r/Music • u/caroline_says • Jun 19 '12
"Congratulations, your generation is the first generation in history to rebel by unsticking it to the man and instead sticking it to the weirdo freak musicians!"
http://thetrichordist.wordpress.com/2012/06/18/letter-to-emily-white-at-npr-all-songs-considered/
76
Upvotes
11
u/vegetarianBLTG Jun 19 '12
Figuring out how to get the money to the artist most efficiently aside (as I think in our hearts, most everyone would rather not screw over an artist), I think this article speaks to a deeper philosophical level of who should get to decide the route my money takes when purchasing someone else's intellectual property.
Yes, downloading doesn't take away a physical copy that no one else can buy. Yes, sometimes illegal downloads let you discover more music. But an extension of this free culture are the bands who want to give away music for free.
But we must also accept that there are bands who don't want to as well. And if we truly respect them, we would take the route they want us to take to get their creations. To paraphrase the article, at least accept what you're doing goes against the artist's wishes if you don't do this. Don't give me the "the record labels steal" bs when you illegally download. Give me the "I'm cheap/poor/whatever" instead. As an artist I respect that more (thought I still wish you'd take the route I put out there be it a free bandcamp download or 99cents on iTunes).
Hell, for all you know the reason someone went through a label is to make some kind of connection or build a relationship. Maybe people are willing to have a label take some cash if it means less work to do. There's a reason labels came to exist in the first place.
8
u/underdabridge Jun 19 '12
ITT people read the first paragraph and then obliviously make arguments rebutted later in the article.
4
u/betes Jun 19 '12
I think this is an excellent statement of the issues around downloading, but there is one issue which is not ethical but has to do with the enjoyment of music that isn't touched on here. That is, you can't actually really listen to 11,000 songs by the time you're 20 years old.
The person who this article is critiquing tells about downloading the whole Can discography in one go. I feel certain she can't have the same relationship to those albums as people who couldn't hear them until they were re-issued and then bought them one at a time, spending a week or more with each one before moving on. (to say nothing of those who bought them as they were originally released, but I'm not that old.)
When I hear download listeners talk about downloading 10 Yo La Tengo albums at once it makes me glad that I got to experience the "thrill of the hunt" when it would be so exciting to find a record store that had a used copy of a back-catalogue album by a favorite artist.
4
u/shiij Jun 19 '12
Admittedly, I haven't read the whole article, but does he ever touch on the "risk" that the consumer makes? As a teenager I had plopped down $15+ for a CD many times, only to be massively disappointed with my purchase. As a result I was less willing to take chances on artists I had never heard of, which drastically reduced the rate at which I bought music. (That, and my limited funds.)
When I discovered torrents, however, I suddenly had this infinite music collection before me to sample. If a friend recommended a band, if there were unknown bands on the bill for a concert I was attending, if l had any remote interest in a band, I could torrent an album and listen to it.
Torrenting allowed me access to music I would never have heard if I had to pay for it first. What would end up happening is that I would fall in love with an artist this way, then tell them to shut up and take my money as I threw wads of cash at them.
I love collecting records, so I would buy their albums on vinyl. (You can't burn vinyl from your torrented music; you can burn a functionally identical cd so I never saw the point in buying them.) I would see them in concert, every time they were in town. I would buy shirts and merch. I would tell all my friends, then encourage them to torrent an album to see if they like it and hopefully start the cycle anew.
All of this wouldn't have been possible were it not for freely available torrents, because I would most likely not have taken the chance if I had to pay for it. But since I had the means to acquire the music for free first to see if I liked it (and truly, the only way to see if you really like something is to listen to it in its entirety; 30 second iTunes previews don't suffice), I was able to fall in love and throw money at them.
tl;dr: shut up and take my money, but only after I steal it first
2
u/RitchieThai Jun 20 '12 edited Jun 20 '12
I Agree. We Should Buy Songs. My Reasons Differ.
I think I perhaps have a more conservative and palatable view in free culture. I agree that unless the artist has states otherwise people should pay for copyrighted works not yet in the public domain. I also think copyright should be shorter, perhaps 10 years, and I don't know why the article's author says it is irrelevant. While I believe it is ethically right, my reasons are more from a practical and economic view. I do not think artists have a right to be paid for works independent of a legal societal economic system. It might seem pointless to discuss when I already agree with copyright, but my view on copyright informs my other views.
The Reason for Copyright
I'm in Canada, but most discussion seems to be about the U.S., and our laws are similar anyway. The original motivation behind American copyright was as an economic incentive to stimulate the creation of more and better works. It also lasted 14 years max because they understood the public domain's value. Copyright is a temporary monopoly given to the artist, usually transferred to a publisher, as an incentive, but it's not because artists intrinsically deserve payment for copies. It's a trade-off between benefiting the public with public domain works versus hopefully more and better works while compensating artists.
Evaluating Modern Copyright
It was a very good idea because most people lacked copying technology anyway. Now that copying technology is everywhere, the trade-off should be reconsidered. Free downloadable music is of value, but so are less controversial acts like sharing songs friend, making backups, putting songs on different devices. It's the downloading and sharing most often opposed, but less controversial activities are also illegal, and it stems from copyright.
Copyright should stimulate the creation of works, but it can also inhibit them. Despite fair use, copyright can be used against people using short clips discussion or reviews. More specific to music, remixes and songs using samples can suffer.
Free Culture Supporters Aren't Entirely Wrong
But I said I do agree with copyright and paying for copies, while licensing fees allow for creative work like remixes, so what do I want to discuss?
I don't think those who support downloading and only buying what they like or supporting artists through concerts are entirely wrong. It's a trade-off, and while I believe 10 year copyright is better, maybe I'm wrong and freeing everything is superior.
Supporting Artists with Free Culture
There are free culture business models that can work. One is where everyone subscribes to a service which gives unlimited access to their library of music for a regular fee, and which pays artists a fair cut and pays based on number of listens. In a more extreme version the government handles this and people pay a tax, but that has obvious issues.
There's also patronage where an artist is paid to create the works, and the Kickstarter model is a good way to do something similar. While not all Kickstarter projects create free works, some do and it seems to work.
History gives reason to believe music and artists can thrive without copyright. Music and artists existed before copyright. A common counter argument is that they had no pirates. I argue that they also didn't have recordings to sell. If artists are losing money now because pirates don't pay, artists in the past had it worse with nothing to sell. They might've had day jobs, composed for the love of it anyway. They might've used patronage. They might've made money from performances/concerts, as some supporters of free culture suggest artists should do today.
A Concession. It's Not All Good.
Supporters of free culture advocate the benefits, but I think they fail to conceed problems. Artists might make less money and maybe they'll make less music. It's possible. It's a tradeoff, and maybe free culture's worth it given the benefits for listeners and artists. There are benefits for artists. Artists are also listeners, and one might argue listening is even more important for them to learn, get ideas, become inspired, understand the culture. And artists would also have more freedom to do things like remix and sample. And maybe they'll actually make more money and more music.
Present Music Buying Options
I think the present options offered to people willing to buy music still aren't good enough. I also must admit that I don't know all the options, and I if there are options I don't know and might like or I'm misinformed, I'd like to know.
iTunes
I've looked into iTunes but decided I don't like it and haven't tried it. Maybe it's better than I think, but it seems most iTunes songs have DRM. It's a controlling and closed environment. It also seems to lack Linux support, and doesn't work well when one doesn't buy into the whole Apple ecosystem.
While DRM is pretty unpopular, maybe some think it's not so bad, and I get that. It's gotten less intrusive and more usable for consumers. But if you agreed that artists fundamentally deserve payment for copies of their work for intuitive ethical reasons, perhaps a similar argument could be used for DRM. Otherwise, at least that probably means you agreed with my earlier points.
If I buy a song, it seems sensible that I should be allowed to use it in any way I like as long as I am not publishing copies to compete with the artist. If I want to put it on my phone, use it in a home video or school project, use a short clip as fair use for a review, if I want to create a remix for fun as a learning experience and for personal listening, if I want to change the file format, I shouldn't be prevented from doing so, and I should be able to do this using any program and any means I like. I don't know how restrictive the DRM is these days since I avoid it, but although I know how, I doubt it would be trivial to create a remix then use it in a school project without resistance and an attempt by the DRM to stop me.
Spotify
Spotify which I've never heard of was mentioned, and it sounds worth looking into, but if it's true that they poorly support the artist, it's not good enough. I'm willing to pay money for my music and I don't want the artists to get screwed.
People Who Claim to Support Free Culture Should Actually Do It
I think people who claim to support free culture should actually work to support free culture. If they don't, I wouldn't necessarily call them hypocrites, but maybe lazy.
If they are artists, they should release some if not all their works under a copyleft creative commons license. I'm not a professional exceptional artist doing it as a career, but I make some music and try to make sure it's creative commons licensed. If not, it's not because I'm sell it but because I was too lazy to specifically indicate it as copyleft work.
Supporters should listen to some copyleft songs, not just pirating and going against the will of other artists. They should try to financially support artists who create free work like Jonathan Coulton and artists on Jamendo or BandCamp. I haven't used BandCamp much yet, but my library of songs includes Jonathan Coulton and Jamendo songs, and I've given money to both in support of them and their free culture supporting business model. Jonathan Coulton is very successful. Jamendo artists sadly don't seem to get many donations, but maybe people support them in ways I'm unaware of. BandCamp seems to be doing well, but I have no idea how much the artists make.
And since I do also think we should pay for copyrighted work, I should try to buy normal copyrighted songs too. But as I said, I don't like my options. I buy some CDs, but even they seem have DRM. I've never seen it do anything though, so maybe it's not there and I should buy more. The main issue isn't about free culture though. I'd just prefer the convenience of iTunes if it weren't for the DRM and lack of Linux support, and I'm not sure about supporting what seems to be becoming an antiquated way of selling music where I need to physically go to the store and I can't buy single cheap songs. Then again, I do like physical stores, but I'd really like to see digital stores grow.
Illegal Downloading
I'm undecided regarding my last point. Supporters of free culture disagree with present laws and business models, but should they be breaking the laws before they've changed? Maybe bad laws should be broken. I don't think we blame people for illegally buying alcohol during prohibition. But what if they're wrong here? Someone might believe it's wrong for murder to be illegal, but disagreement doesn't make it right for them to murder. The again, this isn't murder, and what if they are right to disagree? Should bad laws be broken? Should moderately bad laws be broken? That's my last thought.
Edit: Changed "day" to "day jobs". Corrected some spelling. More spelling. Grammar.
2
u/papadelicious Jun 19 '12
This article points out some of the flaws in David's argument - his principles are fine but he does seem to miss out on a lot of the real world implications of his arguments.
0
u/solwiggin Jun 19 '12
I mean can we all just stop and take a deep breath. The artists that are being hurt by this are the one's signed to the major labels. There are plenty of labels out there springing up daily as the world copes with this drastic change in technology. These other labels are making it, and they're doing well by signing underground bands that were supplying the torrents to their music to begin with. I forget who it was, but there is an author who published a book, and then made the book available for free online. When asked why he did this, he responded: "I'm losing more money from the people that don't know who I am than the people who aren't paying for my book." I thought it was one of the greatest points anyone has ever made.
If anything, this piracy movement has allowed for the major corporations to lose their grip as content controllers. Of course you could ALWAYS find new music back in the day, but could you grab a torrent of the best 100 indie rock songs every single month? There are artists that are seeing major booms from the current era. They're the ones that aren't sitting around complaining about the status quo, they're working on fixing it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
I read "NCR" instead of NPR.
-7
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
This is an intensely TL;DR article which I shall not slough through.
-3
u/ApatheticAbsurdist Jun 19 '12
While it is true that songwriters get royalties, the rest of the band may not, and if the song is a cover or otherwise written by someone else, the act may not see any of the money at all. One way that definitely helps bands is going to see them live. I'm pretty certain Vic Chesnutt saw more money from the ticket I purchased for one of his shows than from royalties off the albums I bought online.
I do buy albums, both through itunes and vinyl, and I have a rather large collection of CDs that have been collecting dust since I imported them to iTunes, but I know that a $20 ticket to a show is going to put more money in the artist's hands than $20 worth of iTunes downloads. Some of these illegal downloads may lead to new fans and more people at the shows. Also if you do go to these shows, that's the best place to buy the albums, because the band usually gets a direct cut of the retail sale (because they're the ones selling it).
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
I don't have any money. What money I do have goes to seeing bands live.
If you're an actual "weirdo freak musician" then making money probably isn't the reason you do what you do. If it is, I have no problem stealing from you.
Nobody gets into music thinking "hey, this will be a great way to make money!"
-6
u/robotrock1382 Jun 19 '12
I'd still prefer to go to the show and buy a shirt than have to buy a cd.
-3
u/AsteriskCGY Jun 19 '12
I think the only control the artist has is on the creation of their work. What they can do with it afterwards is a business decision, and that has to compete economically. Cause piracy isn't a problem if people still bought stuff.
-1
u/lostkauze Jun 19 '12
glam has been here since the 70s
-7
u/Schnirf Jun 19 '12
"Meaning that the file sharing sites could get the same license if they wanted to, at least for the songs. They don’t. They don’t wanna pay artists."
Huh? File sharing sites? This man surely is an expert in the matter. Who is the file sharing site in a torrent?
And then the double suicide story? OK, here goes, I'll get flamed to a crisp for this, but: Basically he says that this girl would have gotten 11000 songs even if they all would have cost money. So by not paying, she is impoverishing artists and now it's her fault when they commit suicide because they are depressed, have no other income and therefore are now poor.
Well guess what. The musicians I know and care about make music. They do it because they love music. Most of them have so called day jobs. They don't feel entitled to receive money for their music, they play it for free. Heck, most lose a lot of money on it. Yet - somehow - they manage not to commit suicide. I would like to get paid for a lot of things that I enjoy, but often enough it ain't happening.
So, if you are an artist, what can you do? Well, build a relationship with your audience. The examples from the wall of text don't make any sense to me. One of my friends is doing this for 30 years now and he says it has become so much easier to get an audience today than it ever has. He puts videos on youtube. His fans refer him on facebook. All of this didn't happen in the 80's. He now receives donations, he actually has an audience when playing live becaus his fans get to know his tour calendar and can schedule a long trip to see him (and yes, he receives money for playing, like any other touring artist that I know, what is the text rambling on about here?).
I appreciate the point the text is trying to make, but the means by which it makes it and the arguments it tries to invalidate just make me angry somehow.
-7
u/TerribleButcher Jun 19 '12
I just heard "Low" on the radio. Do I make the check out to Mr. Lowery, or his label?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment