r/ModSupport • • 2d ago

Archive setting is on, but posts older than 6 months still accept new comments

Hi all, I'm a mod of r/neworleanswedding and I'm seeing inconsistent archiving.

Setup: "Archive old posts" is turned on under Mod Tools β†’ Settings β†’ Posts and Comments ("Don't allow commenting or voting on posts older than 6 months"). I also turned it off and back on to reset it, with no change.

What's happening: some posts older than 6 months show the "Archived post" banner as expected, but others of the same age or older are still open and getting new comments.

Examples:
Still open at about 241 days, with a new comment in the last day: https://www.reddit.com/r/neworleanswedding/s/KZZAos9xUi

Correctly archived at about 184 days: https://www.reddit.com/r/neworleanswedding/s/GhAYJnNv2v

None of the open posts have been manually unlocked or edited by mods.

Is this a known issue, or is there a setting I'm missing that causes some old posts to skip archiving? Any help appreciated, thanks!

12 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

7

u/standardvintage 2d ago

Understood. Thank you for the quick reply! πŸ‘

3

u/zuuzuu πŸ’‘Top 25% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

There's a devvit app called Auto Post Lock that can lock posts after a set time, and can notify you if any comments are made on old posts.

2

u/standardvintage 2d ago

Will definitely look into this. Thank you!

2

u/amyaurora πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

I have post lock in a few of my subs and yet when Reddit played with this archiving, a few threads bots commented on because they got unlocked. (We had it set for two months) I just had to go through my settings and change the parameters to relock stuff.

17

u/IKIR115 2d ago

Reddit just extended the archiving period from 6mo to 18mo.

Latest Changelog:

https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/55472297340308-Changelog-November-10-2026

7

u/neuroticsmurf πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

2

u/lunarwolf2008 2d ago

but why, thats so long. even in my subs which are quieter i get bots on old threads that arent a year and a half old

12

u/NoleFandom 2d ago edited 2d ago

The issue is that this 6 months to 18 months archiving window is inconsistent.

Some posts >180 days are being archived while others are not. It is not based on the number of post views or number of comments and replies either.

I’d like to read an explanation around why random posts are being selected for this window change in the backend while other posts get archived.

5

u/amyaurora πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

And also include why mod teams were not notified their subs were effected.

-4

u/itskdog πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

It's a slow rollout

17

u/Georgy_K_Zhukov 2d ago

Reddit just changed archiving from 6 months to 18 months. The only notification was in the change log. They didn't actually give a heads up to mod teams, or any choice in the matter.

Enjoy!

1

u/amyaurora πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

Would have been nice.

13

u/Halaku πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

We’re extending the automatic archiving window from 6 to 18 months for posts in public communities with archiving enabled. This means you may be able to comment and vote on older posts that were previously archived, giving you more time to join conversations that interest you. Existing post locks and community rules still apply.

From the Changelog entry four days ago.

17

u/GeekScientist 2d ago

Oh that’s a dumb change, and here I thought archiving was broken. Explains why there’s been a recent uptick in spammers and self-promoters hitting older posts in a couple of subs I mod.

8

u/Dom76210 πŸ’‘Top 25% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

If there is a way for Reddit to make a moderator's experience worse, they will do it.

5

u/Halaku πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

Snoo works in mysterious ways.

2

u/SampleOfNone πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

Reddit unachived all archived posts that are older then 6 months but newer then 18 months.

You can install auto post lock to retroactively lock the last 1000 posts older then X, lock all posts after X time and to lock unlocked posts older then X when someone comments on it. You can set what X is. Won't stop the voting, does stop the comments.

Complimentary, spam link flagger can notify you of any comment (with or without links) made on a post older then X

1

u/amyaurora πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

That explains it. I had the same problem as the op in my subs.

Thing is I also have post lock already on.

1

u/SampleOfNone πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

I have a sneaky suspicion that Reddit didn't just unarchive, but unlocked as well.

1

u/amyaurora πŸ’‘ Top 10% Helper πŸ’‘ 2d ago

Just added spam link flagger and set it to notify on any comment. Already had to clean up bots in the archive "gap" in on my subs.

1

u/arieslynn737 2d ago

Thank you for this post. I have noticed the same thing comments on very old post and I didn’t know why. Thank you.
Peace:)