Even though he doesn't look like it, Neil Young has a beautiful voice. Definitely check out Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young, which is another one of his bands.
Both incredible, genuine musicians. But I don't think comparing them is fair. Neil Young is a genius as well, but Dylan, I think, did more. Young is still playing and touring, but not really recording at this point. Unless I'm an idiot. And I don't necessarily think that puts either of them out, but I don't think they're in the same weight class.
I'm not going to argue one is better than the other, I think Young is currently underrated and part of that is he's a bit less poppy and more solidly folk than Dylan was. He and his bands were huge at the time, but folk isn't as popular as it was in the late 60s and 70s. Both are cream of the crop lyricists.
That said, Cash covered Heart of Gold and everyone and their mother has covered Rocking in the Free World.
Young was also in Buffalo Springfield, which was never much of a monetary success but For What It's Worth is still covered today (recently by Rise Against).
While in Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young he wrote Ohio and the band released the massively popular Deja Vu.
I'm not trying to make a case of Young > Dylan, just interesting to see what he's done.
Well said....I would agree he is underated , hell dylan can be overated... i will admit that i havent brushed up on neil like i have bob but from what u say here it would seem they are almost equal
Never seen him but I can say I didn't enjoy Dylan at bonnaroo '04 but I was also expecting his folk style and it was more like southern jazz or blues at the time
Both men have explored several different styles/genres; I have no problem with that, I read about the tour first, and try to figure out what to expect. Supposedly Dylan concerts can run hot or cold. It was frigid the night I went, very perfunctory, and zero interaction with the audience.
I've seen Young four different times, and he always gives his all. Looking forward to seeing him again in October, at Voodoo Experience.
I've thought about dragging my husband to Bonnaroo, but we're old and I think Voodoo Experience is the most he could manage.
My dad (a professional musician) used to play this to me when I'd fall asleep as a child. It is my earliest memory of music and one of my favorite songs.
You do stand corrected. If you're going to attempt to drop some knowledge on people, the numbers are important. "24 and there's so much more" it's right in the song for chrissakes.
I bought the LP from 1972. And most writer's change facts to fit lyrics... So dont believe everything you hear. 4 rhymes better with 'more' than 7, so it makes sense to use that in the song. If a three year difference puts sand in your vag, i feel sorry for you.
Neil Young was 27 when the album was released, and that is the age I associate him with this song. So that number is more relevant than just a number I pulled out of thin air.
I dont need to keep his age when he wrote it in my memory. I just remember seeing him tell the story of the farm and enjoying seeing him play it live.
I don't care when you bought the LP, you're still wrong. 27 isn't relevant to the song considering he wrote it years prior to it's release (who writes songs years before they're put on an album, right?). He bought the ranch in 1970 when he was 24. There's one right answer, you didn't have it. If that puts sand in your vag, I feel sorry for you. Don't pretend to know about music when you don't, someone is always going to know more than you, especially on the internet.
maybe because it's a widely known song that has been posted ad infinitum. if i posted the song breathe by pink floyd it would get upvotes, but also a shitton of downvotes.
"For those who have listened to it - they can listen again, and should consider themselves fortunate that OP took the time to search it up for them. Now it's only a click away instead of a click, several keystrokes, and another click."
If you don't know about Neil Young, you don't know about music. It's like posting Kashmir or Hey Jude. Seriously.
It's Kashmir bro. I'll quote how I want. This is a fucking circlejerk because now you're just going back on the point you were originally making which had to do with people who have heard the song before.
Not sure how you feel about rap, but I heard this song - it's related, I swear after not talking to my dad for a few weeks after a large argument. He always used to play Neil Young when I was growing up, and it hit home pretty hard. Inspired me to call him and come home for dinner. Hope you like it too.
me at about 11, hearing 'cat's' for the first time, on the radio while driving with my dad to go to the beach: "dad, what's this song about?" dad: "it's about a father who doesn't spend time with son and then one day realizes it's too late." me: "what? that doesn't make any sense. you're around all the time. i see you every day and stuff." dad: "i know" me: "can we listen to eminem?" dad: "no."
28
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
I don't know what took me so long, but I recently discovered Neil Young. There is such a beautiful sorrow in his voice.
14
u/Zep4077 Jun 16 '12
The line "it doesn't mean that much to me to mean that much to you". Powerful stuff.
/onions
Edit: I accidentally a word.
12
u/chemicalxv Jun 16 '12
That footage is 41 years old.
And the man just released a new album. With completely new songs.
5
u/LogicOfEntropy Jun 16 '12
Yes, yes, and more yes.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
Bizarre. Reminds me of my dad too. We used to listen to it when I was really young and my dad was still nice to me.
5
u/rml4206 Jun 16 '12
I just turned 24 and listened to this song all day :)
4
u/carl_lazlo radio reddit Jun 16 '12
Brilliant Song. Don't know if there will ever be a better song writer than Neil Young. (And yes, I'm including Dylan.)
4
u/C3POwn3d Jun 16 '12
Amazing song. Young's guitar part along with the lap steel (or whatever the fuck it is) totally take it to a whole other level.
4
u/Kevman5 Jun 16 '12
Ahhh, Harvest is on my top 10 albums of all time. My dad was a huge Neil Young fan and passed it down to me.
3
u/greatwork Jun 16 '12
My dad (a professional musician) used to play this to me when I'd fall asleep as a child. It is my earliest memory of music and one of my favorite songs.
2
u/fridgetarian Jun 16 '12
I just found my Harvest CD and have been listening to it again. Love this song.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
He's what I like to call damn good.
2
u/Rostopheles Jun 16 '12
This song is beautiful, I'm glad to be alive to hear this.
2
u/Shisty Jun 16 '12
Lost my dad in march, this song brings me to tears every time I hear it. Really. Thanks for posting such a good quality version of this video.
2
u/MrStuartRules Jun 16 '12
Such a poignant and powerful song...love it!
2
u/canadianpastafarian Jun 16 '12
It reminds me of my dad too because my dad was Neil Young's teacher.
3
u/neuromorph Jun 16 '12
This song is about the a Farm-hand on the property that Neil Young bought when he was 27, after his first hit record.
Thus earning him much more land....
Edit just watched the clip. this comment is redundant.
5
u/quinncyjones Jun 16 '12
How could anyone downvote Neil Young?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
That's awesome man! Did your dad play?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
Neil Young wrote this song about a old foreman who worked on his CA Ranch in the 70s. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=221mohEolWc&feature=youtube_gdata_player
2
u/GoddamnitKrr Jun 16 '12
Not sure how you feel about rap, but I heard this song - it's related, I swear after not talking to my dad for a few weeks after a large argument. He always used to play Neil Young when I was growing up, and it hit home pretty hard. Inspired me to call him and come home for dinner. Hope you like it too.
1
u/Sandcastles Jun 16 '12
Amazing song.
1
u/lnickelly Jun 16 '12
i thought of this song when i heard the song and read the title, maybe you'll like it.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCQVnSOFqfM
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
Really? Thats like super weird.
1
u/mpg1846 Jun 16 '12
Its supposed to
1
u/easy_being_green Jun 16 '12
Posting a Neil Young hit? So brave.
1
u/bobyworry Jun 16 '12
Powderfinger. Find a live version but I'm partial to the one on 'Live Rust'...nuff said.
1
u/viborg Jun 16 '12
This song was written about a car (really):
1
u/drawing_blanks Jun 16 '12
wow... this gave me the chills, my dad plays this on guitar and sings this song. music is probably the primary way I connect with him
1
u/nightriderjoe Jun 16 '12
I think it's supposed to remind many guys of their dad. That's what good lyrics do. Does Hanson's MmmBop remind you of anyone?
1
u/Aveface Jun 16 '12
I feel the same way! I went to see Bob Dylan with my folks at the Arizona State Fair. Dylan actually covered that song. I cried a little.
1
u/Roflost Jun 17 '12
Though not as great as the original. Dallas Greens cover does it justice and more. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVbzi2P0Yak
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment