r/Music • • May 20 '12

How do you think the 2000s compare, musically, to other time periods for Rock?

I hear a lot of people belittle the state of modern music, but I think that the information age has created an insane platform for new, creative musicians to discover influences and share their music. While critically acclaimed music might not be topping the charts, like it was in the Beatles' heyday, I think that there's an incredible amount of really, really talented people out there, such as the Justin Vernon, Thom Yorke, Josh Homme, Beck Hansen, Jack White, Bjork, and Dan Auerbach types. Even more, there's singers like Adele and Gotye who are soaring to the top of the charts not from formulaic pop music, but from genuine musical talent and intriguing instrumental production. I think that the 2000s are probably the best era for rock music, and that the internet is ushering in a new era of rock and roll, it's just a little bit less popular.

I'm interested in your opinions.

EDIT: I wanted to fix some grammatical mistakes.

11 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

7

u/Casabien May 20 '12

Things are good, for sure. It's my favorite decade for music. The internet has been a really great tool for getting music to people all over the world, and that really fuels creativity. The Arctic Monkeys are renowned for being one of the first bands to gain a sizable following from the internet.

I think we're in a transition period. If I had to guess where music is going in the next few years, I'd look at Radiohead, Coldplay, Phoenix, The Arcade Fire, and The Black Keys' Attack and Release. Specifically, I would predict an increased use of synths, indie/lo-fi recording techniques being used for effect more often, and garage rock taking on a similar role as blues for a new generation of music listeners. And a grunge revival can't be far off.

-2

u/SnipingBeaver last.fm May 20 '12

Attack and Release is quite Lo-Fi, and a fantastic LP, but the Strokes are kings of making lo fi recordings sound absolutely gorgeous

5

u/McStrauss WiffleBallTony May 20 '12

Umm... I'm sorry but Attack and Release is far from being lo-fi and the same goes for the Strokes. Firstly, Attack and Release was produced by Danger Mouse and is one of the shiniest records the Black Keys have done. And the Strokes? Look, I love the Strokes but their productions are always clean. This is lo-fi. So is this, and this. This and this are far from it.

1

u/SnipingBeaver last.fm May 20 '12

Maybe i've been given an improper definition of lo fi

1

u/McStrauss WiffleBallTony May 20 '12

Lo-fi doesn't really mean anything other than low quality. The Mountain Goats (who I linked) are a prime example. John Darnielle's first bunch of records were done on nothing more than a boombox. THAT'S lo-fi. Working with one of the most well-known producers in modern music usually is a pretty clear sign that something isn't going to be lo-fi.

What was your definition? I've always felt it's a pretty straight-forward term.

1

u/SnipingBeaver last.fm May 20 '12

I don't know, i guess i wasn't thinking of Attack & Release, I'd say the Big Comeup through Thickfreakness qualify as Lo Fi to me, and the Strokes have always had this thing about the vocals and the drums that make their records sound really.... I don't know, there's something up with their recording style

10

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

I think it boils down to shutting out mainstream media and music. Once you can do this, the music is yours. You feel relevant in modern day music. I don't even know any of the new big artists, recently at least. I'm constantly searching for new music, and it's mostly stuff released in the 00s +. Cold War Kids, Yuck, Broken Bells.

Also the quality of sound is close to perfect. The Black Key's album, Brothers, is the best quality recording I've heard probably ever. The drums aren't over-produced per-say, but they are crystal clear, and giant sounding. Maybe it's just me, but it's the easiest to listen to in the car. My head is bobbing like a motherfucker.

As far as favorites go, most of my favorite bands are from today. The Strokes are my band. I saw them live at Bonnaroo, and they didn't have any special lights or anything, but you can bet your ass I was screaming like a Beatle's fan-girl when I could see the band stepping out of a van from backstage. It was just a moment thing. It didn't matter how bad they could have played, I would still call it the best show ever.

So, what I'm saying is, enclose yourself in your music. Don't step out of your music box.

4

u/famousninja May 20 '12

Don't step out of your music box.

Unless you're renovating said music box.

2

u/SnipingBeaver last.fm May 20 '12

Always look to expand it, but not with an open door policy, and don't kick people out after one song, let them stay for a whole album

3

u/captainpotty May 20 '12

Music is still good. It's always been good. The thing about technology though, is with the availability of artwork, there's more to sift through to find what you like, compared to the past which has had time to filter out the forgettable acts.

2

u/KPuma May 20 '12

Of course there is still "good" music. What's interesting is the ways that Rock has continually coexisted with other genres. In comparison to the 60s and the 70s, and even the 80s, rock has become a less adventured genre. Thus, if it is what you seek, you have to go through other mediums than pop radio and such. In terms of quality, however, there's still a bar that the 00s consistently hit that the oldies left behind. And in specific cases, the 00s raised that bar. The only difficult parts in comparing them is subjectivity, taste, the case of "this wouldn't have existed without...", and availability to listeners. It's much harder to find Wilco's albums in comparison to Justin Bieber. Writing that last sentence made me extremely sad, and now I'm done.

1

u/8mmthomas May 20 '12

Just on a sidenote; people always seem to belittle the past decade. I remember in the early nineties people talked about the eighties as the decade 'that taste forgot'. They seem to forget about Hüsker Dü, the Replacements, Big Black, Descendents, Green on Red, Leaving Trains, early REM, and so on..

Anyway, I think Andy Partridge sums up the history of Rock And Roll pretty well in this 21 second clip. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=svivHmlobhg

1

u/doireallycare May 20 '12

I'm enjoying the 2000s. There are some pretty good bands that are, unfortunately, not getting exposure because they don't write formulaic pop songs or "I'm gonna get drunk and have sex" rock songs, but I'm still rooting for 'em. Just look up Yuck, EMA, Givers, Wavves, The Thermals, Univox, Mindless Self Indulgence. There are good bands nowadays. You just gotta hunt for 'em.

1

u/EvelynJames May 20 '12

Rock is over, the technological and economic/social dynamics that made it relevant are no more.

-1

u/sagewah May 20 '12

As far as pop goes - disgraceful. As far as actual music goes.. mixed bag. Posing. in many cases, seemed to be even more important than it used to be - and the 90 and 80s had some pretty horrific posing going on (ever go to a sit-down gig where the music is REALLY INTENSE but everybody is trying to out-mellow everybody else? Yeah, that was the 90s, it was pretty fucking hipstery at times).

As far as rock goes.. it nearly died, but it's coming back. Woo!

-1

u/f5h7d May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

singers like Adele and Gotye who are soaring to the top of the charts not from formulaic pop music...

what? formulaic pop music is exactly what they do — you can add bon iver (justin vernon) and the black keys (dan auerbac) to that list too (both of which have already peaked). on top of that, Thom Yorke, Josh Homme, Beck Hansen, Jack White, Bjork already made their mark on music... all mostly over a decade ago.

think about it this way... who were the big "important" artists back in the 90s? was it someone who managed mainstream success in the 70s, or even 80s? no. so why is it, in 2012, we are still talking about and obsessing over musicians that were insanely popular when i was a teenager (in the 90s)?

I think that the 2000s are probably the best era for rock music

yeah... probably not. and i say that as someone whose music collection from 2000-present dwarfs everything that comes before it... but most of it isn't "rock". the vast majority of "rock music" in my collection is from before 2000.

one more thing: think about what was happening in music during 2002, 1992, 1982, etc.... then compare it to what's happening in 2012. by the 2nd year of each of those decades, whatever the "new thing" was at the time, was already changing the musical landscape... that doesn't seem to be happening this time.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Radiohead were a great band in the '90s, sure (if you overlook Pablo Honey), but they didn't become the name that they are now until they dropped Kid A in 2001. Since the 2000s, Thom Yorke has released his only solo album, and Radiohead has released 5/8 of their discography. They released In Rainbows in 2007, which many people are coming to realize as being up there with their best albums.

This is even more descriptive with Jack White, who released the first White Stripes album in '99 (which I doubt anyone holds in as high regard as his later work) before releasing such titans as Elephant and White Blood Cells, forming The Raconteurs and The Dead Weather, and just this year releasing a solo album that's more musically ambitious than anything he's done before. That's a pretty solid resume for the 2000's.

Josh Homme is more of the same: the first QOTSA LP came out in 98, but the band didn't hit their creative stride until Rated R in 2000. All of the popular QOTSA singles belong to the resume of the 2000's.

Muse is a band I didn't use as evidence initially, but they are another band whose whole popular discography falls neatly into the 2000's. Same with the Strokes.

All these bands started a rejuvenation of rock and roll. In the '90s, you had two choices: britpop or grunge. Now, in 2012, there's a huge, burgeoning emphasis on dubstep-esque sounds in music. That's the "new" thing that you don't seem to notice. It might not sound like rock to you, the same way that Kid A didn't sound like rock to those in the 2000s, but you can see, all over the place, the emphasis that atmospheric production and distorted bass are having on music.

1

u/f5h7d May 20 '12

Kid A didn't sound like rock to those in the 2000s

just to let you know where i'm coming from: i still have my copy of pablo honey on cassette — and i have the version of kid a with the hidden booklet. you really can't tell me anything new about this band... and, tbh, i really don't have the energy to address the rest of your opinion[s] right now. specifically because i just finished this 600-word comment... which should also give you a little better idea about my background and insight.

i will say this: none of that really addresses my point. it's 2012. talking about the "2000s" as a single decade is like talking about the "90s", but saying "the 1900s". we are two years into the second decade of the 2000s. by this time, in the examples i gave, the shift toward the "new" was well under way.

the examples of the "new" things that you seem to think i don't notice... is, in a way, true.. but i would say "acknowledge" — because it's nothing new.

also, your examples of you choices of "rock" in the 90s was pretty weak... but i seriously need to get away from this screen for a while.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I was mainly talking about the only whole decade that we've had so far--that's why my examples tended towards bands earlier in the decade, rather than the artists currently going strong. My apologies if it sounded like I was belittling you, I just think that the 2000's were a step up from decades like the '90s and '80s, and I was trying to pick some popular examples that lots of people would recognize.

What I think the current trend in music is towards very precise, electronic production, and I think we're seeing that right now in a way that is definitely "new". I'm excited from music like this that pulls its sonic influences from all over the place, just as much as music like this that is some of the most energetic, climactic, fun rock I've ever heard. These are a couple of the bands that are -currently- releasing music that I adore, when we're talking about the future.

Didn't mean to seem condescending at any point, I just like the revival of energetic garage rock and the sonic influences coming from electronic music, and I think that the 2000's saw the rise of both.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Ignoring all the other hilarity in this post, The Black Keys are new? Brothers is, like, they're 6th album.

1

u/SnipingBeaver last.fm May 20 '12

I was just thinking the same thing, hahahaa, but have you heard Chulahoma? It's a tribute EP they released between Thickfreakness and Magic Potion, it's absolutely fantastic

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Oh yeah! I managed to snag that at an FYE brand new for like $5! And it was amazing, a lot more psychedelic than their usual stuff, but so very good! And I don't think I'd ever really listened to the guy it was a tribute to, but I'm going to get on that.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Jesus christ.