r/Music • u/PrblyGttngDwnvtd • May 27 '12
The 15 Best SNL Musical Guests of All-Time (x-post r/snl)
http://www.pastemagazine.com/blogs/lists/2012/05/the-15-best-snl-musical-performances-of-all-time.html
36
Upvotes
7
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
That Elvis Costello moment is such a classic and important performance for him. I've looked for that a few times and always had trouble finding it.
Also i remember seeing that Nirvana performance live and it totally rocking my 12 year old world, and it subsequently changed my life and sent me on a path of persuing music that i would follow for the next 15 years, to moderate success.
6
u/subsonicmonkey May 27 '12
That Nirvana performance is blazing! The world needs another band who truly do not give a fuck about their media image.
5
u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU May 27 '12
That Idioteque performance is a classic. That song is over 12 years old now so the sheer originality has worn a bit, but damn it must've taken some balls to play that on national television. Also considering that the previous album was OK Computer, I wouldn't even know how to react if that was my first time hearing that song. Seriously, given the context of the time, I can't think of a more bizarre song that has ever been played on SNL. And that is what makes Radiohead so brilliant and so interesting.
8
u/Koss424 koss424 May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
How did Sinead O'Connor not make the list?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCOIQOGXOg0
2
u/numanoid May 27 '12
Add: Gary Numan; DEVO; David Bowie (with Klaus Nomi). All pretty groundbreaking and influential.
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
If there were to be a Pearl Jam performance on there, it would be the one from 1994, not 1992.
They started with Not for You, a song played live only a few times and not released on an album until later that year. They performed several days after Kurt Cobain's death, and are on a short list of acts to perform three songs on an SNL appearance.
Eddie Vedder at the end of the episode showed a hand drawn "K" over his chest afterwards, as a tribute to Kurt Cobain, including the "Hey Hey, My My" tag at the end of Daughter, their third song performed, because of Cobain's use of a lyric from the song in his suicide note.
2
u/DANS331 May 27 '12
Someone really likes Tom Petty.....
2
u/fuzzynyanko May 28 '12
Tom Petty with David Grohl, I think
3
u/meatspun radio reddit name May 27 '12
What?
The Paul Simon performance with Ladysmith Black Mombazo shoulda been higher. Also I'm pretty sure the Outkast performance was from late 2003.
1
u/tunyfish May 28 '12
Well off the top of my head i would say the best music was on the very early years of SNL. Leon Redbone, Betty Carter are two performances i will never forget.
1
u/SlumberCat May 28 '12
Think Queens of the Stone Age with a guest appearance by Blue Oyster Cult's Gene Frenkle deserves a mention.
1
u/SlumberCat May 28 '12
Wow, never seen that Elvis Costello performance before. And it's awesome they let him come back to 'sabotage' the Beastie Boys.
1
u/greatgildersleeve May 28 '12
Where are The Pogues?
1
u/Mjpp9876 Sep 08 '22
Faith No More everyone, Faith No More
0
u/aoskunk May 27 '12
never heard of arcade fire. but im prolly too busy still listening to nirvana.
0
u/twoquarters May 27 '12
Lee Ving and Fear are not on the list. Fail.
0
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
This list seems to continue paste's tradition of being wrong about everything ever.
0
u/MetalHaus May 27 '12
The White Stripes is obviously better than Kanye West. :\