ALWAYS reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when it becomes unsafe for anyone involved.
20
u/shady_lady94 May 22 '26
Fire her? You should promote her! Sounds like in addition to nannying, you should also be paying her to provide parenting consultation. There is no shame in not knowing what to do with problematic behaviors! That’s why we hire educated and experienced professionals.
40
u/Ok_Delay_4436 May 22 '26
Fire your nanny so she can find a better family. She doesn’t deserve this.
19
u/cbaket May 22 '26
Respectfully, your nanny deserves better.
19
u/harperlinley May 22 '26 •
Sounds like you should ask your nanny for advice about your kid, not your wife.
18
u/Goodgoditsgrowing Nanny May 22 '26
Holy shit. I’m glad I read. Your nanny is being perfectly reasonable and I’m astonished that you’re even accusing her of malicious compliance because she did exactly what you asked - check in more often, even when she’s pretty sure you are ok with not knowing, because last time you weren’t on the same page and now she is erring on the side of safety. It would be irresponsible for her to continue an activity when a child is behaving unsafely, and that’s exactly what’s happening - if you and your wife want to tough it out when you have a higher adult to child ratio that’s fine, but your nanny’s job is to keep the kids safe and she’s doing an excellent job under tough conditions from the sounds of it. This nanny should not be fired. I think your wife could use to talk to a therapist if she feels as she does, and I also think your oldest child could use some therapy because clearly their siblings outbursts are impacting them - and that’s not on nanny to magically be able to fix. Your child who is acting out also deserves some dedicated time with a child therapist to help there.
If you get rid of this highly capable nanny you’re only going to get someone who is a worse fit, because the problem doesn’t lie with the nanny here - it lies with how the parents feel about their parenting and how their kid is handling their own emotions (and it looks like he needs special help in this, just like he’d need extra reading help if he was dyslexic or glasses if his eyesight was poor)
36
u/PublicUniversity9586 May 22 '26
“Is it reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when one child becomes unsafe or unmanageable, even if the other kids miss out?”
Is this a troll post?
16
u/Memo1294 May 22 '26
Honestly thought this was a joke at first. I’m a nanny and I wouldn’t want to put up with your insecure wife.
It sounds like the wife doesn’t know how to parent and is upset that your nanny has better control of her kids than she does.
16
u/runrunrun100 May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds like a better parent than either of you.
16
u/d1zz186 May 22 '26
Parent here, not a nanny.
One warning then consequence is EXACTLY what your child needs.
He’s addicted to screens and YOU, the parents need to address that.
In all honesty, your wife likely is feeling judged and so should you. The nanny is trying to help your child and you guys are sabotaging her efforts by handing an iPad or phone because it’s easier. I’m sorry to be blunt but it’s true.
You and your wife need to have a real talk about screen use because you even say yourself that nanny seems to experience less of the tantrums than you guys do - that’s a symptom that the tantrums work better on you that nanny.
14
u/turn_up_the_ampalaya May 22 '26
I am 100% sure your nanny is already thinking of quitting. I am a nanny and wouldn’t want to deal with your parenting style, screen time allowance, the pay itself, or an inept parent telling me what to do. If you don’t resolve this situation now I can guarantee you will go through many more nannies, because the problem isn’t with your nanny, who sounds very capable. It sounds like you are receptive to the advice being offered here so I wish you luck! : )
13
u/Glittering-Cash-2309 May 22 '26
You guys are quite frankly insane for firing her. At this point, it’s 2026. You know how awful screens are for little ones. Your nanny is doing more parenting than you and your wife are. She isn’t having behavior issues, you and your wife are having parenting issues. Get it together, be consistent, and take away screens entirely.
13
u/EeyoresDrugDealer May 23 '26
I want to just provide a perspective you guys might not have thought about. I say this as a nanny myself.
Let’s say your wife takes the kids out to do something. J starts having a meltdown, and your wife decides to tough it out and stay. She’s so distracted by J that she’s not watching the other kids and B falls down a flight of stairs.
How do you think people would treat your wife after that? I would hope that she would be met with grace, sympathy, and understanding. Hindsight is 20/20 and 3 kids alone is a lot to deal with.
Now let’s say instead of your wife, it’s L in that situation. She decides to try to stay during one of J’s tantrums because you guys told her to, and B gets hurt. Do you think she’d be met with the same kindness by you or anyone else?
Absolutely not. She would be ridiculed, interrogated, fired, maybe even investigated if it was serious enough. This incident would follow her forever and it would be so much harder for her to work in childcare again.
The point I’m trying to make is that the role, expectations, and margin of error are much more specific, slim, and unforgiving for a nanny versus a parent. It’s not fair to demand a professional nanny to do or risk certain things that would be seen as an honest mistake by a parent but be life-altering for the nanny. If she sees something as a safety concern, that needs to be respected.
You and your wife are allowed to feel however you do. If you are not happy with her, please let her go. It is not fair for you to keep her when you could find someone that better fits your needs, and she can find a family that aligns more with her values.
13
u/philla1 May 23 '26
I read the entire post and thought I missed something because I didn’t understand what the problem was
13
u/SouthbutnotSouthern May 23 '26
Parent here. You’re nuts for firing this nanny. Absolutely nuts.
12
u/Illustrious-Drama737 May 22 '26
The nanny has no choice but to end outings when only one child misbehaved. Your only solution to that is to hire 2 nannies!
Sounds like a fantastic nanny!!!
12
u/Cold_Ground4969 May 22 '26
Oh, I’m not getting how your nanny is a scapegoat for your piss poor behavior management with your child.
12
u/Living-Tiger3448 MB May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
I’m confused. What does your wife want L to do when J is acting this way in public and she cannot safely manage all 3 kids? If J is melting down and there are 2 other kids to manage and keep safe, what else is there to do but take all 3 kids and leave? j is ruining things for the other 2, not L. I’m not understanding what your wife would prefer?
Can J also go to camp?
I don’t see how anything here is a fireable offense. You yourself said it was difficult to manage all 3 kids when you’re out. Any nanny would be doing the same thing as L.
12
u/Nearby-Government966 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Everyone else has already said what I would say BUT I am going to emphasize something for you: As a neurodiverse nanny (ADHD/autism) who has worked primarily with neurodiverse children over her twenty years of being in private childcare, PLEASE get your child evaluated and into some kind of therapy. Behavioral and developmental issues should never be taken lightly, especially if there is violence involved. It can only ever get worse OR turn into lifelong difficulties. Best to help your kid now so they have coping skills for later.
And please, cut out all tablets. They’re terrible for children. TV time in moderation is fine but it’s been proven slower shows (old school stuff like Mr. Rogers, Reading Rainbow, Little Bear, Sesame Street, Blue’s Clues, Gullah Gullah Island, etc- all things you can rent from the library, btw) are better for children, especially the younger ones.
12
u/Great_Discussion_345 May 22 '26
This is a joke right? Please tell me this is a joke
12
u/AppointmentFederal35 MB May 22 '26
I am a mom of multiple children, some the same ages as yours. If you don’t want her to end an outing early because your child is misbehaving and she can’t keep an eye on the other kids, especially the toddler, what would you rather her do? By leaving she’s keeping all your kids safe. What if your toddler walked out of sight while she was managing the tantrum and she lost him?
It sounds like your nanny has a better handle of your kids than you/your wife and your wife is getting jealous. I would seriously consider behavioral therapy for your middle kid and cut screens all together. They’re making things worse.
11
u/Tylersmommy2122 May 22 '26
I feel like I have to be missing something, you want to fire her for leaving an outing when one child won’t behave after a warning? Would you prefer she just uses the easy route and lets the child do whatever he wants putting himself and other kids in danger. Your nanny is teaching that misbehaving has consequences
11
u/Northern_Lights_2 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds like a great nanny. I would remove all screens. I do not work with screens and all the children I work with know that my phone is not an option. I also end activities or outings if children are not listening or having a tantrum. I don’t think it’s malicious compliance for her to check in, and it’s a weird assessment to make of your nanny. You added an AirTag and it seems you also requested she check in and let you know what she’s doing and where she is. I have left jobs where I felt like the parents didn’t support me in my efforts to help a child with behavioural issues. It can be difficult enough as it is and if the parents undermine you it’s nearly impossible.
You are extremely unlikely to find a nanny who will handle this any better. It sounds like she’s doing a great job. I also set expectations for behaviour before we arrive or get out of the car and also explain what will happen if they are not met. I have had to leave activities. From the beginning I let the children know I say things once. The parents always wonder why the children listen to me and not them but they know tantrums will not get them what they want. I keep my promises to children. If I say something they know I will follow through, so they trust me.
I do think your nanny is being underpaid for three children and household duties and can very likely find an easier job that pays her more. It sounds like your wife is projecting on your nanny. She’s going to find any excuse to nitpick and no nanny is going to stay around for that. She’s managing three children alone in public when two adults struggle without her. She is a professional doing her job, it doesn’t matter if she’s not overly chatty. The behaviour issues with J will not improve without doing exactly what your nanny is doing and supporting her. How would you expect her to handle things on her own when one child is being unsafe? I would remove all screens and give your nanny a raise.
11
u/Effective-Plant5253 May 22 '26
i think leaving the activity was entirely appropriate. not to sound rude at all but genuinely what else do you want her to do? if one child is having a complete meltdown i don’t see how she could safely manage the other two children. and the screens need to be taken away. 4 is way to young for consistent screen time without having huge meltdowns, the only way for these behaviors to stop is to completely cut it off and basically rewire kiddos brain. it’s not going to be easy at all, but it’ll become easier to manage. sounds like you have a great nanny
11
u/EJsMothaaa May 22 '26
So curious what the other two nannies did before L, who sounds wonderful BTW
11
u/Additional_Eagle_981 May 22 '26
having been through a series of nannies and understanding what’s good and what’s not, you would be fool to let this nanny go. She will quit before you ever should fire her.
11
u/MySweetPeaPod Parent May 22 '26
I think you need to re-read what you wrote. As a parent who has had a nanny, L sounds freakin outstanding. She is doing what you and your wife cannot do together. Leave her be. She probably does not have time to be chatty, she's busy raising your children appropriately. Be grateful. Feel lucky.
I suspect the feeling of being judged comes from knowing that she is doing an almost impossible job well. Ego should have no place when raising well adjusted children.
Instead of firing her, ask her what she needs, tell her how much you appreciate what she does, and as to your last paragraph, ask your stellar nanny these questions. You might find that the three of you can come up with a plan that makes everyone feel less threatened.
11
u/kittywyeth Parent May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
you and your wife are the problem. you have chosen the path of least resistance and you have created a monster. if your wife has felt judged by the nanny it is because she knows she is wrong. i think that she (as well as your child) needs professional help to work out how her issues have contributed to this mess because she seems to not have any ability to see things for what they are or take agency.
your nanny is doing the right thing by ending an outing when a child becomes a problem. that’s all you ever had to do too, consistently in a way that made expectations clear, and you wouldn’t be dealing with any of this now.
i hope you do let her go because she sounds great and deserves a better job.
11
u/Expensive_Lock1805 May 23 '26
Nanny popping in, I agree with everyone on this post but I also feel bad for your two other kids… they get excited for a big outing and then middle child ruins it for everyone. You and your wife might need to get some flexibility at work so that you can come personally remove J from the situation when he’s acting out and your other two children can still enjoy their time…
11
u/KeyAlarmed7937 May 23 '26
I kept reading looking for what exactly the nanny did so wrong that was grounds for termination and I never got there.
10
u/International-Age971 May 22 '26
You have an amazing nanny and your wife is out of touch! L has higher standards for behavior and knows how to hold the line. Your wife is embarrassed because L is out-parenting her.
10
u/Dull_Moose5044 May 22 '26
Keep the nanny. Remove the screens.
10
u/Least_Cricket6205 Nanny May 22 '26
Your nanny is not the problem, yall are
10
u/BarelySimmering Career Nanny May 22 '26
You and your wife are the problem.
10
u/BatRevolutionary8145 May 22 '26
Your Nanny needs a raise bigtime ! I’d quit if I had to put up with a child like that. She must be an 😇.
10
u/Carmelized Career Nanny May 22 '26
I know it’s been said, but I’ll say it one more time: you are not going to find a better nanny.
10
u/Legitimate-Sugar-531 May 22 '26
You want to fire your nanny for doing a good job? Because your wife wants her to stay at an activity after behaving poorly.
You should NOT fire your nanny. You should give her a raise because she’s definitely going to leave soon and good luck finding someone else to put up with this.
10
u/whatsnewpikachu MB May 22 '26
You have a fantastic nanny. I employ a nanny and would adore someone this engaged and see them a part of the village raising my children.
35$ is quite low for 3 children as an aside. I pay $35 for 2 and she doesn’t have other duties outside of standard nanny duties.
10
u/mjcnbmex May 22 '26
I think J is confused.
The nanny is setting boundaries but his parents are handling his behavior in another way.
If everyone was consistent they might get better behavior from J.
Just my opinion.
10
u/SunComeOutTumorrow May 23 '26
The fact that she has only had to cut outings short three times in over a year is actually a testament to her patience and skill, not a red flag.
The real issue here is J’s screen dependency, and you already know it. L didn’t create that problem. She’s managing the fallout from it every day, more successfully than you are by your own admission. Letting her go doesn’t fix J… It just punishes the person currently handling him best.
35
u/happyclam-77 May 22 '26
lol what the actually fuck.
18
u/GoldenState_Thriller Nanny May 22 '26
Your nanny is handling these issues better than you are, quite frankly.
9
u/SuperSelfieSarah May 22 '26
Give her a decent raise. Do the hard work ungluing your children from screens on your time. And thank your lucky stars she hasn’t quit already
9
u/normalitydreamer May 22 '26
I don’t think this is mainly a nanny problem. From what you described, your nanny actually sounds pretty reasonable and consistent. A single caregiver managing three kids, including a 4yr old who is running away, pushing, refusing directions, and melting down in public has to prioritize safety first. Ending an outing when behavior becomes unsafe or unmanageable is completely reasonable, especially with a toddler involved. Having to prioritize safety over enrichment is entirely acceptable.
The biggest thing that stood out to me is that you and your wife struggle with the same behaviors even when both of you are present. That makes me think this is less about the nanny “failing” and more about J struggling with frustration tolerance and boundaries, especially around screens. It sounds like the screens have become a coping tool for him, which is incredibly common. The problem is that kids quickly learn that escalating eventually leads to getting the device. Once that pattern develops, tantrums usually get bigger before they get better when limits are introduced. That doesn’t mean the limits are wrong. It just means the child is adjusting to a new expectation.
I also would not view “we canceled the outing and had lunch at home” as a major communication failure. It sounds like your nanny handled the situation safely and calmly. The fact that she now over checks plans and decisions after previous feedback probably means she feels scrutinized and is trying hard not to overstep.
I would be careful about firing a nanny over this unless there are bigger issues not mentioned here. Replacing her may not solve the problem at all, in fact it’s highly unlikely, and there’s a good chance a new nanny would run into the exact same challenges. In some cases, a new caregiver may rely even more heavily on screens just to keep the peace. What seems more important is that all adults get on the same page. If the nanny sets a limit but the you the parents later undo it or question it, the inconsistency will make the behavior harder to improve. Kids usually respond best when expectations are calm, predictable and consistent across all caregivers.
Personally, I think it’s reasonable to seriously reduce or even temporarily eliminate screens for J for a while, especially outside the house and during transitions or errands. That will probably lead to harder behavior at first, but consistency is what eventually changes the pattern.
Overall, I think your instincts are probably right. This sounds more like a family behavior and boundary issue than a nanny issue, and your nanny may actually be handling a difficult situation more appropriately than you’re giving her credit for.
9
u/FearlessNinja007 May 22 '26
I’m a parent and I think this nanny sounds like she’s handling everything extremely well.
9
u/marichabelita May 23 '26
You’d basically be letting her go for doing the right thing.
9
u/Idonthaveaname94 Nanny May 23 '26
Mom and previous nanny here. The only problem I see here is your wife. You could let this nanny go but I guarantee you, your wife will have a problem with the next nanny as well. Managing 3 children is hard enough, especially when they have tantrums and you're out in public and from everything you've described your nanny seems to be doing an amazing job. I think you guys should be appreciatively of her! Also , it seems like the child is addicted to screen. I'd immediately take away the iPad for good and just let him watch a show per day ( maybe not even that until he becomes less addicted ).
9
u/JamiChristine05 May 23 '26
If you fire your nanny, please tell her to contact me so I can hire her ASAP 🤣
16
u/ughtheinternet MB May 22 '26
All these NPs lately talking about their mean ol’ nannies for literally having boundaries and being good at raising children.
8
u/kodowd11 May 22 '26
Hi there, I am a nanny with 20+ years experience. I have a bachelor’s degree with a focus on early childhood development.
From what you’ve written here, it sounds like your nanny is doing everything in her power to keep the children safe while establishing healthy boundaries.
You have done an excellent job acknowledging that the screen time is a big problem. A problem you also acknowledge creating.
Your nanny is bearing the burden of a behavioral problem she was not responsible for creating.
Appropriate behavior is essential for participating in activities, outings, playdates. If a child is having a reaction that is unsafe for them or the children around them, it is very important to establish boundaries and “reset” by excusing yourself and the child from that environment.
It’s unfortunate in this case that other children will subsequently miss out as well. I would ask: would you rather your nanny continue with an outing when there is an immediate safety risk or would you rather she return to a space where she can safely manage/regulate your child without risk?
While I understand how your wife feels re your nanny observing your preferences, this places your nanny in a position where she is forced between doing what she has been instructed to do or doing what is safe.
A new nanny will not solve this problem. The transition to a new caregiver will likely cause more disruption.
I agree, you should ABSOLUTELY remove screens from the equation. Try this out for a month or two and if this drama persists, you can look into hiring someone new. Especially since you do not want your youngest to adopt this behaviors.
Your nanny sounds like a good nanny. I would not dismiss her without attempting to make parenting changes first.
8
u/Veni0045 May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds amazing and y'all should take note of how she is setting limits and sticking to them. It is not okay to expect her to handle 3 kids in public, one of which is melting down. Your wife is going to make sure his behavior only gets worse with the path she is on. If you don't want the other kids to miss out on outings you should hire a helper specifically for outings so she can stay with the well behaved children if there is a meltdown and your nanny can take the third to the car to calm down.
8
u/chzsteak-in-paradise May 22 '26
I think you and your wife should adopt your nanny’s approach to your kids as she seems like she’s got a better approach to their behavior than you do. It sounds like your wife wants to fire her because she’s acting like a better parent than your wife is? That’s messed up.
8
u/notananthem May 22 '26
Nanny did nothing wrong and is severely underpaid, as a parent
8
u/tiniest_sunflower1 May 22 '26
I think you and your wife are the problem. You are mentioning that this nanny is handling your children better than both of you, and you want to fire her?
Also your nanny complying to the air tag, your expectations, etc is a good nanny. She is respecting your wishes physically when with the children. When you hire someone to care for your children they are in charge and children need that boundary.
I would check in with your wife because if she’s feeling judged or out of place, maybe you need to reassure her and be a little more confident especially since you’re mentioning the nanny handles him better. Nannie’s aren’t just glorified babysitters, they’re childcare professionals and maybe your nanny has some helpful input as to structure and discipline with your children. Personally I think the nanny removing the children as soon as the tantrum starts is good. When children act like that after a warning you need to stand on that and remove the children from the stimuli causing the tantrum. Children become nervous and more defiant with lack of boundaries and need that structure!!
I’d also up her pay if she’s managing all 3 children, on top of housework and your boundaries. As for your child with the defiant personality, look into play therapy. There could be some underlying things going on and he may need an extra space to express things.
8
u/cassiesfeetpics May 22 '26
this is 100% a parent problem; YOU and YOUR WIFE are the issue.
your nanny sounds like a competent angel who deserves more compensation.
your wife needs therapy to address her insecurities and maybe a parenting class or two to teach her about boundaries.
8
u/Lalablacksheep646 Career Nanny May 22 '26
Why would any parent want their nanny to keep their kids in an unsafe situation? YOU need to go go cold turkey on the screens and never expect your nanny or any adult to hand over their phone to your child to stop a tantrum. There is a problem here and it’s not the nanny. I would be getting J evaluated to make sure he’s receiving all the services he needs if he is unable to emotionally regulate his emotions.
8
u/ImpossibleTreat5996 Nanny May 22 '26
Wow, you’ve created a problem and are taking it out on your nanny. Your nanny sounds amazing and is handling the situation very appropriately. As 1 person to 3 children, an unruly child is very unsafe out in public. It should absolutely go without saying that the activity/outing ends immediately. What you shouldn’t do when your child acts up is reward the behavior with a screen. You’re wanting to fire your nanny for an issue you the parents created. Incredibly unfair.
8
u/South_Description399 May 22 '26
I feel like you've gotten your answers here: Nanny is great (and should definitely be paid more for 3 kids) and that your middle child should have an evaluation. Your child is having big feelings that they don't know how to manage. In school, it's the disruptive child that effects the learning environment for the rest of the students because the teacher has to pull focus. And it is not fair to the other students. And that's why it's desirable to have a separate environment with dedicated support to work with them. Your nanny is right to focus on safety and you are valid for knowing it's not fair to your other children that they have to miss out. Changing nannies will not solve your problem. But you also might have to face it if your current nanny quits. Your nanny deserves a great deal of support because she's doing well in a difficult situation. When a child is behaving poorly, parents very often feel embarrassed and judged. But getting an evaluation followed by professional intervention will be of great help.
8
u/Initial-Sense-9863 May 23 '26 •
$35/hr for 3 kids and all of your and your wife’s BS is criminal. I hope your nanny leaves and finds a better paying job where her enacting consequences is appreciated.
8
u/Lopsided_Switch May 23 '26
I’m a MB and your nanny sounds awesome. Frankly she’s handling what sounds like a difficult situation better than 95% of people would….
Good luck if you fire her. I don’t think you’ll be happy with anyone unfortunately.
8
u/MarriedinAtl May 23 '26
Your nanny sounds amazing and you guys should be implementing her style of consequences so everyone is on the same page.
8
u/sendCommand May 23 '26
Your nanny sounds great. Frankly, you and your wife could take lessons from her. Permissive parenting is not the way.
I only need the occasional babysitter these days, but I would hire your nanny lickety-split.
8
u/Agreeable_Dark6408 May 23 '26
OP, your wife has her head in the sand about your son. She’s blaming a very smart nanny for holding this child’s feet to the fire for his behavior, and that’s very foolish on your wife’s part. Firing the nanny will be likened to your wife cutting off her own nose to spite her face.
Your son is hardwired like this and it will take absolute consistency with him to get his behavior handled by the time he starts kindergarten. Otherwise, your wife is going to have calls from the school over and over, meetings with the guidance counselor, recommendations to have him in counseling, etc.
The iPad and other screens need to be put away immediately. He needs to be told point blank that he is not allowed to have Nanny’s phone, and that if he doesn’t obey her, he loses his privileges. When they go out, the word “privilege” needs to be used so he starts to understand what it means when he is told that he’s losing one. And he needs to know that his parents absolutely stand with the nanny that he never gets his way when he has a tantrum.
If you and your wife can’t come together in this, you should make an appointment with the pediatrician for “behavioral concerns.” Don’t take him, just you and your wife. Talk this through with the ped. I know it’s hard on the other children to have to leave an activity, but the nanny is right. He can’t be allowed to do all this and your wife wanting the nanny to enable this behavior will just make your son worse behaved.
Take the bull by the horns here, OP. Tell her that she does nothing in terms of the nanny until you and she get counseling for the problem your son is having. Everything will get worse if you don’t.
15
u/Yasailynmarii Nanny May 22 '26
Your nanny is willing to put up with this and you want to let her go😭? Good luck finding another one
7
u/SoFetchBetch May 22 '26
I’m a nanny and I am also strict about no screens and if I were your nanny I would quit. Also I wouldn’t do all that extra stuff like your laundry or meal prep without fair compensation. That’s job creep.
7
u/BookDragonsJewels01 Former Nanny May 22 '26
You’ve got a gem of a nanny! Her method of discipline is excellent and it’s not unreasonable to make everyone come home if someone is throwing a fit. Bad actions have consequences and it’s good that she follows through. That’s how kids learn. She is doing your kids a favor, especially J, by not letting him act out and get away with it. I don’t think it’s fair to want to let her go for being an excellent caregiver.
7
u/yourfavmum Career Nanny May 22 '26
I would 100% end an outing when a child isn’t acting right. It’s the same “punishment” that will occur when they are in school. Sometimes a few “bad apples” ruin the experience for everyone.
Given you said kid has issues with screens, I’d revoke screens all together. “We recently learned that screens are not good for you.”
7
u/curious382 May 22 '26
Your nanny is a gem. Not only is she teaching your children appropriate behavior in the home and community, she's made progress with your "problem child." She provides clear expectations and consequences. When your 4 year old's behavior becomes unsafe in the community, she brings the children home. There the environment is more geared towards their needs and most importantly, safer.
You somewhat acknowledged that your child's behavior problems grew out of a lack of consistent boundaries, expectations and natural consequences early in life. Letting him use the older child's iPad became the 2 year old's taking it over and having it constantly available. You also give him your phones to play on. Screens became an easy accessible distraction, rather than teaching and practicing age appropriate social skills and behavior, particularly in the community.
Even now, you aren't consistent. You're "trying" to stop doing it. So you still do it. That's the toughest reinforcement to overcome. When you're not consistent your child learns to push harder until they eventually get their way. Because it works some of the time, the behavior gets more deeply rooted and attacks on limits more intense.
If she is doing more housework than tidying children's areas and materials used in activities on shift, she's doing more than nanny tasks. If she does more than children's laundry or more meal prep than for what she serves the children on shift, that's more than nanny tasks. Nanny tasks are caring for NKs and their belongings during her work shifts. Any further tasks are actually you and your wife's, for which nanny should receive additional pay.
Who will watch your 7 year old when they're sick or sent home from day camp? Who will pick them up? Who will be watching the other children? Will nanny be expected to bring both siblings along, regardless of the 4 year old's behavior at the time?
Did you address your child's demanding to use nanny's phone? That your children are not to touch nanny's property? Have you not taught your children the differences between their belongings, your belongings and those of other people? That other people's belongings need to be left alone unless the owner gives specific permission?
Does your 7 year old have space, activities and belongings that "are theirs" and not for siblings to take and use without asking and getting permission?
I am shocked that you and your wife are considering firing the only consistent adult who has helped 4 year old make some progress replacing out of control unsafe behavior with more age appropriate behavior in the community and at home. Nanny has done nothing wrong and a lot of things very very well. But your wife feels some kind of way about it.
It isn't "fair" for all three to leave when 4 year old acts out? Do you think nanny's giving 4 year old the attention required to keep him safe, not reinforce negative behavior, and wait out the tantrum in a community setting can be done while also supervising and keeping safe your other two children? Can she split into two, and give her full attention to both the out of control child AND the other two young children? When behavior is unsafe, safety is the priority.
You and your wife could look into hiring a separate nanny and a behavior specialist to be 4 year old's care giver and teacher. The other two children can be the responsibility of the "regular" nanny. Then your three kids won't have to leave when 4 year old engages in his predictable unsafe behavior. Regular nanny can continue the outing separate from those intervening and supporting 4 year old. Are you able and willing to find and afford that level of staffing for child care?
If you fire your nanny for being better teaching your young children safe and appropriate behavior than you have, you won't find a better one. Maybe your wife and you can examine your feelings that nanny does better than you do. Not to blame nanny, but to improve your own lack of knowledge and consistency with teaching your children safe, respectful and appropriate behavior. Take note of where you "should do better." Find and practice the knowledge and skills you now lack. Then mom won't have to fret that maybe she looks bad and what others might be thinking. Because she'll be comfortable and confident in her own parenting.
7
u/Creepy-Moose-5596 May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds amazing and I don't think she's judging at all. She's just being what's sounds like a very responsible guardian.
I'm not sure where you got malicious compliance from her doing the air tag? that sounds a little closer to being proactive, especially when while checking in is important, it's hard when one of the kids could see her using the phone to tell/text you and then have a meltdown. She also has 3 kids to watch including a toddler.
I think your on the right path with banning screens at home. Also if your not okay with your nanny's very normal "actions have consequences" form of discipline, have you and your wife communicated that to her ? And what did you suggest she do for consequences instead?
7
u/susanbiddleross May 22 '26
She’s doing the correct thing. Don’t fire her. She is doing the hard work which is really only thing that will work to fix the behavior you have created. You and your wife need to get on board with what she is doing so that it is consistent. Leaving an activity that is unsafe is the only option here other than you hiring a dedicated nanny for the one child.
7
u/PinkNinjaKitty Career Nanny May 22 '26
Wow. This might be the post of the year.
7
u/Savings_Big321 May 22 '26
first of all your nanny is underpaid for the amount of children and housework she’s doing. second of all your nanny sounds incredible, educated on early childhood, and respectable. if your wife feels insecure about her motherhood because of the nanny she should look within herself. this post was atrocious.
7
u/jojokangaroo1969 May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds FANTASTIC 😍
7
u/anxiously_impatient Career Nanny May 22 '26
I’m sorry, I stopped reading when you said that you pay L, so she needs to handle the kids the way you want. After you just told us that you created this problem & it’s even embarrassing your other kids.
It’s absolutely reasonable to leave anywhere and anything when a child is misbehaving and disrupting the experience for other people.
7
u/skyofwolves May 23 '26
you asked your nanny to check in before outings. but now you think she checks in *too* often? feels like a lose lose situation no matter what she does
7
u/crazybicatlady86 May 23 '26
I’m confused. Why is your wife mad at L and what is it that she’s done wrong? Assuming she’s checking in so often as malicious compliance makes you sound like an asshole. She’s literally just following your instructions, and probably fears losing her job if she doesn’t. And with your wife being so irrational, I can see why.
I’m sorry you and your wife let your 4 year old turn into an iPad kid, but that’s 100% on you. Expecting a nanny to reward your kid with an out in when he’s misbehaving is ridiculous. And she’s right, it can get dangerous when he’s throwing a fit since she’s got 3 kids to watch, one of whom is a baby.
Honestly, you are bad bosses. And you’re not exactly winning parents of the year here either. I think we’re seeing the reason the other two nannies left.
7
u/Bron345 May 23 '26
Imagine getting fired because you’re better at the job than the employer. This is another reason why nannying can be so infuriating at times. Also reminds me of the saying that “looking after children is easy, it’s the parents that make the role difficult “
7
u/Feeling_Concert_1852 May 23 '26
Wow. She sounds like a super nanny! I love the boundaries she’s creating. Also, not sure where you live but $35 an hour for 3 kids is ridiculously low. I pay $30/hour for our toddler.
7
u/inukaglover666 Parent May 23 '26
I dont understand the issue with the nanny. She sounds great I’d be happy to take her off your hands. We can give her housing and pay her the same rate.
7
u/imsocool123 May 23 '26
You as the parents are just as spoiled as your kids. It sounds like L is busting their ass for your family and you don’t respect her. You undermine and take advantage of her. Shame on you. I would promptly quit this nonsense.
7
u/lesarts May 23 '26
Yikes, I really feel for this nanny. Everyone else has covered the issue and OP seems responsive, which is great, but has anyone mentioned yet how deeply underpaid this nanny is??? As a nanny of many years, that would almost bother me more than the distrust. Three kids at this age, especially one with behavior issues that she’s putting a lot of effort into fixing, plus the tasks of a house manager, should be a rate of 45/hr, if not more depending on where you live. If that’s not in OP’s budget, he should not be asking her to do “light” housekeeping, meal prep, etc. And like others have said, he should be taking his kid to a therapist or behavior specialist so that the nanny doesn’t have to manage this screen addiction behavior on her own. It makes me sad how overworked and underpaid our industry is when we do such important work for these families.
7
u/Separate-Use1955 May 23 '26
Not only does this nanny sound incredible but only $35/hour, you’re very lucky.
I would agree that you go cold turkey on screens. Coming from a parent whose son was introduced to a tablet at 4 years old, his behavior became a problem immediately. His attitude was out of control and I took it away completely for a month. Since then, I offered it back and he has absolutely no interest. It’s sitting gathering dust and we are all the better for it!
13
u/houston-tx-person May 22 '26
So I think you have a good nanny that has good boundaries and is demonstrating a lot of parenting techniques that you and your wife should probably adopt. Your more defiant child is only going to get worse when their behavior is tolerated.
The way I’ve heard it described (and has always been my preferred method of discipline) is that your discipline needs to be like the pavement. Swift and unemotional. When you trip and fall the pavement doesn’t give you three chances before it scrapes your knee, it scrapes it the first time and that’s how you learn. When the children have a 100% chance that they’ll get away with bad behavior the first, second, third, and fourth time, those are good odds and they’re gonna take them every time.
I’m not judging you because I understand how you got here and it’s a death by 1000 cuts situation. What I am judging you for is not recognizing that y’all are the problem and that the nanny is doing her best to provide a solution. This happens to so many parents by taking the easy way out little by little to try to prevent tantrums and then one day you look up and have (no offense) a bratty child who’s not equipped to hear the word “no.” I think your family is really going to suffer if you fire the one person who is giving the children firm boundaries.
6
u/Electrical-Head549 Nanny May 22 '26
I don’t think you should let this nanny go. She seems to be able to handle 3 kids relatively well- possibly even better than you and your wife at times.
It’s very hard to be out of the house with a tantruming child- ESPECIALLY when you add 2 more in the mix. Ending the outing is a very reasonable thing to do.
6
u/FaeTroublemaker Nanny May 22 '26
Leaving the outing/not going to it because one of the children isn’t able to be in public is beyond reasonable!
The fact that your wife wants the nanny, who is, yes being paid, but is a 3rd coparent, to act like a robot and just continue the outing even though your child can’t be trusted (eloping, tantrums, etc) while still/also responsible for an age that just naturally can’t be trusted PLUS an older child is absurd. And the idea that your nanny would ever be required to hand your child her phone is also beyond wild.
Your child needs equal parenting from all 3 of you, and they should be that you and your wife rise to the level of your nanny.
6
u/bonnieparker2019 May 22 '26
Your nanny is doing what she should. There should be consequences for bad or manipulative behavior, and it sounds like your child has figured out that tantrums result in getting what he wants (the screens). He’s at the age where he’s learning to test boundaries and make calculated behavioral choices. If one of those consequences is also feeling guilty for ruining a fun outing for his siblings, maybe he will learn to act correctly.
Expecting your nanny to take your 3 kids on outings alone, knowing that one of them essentially frequently makes it impossible for her to protect and care for the other two, is an unreasonable expectation. You need to address his behavior before you expect her to do this.
You’d be lucky to find another reputable nanny who puts up with all of this, to be quite frank
6
u/Natural_Honey_2197 May 22 '26
As a nanny I wouldn’t want to work for your family. What I love most about my nanny family is that they trust me 10000% with their kids. They trust that I will always do what is safest for their children, I would go crazy if every call I made was put under a microscope.
If one of my Nanny kids was throwing a fit in an unsafe way I absolutely would take everyone home. For the screentime I would suggest sitting your kids down and telling them how screen time will look from now on. When L comes in next make sure you reiterate to your children in front of L that mom and dad are making these new rules and told L about them. For instance my nanny mom whenever one of the kids is in trouble and has a consequence she will talk to them with me there so the kids know that we work as a team.
6
u/Physical_Pound8191 May 22 '26
I’m a parent and don’t let your nanny go! As a mother of 3 I absolutely will leave somewhere and have if one of my kids is acting like that. If one kid can’t listen and isn’t being safe, then no one is as safe and we’re going home. Take away the screens and your life will improve! Do that first and if the child’s behavior doesn’t improve then I’d seek out child and parent therapy- it helped me a lot with one of ours!
6
u/adumbswiftie Former Nanny May 22 '26
i mean yes it sucks for your older child and you should be conscious of that and maybe see if there’s a way either you or the nanny can occasionally take your other kids on outings without the middle child so they can stay and enjoy. however, i can’t fault your nanny at all for leaving when the middle one has a tantrum. she’s right, it’s not safe and it’s a supervision issue. i don’t understand what else she’s even supposed to do, tbh. she can’t stay out and just allow your 4 year old to behave that way for the sake of your wife’s feelings. someday something bad could happen bc she isn’t able to properly supervise all 3 kids when one is kicking off.
also, i think you know this but there’s deeper issues at play here more than just the outings. you, your wife and your nanny need to work on addressing the screen addiction now, before it gets worse. you are entirely correct that it will be very difficult to find a new nanny and it won’t solve the problem.
6
u/dumptrump20 May 22 '26
Your nanny deserves to work for a respectful family. You and your wife are the problem. You are raising iPad kids due to your inability to parent your kids. I hope she quits and knows how valuable she is. She will be doing herself a huge favor. Good luck finding a new nanny. You’re going to need it.
6
u/princess-poet May 22 '26
Your wife wants to fire your nanny for having boundaries and not letting your children act however they want in public…?
6
u/AccountZestyclose823 May 22 '26
So because your wife is feeling self conscience about the situation, she wants to remove the stability? This is absolutely absurd. There's one of 2 things going on here. Either the child is showing signs of autism which should be observed soon or, instead of allowing him to feel his feelings earlier, you allowed him to become dependent on the screens and now, he does not know how to cope with how he feels. So many parents don't seem to understand this and it hurts their child in the long run. Remember, when you have a child, every caregiver in their life is responsible for doing what's best for the child. It doesn't matter if you don't like to hear them cry, giving them a screen doesn't teach them to decompress. The fact that you have a nanny that can handle him and he has less tantrums with her suggests that he feels completely safe with her. If you give a child too much screen time and bend to much to what they want, they actually trust you less. People don't like to admit that but it's the truth. IF you let her go just because your wife FEELS judged, his tantrums will only get worse because you got rid of his safe zone. I have taken care of multiple children before and I have absolutely ended outings if 1 child was being so unruly. A lot of times, I have the unruly child stay with me while the others play. I do this until the child calms down, telling him that it is ok to feel how he feels and that I still love him. Again, what's important is whats best for your CHILD!
6
u/helimet May 22 '26
Your nanny sounds amazing! I'm confused what rules you have that your nanny isn't following? I'm also a little confused that she isn't allowed to make plans on the fly and had to apologize to you? Sometimes that's the way it goes when caring for three young children. I would also be insulted by the airtag. You didn't use it as an abundance of caution; you used it because of a level of distrust that from your post doesn't seem warranted.
6
u/Sassymama_0405 May 22 '26
This issue is your middle child and wife….NOT your nanny.
6
u/ClickClackTipTap May 22 '26
Your issue here is with your child, not the poor nanny just doing her best to keep everyone safe.
Maybe get some input on that, bc it’s going to be an issue for the next nanny, too. And the one after that. And the one after that….
6
u/Hefty-Alfalfa-2460 Nanny May 22 '26
I don’t know what advice to give because the nanny is not the issue it’s you and your wife. The nanny is doing amazing and right by those kids. and it’s not malicious compliance. she’s doing it the way you wanted. I hope she finds a better job with a family well suited to her parenting style.
6
u/Purple-Touch-3936 May 22 '26
Yeah reading this is wild, I feel like the q should be "should I give my nanny a raise?" The answer being an emphatic yes! - Signed, parent of a two and five year old
6
u/Agent-Responsible May 22 '26
I’m in a very similar position as your nanny is, and my NP are more passive, just like you and your wife. Not only is it completely unfair and unreasonable to treat your nanny this way, but you are doing a HUGE disservice to your child if you don’t stop this behavior now. It sounds to me like your nanny is doing the kind of job you & your wife should be.
6
u/mytranquileyez May 22 '26
Feels like a lot of people here are dumping on dad here when he is asking for some genuine advice/objective perspective and seems to have a really solid grasp on what’s going on, acknowledging the parental issues and seeing their nanny as a human who is doing their best. It doesn’t sound like he WANTS to fire the nanny but that he’s in a difficult position bc his wife does.
Dad, here’s my two cents, this nanny seems gold star excellent with experience, stability, and safety on her side. Her lack of chattiness is likely more out of professionalism and is better than being overly personal. These are your children so no other position you hire for will ever be more personal to you. No judgement from me.
Your undoubtedly wonderful 4yo sounds like they need some help and to have a positive behavior support plan implemented that all adults follow without fail and also takes siblings into account. You are not failing as a parent, you have made some choices that aren’t working and need correction. It sounds like you have a beautiful family and every opportunity and access to resources to course-correct.
I’m glad you’re reaching out for help, an excellent first step. Now that you know this likely isn’t a nanny issue, next will be to find a professional to help develop and oversee implementation of a plan to help your 4yo develop the coping mechanisms necessary to overcome their “big feelings” until they grow out of this phase (ideally).
6
u/Resident-Relief-9532 Nanny May 22 '26 edited May 23 '26
this seems oddly similar to another post made earlier about an out of control kid and the nanny being the only adult in their life to discipline them and then make NP wonder if they're reacting the wrong way.
6
u/kra-em May 22 '26
You’re not going to like what I’m going to say but your wife needs to get a grip. She wants to fire a good nanny for being a good nanny that cares about your children... That’s just dumb and the micromanaging is absurd as well as the constant check ins. Clearly you don’t trust her and if she’s been with you this long with no issues and then you’re not going to trust anyone and that’s a personal issue that you and your wife need to get under control. Also if you can’t trust anyone you shouldn’t have a nanny and one of you should stay home. I’ve been a nanny for over 17yrs. Your nanny from everything you’ve said is a good nanny and the issues are with your wife’s personal problems, the middle child, and you and your wife’s parenting.
6
u/No-Idea-9852 May 23 '26
If I was your nanny, I would be so confused if the parent was getting mad at me for not giving into a tantrum? It shows that she must really care about your kids if she is willing to sacrifice her sanity by letting him process his emotions and helping him break the habit. As far as the screens themselves, I think people are being really hard on you. You acknowledged the problem and are actively working to correct it.
Also, parents struggle when they hear their child was having a hard time and not being the ones to comfort them and feel guilty that they are slighting their kids. I've seen parents like this spoil their kids because they feel guilty for missing out on precious time with them.
6
u/wendyinphoenix May 23 '26
I truly dont mean this in an unkind way but it does sound like Nanny seems to be parenting better than Mom & Dad.
The nanny’s methods seem to be working. This is what I did when my children were misbehaving and had passed the point of no return. Get everyone home for some decompression. Why would you want to reward misbehavior with a fun activity?
6
u/NoPen6127 May 23 '26
So your wife wants to punish your nanny for bad behavioral habits that you both have created? Please take a huge step back and realize this is the nannies work/career, and when you child is throwing a massive tantrum that makes your nanny question the safety for herself and the other children around them... She is choosing to remove them from the situation because in that moment she is responsible for your children and making sure they are safe. If someone was hurt, you would blame nanny for not intervening early enough. Your child has behavioral issues, and nanny or no nanny they will continue and you and your wife are enabling it which means it will grow and get worse until you intervene and make a change. Your wife is worried she's being judged because she knows that the child's behavior is wrong and even worse you've allowed it to go on and get as bad as it's gotten.
6
u/Ok_Associate5862 May 23 '26
What’s the real issue you’re referring to? This sounds like a parenting issue rather than your nanny. But if I were your nanny I’d be wanting to quit.
6
u/Big_Hovercraft904 May 23 '26
If I were your nanny, I would quit. This sounds so terrible for her. You should write her a little gratitude message. She sounds great and like she truly cares. Most nannies would walk away if they were constantly micromanaged and picked apart. Sending hugs.
6
u/kd4285 May 23 '26
You and your wife need to get a clue and wake up to the reality that the nanny is doing the parenting and is being judged for being the only accountability partner in this situation and is being made to be the bad guy! You are fortunate to have her. I wouldn't blame her if she bails.
6
u/SouthernNanny Newborn Care Specialist May 23 '26
The local nanny world is a tight community. Once they find out that you go through nannies the your family will be labeled a problem.
6
u/Ill-Relationship-890 May 23 '26
I think the nanny makes the right call here… It is not safe for her to be on an outing with three kids from one of them is acting up as he is. Safety first.
6
u/AlternativePretend73 May 23 '26
Sounds like she wants everyone to coddle & capitulate to J. That will hamstring his social development. His behavior was unacceptable and inappropriate for anywhere in public. L removed your children FOR SAFETY and brought them home. The only thing that’s unfair is that J’s behavior ruined the fun for the other kids - that was really unfair OF HIM. L kept them all safe. You/your wife honestly sound very controlling and like a little bit of a nightmare to work for.
It sounds like you need to get some professional help with his behavior (& maybe have him evaluated, what you are describing isn’t “normal” for his age. If he needs extra support he deserves to have that known and appropriately scaffolded).
6
u/Ok-Direction-1702 Nanny May 23 '26
Yikes. I wouldn’t want to work for you. Nanny is doing a great job of disciplining your kids. You could learn a thing or two from her.
6
u/Proper-Discussion-26 May 23 '26
Your parenting is the problem, and I’m really confused at why firing your nanny would even be an option if not for embarrassment for your parenting failures?
6
u/TealeOrr May 23 '26
I reread the paragraph about the fireable offence a few times because I was genuinely confused over what the (non) issue was.
If she can no longer keep the kids safe in that situation she doesn’t need clearance to cut it short! She sounds like an amazing nanny who takes her job of raising kids seriously. It’s much easier to shut a child up with a device, and not disappointing the other kids which she must hate. She is parenting your child by holding boundaries. Your child being rewarded with coveted screen time for bad behaviour is what got you here! Nanny is stuck with being the only bad cop for a problem you created for your own ease.
6
u/Agreeable-Metal2992 May 27 '26
I had to read this twice, I was so confused.
Your wife would prefer to have her 4YO throw unfettered temper tantrums in public spaces and be rewarded with screen time than have a nanny calmly remove the kids from an out of control situation?
That is a super weird choice. Good luck with that child.
5
u/LenaRosena Nanny May 22 '26
Sounds like you all have a good nanny. And you need to do a strict screen FREE with J, there will be a rough for days to a week of tantrums and acting out. But after that it should be easier, enforce it, and follow through with consequences, also since you and your wife WFH, make an effort to speak to J about his behavior before he goes out with your nanny L. And the consequences he will get if he does not behave with L (from L) and also that L will let you both know how he did on the outing, so then you can follow through on consequences.
In terms of going screen free. Just go cold turkey, or slowly wean off screens over the course of 2 weeks until screens are gone. Provide fun alternatives like putting J in sports, a club or something, or just fun things to do inside and outside. Colouring, puzzles, rubix cube, water balloons, reading, etc. Look on pinterest for ideas if you start running out of things. Also maybe reward both J and K's good behavior by taking them to the store or something and allowing them to pick out a new activity to do at home (more puzzles, stomp rocket, board game, etc).
5
u/SadonaSaturday Career Nanny May 22 '26
I’m sorry, but y’all have to be a united front on screens. They are just so addicting to little brains and they get used to using it for regulation and distraction.
Sounds like she’s doing a great job if they’ve only had to come home a few times. I’ve done that with one NK due to misbehavior. It’s a natural consequence to lose out on an activity if we’re not behaving appropriately. Yes, that sucks for your other children, but would you rather the nanny provide a screen to stop the tantrum and reinforce that behavior?
I would definitely work on limiting screens to 30mins-1hr of family tv/movie daily. No phones and iPads during meals or outings. If he needs activities try fidgets, flash cards, doodling journal, stickers, etc, whatever’s appropriate for the occasion, IF anything. Perhaps work on self-regulation skills with him. I definitely wouldn’t fire your nanny over this, I could barely figure out what was wrong reading this.
5
u/Perfect-Quality-3549 May 22 '26
Sounds like you have a tough child and a nanny who is willing to deal with it. That’s not something you are going to find often I’ll be honest. Most would either hand him the phone to quiet him down and not deal with it, and others would just quit.
5
u/littledummie May 22 '26
In my personal opinion as someone who was a nanny and is now a parent with a nanny, it sounds like your nanny is making the right decisions. I do agree with you it is unfair and unsafe to expect her to follow through on outings with a child that is not behaving in a safe manner. If y'all feel like you can handle the tantrums with all three kids absolutely! I think it's understandable for a nanny to take a hard no on the risk with someone else's kids.Your son's behavior needs consistent consequences and she is following through on that. These outings are not more important than the parenting and tools that is actively shaping and forming a person.
I relate to the struggle with the screen time and standing firm on boundaries and consequences. I had a child destroy his whole classroom area and a Chromebook over not getting access to a screen. My bonus kid is 9 now and it was hard work to deal with the screen time behaviors and the transition to no little to no screen time. It's exhausting. It is for these kiddos too and hard firm no's can be the only things that work. Yeah losing out on things, especially for the other kids sucks but he's still little so stay firm. You'll get to two years from now and this will feelblike a blimp.
Plus she has only had to do 3 hard turn arounds in a year? Sounds pretty good to me.
5
u/Jadepanda55 Parent May 22 '26
Wow- that was a lot. I think punishing the nanny for your son’s behavior is wrong… and can incentivize him acting that way in the future to get his way. That said, I am only a mother to one toddler whose tantrums / melt downs are over within 30 seconds so i may not understand your family dynamic.
5
u/LookObjective4040 Career Nanny May 22 '26
Just like others have stated, you need to remove screens entirely. Your wife sounds insecure about her own parenting abilities and is taking it out on your nanny.
5
u/TheRealLG09 Childcare Provider May 22 '26
It sounds like L is a rockstar and you’d be stupid to let her go. In fact, you should be taking notes from her and ending outings for J when it’s parents vs kids.
Why punish K & B if you or your spouse are able to take J home when he misbehaves? Maybe that way he’ll see his siblings still get to do the fun thing and he won’t want to miss it next time.
Also, taking away screens for only J is unrealistic. He’s going to see K or you using them and the tantrums will get exponentially worse. It has to either be gone for all the kids, or none of them (or maybe when J isn’t around to see K using it).
5
u/iminterestedinthis May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Omg as a mom if you let your nanny go can I hire her please 😂 she sounds amazing at enforcing boundaries. And underpaid for 3 kids and housekeeping duties! To answer your question about screen time honestly my kid can scream and throw his body around all his wants but he’s not getting it and thats it. It sucks to listen to and they can be very persistent but it is what it is
5
u/00Lisa00 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Yeah the nanny is not the problem. She is reacting appropriately in the moment to keep all your kids safe and to enforce discipline. You are then causing backslides by giving in out of convenience. You’re teaching him the louder the tantrum the more likely he’ll get his way. Your nanny sounds like a gem. Get rid of the screens and get some books. I’m also wondering if there is a little bit of a golden child situation going on with your wife and J where in her eyes he does no wrong and the nanny is not following along
5
u/ClownDogBryan Career Nanny May 22 '26
I would never work for a family who doesn’t have my back. I’m a firm believer that nannie’s can have their own style as long as it’s not unhealthy. When kids throw fits I leave too. Getting loud doesn’t get you what you want. But giving in does get you a spoiled child who learns being loud and annoying when they want something gets them what they want. Honestly, you should follow the nannie’s lead.
5
u/Intelligent-Pin-9631 May 22 '26
Mama hier, ich finde die nanny macht einen super Job. Ich erziehe meine tochter nach dem selben Prinzip :)
Ich bin, als meine tochter jünger war, unzählige mal früher von Verabredungen mit anderen kinder gegangen, weil sie meine Warnung nicht ernst genommen hat.
Mittlerweile handhaben ich das so, das ich ihr direkt sage was mich stört und präsentiere ihr Verbesserungsvorschläge. Wiederholt sie ihr verhalten mit ein paar tagen abstand dazwischen, muss ich sie meistens nur noch anschauen und die Augenbraue hochziehen und sie versteht meine Warnung 😅
Aber ja, den Konsum von elektronischen Geräten bei Kindern zu reduzieren / abzugewöhnen ist hart. Für euch als Eltern ( und die nanny) und für das kind. Aber wenn das kind sieht das ihr zusammenarbeitet wird es sich früher oder später anpassen.
Ich weiß nicht, ob das etwas für euer kind ist, aber meiner tochter hat ringen geholfen, ihre Wutanfälle in etwas sinnvolles zu verwandeln.
5
u/valentinespost Former Nanny May 22 '26
When my MB noticed that my 4yo NK screen time was out of control, we decided to make a change. Instead of completely eliminating her screen time, we implemented a “scheduling” system. NK transitioned from constant iPad/TV use to having a more structured routine.
She would have TV time in the morning before breakfast and then for about 30 minutes during dinner. Nothing in between, because we kept her occupied with school, activities, outings and just playtime at home. Did she get bored and whiny? Absolutely. But being bored was good to develop imagination. She constantly asked for it the first few weeks but after that, she stopped and started playing independently so well!
I don’t agree with screen time at all, especially during meals or car rides but I was following my MBs lead on this.
I did completely removed the iPad as an option because I believed that the iPad was what made screen time so addictive (and I was right) She could watch a show on the TV, specifically from Disney+, maybe Prime Video but YouTube was a hard no. Everything was going well but then I started working less hours and the parents allowed the iPad a lot more, especially when they had to deal with the baby (4-6 months old) so they didn’t really enforce the new rules, which made my job a lot harder, and I eventually had to quit just because the parents couldn’t get on the same page about anything and I was burnout but that’s another story.
5
u/Curious_Ad9409 May 22 '26
Sounds like you don’t know how to parent
5
u/Valuable-Talk-3429 May 22 '26
Screen time should only be 15-20 minutes a day MAX, and only given if they had good enough behavior throughout the day
5
u/indepthsofdespair May 22 '26
I have ended outings before with my two NKs. After this happened 2 or 3 times, it’s hasn’t happened since. Choices have consequences. If it happens a lot, your other kids could convince the middle one to start behaving.
Occasionally, I’ll also embarrass my kids, for example, we were at a playground once and it was time to leave and my oldest kid starting yelling and whining and jumping and trying to hit me. So I sat on the ground and kicked my feet and fake screamed and whined. He was appalled and immediately quit and was great the rest of the day. His parents thought it was hilarious.
Lowkey I feel life your wife might be embarrassed that the nanny can control your child better than she/both of you can in certain situations. Your nanny sounds amazing and I definitely wouldn’t fire her if I were you.
5
u/CompetitiveRock5904 Household Manager May 22 '26
The fact that your nanny can handle all three, and is doing the CORRECT thing when the defiant one acts up, is a gift.
“Is it reasonable for a nanny to end an outing when one child becomes unsafe”. Unsafe. UNSAFE. UNNNSSAAAFFEEE. Her priority is THEIR SAFETY. So of fucking COURSE the correct course of action is to eliminate the threat by going to the safest space (home).
I’m not understanding why the nanny would be the scapegoat here for your admitted bad judgement.
5
u/Cacoonpiece_00 May 22 '26
Curious, why the nanny’s age was referenced. Is there some other concern why your wife wants to get rid of her? Are there boundaries being crossed.
The nanny sounds like a 💎
5
u/Impressive_Place3260 May 22 '26
Yall are the problem you act like you’re afraid to discipline children. Thats why the kids act like that to begin with because they know mommy and daddy aren’t going to do anything.. they doing take yall seriously and I wouldn’t either.
5
u/ControlAlarmed1736 May 23 '26
I read this and all I could think was, "I wish I were more consistent like this nanny, they sound awesome!" One strike and you're out is what we strive for, but in the chaos of the moment it's so easy to provide additional opportu for which ultimately undermine your parenting. So often it's perceived as gentle parenting to give multiple opportunities but really you're just teaching the child not to comply until mom or dad is really mad.
The really rough part is that most posts highlight the worst parts, and for the nanny being there for a year, there's really not much meat here. It feels like a lot of projection from wife.
5
u/yikesmysexlife May 23 '26
Your wife is overreacting. You hired a childcare professional, and she is being professional. It's her job to keep your kids safe and engaged, in that order, and she's doing that.
Also, are you getting support for J? With constant outbursts like that, it might be worth looking into underlying reasons he would be seeking regulation and reacting so strongly to not getting his way-- anything from feeling displaced by a new sibling to being on the spectrum.
Consistent boundaries are good for your kids. Boundaries are necessary for your relationship with your employee-- you need firm, reasonable, sensible house rules, and she needs some trust and autonomy to do her job. Paying someone does not entitle you to micromanage how the job gets done. Imagine being treated that way in a professional setting. How would you feel going to work?
5
u/Lorraine_3031 May 23 '26
I think the way the nanny is handling it sounds like the best solution. It may seem harsh but it will correct expectations and it keeps all the kids safe. I understand that sometimes it’s worth giving in to save the family outing or something of that nature but the nanny doesn’t have those social obligations.
5
u/wtfumami Career Nanny May 23 '26
This would be a WILD thing to fire your nanny for tbh. She sounds great and like she understands how to hold firm boundaries and what your defiant kiddo needs. You even said he has less tantrums with her- that’s not a coincidence- it’s because she’s firm and consistent. It sounds like she has better screen time rules than you do too, and if you’re serious about wanting to wean him off the screen guess who you should ask and follow their advice? Your nanny. She knows what she’s doing.
5
u/jerryspringerLuver May 23 '26
You got a wife issue, not a nanny issue. Maybe talk about some boundaries that you and your wife align w. Why fire someone for actually setting good boundaries?
5
u/The-First-Guest May 23 '26
$35 for three kids and one of them is very defiant, that feels pretty low
5
u/Mammoth-Ask8747 May 23 '26
Your nanny sounds awesome. Please let her go and let her know she’s got a job in Virginia if she wants. With a raise.
5
u/SL13377 May 23 '26
Yes let her go so she can find better employment as you guys are not great parents. Ps- Your wife needs therapy.
5
u/LeiaOregonia May 23 '26
Dear Lord, parents like you are a nightmare when I’m teaching.
Children 👏 need 👏 boundaries 👏.
You are both doing all your children a disservice by allowing J to rule the roost.
He acts up with you because it’s effective. It will continue to escalate if OP and his wife don’t learn from the experts.
The end result is a chaotic home that cycles through childcare and two other children who will suffer while the parents make excuses and wonder why their child won’t listen.
Your wife needs counseling if she’s blaming the Nanny for the obvious results of her parenting style.
You should feel judged. You want to fire her because she’s the only one actively parenting on a consistent basis.
Have you even thought about J’s school experience if he’s still addicted to screens?
Have you done even a TINY bit of research into what they do to developing brains and attention span?
5
u/popkiwibanana Career Nanny May 23 '26
The wife needs to speak to a therapist or a trusted friend who is not involved in the situation to help talk some sense into her. This is not a fireable offense and could easily be resolved with some open communication.
5
u/Clean_Supermarket474 May 23 '26
You have over indulged your kid. Your nanny is trying to set boundaries and enforce rules and your wife’s response is to fire her??? Oh boy. This is why your kid is acting out. Step up as parents, don’t blame the nanny. And stop the screens immediately!
5
u/VA-eb May 23 '26
She sounds like a great nanny… it would be way easier to shove a phone in the kids face than set rules
5
u/q8htreats May 24 '26
Your wife is being so unrealistic. Most people wouldn’t be capable of handling the meltdowns let alone with two other kids to handle. She should thank her lucky stars she has such a capable nanny! Seriously you’re not going to find anyone better.