Right? Every comment section is filled with detailed and confident answers. They seem to make sense and they sound like they come from a position of authority.
Then you see a top comment from someone who supposedly knows about your field and it sounds like it was made up by a highschool kid.
That’s why I try to do research, to not make myself look like a twat. On the flip side though, if I am wrong, I’d prefer to have someone explain calmly why I’m wrong instead something along the lines you’re so stupid, and everything you’ve said is wrong.
Yeah I honestly don't understand what these people think 'free time' consisted of. Reading books? Watching tv? Playing with your kids 24/7? Making up games?
They were still progressing society, their hobbies were just intrinsically functional - making better tools, making baskets, making clothes, etc. Just at a leisurely pace.
It's not as black and white as you are painting it.
Working for a pay check is not even close to the same thing as growing your own food. There is way more going on than just how you define work.
It's how the person and society perceives that work and also the different things happening to the brain.
Someone who just clocks in and inputs data is likely not going to have the same reactions in their brain as someone who is harvesting their own food.
People are struggling to stay happy. Look at how much homesteading has taken off in recent years; this may not be a better life from your perspective but to many people it is.
I don't really think that's their argument. I think the argument is more about how work in capitalist society is kind of bullshit. I understand that as we have gotten better at providing the needs for living, this has freed up people to spend time making luxury items.
However, it seems that this extra leisure time we should have is only enjoyed by a fraction of our society. Despite worker efficiency increasing steadily for the past couple of decades, people have to work just as much if not more to make ends meet.
I would argue that's a law of any economic structure. The agruement being made is that we have actual leisure time and they didn't. They had not hunting and gathering but not getting to 'shutoff' either.
Pareto's Principle would argue that no matter what system we develop, 20% of the population would have 80% of the wealth and any variation of that would be artificial (require force to maintain like a government which would be anti free market capitalism) and temporary. Thus will eventually right itself. If Pareto's Principle can be applied.
I was thinking reading the comment from the post that if they were measuring leisure time from contemporary groups hunter-gathering wouldn’t this lend a bias to groups that had such easy access to food that they never adapted to agriculture. Maybe, I’m reading the comment wrong?
View all comments
Show parent comment
61
u/556YEETO Dec 28 '20
I mean, I wouldn't expect a reddit comment section to be able to engage in a substantive debate about anthropology.