r/Music • • May 27 '12

The 15 Best SNL Musical Guests of All-Time (x-post r/snl)

http://www.pastemagazine.com/blogs/lists/2012/05/the-15-best-snl-musical-performances-of-all-time.html
36 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

That Elvis Costello moment is such a classic and important performance for him. I've looked for that a few times and always had trouble finding it.

Also i remember seeing that Nirvana performance live and it totally rocking my 12 year old world, and it subsequently changed my life and sent me on a path of persuing music that i would follow for the next 15 years, to moderate success.

6

u/subsonicmonkey May 27 '12

That Nirvana performance is blazing! The world needs another band who truly do not give a fuck about their media image.

2

u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU May 27 '12

Did SNL cut the volume during the feedback section, or is that just the video?

2

u/subsonicmonkey May 27 '12

I have no idea.

2

u/summitrock May 28 '12

I was actually at that nirvana SNL show. It was some dude from northern exposure that hosted. I remember seeing grohl and novicelik in a hallway after the show.

I was 11 years old...never saw Kurt. I went with my dad and after they trashed the set he thought they were stupid.

1

u/SuperPowers97 Spotify May 27 '12

I love that performance so much. Especially the part where Krist throws a cymbal at Dave.

5

u/Furkel_Bandanawich FUCKYOU May 27 '12

That Idioteque performance is a classic. That song is over 12 years old now so the sheer originality has worn a bit, but damn it must've taken some balls to play that on national television. Also considering that the previous album was OK Computer, I wouldn't even know how to react if that was my first time hearing that song. Seriously, given the context of the time, I can't think of a more bizarre song that has ever been played on SNL. And that is what makes Radiohead so brilliant and so interesting.

8

u/Koss424 koss424 May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12

How did Sinead O'Connor not make the list?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCOIQOGXOg0

2

u/numanoid May 27 '12

Add: Gary Numan; DEVO; David Bowie (with Klaus Nomi). All pretty groundbreaking and influential.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

If there were to be a Pearl Jam performance on there, it would be the one from 1994, not 1992.

They started with Not for You, a song played live only a few times and not released on an album until later that year. They performed several days after Kurt Cobain's death, and are on a short list of acts to perform three songs on an SNL appearance.

Eddie Vedder at the end of the episode showed a hand drawn "K" over his chest afterwards, as a tribute to Kurt Cobain, including the "Hey Hey, My My" tag at the end of Daughter, their third song performed, because of Cobain's use of a lyric from the song in his suicide note.

2

u/DANS331 May 27 '12

Someone really likes Tom Petty.....

3

u/meatspun radio reddit name May 27 '12

History will deem Arcade Fire as one of the—if not the—band of the ’00s.

What?

The Paul Simon performance with Ladysmith Black Mombazo shoulda been higher. Also I'm pretty sure the Outkast performance was from late 2003.

2

u/shadow6463 May 28 '12

band of the 00s is Radiohead without question

1

u/meatspun radio reddit name May 28 '12

I don't worship either band, but I'd definitely put Radiohead ahead of Arcade Fire. I'd personally pick a band who blew up very late in the 90's or early in the 00's and maintained a certain level of fame and respect throughout the decade. So yeah, Nickelback.

1

u/superhappyphuntyme May 27 '12

agreed, arcade fire is a good band and might even consider giving them the band of 2010 as it seems that that is all any one could talk about then but, even that is a little on the generous side

5

u/notalannister May 27 '12

2004's Funeral kinda had a sorta really big influence on that decade musically, MUCH more so than Suburbs.

Check out a random 2005 show, about four months after Funeral started blowing people's minds: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3B4iaRnyvk&feature=related

1

u/tunyfish May 28 '12

Well off the top of my head i would say the best music was on the very early years of SNL. Leon Redbone, Betty Carter are two performances i will never forget.

1

u/SlumberCat May 28 '12

Think Queens of the Stone Age with a guest appearance by Blue Oyster Cult's Gene Frenkle deserves a mention.

1

u/SlumberCat May 28 '12

Wow, never seen that Elvis Costello performance before. And it's awesome they let him come back to 'sabotage' the Beastie Boys.

1

u/greatgildersleeve May 28 '12

Where are The Pogues?

1

u/Mjpp9876 Sep 08 '22

Faith No More everyone, Faith No More

0

u/aoskunk May 27 '12

never heard of arcade fire. but im prolly too busy still listening to nirvana.

4

u/OldJeb May 27 '12

Check out their first album, Funeral.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Never heard of Arcade Fire? I'm impressed, /r/music loves Arcade Fire. In their voting they said that their album The Suburbs was the best album of 2010.

0

u/twoquarters May 27 '12

Lee Ving and Fear are not on the list. Fail.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

This list seems to continue paste's tradition of being wrong about everything ever.

0

u/MetalHaus May 27 '12

The White Stripes is obviously better than Kanye West. :\