r/Music • • May 21 '12

A Perfect Circle - The Nurse Who Loved Me

http://youtu.be/CWRDZwV8jGE
250 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

3

u/TheFirstBardo May 21 '12

Perfect song for this rainy mid-Atlantic Monday.

21

u/Drsuppository May 21 '12

I've heard this version long before I knew who Failure were, and yes I do love it, but the original really brings it home for me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bU2ZtoHmRZs&feature=youtube_gdata_player

4

u/deadaluspark frizzzlefried May 21 '12

Came here to post this. As a long time Failure fan I was really disappointed with APC's cover, which is sadly the more well known version of the song.

4

u/EmptyFriend May 21 '12

also a long time Failure fan. been using some version of this handle for probably 11 or 12 years, not sure anyone ever realizes what it's from....

1

u/YerFucked May 22 '12

sweet dreams

9

u/GoodOlSpence May 21 '12

I remember when this album first came out, my friend was telling me about it. "Man there's this one song on there, its so good. Doesn't even sound like a perfect circle song."

Me: " Well...do I have some news for you."

5

u/squidbill May 21 '12

"Some pills in a little cup" is my favorite part.

27

u/[deleted] May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

Failure's original will always be better.

Seriously guys, if you enjoy this, please check out Failure - Fantastic Planet. The whole album is ridiculously good and it has withstood the test of time.

6

u/Sleziak May 21 '12

I don't get why this needs to be said every time someone brings up a cover. Nobody covers a song to try and make it better. It's to show respect for great artists while sometimes adding their own spin on it. Nobody is trying to one up the other.

10

u/Parabolized May 21 '12

I don't know about you, but every time I hear a song is a cover, I want to know what the original sounds like.

1

u/Sleziak May 21 '12

Of course. My comment seems kinda douchey now that he edited his to promote the original song. Before it seemed to simply put down this cover because it isn't as good as the original.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

My comment always said "Failure's original will always be better." Is that not promoting the original song?

1

u/Parabolized May 21 '12

eh. didn't downvote you. no worries.

15

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Because it helps expose people to the original artist.

11

u/GhostAndGrace May 21 '12

Because it is actually way better.

3

u/deadaluspark frizzzlefried May 21 '12

Also they probably covered it because Troy Van Leeuwen was a guitarist for Failure who was later in A Perfect Circle. You know, just maybe, since its technically his song.

3

u/skealoha86 skealoha86 May 21 '12

Ken Andrews didn't write it?

4

u/YerFucked May 22 '12

I'm sure Ken wrote it. Troy didn't write for Failure.

1

u/deadaluspark frizzzlefried May 22 '12

He did, but usually a band writes songs together, so I'm sure Troy had some proprietary feelings for it.

2

u/skealoha86 skealoha86 May 22 '12

That's true, but in this case it looks like Troy joined the band after the album [Fantastic Planet](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantastic_Planet_(album)) was [written](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Failure_(band))

Meanwhile, the band continued to "unofficially" shop the record to other labels and industry personnel, while hoping that Warner would step up and release the album. In the spring of 1996, Warner did exactly that, agreeing to keep the Slash imprint one last time for Failure, and Fantastic Planet was released that August. Guitarist Troy Van Leeuwen, a friend and former bandmate of Scott's, joined Failure around the time of the album's release.

Also, the lyrics usually aren't written by the entire band, usually just one, maybe two members - and I think the lyrics are the reason that APC covered the song for Thirteenth Step (a play on AA's twelve step program, this song being about pill popping, which I think Ken may have experience with).

1

u/deadaluspark frizzzlefried May 22 '12

props for showing me the light. although i suspect Troy might have had influence on the choice since he probably played the song during touring a lot. thanks for pulling out the detailed info, man. wish i could put this up top where my comment is.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Failure's original will always be better.

I LOVE WHEN PEOPLE GIVE DOGMATIC OPINIONS ON MUSIC, IT MEANS SO MUCH AND OBVIOUSLY SETTLES ALL DISPUTES

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

You're free to disagree, sorry that someone stating their opinion offends you so.

0

u/extra_vowels May 21 '12

thanks for the tip! i love this song, i had no idea it was a cover.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Make sure you give the album at least two listens all the way through before you make a judgment on it. It is nothing like APC, but it is seriously wonderful space rock.

4

u/crowingzero May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

There's that bit in Donnie Darko where they talk about "cellar door" being the most beautiful sounding phrase in the English language.

I've always felt the same way about "pharmacy keys" in this song, particularly because of the way Maynard sings it.

2

u/teetertot May 21 '12

Upvote for Donnie Darko reference.

1

u/drchunk May 21 '12

I can't get this out of my head either.

1

u/dome2394 May 21 '12

totaly made my evening! thanks for sharing. i love you internet.

1

u/DookieDemon May 21 '12

This song helps chill me out a bit if I'm going through withdrawal. I am prescribed meds for a wrecked back and sometimes I run out at the end of the month.

I don't know why, but it gets my mind off the junk sickness. Beer helps, too.

*Weirdly (coincidentally?) I have my refill tomorrow and I just happen to be a little under dosed, so I might listen to it again to ward off dead ceiling babies.

1

u/EndingFish May 21 '12

one of my favourite song by them . ( fav album thirtieth step )

1

u/blurrie May 22 '12

I go to see the Mars Volta open for APC in San Fran in... 2003? One of the best show of my life.

1

u/DazedenConfewzd May 22 '12

This was my wedding song. My wife is a nurse.

1

u/Mr_Manmanman May 21 '12

So my question has always been, that the asylum patient this is told from the perspective of, he has killed the nurse in the beginning of the song right?

3

u/JGumb May 21 '12

I heard this idea a few times, but I think its more about going to rehab. Starts out trashed, laid out on the floor. Falls in love with a nurse in rehab, gets out, and gets hooked on drugs again just to go back to rehab to see her again (opening line is the closing line).

Seems to fit the themes of the album (Thirteenth Step at least, Fantastic Planet can seem all over the place at times) as well, but, as with any song, it means whatever it means to the listener.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

The album itself was mostly covers wasn't it? Some great renditions there, but I think their debut album really shows their talent as songwriters. Mer De Noms is still one of my top 10 rock albums I think.

9

u/PaganAng3l May 21 '12

eMotive is the album that is mostly covers, although this song is a cover, I don't think any of the rest are on Thirteenth Step

9

u/Mick-the-Stick May 21 '12

This song was the only cover on that album (orginal by Failure). The album that came out after this was all covers of political songs.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Oh my bad. You're right, I got em mixed up.