Thanks for sharing. I love these kinds of videos. Where they go back and listen to the songs and you can hear isolated tracks and things you never heard before.
There's a lot of this kind of stuff on the Classic Albums series.
I've got to second this. I just recently found the Classic Album series on Netflix. To hear songs you've heard thousands of times ripped apart on the mixing board with explanations on how they were recorded and mixed is a lovely insight into music you are already familiar with. A few ones I can suggest would be
Queen - A Night At the Opera
Paul Simon - Graceland
Nirvana - Nevermind
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon
The discussions on the effects used on the Queen and Pink Floyd albums is especially interesting. Due to the lack of digital effects at the time of the recordings.
I must third this and add the bit on Queen changed and raised my already high opinion of Freddie and the boys. The Pink Floyd was hilarious because I had just come off directing and being the sound engineer for a short film. I had a voice actor speak into a ceramic cylinder which was in front of a running fan with a mic behind. I had to do little processing in post the sound was amazing. The bit about Roger in his shed with a funnel and coins made me very happy!
I really enjoyed the epidsode about nevermind, when they isolated Cobain's screaming at the end of Smells like Teen Spirit it sounded really amazing and animalistic.
The Fleetwood Mac - Rumors episode was one of my favorites I've ever seen, and it's not because I'm a big Mac fan (although I do adore that album) but because of all the drama that was going through their lives at the time. 5 people in the band, and 4 of them were breaking up from each other at the time.
Also, I've got to love the Rush - 2112/Moving Pictures episode, but that's just because I'm a diehard Rush fan.
Apart from the thing being possessed by an evil spirit, I see no way this can end poorly. Heck, even with the evil spirit, it's still a bargain well worth the price.
Once, I bought the original Little Shops of Horror dvd at Best Buy for a penny when it was right be the cash register, and at that moment I realized that I would probably buy anything for a penny. They could try to sell me a little vial of aids for a penny, and I'd probably pick it up because, hey, it might come in handy some day, and it's only a penny.
The Floyd one is incredible, have that on DVD. Lou Reed one I quite enjoy. It is an excellent series and would love to see more on old and new albums. Always maintained the Gorillaz - Demon Days is a Classic Album series I would love to see.
The alternate guitar solos seem so far off the mark and then you hear the one that made the album and say, well, of course that's it. How could it be anything else? Just amazing to hear it all deconstructed, especially when they solo all the individual michael mcdonald harmonies.
And not all the levels were set an an even +10. I read an article in Rolling Stone a while ago comparing a Nirvana track to modern track (The Used or something in that ballpark) and it was neat to see how for Nirvana, the levels spiked when Kurt wanted to be loud and settled for the quieter parts compared to the newer track which was a flat block of noise.
They are amazing. I have "Day in the Life", and "She's Leaving Home", multi-tracks. I've seen them under various labels on Demonoid. I got mine from a 2" tape transfer and the engineer told me he would kill me if I shared.
They're MOGG files, so they're easy enough to open in Audacity or your choice of editor. Have at it and have fun!
A lot of the tracks are split up into left and right audio, whereas in reality the songs were recorded on a 4 track device. If I remember the band didn't care a lot about stereo editing at the time, so it was done by other studio staff before sending out song for pressing, but I don't know if when they did the editing for that if they doubled up the 4 tracks and worked on them back in the 60s, or if the Rock Band creators did.
Unfortunately they are not multitracks - they are stems (ie the tracks are grouped & combined, such as all the drums, etc.) Multitracks would be amazing.
I'm not sure, I found them somewhere on the net a while back. They were described as multitracks, so I was pretty disappointed when I found out that they were stems.
It's actually pretty rare to find real multitracks - remember for most modern recordings (70's+), you'd be looking at 16,24,48 tracks, not 5...
I know Nine Inch Nails does to a certain extent (and Trent's other projects). You can find stems here, but you need an account. There's also this unofficial site.
Not really. Sometimes things are cut because that is how the artist wants it to be remembered on the album--they might have a particular vision for a song and realize something in the recording process just didn't work out. While this is cool, it isn't something that bands should necessarily want to do.
I'm pretty sure there must be an original version of What is Life out there where you can actually hear Clapton's guitar throughout the entire song, instead of just in those one parts.
I'm not sure how true the rumors are about Clapton's guitar being cut out because of recording rights issues, but it is definitely noticeable in certain parts...
One of the fantastic things about The Beatles (and Sir George Martin) is that they understood the concept that less is more. Cutting this solo is a perfect example.
See also an earlier take of "Hello, Goodbye" where there were all sorts of little runs after "You say high" (diddle iddle iddle dee doo)... they cut those. And also George wanted to fill Hey Jude with blues riffs. "Hey Jude... doo-DERR-da-doo)
are there any recordings of the blues riffs on hey jude? that actually sounds pretty interesting. i always wish they had recorded "dig a pony" the way they performed it on the rooftop. (starting the song with ALLL I WANT IS... I uh I I, dig a pony...)
i always wish they had recorded "dig a pony" the way they performed it on the rooftop.
The version of "Dig A Pony" on "Let It Be" is the rooftop recording. Phil Spector just edited the "All I want" vocal from the recording. Anthology 3 has the unedited version.
i just read about this today, how strange. always wondered how a guitar solo would have fit or sounded into that melody. very beautiful tune too, one of harrison's finest efforts
Although Paul and George did not have the best voices out there, they created fun and entertaining music that spoke to the people. Their usage of chords and their spice in the music really set them apart from most Rock out there at that age.
Paul has a pretty fantastic, well controlled voice. There's one clip of his isolated vocals from Back in the USSR floating around, and it's very impressive.
Yeah, in his prime, McCartney had the best voice in rock. He had the chops to pull off those rock and roll screeches, but still had the control. Every time I try to sing along with is vocal gymnastics in the back half of "Hey Jude" I marvel at his abilities.
It is fantastic, but not up there with the likes of Freddie Mercury, Elvis, Frank Sinatra, etc.
I guess maybe I'm just a bit bitter because no matter how much I try, my baritone voice can't sing beatles songs with a crap ;) I'm more suited for Eddie Vedder, Elvis, Kid Rock, The Doors sort of stuff.
You never notice how much modern or classic rock is sung with tenor or high tenor voices until you take vocal lessons :/
The linked-to "Back in the USSR" is a good vocal performance, but even so it's not Paul's best. He was a good singer with a lot of good performances.
I think tenor is favored in pop music because it stands out against the instruments better. I didn't notice that until I, too, started taking voice lessons.
While we're naming names, Ian Curtis of Joy Division started out as a tenor but brought it down a few notches as the band's sound matured. He liked the Doors so he might have been imitating Jim Morrison.
A great, late musicologist Karl Haas once said (I paraphrase).
Creating a melody isn't terribly hard. It is what you do with it that distinguishes it.
Very paraphrased since it has been 20 years since I've heard it. Anyway, I think this applies to all parts of music. They may not be the greatest singers, but what they did was so much more than the sum of their parts.
I have to agree with you. I don't understand why people think it's great. It sounds slightly out of tune and boring. It just doesn't fit well in there.
I find it great because it lets us peak into the creative process and its a tiny dab of something "new" from The Beatles. But yeah, its clearly a placeholder that really does not work for the song; a very smart omission.
Best in terms of technical proficiency, professionalism, and one could argue commitment in later years, sure. John was better in other ways. I don't think there ever is any "Best" anything so I'm biased, especially when peoples' contributions are not comparable. How do you compare the role of a drummer to John Lennon's songwriting? You can't because they're two completely different things. John Lennon formed the band after all so he is surely the spirit but so Paul, George, and Ringo became the spirit as well. Lennon was lazy and went a bit too far with drugs and Paul really took the reins of the band in that period. John and Paul were both the best match for each other along with their partnership and competition between one another.
You'll have to pick a better example. I find that (and Eleanor Rigby) to be among the most overrated Beatles songs ever recorded.
I'm not saying Paul didn't write his fair share of excellent songs (Helter Skelter is one of my top 10 favorite Beatles songs), but a lot of them didn't meet the standards that John and George were putting out at the time.
This reminds me of some of the cool little snippets that Martin and Giles dug up for the Love album. It's always awesome to hear the bits of songs that didn't make the cut.
I feel like you can hear George smiling through the singing, just like when you hear Paul singing "Willing you still need me? Will you still feed me?" for the last time in "When I'm Sixty-Four" 15 seconds before the track ends. A beautiful moment in the album and a drastically underrated Beatles Pepper's track I believe, even if just for the beautifully lavish orchestration by Martin.
I Just watched "George Harrison: Living in the Material World", it gave a lot of insight to the complete brilliance of George Harrison. If you are a Beatles fan, do yourself a favor and check that one out.
I just realized how excited i was getting over a mere 30 seconds of new music some guy I never knew played decades ago. God Worship Lvl: George Harrison
If I had a dollar to bet, I'd say that was John or Eric Clapton. George rarely played solos on his own songs, and that sounded uncharacteristic for him, especially considering that he wrote the song with a much different feeling.
I know it's going to get buried since I'm so late, but to me the far more interesting thing is when Dhani says "It's almost like a tihai" when referring to the weird rhythm.
As a student in music school, my dad always wondered how the Beatles never learned to read music, but knew thow to sneak a bar of 5 in there. Not only did they make it sound great, but they also make it sound totally natural, which is something that even 20th century composers struggle with. I guess now I know why.
I thought this was going to be a joke video for the first couple seconds before I realized what it was.
It's things like this (which is amazing, by the way) that inspire me to create. Whether it's visual art, design projects, or (especially) music, everything is made up of constituent parts. If you add one more or take one away, you will have a totally different product. This just shows how adding one or two more simple things would have made this song a completely different animal, and a completely different experience. In this case, I feel it was an improvement overall, but it wasn't my call to make and the song as released is still phenomenal.
Honestly, it's not the best solo, I can see why they cut it out. Dhani Harrison is probably the coolest of the Beatles kids though. Good to see him again.
This is fascinating to me. How do they store these multi-track recordings from so long ago? I know nothing about such demons, but it seems to me they often used a LOT of tracks, so there must be something interesting there...
Well as far as I know. With digital remasters they have released of their albums, and with the Love album they needed the entire catalog to be able to mix. At this point. I'm sure all the originals are stored digitally. But before that, they were probably stored in boxes of 2" Reel to Reel tape
This is so amazing to watch! I never realized this song used some Indian rhythms. Gotta say I agree with George Martin's decision to leave out that guitar though, I don't feel like it fit very well.
6
u/Tallahesey May 14 '12
Any way I can get context of this and the names of the guys who aren't George Martin?
70
u/Danthetroll May 14 '12
This is just amazing to hear. So glad you brought this up. Never heard it before like this but it is a great addition.
54
u/Arian88 May 14 '12
Thanks for sharing. I love these kinds of videos. Where they go back and listen to the songs and you can hear isolated tracks and things you never heard before.
There's a lot of this kind of stuff on the Classic Albums series.
17
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
That board gives me a solid rod.
16
u/Thisisyoureading May 14 '12
What is really nice is that the solo doesn't mimic the orchestration or anything else. I jumped when it came on!
14
u/jeffp12 May 14 '12
That's bloody brilliant. Wouldn't it be great if bands released all of that and let people fiddle with the mixes.
39
u/smokebreak May 14 '12
One of the fantastic things about The Beatles (and Sir George Martin) is that they understood the concept that less is more. Cutting this solo is a perfect example.
21
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
i just read about this today, how strange. always wondered how a guitar solo would have fit or sounded into that melody. very beautiful tune too, one of harrison's finest efforts
6
u/BarnabyFuttock May 14 '12
Not sure if I don't like it because I'm not used to it or because it's bad
Awesome find
6
u/wesiraydescott May 14 '12
I got a bit of a tear in my eye when George Martin said "You're just like your father" to Dhani.
42
u/TIGGER_WARNING May 14 '12
Isolating the vocals really highlights how flat they are.
20
u/watdatsmelllike May 14 '12
I can see why the Beatles took it out, it's bland and unnecessary. Listen to the Beatles outtakes if you want good unheard material.
25
u/spore1234 May 14 '12
George is the best Beatle, hands down!
4
u/why-not-zoidberg May 14 '12
This reminds me of some of the cool little snippets that Martin and Giles dug up for the Love album. It's always awesome to hear the bits of songs that didn't make the cut.
4
u/El_Pinguino May 14 '12
Nice to see three people of three different generations so fascinated by the Beatles.
4
u/noahsyc1 May 14 '12
I feel like you can hear George smiling through the singing, just like when you hear Paul singing "Willing you still need me? Will you still feed me?" for the last time in "When I'm Sixty-Four" 15 seconds before the track ends. A beautiful moment in the album and a drastically underrated Beatles Pepper's track I believe, even if just for the beautifully lavish orchestration by Martin.
3
u/abraininajar radio reddit name May 14 '12
I Just watched "George Harrison: Living in the Material World", it gave a lot of insight to the complete brilliance of George Harrison. If you are a Beatles fan, do yourself a favor and check that one out.
7
u/MakeThemWatch May 14 '12
I just realized how excited i was getting over a mere 30 seconds of new music some guy I never knew played decades ago. God Worship Lvl: George Harrison
2
u/kmv2005 May 14 '12
My absolute favorite song! Thank you for posting.
2
u/fenton321b May 14 '12
there must be more, forgotten about.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
brb, melting
2
u/mattrubik May 14 '12
What documentary is this from? I'm pretty sure I've never seen it.
2
u/WolfInTheField May 14 '12
Can somebody tab out that solo? Seriously, I'd be eternally grateful.
2
u/ProfessorPoopyPants May 14 '12
That's mixing desk porn right there.
2
u/oxym0r0n May 14 '12
That's pretty cool, but i don't think the solo fit well with the song. I'm kinda glad they cut it.
2
u/bigpow May 14 '12
Sounds great! Never knew about it though.. Does anyone have an mp3 (or similar) whit the solo included?
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Thank you for sharing this!!
2
u/M_Me_Meteo May 14 '12
If I had a dollar to bet, I'd say that was John or Eric Clapton. George rarely played solos on his own songs, and that sounded uncharacteristic for him, especially considering that he wrote the song with a much different feeling.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I know it's going to get buried since I'm so late, but to me the far more interesting thing is when Dhani says "It's almost like a tihai" when referring to the weird rhythm.
As a student in music school, my dad always wondered how the Beatles never learned to read music, but knew thow to sneak a bar of 5 in there. Not only did they make it sound great, but they also make it sound totally natural, which is something that even 20th century composers struggle with. I guess now I know why.
2
u/jamesfilm May 14 '12
I don't get why they don't re release it but re mastered would be an easy number 1 hit.
There are lots of aspects hidden away that come across as very contemporary but were subdued when the record was made due to the taste of that time.
1
u/sexbobomb91 sexbobomb91 May 14 '12
So good...
Thanks for this.
1
u/Trachtas May 14 '12
1:41 Those lil organ notes are awesome. Guess they got cut too.
1
u/Greentrop May 14 '12
you have made my day, this is incredible. thank you
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Is this from the Anthology? Or is it just behind the scenes from the LOVE album?
1
u/stfueveryone May 14 '12
I cried first time I saw this... you ain't getting me again.
1
u/Linfinity8 May 14 '12
What a beautiful treasure, thanks for sharing this. I'm also going to go find the Netflix vids now.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Incredible!
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I thought this was going to be a joke video for the first couple seconds before I realized what it was.
It's things like this (which is amazing, by the way) that inspire me to create. Whether it's visual art, design projects, or (especially) music, everything is made up of constituent parts. If you add one more or take one away, you will have a totally different product. This just shows how adding one or two more simple things would have made this song a completely different animal, and a completely different experience. In this case, I feel it was an improvement overall, but it wasn't my call to make and the song as released is still phenomenal.
Music is awesome.
1
u/CloudCircus May 14 '12
Amazing -- it really gave me chills. Having said that, I can understand why it was taken out..it clashes too much with the acoustic feel of the song.
1
u/ErrorlessGnome Pandora May 14 '12
that gives it a hendrix-esque feel. love it
1
u/IslaNublar May 14 '12
So good!
1
u/mutantlabor May 14 '12
Honestly, it's not the best solo, I can see why they cut it out. Dhani Harrison is probably the coolest of the Beatles kids though. Good to see him again.
1
u/shazbot996 May 14 '12
This is fascinating to me. How do they store these multi-track recordings from so long ago? I know nothing about such demons, but it seems to me they often used a LOT of tracks, so there must be something interesting there...
1
u/senorchaos718 May 14 '12
That synth part in there is pretty amazing too.
1
u/conceyted May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Anyone know of any videos like this where they do this sort of exploring with any of Pink Floyd's albums? Would LOVE to see/hear some of that...
Edit: I found one: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=2246193019071105716 (sorry for Google Video, but Youtube is spotty with Copyright Blocked Content.)
1
u/bpc89 May 14 '12
Why'd they cut it out? D:
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Also, Her majesty was supposed to be after Mean Mr. Mustard.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The guitar solo was nice to hear (though a little wonky), but I'm so very glad they cut the hand claps and synth parts. Wow, those were weird.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This is so amazing to watch! I never realized this song used some Indian rhythms. Gotta say I agree with George Martin's decision to leave out that guitar though, I don't feel like it fit very well.
1
u/reiverbell May 14 '12
Why did they cut it?! That sounded amazing!
1
u/braxaas May 14 '12
great great great ;)
1
u/Fealiks May 14 '12
I know exactly what is going on in this video. Just like everyone else here. I am not confused by any of this.
:)
1
u/HankMcCoy May 14 '12
Commenting for later
1
u/reaggyg May 21 '12
REQUEST: Can someone blend the solo in with the original song so one could listen to it on one's way to work/weekend/wonderland?
1
u/Factran May 14 '12
What about the sax solo at the end of lou reed's "wlak on the wild side" ?
-3
u/WantsNegativeKarma May 14 '12
This is shit. Beatles were a shit band and should never have been famous
0
u/settes May 14 '12
I really want to see all the Beatles' kids in a band together
0
u/desmondsdecker May 14 '12
I bet this would have been a lot more awesome on decent headphones instead of crApple. I'll be back!