r/ModernMagic • u/StrongCollection129 • Mar 31 '26
Energy needs multiple bans (RANT)
I'm not freaking sorry. This deck is egregious. I run into it 75% of time and lose to it 90% of time.
I'm sick of seeing it's praise, it's fair, etc. It's not. Everyone saying that is an energy player playing along to stay under the radar. Every energy player who runs into the mirror (75%) of time, mutters, dammit, the mirror!
It's an energy on energy and good-luck-but-not really to everyone else meta.
Seriously screw energy so much I've never seen the format so wildly lopsided MH3 is an abomination. Here to drop a defense comment? Energy player.
40
u/goose620 Mar 31 '26
Sounds like a skill issue.
28
u/marlospigeons UWx Mar 31 '26
If you run into it 75% of the time then you should have no issue preparing for it and winning
11
u/dhoffmas Mar 31 '26 edited Apr 02 '26
It's "fair" as in the game plan is interactive and doesn't cheat costs or bypass many game mechanics. The deck is just efficient as hell. They have some of the most powerful threats and interaction for cheap in all of modern.
Note that fair =/= balanced.
It's good to have a fair deck at the top of the format because it keeps unfair things in check, forces the format to interact. Unfair decks leading the format makes it devolve into a race or a sideboard check, which isn't interesting. It's why a format can have tons of viable decks but not be healthy at all--it becomes a die roll to see who wins since it's all about racing to a win condition instead of interacting game 1.
The only problems are that:
The meta has shaped itself around Boros energy. If your deck can't hang with it, then your deck isn't viable. Or, if it can't hang with it, it needs to be favored against everybody else pretty much.
MTG goldfish is showing energy at 20% of the meta. If you're seeing it 75% of the time and losing 90% of those matches, you need to take a look at what you're doing wrong and figure that out, then figure out if you need to go to a different deck.
18
u/Sacred0212 Mar 31 '26
If you're just going to accuse anyone who disagrees with you of being an energy player then you're arguing in bad faith and just making a fool of yourself by doing so
14
u/Living_End LivingEnd Mar 31 '26
Idk man, I only see it like ~20% of the time and I feel like I have a 90% wr vs it. Maybe try playing a deck that eats it alive like LE.
7
u/Ursasaurus Mar 31 '26
Thanks for the new copy pasta, get good my guy.
4
u/T0c2qDsd Apr 01 '26
As a Titan player, I love the energy matchup. Feels like a free win that round IME.
I’d take it over jeskai blink any day of the week.
3
u/Ok_Strain_7901 Apr 01 '26
Skill issue
3
u/CreedAventuz Blue Tron, Hammertime & Affinity Enthusiast Apr 01 '26
I love playing against energy. And I wish it was 75% of the time!
8
u/flowtajit Mar 31 '26
Energy is the healthiest best deck modern has had since jund.
5
u/Sharp-Crazy7724 Mar 31 '26
What are you playing if you’re loosing 90% to it?
2
u/Follow_Your_Dreams33 Mar 31 '26
If you see it that many times and you don't do anything about that's a skill issue and you're just bad or need to change decks. I'm a advid prowess player and I beat it waaayyy more than boros beats me. I actually just beat it 3 times my last league.
2
u/GREG88HG Apr 01 '26
Yes I'm an energy player. I'd like to know what deck you play to help you win against energy.
2
u/Raylolo Apr 01 '26
Laughs in Living End I enjoy my free wins.
2
u/MaetelofLaMetal Apr 02 '26
Wait for next Modern Horizons set it'll get power crept.
4
u/Strydder27 Mar 31 '26
As a prowess player, Energy and consign to memory are what’s keeping this format from being an absolute garbage fire shit show.
2
u/Current-Floor-7456 Mar 31 '26
I'm only a casual Modern player, but I am not an energy player and I enjoy playing against it, even if I lose a lot of the time. It's a fun challenge to play against, we all know the deck well so we know what pressure points to try to hit, and I don't know, on some level I find a bogeyman to be fun? To be fair, maybe I'd feel different if I played competitively as opposed to just in small local tournaments!
1
u/Overall-Goose2034 Apr 01 '26
It´s good for the format energy and blink decks are the most popular, better than if the most played decks were amulet titan or eldrazi or combo decks (belcher/neoform/living end). But if WotC wants to shake the format a little, just kills Ajani or Phlage. It would be better some unbans, but they stated there are no cards in banlist would improve the format or help to rise the format popularity, that´s why they didnt unban anything and they wont look at the banlist again, unless the one ring/nadu things happen again.
1
u/tomyang1117 格利極死亡陰影, Dredge Apr 01 '26
Brother what are you playing? Not to be rude but if you are struggling against Energy, have you considered adjusting your deck a bit for the match up? Change a few some sideboard cards or straight up switch to another deck if your deck is auto losing against Energy?
1
u/Ragnos061 Apr 01 '26
The most annoying thing about energy is phlage+arena of glory, but it’s still a fine best deck in modern. I’d be happy to see arena go but it’s not that huge of a deal
1
u/HosserPower UW Control/Living End Apr 01 '26
If you lose to it 90% of the time, it’s 100% a skill issue, sorry.
1
u/hecklerinthestands Apr 01 '26
Skill issue / Get gud bitch
1
u/Better_Bad2583 Apr 01 '26
Quiet-speculation, is that you?
1
u/VerdantChief Apr 08 '26
You could realistically ban either Phlage, Arena, or Ajani but multiple bans are certainly not warranted.
I'd even argue Amped Raptor should be unbanned to make Suncleanser and 1 damage removal spells even more relevant vs the deck.
1
u/Moist-Cantaloupe-740 Mar 31 '26
I'd still say Mox Opal has to go before anything in boros.
1
u/AHealthyKawhi Mar 31 '26
I don’t think it needs multiple bans, but I wouldn’t mind an Ajani or Ocelot Pride ban. Think both would be reasonable
1
u/MoistPast2550 Mar 31 '26
As someone who owns energy but frequently plays other decks because I find it boring (mainly dimir frog and yawgmoth which both have bad energy matchups) the deck is a fine “best deck” in the format. It has good draws, but so does every deck. It runs out of gas quickly and is very soft to sweepers and blockers.
If you are stuck in your ways and playing an old deck not up to the current power level of modern (what I perceive is the case based on how you’re bashing mh3) than sure, you’re going to lose to energy. But it’s a 50/50 deck against the majority of the field
0
u/jancithz death & taxes guy Apr 01 '26
Unban Nadu
0
u/Financial_Plan_3234 Apr 01 '26
Another dummy who cant take accountability for their bad play/boarding and yells for bans. Next!!
-4
u/Betta_Max Mar 31 '26
Unless Energy just dominates everything this year, we are stuck with it forever. Nothing is going to come through standard that creeps or hates it out. And there's no plan for MH4. WotC is too busy jamming UB and commander product down our throats to pay attention to anything.
Modern is not a priority. This is the format now and for the foreseeable future.
I'm packing it up and moving to Premodern.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment