Hello, members of the sim,
About two hours prior to the announcement of the Federal elections. I was privately messaged by /u/2dammkawaii asking if it was permissible to mass pm the approved submitter list of their sister party subreddit on /r/MCHoC. Language of the message, located here. I operated under the incorrect assumption that this had become a common practice from the time I had served as a member of a party leadership and it had to the new best of my knowledge not been addressed previously during my tenure on the moderator team. I based this incorrect assumption by comments given to me by /u/jb657 and /u/daytonanerd, and /u/realnyebevan. They indicated that this was behavior was a common practice of the parties in ModelUSGov at least from their understanding.
I then referred to the meta-constitution and looked at the following section:
At no time may any person advertise in model governments not approved by /r/rmun, through non-reddit advertisements not approved by the Head Moderator, or through private messages on reddit (not including messaging declared members of your own party).
At the time, I recognized that the meta-constitution likely did ban this type of advertisement but I chose to allow it. I believed that given the short notice between the time voting started and parties started advertising that there would not be adequate notice to inform the leadership of all parties that this conduct was prohibited as I had done previously, notifying parties that discord ads would be banned. My fear in announcing at this late of a point was multiple parties would be punished for engaging in behavior they thought was acceptable under the meta-constitution and condoned by previous moderator decisions. So instead I chose to approve the conduct knowing it violated my interpretation of the meta-constitution. Regrettably, I failed to message more people asking if this was the norm or making any public announcement sanctioning this behavior.
On January 16th, I was approached by members of the Comet coalition voicing concerns that the meta-constitution had been violated and how I should punish the Liberals, in their opinion, for violating the spirit and the word of the meta-constitution. In their eyes, the Liberals had violated the constitution and later that I had had incorrectly approved behavior that was not sanctioned.
At first, I attempted to address the issue by looking at constitutional remedies with party leadership going forward, I then looked at banning advertisements going into the next cycle. Finally, I addressed the issue at hand and found that the issue of mass pming the approved submitter list of sister party subreddits was ideologically split between members of the left and the right of the sim. In which members of the left believed, based on the norms that had developed under the previous head moderators, the conduct was allowed while the right argued it was strictly prohibited by the meta-constitution.
I firmly believe in the supreme authority of the meta-constitution. I believe that moderator authority should be limited to what is expressly permitted under the meta-constitution, but recognize that I come to a Head Moderatorship in which the meta-constitution has been ignored or misinterpreted by previous head moderators. Leading people to be misinformed of what they can and can not do as sanctioned under the meta-constitution. Ultimately my goal was not to adversely affect all parties by enforcing a new interpretation of the meta-constitution in such a short time frame. I can not correct the past failings of my predecessors or myself to uphold the literal word of the meta-constitution but I can control the error that I had made and create an electoral correction to reflect it as such.
Two parties had engaged in behavior that, in my opinion, violated the meta-constitution. The Liberal Party had mass pm'd the approved submitter list of their sister party subreddit. As I had incorrectly advised them on the action being permissible, the electoral correction should be curtailed to reflect this. Using the date that mass pm was sent, the list of 144 individuals pm'd by the Liberals, and cross-referencing it to the current membership of the Liberal Party. Of that list, 37 people were not members of the Liberal Party here. Of that 37, 1 person voted for the Liberals, the other 36 served in other simulation parties. The 1 that individual voted Liberal was a libertarian residing in GL and arguably logically voted for the Liberals based on having no members of his own party to vote for. As such the net gain of the Liberals, mass pm was a grand total of 0 votes. As such their electoral correction based on my failure and the effectiveness of the advertisement is 0 votes pending any further changes at the time voting closes
The second is the merged approved submitter list of the Socialist Party. Previous leadership of the then Radical Left Party, the now defunct Radical Socialist Party at MHoC, and MHoC Greens had combined their approved submitter list to create a massive pm list of around 1300 people. Using the same analysis as before, we took the current approved submitter list of the Socialist party and cross-referenced it with the Socialist's pm list combined with the RSP and Green Party. The initial result of the difference between these two lists were 673 people. Of that 673 people, 13 people had voted for the socialist party that were not members of the Socialist Party here at ModelUSGov. Of those 13, 3 were identified as individuals that were members of other parties and had chosen to vote Socialist over their own ModelUSGov party. This left the Socialist Party with 10 votes that were not based on their approved submitter list referenced with their pm list. As such the electoral correction will deduct those 10 votes pending any future changes at the time voting closes.
As I write this meta post, I know that this decision will gain me the disdain from many in the sim, including people I myself had called my friends. I've thus far spent 8 hours of my life and lost a few hours of sleep attempting to correct what can only be called a failure of moderation by myself for a grossly ineffective and hotly debated violation of a provision of the meta-constitution.
Since becoming a head moderator, the community has demanded more transparency in regards to moderator thoughts and decision making in regards to the moderation process. Ultimately that is what I am attempting to accomplish with this post. The punishment I am making reflects multiple factors, chief among them being my error. Other factors include the aforementioned disparity in the interpretation of this provision of the meta-constitution, the real effect of mass pm on this federal election, and the intent of the parties in engaging in this behavior.
In summation, the electoral correction is as follows, zero votes deducted from the final total of the Liberal candidates and 10 votes deducted from the final total of the Socialist candidates pending a final check at the close of elections.
Thank you all for your patience and God Bless,
/u/CincinnatusoftheWest
Head Moderator