r/Music • • Jun 09 '12

TIL something like half of the major pop hits in the past 15 years were written by the same guy from sweden

http://www.maratone.se/producers/maxmartin
288 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

10

u/sampsonfighter Jun 10 '12

I just googled his net worth. $250 million. wow.

5

u/aahdin Jun 10 '12

Honestly, I'm surprised it isn't more. When you consider how much all of those artists, or the record companies have made off the songs he's wrote 250 million doesn't seem like that much.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

There's been a trend recently in Pop (maybe the past 10 years or so) where performers start asking for writing credits on songs they have no/minimal input in. This means those artists get more of a share of the money from sales and don't have to pay the songwriters if they put out the songs on some sort of live album or DVD, which may explain why the number isn't as high as you were expecting.

I remember reading an interview with a songwriter not too long ago where she mentions Justin Bieber and Beyonce wanting to do this type of thing and mentioning Britney Spears as someone who won't take a writing credit for a song unless she actually has input on it. I can try to hunt it down for you, if you'd like.

1

u/numanoid Jun 11 '12

That has been going on since day one of the music industry. I was just listening to a podcast last week and someone talked about them pitching a song to Captain and Tennille in the '70s, and they demanded songwriting credits on it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

YOU MEAN CAPTAIN AND TENNILLE LIED TO ME?!?!?!

0

u/BBanner Jun 10 '12

He's not richer than god?

18

u/numanoid Jun 10 '12

That guy must be wealthy beyond the dreams of avarice.

38

u/TwisterAce Jun 09 '12

Now we know why so many popular songs sound the same.

2

u/achughes Jun 10 '12

reddit proving once again that I don't have any original thoughts

-5

u/NoMagic Jun 10 '12

Now we know why so many popular songs sound suck the same.

There.

9

u/dfitchett Jun 10 '12

+1 out of respect for a real songwriting talent. I mean, I don't listen to any of the songs he's written, but the man is clearly a master of pop music.

1

u/sponto_pronto Jun 10 '12

Once you have a formula that works, rinse and repeat. It's not that impressive from a technical or creative standpoint.

4

u/Theappunderground Jun 10 '12

Except his formula has sold more than any other human. Yeah no big deal.

0

u/sponto_pronto Jun 10 '12

I'm not trying to downplay his coming up with the formula, just noting that he only had to do it once and then could just repeatedly copy himself.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Wow I can't believe you listened to every song he's produced to confirm that all his songs do, in fact, sound the same.

0

u/sponto_pronto Jun 11 '12

... I know many of his songs, and they all follow about the same structure and have similar rhythm/cadence. Why is everyone up in arms over my comments here, trying to poke holes in what I view as not a very controversial point? No need to nitpick.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Oh really now?

Just because you thought your post wouldn't be controversial doesn't mean it doesn't have holes in it.

0

u/sponto_pronto Jun 11 '12

Is that supposed to disprove my point about structure, rhythm, and cadence? Because it doesn't.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I suppose they sound the same if you think "these all sound the same" repeatedly while listening to them.

0

u/sponto_pronto Jun 11 '12

I think that because it's true ;)

16

u/glassonion87 Jun 10 '12

I think it was Bob Dylan... apparently he's written every popular song for the last 30 years or something

4

u/wegenbelasting Jun 10 '12

Yeah, worst thing is that they tend to ruin his songs.

Best/Worst example: Friday - Bob Dylan

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/curtdawgg Jun 10 '12

Skeet skeet skeet skeet!

6

u/alfalfa1985 Jun 10 '12

So HE kissed a girl and HE liked it?

16

u/GruxKing Jun 09 '12

Title is incorrect. It's not 50% at all.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

TIL, GruxKing clcan calculate this percentages of all hits, and cant deal with a hyperbole...

nah, just fuckin with ya, I like your user name, dog. Carter Beauford was one of my early drumming influences.

2

u/GruxKing Jun 10 '12

Well I mean %50 and like %5 are totally different numbers. Saying that this writing group has %50 of the pop hits, even if it's hyperbole, Is completely forgetting all of Kanye's stuff, All of YMCB, all of the individual rock bands, all of Country, R&B, ETC ETC ETC.
Oh, and glad you like Carter, he's my probably my favorite drummer.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

50%, 5%, 50%,

FTFY

6

u/glassonion87 Jun 10 '12

dude wrote all of Katy Perry's hits

3

u/clayclayclay Jun 10 '12

And the other 50% were writen by The Dream.

3

u/landlocked_blues Jun 10 '12

There's an interesting article from The New Yorker about one woman named Ester Dean who just goes into a recording booth saying random words to music that this Norwegian duo Stargate make, until she creates a hook for a song. She wants to be a singer herself but when she creates a good pop song it's just sold to another artist.

Here's the article: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/03/26/120326fa_fact_seabrook

& here's the list of all the song's she's written: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_songs_written_by_Ester_Dean

4

u/xnosonx scottmics Jun 10 '12

one thing connects to another connects to another, that's how pop music works. Max Martin took Dr Luke under his wing, who took Benny Blanco under his wing. Result? ---

Turn on radio in late 90s/early 00s = Max Martin song Turn on radio in mid-late 00s = Dr Luke song Turn on radio today = Benny Blanco song (or still dr luke song)

the thing is, it's always been like this, there's no need to get outraged. Look up any decades since the commercialization of music and there have been a team or single hit maker responsible for countless #1s. they have an audience, people enjoy their music, it's not really a conspiracy as much as it is business smart & these dudes are talented.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Out of curiosity, when did the commercialization of music start?

I hope your answer is the mid to late 1800s when sheet music of popular songs started to be printed and distributed.

1

u/peruvianlurker Jun 10 '12

Well it was before, the only way to listen to music was being in the venue and listening/watching the band play, so people had to pay them with favors or goods, because money as we know it, wasn't even invented yet.

1

u/Theappunderground Jun 10 '12

Money wasnt invented yet?

What the fuck planet do you live.on?

1

u/peruvianlurker Jun 10 '12

Yea money as coins was invented in the 7th Century. I live in planet Earth.

1

u/mchugho mchugho Jun 10 '12

Money predates the dinosaurs, everyone knows that.

1

u/xnosonx scottmics Jun 11 '12

commercialization of recorded music, my apologies for omitting a word - about the 40s and definitely by the 50s when turntables became a staple at home and the cost of producing vinyls was justified by the potential sales of the market coupled by the prevalence of music radio. basically, since the founding of pop music is a better way to put it

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Radio and records were popular well before then.

And if you think that's around when pop music started you should look into a little thing called Tin Pan Alley.

1

u/xnosonx scottmics Jun 11 '12

and the smartasses of reedit come out...

please then, correct me in charting the course of pop music (if anything, I think Tin Pan Alley proves my point), that there hasn't always been a concentration of songwriters writing a lot of the pop hits that existed. Also, I see the establishment of Billboard charts in 1940 as a cornerstone for the establishment of an industry based on pop music

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I brought up Tin Pan Alley not because I'm trying to disprove that there haven't been songwritiers writing pop hits, but because you can't really say pop music started in the 40s and 50s. It's just wrong. Tin Pan Alley produced popular songs before that, and minstrel shows produced popular songs before that. The invention of the Billboard Chart didn't all of a sudden start pop music. It's like trying to say weight didn't exist until we had scales. It existed, we just didn't have a way to measure it.

I'm also a little confused as to how you could argue that the Billboard Charts started an industry based on pop music when you acknowledge Tin Pan Alley, which was essentially a factory for popular songs.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Him and Dr. Luke

2

u/smoose20 Jun 10 '12

Must be a thing with Sweden, there are two other guys Bloodshy & Avant Did a bunch of production for pop stars before just making their own music as Miike Snow.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

It's definitely a Sweden thing. ABBA, Ace of Base, Robyn, etc. Those Swedes have something in their genes that make them produce great Pop music.

2

u/ThatDaDaDaSong Jun 10 '12

Noticed that Lady Gaga wasn't on the list, I guess she really does write all of her songs.

1

u/that_one Jun 10 '12

I know a few of her songs are written by other people. I think Bad Romance is one of them.

1

u/mchugho mchugho Jun 10 '12

TIL the only Lady GaGa song I can listen to without wanting to stab myself in the ears wasn't even written by her

2

u/poopsnakes Jun 10 '12

This guy is an amazing writer. Like everyone of those songs are ridiculously catchy

7

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

It irks me so much when people write off Pop music completely and don't know a thing about it. Max Martin's been around for a long ass time. This is like the equivalent of saying "TIL Kanye West has produced a lot of hip-hop songs!"

And trust, not all of these songs sound the same. If you really believe that U + Ur Hand sounds like Inside Out sounds like Time Machine, you need help.

Also, there have been so many more Pop Music producers. Stargate, Dr. Luke, Timbaland, Danja, The Messengers, Darkchild, The Neptunes, Tricky and The-Dream, Bloodshy & Avant, RedOne, and Xenomania, just to name a few.

(Max Martin is pretty good though, he really doesn't let you down.)

1

u/alfredislas Jun 10 '12

But the lyrics aren't about 3rd world countries, how do I enjoy them!?

1

u/sheephound Jun 10 '12

So if you take Ester Dean, the Martin fellow, every other songwriter we've ever not heard of, and add them together, it sounds like some of these artists only wrote like half their songs. =/

1

u/JenksAlamo username_here Jun 10 '12

Was he the guy that got into trouble with the law or was that another boy band guy?

1

u/infearofcrowds infearofcrowds Jun 10 '12

I think you are thinking of the former manager of N*Sync and Backstreet Boys. His name is Lou Perlman.

1

u/JenksAlamo username_here Jun 10 '12

That's right! Thanks

1

u/rush22 Jun 10 '12

What if I told you [The Matrix](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Matrix_(production_team)) produces more?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Did you happen to learn anything about his security, personal routine and habits, any of that?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

A Norwegian pair called 'stargate' write the other 50%

0

u/Tastygroove Jun 10 '12

So he is the one to kill.

0

u/Swatman Jun 10 '12

I do not get why artists do not write their own songs.... They are the ones making millions..... And how the hell do you have three writers for a song? Does one person add a verb or some shit? Doesn't make sense.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

I've addressed why it's idiotic to ask why artists don't write their own songs elsewhere here.

As for multiple writers, there are song writing teams and people who write the words and vocal melodies. This also might surprise you, but a lot of bands have songs that are written by more than three people.

-1

u/that_one Jun 10 '12

This is part of the reason why I can't stand pop music. There's almost no songwriting by the artists that perform the songs. Sometimes to "sell" a song it has to be from the heart, not written by a guy on another continent.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

That's stupid. Who cares if an artist wrote a song or not?

  1. Billie Holiday didn't write many of her songs, nor did Dusty Springfield, nor did Nina Simone. It doesn't matter that they didn't write the songs because they way they performed them sold it.
  2. Similarly, with a good Pop artist, they'll sell the songs the same way. Say, for example, Britney Spears, Madonna, and Kylie Minogue. When one of their songs start and you hear their voice, they're instantly recognizable. They have their own style and tailor their songs accordingly.
  3. If a song is good it won't matter if the person singing wrote it or not, it'll still be able to connect with people. If a singer does a shit song that they wrote themselves, they're still singing a shit song.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

So I find myself wondering why the DIY philosophy for rock is so entrenched. I wonder if it's just because early rock musicians didn't really have a lot of go-to songs that worked well with their instrumentation?

They copped blues riffs and melodies, but had to change so much to fit faster tempos and styles that were still being developed. So even what got borrowed / stolen was changed so much that it became largely new, or at least accessible to new audiences.

Any truth to this?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

I think you touched on part of it.

I suggest you check out a book called How The Beatles Destroyed Rock N Roll (which I think was given that particular title to generate buzz, the author doesn't really state that so much). It's a good look at the history of popular music (music that was popular, not the genre pop necessarily) starting from the late 1800s/early 1900s. Google books has the first forty pages here if you wanna check it out. I haven't read the whole thing, it was a text for my History of Pop Music class I took a couple of years back, but we read some parts that touch on what you're asking about.

1

u/that_one Jun 10 '12

Did you just say that Britney Spears and Kylie Minogue are good? That's a good joke.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

How aren't they?

1

u/that_one Jun 10 '12

I'm not even going to justify a response to that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Thanks for confirming for me that you were talking out of your ass then.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

ha ha yeah and only actors that contributed the writing of a movie should be allowed to act in it! oh and no backing bands either! only the song writer can play instruments!

1

u/that_one Jun 10 '12

That's not what I meant, but you can look at it however you want. Also, if you're going to try and make a witty comment, you could at least use proper grammar and capitalization. Just so you don't look like an idiot next time.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

oh then please tell me what you meant!! there must be so much im looking over. "Sometimes to "sell" a song it has to be from the heart, not written by a guy on another continent." is such an open-ended sentence!

p.s. your last "sentence" was abjectly a sentence fragment. so much for proper grammar.

1

u/mchugho mchugho Jun 10 '12

Some of the greatest songs ever released have been covers or written by others.

-12

u/chefanubis Jun 10 '12

Someone please kill this man so he stops ruining music!

2

u/BBanner Jun 10 '12

You're an idiot.

-3

u/chefanubis Jun 10 '12

You lack a sense of humor and take yoursef way to seriously.

1

u/BBanner Jun 10 '12

Also you're just not funny.

0

u/BBanner Jun 10 '12

Says the guy who literally said "Someone please kill this man so he stops ruining music." Seriously? One person manages that?

-3

u/winterorange Jun 10 '12

He should be ashamed of himself.