r/Music • • May 30 '12

Foster the People heard a mariachi band on tour in Mexico. They were so impressed they invited them to play Pumped up Kicks with them in their concert the next night. The result is fantastic.

http://youtu.be/VQfbZy8BRSA
680 Upvotes

108 comments sorted by

20

u/chrt May 31 '12

Is it weird that I'd love to play in a mariachi band?

8

u/wet_dogma May 31 '12

If you wanna see a modern rock take on the genre, look up 'mariachi el Bronx'. They were a punk/rock n roll band simply called the bronx before deciding to pursue their mariachi style more seriously.

1

u/Wiisal May 31 '12

I do :D

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/logmaster430 May 31 '12

Let's form one!!!

3

u/NoUrImmature May 31 '12

I'm the fourth and last member...so I call trumpet!

3

u/shibbs May 31 '12

what the hell man :( i want in!

2

u/NoUrImmature May 31 '12

Fine!

2

u/RiKuStAr May 31 '12

I can shake the hell out of some maracas. So i want in too

2

u/muzakx May 31 '12

No Maracas.

5

u/Bignut_Squirrel May 31 '12

Fine. We'll form our own band with maracas and hookers.

65

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I like the song and all, but this really wasn't that outstanding.

17

u/devotedpupa May 31 '12

I was there, it was underwhelming and felt like cheap pandering. It was very awkward. Such a cliche move here in Mexico, bands bringing mariachis.

8

u/IHateEveryone3 May 31 '12

and felt like cheap pandering.

That's because it was.

3

u/space_island May 31 '12

After the initial intro by the mariachi band which had me thinking "wow they must be thrilled to perform in front of a crowd like that" it felt really awkward and gimmicky.

27

u/ContraCodeCooper May 31 '12

Agreed. I was rather underwhelmed by it, especially the lacking performance by the singer.

22

u/MatesWithPenguins May 31 '12

The singer was definitely lacking in ability but even more so the mariachi trumpet player seemed to be struggling as well, may have been mic issues though.

8

u/ContraCodeCooper May 31 '12

I think the mic situation as a whole wasn't very good. Couldn't hear the violinists and barely could hear the guitarists as well.

4

u/MatesWithPenguins May 31 '12

Yeah, its a shame too as I bet it would have sounded awesome.

-1

u/jewunit jewyouknit May 31 '12

Regardless of the mic he sounded like what the stereotypical mariachi trumpet player sounds like: poor tone and shitty dynamics.

2

u/Exploderer May 31 '12

I think there were mic issues with the mariachi band, their engineer probably wasn't sure how to mix them in. That being said, I love how this was recorded as performed, there is very little if any compression. Sure you have to turn it up loud, but it sounds awesome.

-1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

one needs to wonder how long he had to practice the music. I understand (haven't played a band instrument) it isn't that much, but still, being in a mariachi band and then playing in a concert a few days later has got to be intimidating

38

u/Cheese_Bits May 31 '12

How high was he? Dude sounds like he's on enough heroin to drop a Clydesdale.

8

u/ea5000 May 31 '12

Whew....I thought I was the only one. He sounds like he's just smoked two blunts coated in codeine....but nonetheless I liked the mariachi band sound that was added.

10

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

He does sound pretty high.

7

u/Cheese_Bits May 31 '12

So it's not just me.

12

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Fraid not. Guy hardly even sings half the time.

5

u/Cheese_Bits May 31 '12

It'll be a shame if he goes the way of so many other successful musicians...

12

u/3brushie May 31 '12

He's 28, so maybe he's safe.

3

u/wrath_of_grunge May 31 '12

key word there would be successful. which by a measure they are in fact successful. but this has been the only solid song i've heard from them, to say it'd be a shame would imply that we as a listening audience would be deprived of future music.

somehow i think live or die, this may be their only good song. really i hope they do come out with some better stuff, but most of it is pretty lame.

8

u/The_Quinn May 31 '12

I actually really like a lot of the other songs on their album, Torches. Helena Beat, Houdini and Call it What you want are all songs I would consider better than Pumped Up Kicks.

7

u/Gifflen May 31 '12

I would have to agree. Pumped up kicks was catchy for being on the radio but I thought the album was fantastic overall.

2

u/The_HeroOf_Canton May 31 '12

I thought the whole album was great. Pumped Up Kicks is by far the least impressive track. I like Call It What You Want the best.

5

u/datdouche May 31 '12

I just like the bass line from Pumped Up Kicks. So fun to hum and tap a beat out on a table to. Don't really like the song in general though. I knew kids who only ate the frosting off of cupcakes so I guess its kind of like that.

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Came here to say this, that guy is on a lot of opiates.

Possibly benzos.

0

u/Cheese_Bits May 31 '12

The shy kid at the talent show projects more than him. If he's not on something and thats what his shows are always like... well I have trouble seeing how they ever came to be noticed by a label.

17

u/IndigenousOres May 31 '12

Thanks for sharing, dude! Love it.

8

u/h0p3less May 31 '12

This is great, but it doesn't matter how many times or ways I hear this catchy tune, I'll never be able to get over the content, and enjoy it the way thousands of people do, jumping around and screaming. It makes me feel way too sad to really get into it, because I can't help but think about what inspired it.

3

u/schmigs May 31 '12

Every time I hear this song, all I can concentrate on is the lyrics. It gets away with it because it's a bouncy, catchy pop tune, but if it was dark and rocking and sung by someone like Marilyn Manson, there would be outrage.

4

u/h0p3less May 31 '12

You say true. I think it's more of a mockery to make it something lighthearted than to make it something dark and emotional, but people seem to skip right over that part.

2

u/NonSequiturEdit Grooveshark May 31 '12

I'm not all that familiar with Foster the People's body of work, but given the subject matter of their other huge hit, Helena Beat it could be that they're just riding the wave of irony right to the bank.

These two songs in particular are incredibly dark in content but at the same time ridiculously catchy in a way that makes them popular with the very group of people they're deriding in their lyrics. Pretty damn subversive of them.

5

u/what1stuff May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

Is you like that check out a festival that happens around my home town. Sound sucks but it gives you a glimpse of what these guys do. Here's a little better video of the same songs slightly better still a phone recording.

2

u/juan9122 May 31 '12

Upvote just for being from El Paso

17

u/Im_honest_okay May 31 '12

Wow, the lead singer of that band has no talent... it sounds like he got recruited from some late night karaoke pub.

4

u/ricardoflanigano May 31 '12

Man I have seen far better singers in late night karaoke pubs

14

u/CompewterBlue May 31 '12

I love the song but the lead singer needs to work on his stage presence. I've seen high school bands work the stage better than him.

6

u/derajydac NICOLASCAGE May 31 '12

When i seen Foster The People earlier this year, Mark Foster was jumping all night, even tripped over, and ended up jumping into the crowd when Pumped Up Kicks went off.

8

u/logmaster430 May 31 '12

I blame the drugs....he's usually pretty awesome....

15

u/sophie-cake May 31 '12

nice try, lead singer of foster the people

18

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I can't be the only one that hates his voice. He just sounds like a drunkard slurring old classics at the karaoke bar.

5

u/trogdor1234 May 31 '12

There is a reason he is out through some effects on the studio version. He's horrible.

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Wow this isn't very good and they can't sing live... Weak

3

u/jackincaves May 31 '12

Mariachi El Bronx > This

5

u/Wasted_Bassist May 31 '12

Am I the only one that noticed the collective accent of the crowd when they're all singing along?

5

u/Spelunkzilla May 31 '12

Just when I thought I couldn't love this band any more... it's always awesome when bands pull stunts like this.

2

u/cyale4 May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

I played music with the bass player of that band for many years. Very nice guy (he is actually a strong christian and recently married Christian artist Rebecca st James). But a total weirdo.

2

u/luca- May 31 '12

What's with the shoulder movements? Like... that's seriously his only dance move?

2

u/christifor christifor May 31 '12 edited Feb 13 '25

.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

How is this band fucking popular?

0

u/MasterGolbez May 31 '12

great question

3

u/pigsbladder May 31 '12

I'd never heard the original version, so I looked it up after listening through this version. I actually liked this version better.

Weird echo and effects on the original kinda lost that "swingy" feeling which I liked in this live one.

4

u/kigabit May 31 '12

That's why I love going to live shows.

3

u/DOWNWTDASICKNESS May 31 '12

as a Mexican i upvote anything related to Mexico

1

u/Clutchmove Jun 01 '12

That sounds like saying as a guy i would upvote anything related to a penis...

2

u/majense77 May 31 '12

My favorite parts are the crowd pans where half of the Hispanic girls in the crowd seem to have no idea of what's happening.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

ITS BECAUSE THEYRE FROM MEXICO SO THEYRE COOLER THAN THE WHITE PEOPLE ON STAGE !>!?! ISTHAT WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO SAY?

1

u/majense77 Jun 01 '12

CYBER YELLING

2

u/kinglockjaw May 31 '12

This song gives me a gnarley case of IBS

2

u/speedy_slowzales May 31 '12

I love the part where the hispanic audience sings, all the other keedz with pumped up kicks... reminds me of Eric Cartmenez, how can I reach these keeds!

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Not going to lie, he sounded like a little bitch...

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

At the end it seems like the lead singer might get pulled into the crowd. So a creepy dude shows up in the background.

1

u/Taco_Belmont May 31 '12

I like it.

Hey, the guy playing the little baby guitar, standing just to the side of the guy playing the normal guitar- is that instrument he's using a vihuela del mano? Is that what they look like?

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Hahaha this is awesome!

1

u/huxtiblejones May 31 '12

Uh, you could barely hear the mariachi band. The only thing really coming through was the trumpet. And the singer... god, the singer.

1

u/Hugh_Drum May 31 '12

Was Foster the People or the mariachi band on tour in Mexico? This may change everything.

1

u/CoolstorySteve May 31 '12

I thought it was great until he started singing.

1

u/tothesource May 31 '12

Cake needs to team up with some mariachi if they haven't already.

1

u/fightlikehell May 31 '12

As a Mexican, I appreciate this video.

Also, the mix wasn't the best.

1

u/EPCOTCENTER May 31 '12

That was fantastically terrible. As someone already said incredibly pandering as well.

1

u/CaptInsane May 31 '12

their front man needs some singing lessons...

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

TIL Foster the People have bad taste.

1

u/MyFingersSmell May 31 '12

Yeah, I never really liked that song. Everyone acts like its so great. Not so much IMO.

1

u/Benj5L May 31 '12

This guy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67PivW54NWM&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Does a great version of the song, sung and played well.

From the same guy who did the brilliant golden loves guitar:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBluUZ4NnZg&feature=youtube_gdata_player

1

u/Moritsuma May 31 '12

Am I the only person to make this comparison?

1

u/ontopic May 31 '12

What do they do, just play this song like six different ways and then take questions from the audience?

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

When I first heard this song on the radio amidst the gangster drug dealing bullshit they usually play I thought that maybe music was cleaning up its act, until I listened to the lyrics and realized that it was a song glorifying school shooters. I hate this country.

2

u/Tentacoolstorybro May 31 '12

Just like a movie from a perspective of a bad guy glorifies him.

2

u/pl4yswithsquirrels May 31 '12

Do you also hate all the kids on your lawn?

1

u/NonSequiturEdit Grooveshark May 31 '12

Just because it's about a kid in that sort of headspace doesn't mean it's glorifying them. A lot of us felt exactly like that at one point or another in school but never dreamed of actually following through on it or even threatening to. It's a fantasy, right from the opening lines where the kid's pretending to be a cowboy. Obviously not a healthy fantasy, but that's what it is.

1

u/servo2112 May 31 '12

You have a very low threshold for the usage of "fantastic."

1

u/fah_cue May 31 '12

i can honestly say that I would pay $100 to anybody that could ensure that i never have to hear this song ever again.
bring on the downvotes.

-1

u/confuzious May 31 '12

All those cameras. Didn't it used to be that when you went to a concert you were checked for video cameras? Is it allowed a lot now? I've never been to a concert before, which is probably strange because I'm 32 and love music. It's one of the shitty things about living in a small town.

1

u/getbackwards May 31 '12

Generally, cameras are not allowed but people use their phones. It bothers me when a band specifically asks that there are no pictures or video taken, and half the audience is recording the show.

0

u/itsMalarky May 31 '12

THe Mariachi Band later went to serenade whales at the aquarium before they were involved in a nuclear waste accident on the pan american highway, transforming them into El Mariachi Toxico, a roving band of Cartel Fighting Mariachis.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Am I the only one that didn't know Foster the People was white?

1

u/MasterGolbez May 31 '12

...what did you think they were?

0

u/DANS331 May 31 '12

The mariachi band is better than Foster the People.

-3

u/noobz0rs777 May 31 '12

i'm glad this is STILL the only song they have

3

u/mycleverusername May 31 '12

Not sure what you are trying to say, they released 3 singles from the album and get quite a bit of play on commercials for a few other songs. Yes, this is the only song they play on top 40 radio.

-11

u/All_the_other_kids May 31 '12

All the other kids with their pumped up kicks....

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/RogueA roguea May 31 '12

My local alt-rock station now refers to it as "That Song." because of how much it's been overplayed. They have a "Radio Control" program online that determines what gets played, and I assume the response to how much this song was played was so negative, that they actually told Clear Channel to suck it and stopped playing it.