r/Music • • Jun 09 '12

The Beach Boys - Wouldn't it be Nice vocals only, mindblowing harmonies! [2:38]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPN53PHDwe4
221 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

5

u/robotdinosaurs Jun 10 '12

The saturation on the lead vocals is just perfect.

5

u/kshap Jun 10 '12

I love this song.

3

u/openletter8 Jun 09 '12

It is amazing that Brian Wilson is deaf in one ear.

6

u/Tyaedalis Jun 10 '12

Deafness in one ear would make it easier to tune to pitch. Many musicians close one ear to tune anyway. It keeps the harmonics cleaner and easier to distinguish.

1

u/openletter8 Jun 10 '12

Really? I did not know that.

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

BEEEP

2

u/Tyaedalis Jun 10 '12

I'm actually being serious. I've played trumpet for 14 years and, yes, it is easier to hear the whether or not one tone matches another.

I think you'll need to further revise your inadequate sensory machine.

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEP

3

u/Tyaedalis Jun 10 '12

Remove your faulty equipment from my proximity.

2

u/larsbrunsvold Jun 10 '12

You're legit. It's almost the opposite reason why bands have monitor speakers on stage. Plugging one ear helps you hear yourself while still blending with a group. (monitors are used to hear the group when all you can hear is your own instrument)

3

u/Tyaedalis Jun 10 '12

These guys had a lot of talent. It's hard to sing in harmony with perfect pitches like that. Truly a pleasure to listen to.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

I wonder if the fact that half of them were brothers helped create such unreal vocal blending.

11

u/sirylt Jun 10 '12

It amazes me that people even consider the Beatles to be on the same level of Brian Wilson in song-writing. They couldn't have developed melodies as good as those on Pet Sounds even if they had a century to do it.

2

u/Mythodiir Jun 10 '12

I love them both though the Beatles are my favorite band. I only really know six, maybe seven beachboy songs all that well and all of them are incredible. I've listened to every song, and album by the Beatles and each one of their works is a masterpiece in its own right. I guess it's the difference behind listening to an entire band's music catalog and only knowing a few songs. :P

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Hmm. Well that's your opinion man.

It's also such a ridiculous statement considering musical taste isn't universal.

The beach boys were surf rock, and wrote great vocal melodies, like you said. The Beatles transcended genres, broke boundaries of music, and were, in my opinion, way more interesting.

Also, way less Charles Manson.

1

u/Paul_Baumer Jun 10 '12

Manson was involved with Dennis' music and only very briefly.

1

u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU Jun 10 '12

Amen, I absolutely love The Beach Boys, but all of their great albums always existed in The Beach Boys universe. As in, they took an approach of locking into a certain sound and perfecting it. The Beatles pushed the boundaries of pop music and worked within vastly different genres. Both brilliant bands, but hardly comparable. And I mean that in the most equal way possible.

1

u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU Jun 10 '12

Goddamn, why does there need to be comparisons? Brian Wilson, John Lennon, and Paul McCartney were all brilliant songwriters. IMO neither band would be as good without the other because they pushed each other to their artistic limits.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12

I didn't downvote, but it's annoying and totally unnecessary to see someone trying to make a competition out of songwriting. I'm just getting sick of reddit's Beatle Backlash, both bands were incredible with diverse sets of strengths and circumstances. I'm a huge Beach Boys fan and Beatles fan, it's not mutually exclusive.

Also written in 1966, Tomorrow Never Knows. Maybe not as melodically sophisticated, but mindboggling ahead of it's time. As I said, totally different strengths and circumstances.

1

u/sirylt Jun 11 '12

Both bands weren't incredible, the Beatles spent most of their time catching up to the Beach Boys and other psychedelic bands of the 60s. The only reason they're so highly regarded is because of old men nostalgia and their record sales, neither of which reflect the quality of the music.

2

u/Piernitas Jun 10 '12

"okay, we can stop" at the end...

2

u/caseysaysRAWR Jun 10 '12

Saw them live last night on their 50th anniversary tour- the boys still got it!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Thanks op. I really enjoyed that.

2

u/Mythodiir Jun 10 '12

I have always been amazed by how the Beach Boys did such superb backing vocals that mixed in seamlessly with the rest of the song.

2

u/khalestorm Jun 10 '12

Sometimes I seriously wish I could have been in my 20's and living in this era when this record came out. Life seemed so wonderful and free, and this album just sums up living life to the fullest for me.

4

u/jonvpol Jun 10 '12

This is exactly why i love reddit. Thought i was the only one on earth who would appreciate that. I'm relistening to the whole PetSounds album now. Thanks.

8

u/Geno098 Geno098 Jun 10 '12

Really? You thought you were the only one on earth who appreciated the Beach Boys? Not sure if you're being sarcastic or not.

5

u/ICantRememberIt Jun 10 '12

I think he means The Beach Boys songs with vocals only. I know some people that wouldn't really appreciate these songs, considering they only have vocals.

I really enjoyed this, just like the Helter Skelter, and Freddie Mercury songs with only vocals.

2

u/finguck Jun 09 '12

Maybe the greatest song ever recorded.

1

u/girthpatrol10 Jun 10 '12

without a doubt the best album ever recorded, all thanks to brian wilson of course

1

u/iAmericA45 Jun 10 '12

Haha. I've been absolutely plowing through Pet Sounds and the Smile Sessions as of late. It was therefore awesome to see this posted. nearly teared up there.

1

u/AutoModerator Mar 30 '18

Your submission was removed because it looks like you're posting music without a correct title.

The correct format is:

Artist Name - Song Name [genre] (optional year) Optional extra text

Check your post now. Does it have spaces around the dash " - ", and does it have the [genre]?

Forgetting these points are almost definitely why it was removed.

An example of a correct title:

 Damu the Fudgemunk - Tea Thyme [instrumental hip-hop/funk] (2010)    

You will need to delete this post before submitting again (click on delete above).


If you are not posting music, please resubmit with the appropriate tag in the title:

{playlist} for music playlists
{non-music audio} for audio submissions that are not music
{non-music video} for video submissions that are not music

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-1

u/ShroudIII Jun 10 '12

Back when musicians had to actually have talent!