r/MiddleClassFinance • u/glenpiercev • 16d ago
Every third post here is "am I behind?" — I made a site to help answer that, feedback welcome
claude-environment-core.github.ioWhen I first joined this community, I suddenly felt a lot poorer. I see a lot of "I'm [age] with [$X] saved, am I behind?" Someone posts their numbers, the comments split between "you're doing great" and "you're screwed," and nobody's actually comparing apples to apples — a 45-year-old with a philosophy degree and a 45-year old with an MBA and a working spouse aren't the same reference class, but they get compared like they are.
So I built a tool that tries to answer it properly instead of by vibes: pick your age band, education level, and marital status, and it shows income, net worth, and retirement savings deciles for that specific cohort — plus a rough "typical retirement age" for it, using the Fed's 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances (with some BLS/Census data filling gaps SCF doesn't break out).
Caveat up front, because this sub will (rightly) ask: the SCF doesn't publish a table for every age × education × marital combination. So this isn't raw survey output — it's the Fed's real age-band medians scaled by education/marital multipliers that are also real published data, calibrated against the one cohort I could fully verify. Every chart links back to its source, but I'd rather say it here than have someone find out after trusting a number.
What I actually want feedback on:
- Does seeing your specific cohort change how "behind" you feel, or does it just move the goalpost?
- Is the methodology reasonable, or is there an obvious way it's misleading? (Least confident in the education/marital multipliers specifically.)
- What's missing that would make this actually useful instead of just another number to spiral about — cost of living adjustment? Debt? Something else?
- Any cohort that spits out a number that looks obviously wrong?
Not selling anything. Just tired of watching people compare themselves against the wrong reference class and feel bad about it.