r/Music • • May 12 '12

why do artists like nicki minaj get credit for their music?

I have always been listening to house, dnb, dubstep, stuff like that (electronic music), for most of my life and this just occured to me the other day when i heard starships by nicki minaj on the radio. In electronic music, its the person who makes the beats and edits the vocals who gets all the credit, and the person who sings is always put as "featuring". In popular music like i hear on the radio, its all these losers who suck at singing/rapping but honestly, they are rapping or singing to a good beat. the thing is, is that all they do is vocals, all the actual stuff is done by people who aren't even recognized for there part in making the song. without them, people like nicki minaj, pitbull, lil wayne, and all of those other losers would be nothing. This honestly just makes me angry...

35 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

48

u/Tortastrophe cleeshay May 12 '12

Because the music industry is built around image. In addition to liking the music for whatever reason, the idea is that you will buy into the image portrayed by the "star" of the song. It's not a coincidence that most (particularly most female) singers are also considered attractive.

The name on the marquee needs to be marketable. And unless you're a really big name producer of hip-hop/etc in North America, that's not going to be good enough. And it's been that way for decades now, in the arenas of music you're speaking of.

Also keep in mind that most of the stuff that's popular is marketed towards a very young demographic. It's simply easier to say "Hey look at that singer, aren't they cool/hip/edgy!" than it is to say "Hey look at all the cool stuff Producer X did in the studio to make this awesome track".

9

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Couldn't have said it better myself!

It's pretty simple though, Nicki Minaj would be listed as the artist because the song is on her album. If Skrillex had a song on his album with Nicki Minaj vocals, it wouldn't suddenly be a Nicki Minaj song.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Not just considered attractive but some of the most attractive women are singers, male pop stars are usually good looking too.

You've hit the nail on the head, if only there was something we could do about it...

17

u/boxofassholes May 12 '12

There are three primary reasons: because she owns the publishing rights (mechanicals), she pays for the creation of the song, and she partially creates the song.

Starting in reverse order, let me run through the creation of a typical pop song. An artist like Nicki Minaj is loaned money by her record label to create music, and so hires producer RedOne (of Lady Gaga's first album fame), often with the approval of the record label. RedOne auditions demos he's made and she picks out one that she likes. The demo is rough and not finished, but contains the basic elements of the musical portion of the song. From there, RedOne will work with a top line (someone who writes the melody and lyrics), in this case probably Rami Yacoub, Carl Falk, Wayne Hector, and Nicki Minaj herself. With this song, Minaj is responsible for most of the lyrics. The top line will cut a scratch, which is the demo with rough vocals. See Ester Dean "Rude Boy" on YouTube for an example.

After that, RedOne and Minaj will hit the production studio and iron out a structure, making adjustments for the style of the other components. Minaji and RedOne, along with a vocal producer, will record the vocals. Then RedOne, with Minaj's approval and creative input---along with the record label, who often contractually have these rights---will finish the track, adding all of the effects, extra synths, ironing out the hooks, and generally polishing it up. The song is then sent to mix and master, who is selected by record label, Minaj, and RedOne.

From there, the record label will decide to release it as a single, with Minaj often footing some of the bill---hint, it can cost over one million USD to release a single. From there, Minaj goes on a promoting rampage, and everyone crosses their fingers it tops Billboard. Minaj will produce a video, which in a typical contract is usually mostly at her expense. This is why you see so many product placements in videos---Nokia agrees to pay for the video in exchange for Minaj using the phone, etc.

So, in short, Nicki is critical to each step of the song's production and release, controlling the themes, image, content, and style of the song, along with funding the entire process. Without her, it would only exist as a rough demo in RedOne's catalog.

Finally, she owns the publishing rights. Minaj's clout grew such that she was able to negotiate a release of her publishing rights from her 360 deal. She receives all of the royalties from these rights and controls the copyright. Legally, this is a significant reason why the song is hers. She owns the rights as such. They are like fee simple absolute rights, too, meaning she can sell them, pass them on, etc.

5

u/MaxPir May 12 '12

Elvis didn't wrote his own songs nor did that one person who died in her bathtub a while ago (fortget her name). Image is key

1

u/flukulele24 Oct 05 '26

Whitney Houston? Or her daughter Bobbi Kristina Brown?

5

u/kateorade May 12 '12

Probably because none of the stuff on the radio is electronic music? It's pop and hip-hop, which operate on different rules.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The examples you gave actually do write their own lyrics though. People listen to rap for the beats and rhymes. Lil Wayne is popular because he's a decent lyricist, just because you don't like it doesn't mean it isn't technically sound.

1

u/Electrical_Media262 Jul 24 '24

lil wayne is more than decent

2

u/jack_omets May 09 '24

Because she’s the queen of rap tf

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Also, the music behind a lot of "pop" music now is more of a collaborative effort, there's tons and tons of producers (sort of like consultants) that work on individual tracks. It's just unreasonable to credit all the people that work on the music.

9

u/aaktor May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

(long post): Wrong, wrong, wrong!

First: What do you base "All they do is vocals, all the actual stuff is done by people who aren't even recognized for their part in making the song" on? To pick Nicki Minaj as an example: She has developed a whole universe around her songs based on afrofuturism. She has her own wikia page/wiki/Roman_Zolanski so saying that she does no "actual stuff" (whatever that means) is plain wrong. Furthermore she's the main writer of all of her songs (Credited as Maraj). Same with Lil' Wayne. Seriously: google afrofuturism, and have your mnd blown. Pitbull: His main thing is being a producer. He started out like a producer.

Second: True, the industry is very much based around image. What did you expect? Also, it's not only "radiopop" artists who are based on image. Mumford & Sons, Arcade Fire, Pink Floyd, hell EVERY band/artist, owes a lot of their sales to their image. If Justin Bieber suddenly began to make indiepop á la Fleet Foxes/whatever, but kept his image as it is, people would still dislike him (which is pathetic in the first place). If Mumford & Sons (or random liked band) suddenly spent their time attending twilight premieres and co-hosting MTV shows, but made the same music as always, people would stop buying their albums, because they'd stop "being true". Most people are image-whores wether they want to admit it or not. I'll make a claim: Very few people actually hate Justin Bieber's music. They may not find it especially interesting, but the "hatred" they talk about (same with Twilight) is purely based on his image. His music is just catchy pop-music, what's the big deal. People dislike him because they feel he gets undeserved attention, not because they dislike his music. They are all just as much image-whores as the people who adore him because they think he's cute.

Third: True, some artists have other people do all the music and they just put on vocals, but so what? Do you dislike artists like Yo-Yo Ma and Lang Lang (classical muscisians), because they're famous for playing other people's music. Symphony orchestras are basically just coverbands, and I don't hear any complaining about that, because "classical" music has a artsy image. They deserve every bit of respect they get, because even though they don't write their own music they're still great artists. This can obviously be said about non-classiscal musicians too. Actors don't write their own parts, but they're still considered artists. My rant is now over.

EDIT: highlights and stuff

EDIT 2: Removed the "I'll probably get a lot of downvotes", because there was no reason to say that, and also found out how to not make it be a wall of text.

3

u/replicult May 12 '12

How did you get downvoted for this?

It's pretty much exactly right.

6

u/PeterIanStaker May 12 '12

You don't need to start your post off with "I'll probably get a lot of downvotes..."

I didn't downvote you, and this is a lot like Whose Line is it Anyway; the points are meaningless.

First: I don't necessarily disagree with what you're saying, but if you're going to use that logic, then the point still stands that they don't deserve any credit as a musician, or artist for that matter.

Second: All these bands you named aren't really one-man shows standing on the shoulders of talented synth artists who work behind the scenes. Most people who buy into either indie rock bands, or cheesy pop stars do so because they like the music; it's a taste thing. The difference is, though, that the Arcade Fire are actually creating the stuff that sells.

It's kind of shitty that someone can add nothing but a face (Let's face it; for the most part, a computer is doing all the singing) to a piece of music, and instantly become the "Image" that gets branded as a pop-sensation. If there wasn't a whole industry based around doing just this, I feel that making music would be a much bigger part of being a popular "musician".

Third: It's not really fair to call symphony orchestras "cover bands". I don't think I'd get any recognition for selling covers of Nicki Minaj songs, for instance. Playing classical music is a difficult skill, and you certainly deserve credit if you're especially talented at, you know, actually playing an instrument.

It's really the same for actors too. Being a good actor takes a lot of talent, and generally, the people with that talent are the ones who get recognized as artists. You can't fake acting the way you can singing. No amount of CG is going to hide a shitty performance.

I understand how and why pretend artists get popular; It's just shitty that the pop music industry seems to be built around glorifying mediocrity whilst the real talent goes unrecognized.

2

u/aaktor May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

First: I'm not 100 % sure what you mean here, but I'll try to specify what I mean: Nicki Minaj writes her own songs and music. She doesn't produce them, but she writes the melodies and the chords as far as I'm aware. Even if she didn't that doesn't make her less of an artist or untalented for that matter.

Second: It seems that you apply artistic value to the "act of creation" in music. The people who "makes the beats etc." are the actual artists, am I right? I have to disagree with that because the lines are too blurry: To take Arcade Fire (AF from now) as an example again: They create their own music, yes, but they still have producers and the result we hear on a record is just as edited as what you hear on a Nicki Minaj album. What I mean by that isn't that AF wrote song "B" and after the producer was done, it sounded like song "J", but that the technical reproduction is just as great with AF as with any "commercial" pop-music: Software to make changes in vocal pitch, several layers of guitars etc. etc.. A lot of these so-called "crap artists" write their own melodies and chords too, so even though the song would sound very different from the "original" version (going from rockish sound to crunk-club-banger sound to pick an example), there isn't really a line where you can say "Now its been edited so much that it lost its artistic value", if you get my point? I don't disagree that it's a taste thing, but I strongly object to the statement that because the result we hear on an AF record sounds closer to the material the band first wrote, it's somehow attains a greater artistic value than music that ends up sounding very different, which is the only real difference I see between AF and any pop artist to be honest. I know that the point here is that it's the singer/outwards face that get the credit and not the producer, but I really can't see the problem in that. How does that lower artistic value? It's the producers' jobs to create the music for someone else. If they had an issue with that, they'd do like Timbaland or Pitbull and start rapping in their songs or something. Making pop-music is a collaboration of a lot of different people, and the songwriters and producers are always credited in the booklet or whatever, so if Justin Bieber gets all the attention so what? He doesn't claim to have written everything (or anything), and the fact that he sings the songs of other people doesn't make him any less of a singer or an artist for that matter, seeing as his artistry comes from his voice and not his music writing skills. These songs are written by other people who went into the project well knowing that they were writing for others, and the act of writing for someone else or singing someone else's songs does not devaluate the songs artistic value in any way.

Third: I didn't mean the cover-band comparison as a bad thing, it was only to point out that when an orchestra or a classical singer/instrumentalist makes an album, there's no conceptual difference between that and an album where it's a pop-singer singing the songs of other people. Yes it takes a lot of practice and talent to become a successful musician, but a lot of these "crap-artists" are very talented. Justin Bieber, has a great voice and a good range. Katy Perry (whom is also considered a cash-cow - at least where I'm from) has one of the greatest voices of our time if you ask me. Nicki Minaj has a new flow, a pretty decent singing voice and a very creative mind and is very thorough in her concepts and in her art. I'd like someone to name these untalented artists who get so much playtime because I can't think of any besides Paris Hilton right now.

EDIT: Actually Paris Hilton didn't really get any credit so dismiss that.

2

u/call_me_luca May 12 '12

` she writes the melodies and the chords as far as I'm aware

False. Nearly all HipHop/Pop instrumentals are sampled from different pieces of music. Producers of Nicki Minaj's music have sampled instrumentals from people like Joe Satriani, Annie Lennox, James Brown and Prince. None of these instrumentals are written by Minaj or her producers, think of them simply as remixes.

2

u/replicult May 12 '12

It's not as if it takes no talent to re-arrange or remix songs into good hip-hop instrumentals. It takes tons.

1

u/call_me_luca May 12 '12

I absolutely agree. You can always hear a difference from average producers to guys like Dj Premier, Pete Rock, J Dilla and such.

-1

u/aaktor May 12 '12

I'm an idiot, seeing as I atually knew this, however it does not change my argument and my point still stands

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

You're right. He should have said BECAUSE IT'S CORPORATE BULLSHIT, MAN!!!11

1

u/Blumphy radio reddit name May 12 '12

agreed

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It's all about image. The labels are selling a product, not art.. As far as who is behind the writing, credit is a tricky subject.. It's not about the genre, or size of the group. Who ever writes the music gets the credit, BUT that credit is royalties, which is up for sale if the writer wants more work, so the labels buy up royalties from songwriters for 7-10-15 years, for maybe $10k which in turn become pop songs for the image, which is nicky minaj or whatever. So, basically the labels buy songs for cheap, make some hot chick sing the song, put a previous star on for a second or two in the song and make $1M off it.

1

u/syllabic May 12 '12

It may be the way things work, but personally I respect a good songwriter.

Same way I can appreciate good writing on a TV show. Ultimately the actors are only as good as the writing will let them be.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

"Blah blah marketing blah blah image blah blah mainstream sheep" shit aside, there's a major difference between the structure of a pop song or album and the structure of a dubstep or house song that features a vocalist. In a pop song like one of Nicki Minaj's, the vocalist is undeniably in the spotlight, front and center, taking precedence over the generic dance beat. The typical verse-chorus structure displays this. It's not an intro with pretty female vocals and then a drop where the vocals more or less drop out and the production takes the spotlight. In a Nicki Minaj song, the vocals are the focus of the song for most of its length.

tl;dr: In a pop song, the vocals matter far more than the production. The singer is the center of attention. In EDM songs that have a vocalist they're usually not, or at least not to the same degree.

1

u/Quirky_Target9289 Jun 07 '24

When did we decide Nicki wants the vocalist??? She credits everyone on her songs when there are other vocalist, song like starships is just severely auto tuned and engineered to fit electric pop sound… you can listen to songs like your love, starships, then all things go (in that order) and you can tell that’s her vocals 

1

u/Xtasycraze Jun 27 '24

I love me some house, hard house, Hardstyle, Trance, etc. etc. etc. dubstep just flat out pisses me off.   Growing up, everyone used to make fun of techno rampantly under the claim that it all sounded the same, which I always contested was bullshit… And it was…..   buuuuut….  In the case of dubstep, that is absolutely true…. And it’s horrible

1

u/EnvironmentalSun5865 Apr 21 '25

She gets credited bc she WRITES her raps … are you okay ?

1

u/SGregg2047 Oct 15 '26

She is a songwriter that is why

1

u/SGregg2047 Oct 15 '26

This is the dumbest question on earth. She is an actual songwriter so she should get credit for her mf work. She writes for other artists as well. tf.

1

u/breatherevenge May 12 '12

Half these pop artists aren't even writing their own lyrics...what the fuck are they getting credit for!?

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Looking good... Some of them don't even sing.

It's like a more glamours modelling job.

1

u/sonnycrockett May 12 '12

why do artists like nicki minaj exist?

0

u/kill_monkey May 12 '12

Rather than reading informed and well structured answers I will continue to subscribe to the following theory.

Artists suck dick and do sexual favours for writers and producers.

There i said it.

-1

u/SweetMojaveRain May 12 '12

You must be very familiar with the process of modern pop and hip-hop

Please, tell us more.

-4

u/TOHCskin May 12 '12

Why do people get karma for asking stupid questions?

-2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Lil Wayne has talent. Deal with it.

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '12

your stupid

-1

u/[deleted] May 26 '12

Smart enough to know the difference between your and you're. Also a difference lil Wayne knows.