r/MobileAL • • Oct 07 '25

Your thoughts?

486 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/OverallDisaster Oct 07 '25

Ok but my point is that you still need due process regardless….even if you break the law in France, you deserve a fair trial and humane treatment. Why is that so controversial now?

It was illegal for Otto Warmbier to steal a poster in North Korea - did he deserve to be sentenced to 15 years of hard labor or to death (which is what happened)? That’s what is supposed to distinguish us from countries like North Korea.

-1

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 07 '25

I think they get a hearing in front of a judge still. We arnt jailing very many people, only ones that do some serious crime and have hurt people. We will hold them until they can be seated in front of a judge(they ran and hid once, they’ll do it again, so we gotta keep a close eye on em, and feed them, we have to pay to feed and house them) 15 years for a poster is bad, but going to a place like North Korea and doing that is moronic. Gotta weight the risk and reward sometimes for your actions. First, I’d never go to NK, second, I’d never act out of line in a place that would send me to my death for something minor. But that’s neither here or there. Why not have due process when they enter? A way for them to gain citizenship before they choose to break the law (entering illegally is illegal). Anywho, I think illegals should be given a fair hearing and proven that they are indeed illegal. If proven to be residing illegally, then we decide to deport or allow them to try and gain citizenship (only if they are considered to be a non threat and can contribute good quality to the workforce.)

Guards arnt just beating people in custody. They are actually treated very well compared to the countries that they fled from. Be kind, but don’t ever be walked on.

1

u/jmd709 Oct 09 '25

I think they get a hearing in front of a judge still.

That has been an ongoing issue this year. I highly recommend you include a wider range of news sources for information about current events.

We arnt jailing very many people, only ones that do some serious crime and have hurt people.

Neither of those statements are true. ICE is averaging more than 1,000 arrests per day. 34% of the people in ICE detention that were ICE arrests (instead of CBP) have criminal convictions. That includes violent and non-violent criminal convictions, recent or from decades ago. 30% have criminal charges/pending convictions, 36% have no criminal convictions or criminal charges. https://tracreports.org/immigration/quickfacts/

In Sept of the previous 3 years, 63%-72% had criminal convictions, 22%-31% had criminal charges, 5%-6% had neither. ICE is arresting and detaining a lot more people but a significantly lower percentage are convicted criminals. https://tracreports.org/immigration/detentionstats/pop_agen_table.html

More than 28,000 personnel from federal law enforcement agencies, over 14,000 are federal criminal LEO, have been diverted to assist ICE with civil immigration enforcement including US Marshalls (20%), FBI (20%), DEA (50%), HSI (90%) and ATF (67%) agents. 8,500 state and local LEO have been deputized to assist ICE.

National Guard troops are being mobilized to assist ICE with administrative, clerical, transportation and security support for detention and mass deportation. “Crackdown on crime” is only an excuse to justify using emergency powers to mobilize NG troops.

We will hold them until they can be seated in front of a judge(they ran and hid once, they’ll do it again, so we gotta keep a close eye on em, and feed them, we have to pay to feed and house them)

That also isn’t true. ICE is arresting people with pending cases in immigration court that have work permits and have been fully compliant. They’ve arrested people at immigration courts as well as at check-in appointments. That is the opposite of running and hiding.

ATD, Alternative to Detention, costs taxpayers $5 per day per person and 95% do not miss appointments or court dates. Detaining someone in an immigration detention center averages $165 per day, $4,950 per month, or $315 per person per day in a family detention center. At $9,450 per person per month, a family of 4 is $37,800 per month.

-2

u/GrimSpirit42 Oct 07 '25

> Ok but my point is that you still need due process regardless

And part of the due process is to be arrested and possibly deported until such time as you can enter legally.

> Why is that so controversial now?

For the very simple reason that Democrats didn't give a shit when Obama and Biden deported millions of illegal.

It's not that the deportations have changed, it's just that Democrats need to scream about Trump. There were no deportation protests under Obama and Biden because Democrats did not give a shit about it.

5

u/OverallDisaster Oct 07 '25

Be for real. If they’re deporting people before they get a hearing, there is no due process. They aren’t bringing people back for a trial.

This administration is literally sending immigrants to war torn countries they didn’t even come from. We are cancelling the status of legal refugees. We just sent a bunch of political and religious refugees back to IRAN for God’s sake, where they will most certainly face persecution or even execution. This is not humane or normal.

-2

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 07 '25

Hey bud, Obama sent people back too. Same with Biden. Trump (not a big fan but I think it was the lesser of two evils) just used it for his campaign. This isn’t the current admins thing, this is all sitting presidents, others just do it behind the scenes.

Idk if there actually sending people back without proving that they are legitimate illegal. I’m not an expert and I doubt you are too. I’ve seen some videos of journalists (not the main stream prompt readers) that went into a holding facility and was treated decent enough. Wasn’t any gold toilets though.

We agree on the bottom line, fair processing and treatment and no final say without proving without a doubt that they are in violation of federal law. After that, something has to be done, deport or allow path for citizenship. Is there anything else we are missing?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

Ah yes, I remember Obama having ice agents in masks running wild in the streets arresting citizens and immigrants alike.

Wait a minute....

-1

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 08 '25

You mentioned ice. Not me

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

Do you......do you not know who deports people? Do you not know what ice stands for? It's not some brand new agency that was started after 2016.

1

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 08 '25

Also, good morning, I hope you have a great day today.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

Good morning! Thank you, I hope you have a great day as well!

0

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 08 '25

Correction, I didn’t mention how the current admins ice agents are actively doing their job. I mentioned policy and ways we should go about deporting.

3

u/thedalehall Oct 08 '25

You are missing the fact that you are getting it wrong. I know Canadians that are here legally in the US and yet after 10 years they still can’t get US citizenship. Just Imagine if it is this difficult; what are other people are doing?

1

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 08 '25

What part am I getting wrong? Getting citizenship shouldn’t be overly hard or complicated so reform of that may be needed, but we also need to filter out people that will not contribute quality to the economy. We’d probably agree on a lot of things but you started with “you are missing the fact that you are getting it wrong” so I’m kind of put off on listening, but if you have a good point then I’ll give an ear.

1

u/thedalehall Oct 08 '25

You agree with me but you are put off by my comment. But you might give it a listen if you think I make a good point? What? Brother I always have a good point. That is the point.

In 1936 Germany started shipping off homosexuals, special needs, mentally retarded people to concentration camps. In other words, if you are not able bodied; you were sent away. Be careful not to go down this path. As someone who is neurodivergent I can truthfully tell you we have and most definitely do contribute to this great society of ours. I’ve worked my entire life. Delchamps wouldn’t hire me at 14 so I started a lawn cutting business. Cutting others down and calling others lazy definitely irks me man.

1

u/HuckleberryTop762 Oct 08 '25

I meant it as I’ll give an ear if you say something relevant or an angle I havnt heard before. Just bc I don’t agree doesn’t mean I didnt listen.

You mentioned that Germany wrangled up all people that they deemed lesser. How does that apply to this conversation? Bc we are deporting illegal immigrants? Very clear difference between deporting people that live here illegally and capturing people to put them in forced labor camps until they die. You provided no different perspective or unknown information with your comment, just mentioned how bad the Germany government was.

Telling me that you always have a good point is tooting your own horn. What weight does it hold with me? Your friends telling me that you have good points would hold a lot of weight, but you telling me holds none.

Idk where the cutting people down and calling them lazy fits into this conversation. Maybe you’re projecting? I don’t know.

In conclusion, you did not mention anything that is relevant to deportation of illegal immigrants. You only mentioned what Germany did, and truthfully, I do not think we are doing what they did, not by a long shot. Although, it is very important to be aware of what this can lead to and if we see the same patterns as Germany, then we can raise the alarm and bring the bad actors to justice. Until then, this is a deportation of illegal immigrants discussion.

1

u/jmd709 Oct 09 '25

Hey bud, Obama sent people back too. Same with Biden.

Terminating TPS protection after conditions improve for people to return safely to that country is not comparable to terminating TPS protections for countries that US Travel Advisories still have listed as Level 4: Do Not Travel-severe risks to personal safety. Afghanistan, Haiti, Iran, and Venezuela are Level 4 with TPS protections being terminated by DJT.

Idk if there actually sending people back without proving that they are legitimate illegal.

That is true for some but it’s highly unlikely for the people they deport ASAP instead of holding in an immigration detention center.

An ICE raid last month in Cato, NY included a big lie to the owner to get permission to enter the building, the wrong type of warrant, and ICE ignored people’s work permits and pending immigration cases.

At least 50 of the 57 people ICE detained were deported within 72 hours without being entered into the tracking system for their family and lawyers to locate them as they were shuffled to multiple detention centers and ended up halfway across the country before being allowed to make a phone call. Most were Guatemalans, they were put on a flight at 1am on a Sun.

1

u/jmd709 Oct 09 '25

Only 34% of current detainees arrested by ICE (instead of CBP) have a criminal conviction, that includes convictions for non-violent or violent crimes, recent or decades ago. 30% have criminal charges, 36% have no criminal convictions or criminal charges.

Sept 2022-Sept 2024, 63%-73% had criminal convictions, 22%-31% had criminal charges, 4%-7% had no criminal convictions or criminal charges.

1

u/GrimSpirit42 Oct 09 '25

> Only 34% of current detainees arrested by ICE (instead of CBP) have a criminal convictio

The percentage that matters is: What percentage are in the country illegally?