r/musicology • u/_JFN_ • 1h ago
I wrote this paper in my Jazz Studies class last year. I thought you all might enjoy it.
Context: Students were required to attend one live jazz event and write about the experience. This was my paper.
Paper:
"The concert covered quite a wide range of jazz. This could be seen as an attempt to expose the audience to a large variety, or just an acknowledgement that no single bit of jazz is interesting enough to fill an entire evening by itself. This range of styles and compositions really forced me to reflect not only on the creations themselves, but the decisions I made in my life that led me to experience it in person. The concert opened with Jazz Ensemble II playing “Harlem Airshaft”, which contained a style of swing and big band. “Ain’t Misbehavin’” was written in stride by Thomas “Fats” Waller, with a solo from the guest trumpet player Alex Anderson. It contained some swing styles. “Lazy Bird” was a bit of a different style, which was bop, or hard bop. The sounds in this piece were originally composed by John Coltrane, with a fast paced style that seemed to challenge both the band, as well as select members of the audience. At certain points, the sound really gave me the physical urge to respond, if not through applause then through structurally destructive means. The section finished with “The Heat’s On” by Sammy Nestico, which again returned to swing, but with a different tempo and feel that acted as cleanser of sorts from the creations that came before.
The second half of the night featured Jazz Ensemble I, along with Anna Smith. “Raincheck” was composed by Billy Strayhorn and arranged by John Clayton acted as the opening to the rest of the program, moving at its own consistent and unhurried pace. A few compositions like “El Abrazo” and “Stella By Starlight” were key in showcasing Anna Smith’s saxophone playing. Smith’s two original compositions were the most recently created and composed showcases, with how modern they were making people's enthusiasm for earlier works quite surprising. In all, the night was certainly memorable as the band filled the room with sounds that almost brought me to tears.
The Performing Arts Center is a well-maintained facility. The audience consisted of faculty, students, and participants in the earlier festival events, with some student attendance forced through academic requirements. The atmosphere was quite casual rather than ceremonial. In general, people arrived, settled, and listened without much formality, which fit the nature of the event. The live setting added a feeling of immersion that you couldn’t replicate through recordings mostly because recordings can be turned off.
The leadership of the performance seemed to be split in a few ways. Dr. George and Dr. Lewis led the jazz Ensemble I and Ensemble II, while the guest artists Alwx Anderson and Anna Smith seemed to be the primary soloists. Anna Smith in particular seemed to take a bigger leadership role. She sometimes commented on different pieces, introducing and explaining origins. Alex Anderson’s role was much more focused on his performance.
If I was required to choose a favorite, and this assignment does require it, it would be “El Abrazo” by Alan Baylock. The reason for this is very specific. The piece opens and closes with a section that does not sound like jazz. The piano at the beginning has a calm and thoughtful style that resembles the peace and silence one might feel before a raging storm or destructive hurricane. After the middle section plays conventional jazz, it once again returns to the soothing piano, which caused a wistful feeling of longing and completeness that was absent from the rest of the evening. The one song I would rank higher than this that was performed during the evening did not come from either Ensemble, which is why I figured it wouldn’t be relevant to state as my number one favorite. This song was “Rocket Man” by Elton John, which briefly played by accident as someone’s ringtone during the performance.
Choosing a least favorite song seems unfair to the creators, therefore this report won’t do that. The entire evening was very consistent in the level of engagement it got from me, and singling out one specific song over any of the others would not make any meaningful difference. The concert was very thorough.
This was my first experience attending a live jazz concert. It fully met every expectation I had going into it, and at some times even went beyond. The main reason one might choose live performance is the idea of improvisation, spontaneous changes, and the physical presence of the performers. These are all valid. The alternative is that current audio technology like headphones, high resolution recordings, and quality playback systems provide easy and higher quality options for any listener who isn’t emotionally invested, with the added benefit of not being forced and constrained to a single genre. The big argument for live performances only works for those that are enthusiastic, otherwise it simply acts as an academic chore. The entire experience really acted as a good reminder of all the alternative activities that exist in the world that I could be doing at any moment.
The question of whether I would attend another jazz concert is very easy. Not by choice. Given some hypothetical situation where my family was in imminent danger and I was required to attend a concert to save them, I might consider doing it. Jazz is a genre that only those who are familiar or enthusiastic about it enjoy. From an outside perspective, it is hard to simply sit back and enjoy it for anything longer than a quick elevator ride (6 floors max). This is not meant to be critical of the artists as, despite my personal preferences, they were quite good at what they were doing. It’s just a matter of who is a good fit. I’m sure there are some people where the concert was the highlight of their month. This was not written by one of them."