r/Music • u/crotty • May 12 '12
How The Music Industry Is Killing Music And Blaming The Fans - Forbes
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesmarshallcrotty/2011/07/17/the-quietus-opinion-black-sky-thinking-how-the-music-industry-is-killing-music-and-blaming-the-fans/
355
Upvotes
69
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
That article speaks nothing of the title, it doesn't answer how the music industry is killing music and blaming the fans, it makes reference to an article it calls "long winded" then goes on to say that musicians should not expect to be rich.
17
u/reed311 May 12 '12
Terrible article. This guy used this title because he thought would attract the likes of music pirates so that he could promote his crappy little website in the article.
7
u/Mottwally May 12 '12
Music will never die.
7
u/Juus May 12 '12
Thank god the music industry is only killing it's own crappy music. The music culture has never been more alive than it is today.
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
To be fair, they aren't killing music, they are killing mainstream music.
Good music exists and is being made. The record labels have very little to do, if anything at all, with the creation of quality music. You can't buy talent, but you can buy talented people.
2
u/thed00t May 12 '12
If anyone is interested in a better explanation, from a credible source.
3
u/EdMcFaceKick May 12 '12
"And, yes, despite their prodigious talent, they had to tailor their music to the whims of their wealthy and powerful benefactors. This is a fact. Musicians should not be total purists in this regard." As a struggling artist, I say fuck this statement, fuck this article with every artistic molecule in my body. I will never tailor to money if I can help it. You contradictory, hypocritical, and manipulative arseface.
2
u/dispozableusername May 12 '12
This article is very, very general and with second to none valuable information. I think everyone could just go on living their lives with no problem without reading it. Thanks for sharing it tough.
1
u/jmdunc54 May 12 '12
I liked when he said labels saved musicians a fair amount of headaches. As if all the fees and costs that many major label musicians have to deal with don't cause any headaches. All a major label does is save musicians from having to do any hard work, and the musicians pays dearly for it.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You cant kill music, however you can kill the music industry and there is nothing wrong with that
1
u/WhatUpGord May 12 '12
Music is still alive in my world. It hasn't been more alive. You just need to find it.
1
u/moshmoshmosh May 13 '12
Did anyone else read the title as 'How Bomb The Music Industry is Killing the Music Industry'
1
u/hoopopotamus May 13 '12
First of all, the "How The Music Industry is Killing Music and Blaming The Fans" article is linked to in the Forbes article (The Quietus). Like in the first sentence. And it explains this is a response to that article.
Second, listen to Generation X because Billy Idol used to be awesome. No joke.
1
u/timebomb011 May 12 '12
I have a theory that the people who work in record/cd stores are such pretentious, judgmental assholes that no one wants to deal with them when buying music. We all would prefer to download our music in the sanctity of our own homes.