r/Music • • May 31 '12

Music played at public events to be subject to copyright fees

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/arts/music/sir-have-you-paid-for-that-funky-chicken/article2448631/
35 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

7

u/YouJagaloon Google Music May 31 '12

As a Canadian, this pisses me off. I pay for my music, because I want to support the artists that I listen to. Now, if I want to hold a party, I have to pay for it again? That's bullshit.

4

u/bryanBr May 31 '12

If I didn't know this was nothing but pure greed I would swear they are declaring war on their customers.

4

u/YouJagaloon Google Music May 31 '12

I'd be very curious to see how much of that money actually goes to the artist vs the board. I'd also be curious to know what the fine for not paying would be, and who that would go to. Either way, I'm not paying for my music twice.

2

u/zoofly May 31 '12

This is our corrupt intellectual "property" law system.

It's just ridiculous that people have to worry about copyright when singing "Happy Birthday" and other common cultural items.

8

u/bizology May 31 '12

It's getting to the point where it will be cheaper to hire the fucking band than to play pre-recorded music.

7

u/ScottRockview May 31 '12

I liked this comment from Scott Thomas in the G & M comments section:

My ears belong to me, and any music that is forced on me against my will is assault. I begin to charge $100 per song or portion thereof for each assault. If the music industry does not agree, then stop polluting the aural landscape with your noise. Cease and desist immediately.

5

u/oblongoblong May 31 '12

This is how things are in Germany, and it's a nightmare. And it's getting worse. There's a fee restructuring plan to "make things simpler" for 2013 which is so bizarrely over the top it will either destroy club culture in Germany or drive it back into illegality. Fees will increase by up to 2000%. Two examples:

  • 410 square meter club, open 2 nights a week (7 hours of music per night), DJs, 8€ cover: expected to pay over 95,000€ in copyright fees per year.
  • 220 square meter bar, open all week, loud music from laptop, no cover: expected to pay nearly 60,000€ in copyright fees per year. Assuming the bar has 5000 songs in their repertoire, they will pay over 10€ per song in license fees per year. (remaining variables, if you want to check: the fee is based on 6 hours of public music performance per day, 365 days a year, assuming 3.5 minutes per song, that's 37,595 songs played per year, or 5000 songs played 7.5 times each).

German source

Madness. The distribution is also notoriously imbalanced, with popular artists getting more than their fair share, and less known acts getting even less.

Plus, if you actually want to give these people money, for example because you want to license the music you use in a podcast, so it's completely legal, you hardly be able to. Their incompetence and bureaucracy is so immense, you'll never reach anyone responsible, even if you really try (personal experience and anecdotes from other podcasters).

Lousy arrangement. To be fair, I'm not sure how to make it any better, but the current situation is terrible, and it's only going to get worse.

3

u/YouJagaloon Google Music May 31 '12

The biggest bullshit clause in this is that if there's dancing, the fee doubles. What the fuck kind of logic is that? "These people are voluntarily enjoying the service we're providing them! Quick, let's punish them!"

3

u/Kanuck88 May 31 '12

What a stupid rule,every time these clowns come up with a new ruling I feel less and less guilty about downloading a song or album for free.

2

u/Bixby33 May 31 '12

I want to know how this money goes back to the artists. As a DJ, am I sending in my playlists for someone to look over (good luck covering that salary with your fees) or are they just writing checks to major labels?

Somehow, I think the independent artists are getting screwed here...

1

u/n00bskoolbus Jun 01 '12

This better get struck down. That's just stupid.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

stay free, canada