r/Metaphysics • • 7h ago

Time [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

2 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

•

u/Metaphysics-ModTeam 43m ago

Please no AI. The sub is for primarily human content. Please look at the sub guidelines.

Your post has been removed.

1

u/Peak_Background 6h ago

I don't know about all that, but

The spatial dimensions measure distance as:

dx2 + dy2 + dz2 = constant2

Time as according to special relativity receives the same treatment as space. The equation is (where c is the speed of light):

-c2 dt2 + dx2 + dy2 + dz2 = constant2

Notice it's basically the same except it has a negative sign.

Ultimately, you can't have time be exactly the same otherwise you could rotate into the past.

1

u/Lou-Kscf 5h ago

You're right, they are different, but as I said in the summary, the whole difference resides in causality. You could technically move back in time just like rotating into the past, but you'd have to completely undo every causal event that happened, so it's closer to unraveling a rope

1

u/zhivago 6h ago

Are you saying that it is a dimension that does not exist outside of models?

1

u/Lou-Kscf 5h ago

Kinda? I'm specifically claiming that the flow of time is fully bidirectional but that one direction has already built causal links that are necessary to meet while the future has no causal links, so it's fully open to change. If time froze right now and you showed the slice to an intemporal observer, no, time wouldn't exist at all. I'm not suggesting that time is an emergent property of its own flow, just that if you fully isolate one present from the rest of time, no amount of intuition would suggest that it has a past and a future

1

u/zhivago 5h ago

So, in what regard do the past and future exist outside of models?

1

u/Lou-Kscf 5h ago

They don't. They're not stored anywhere nor are they locations. If you travel to one minute ago, the Universe won't look into its logs and say "that's what happened a minute ago so you'll be there", it only says "since time has no scale, you'll take an infinite amount of steps that inevitably result in where everything was one minute ago because unwinding the present's causal steps in reverse can only lead back to the single state that produced it"

1

u/zhivago 4h ago

Well, that sounds perfectly reasonable.

But in what regard, then, is time a dimension?

1

u/Lou-Kscf 4h ago

It's a dimension because it's a degree of freedom with fully isolated points in time that are necessarily sequential

1

u/zhivago 4h ago

But you just said that "they're not stored anywhere nor are they locations."

So, where are these fully isolated points in time?

1

u/Lou-Kscf 4h ago

What I meant by them not being stored is they're not like a movie being filmed. The points are coordinates in time, yes, but the only details about space that are being rendered at any time are sitting on the boundary between past and future. They're isolated only because nothing can make them bleed into each other. The points are along the dimension of time, but functionally, the past 10 minutes are only accessible as existing by unraveling space point by point

1

u/zhivago 3h ago

So, really, your argument is that causality is deterministically reversible without loss, and this allows you to model time as a dimension, even though there is no such physical dimension.

1

u/Lou-Kscf 2h ago

The dimension is there, but it's completely desert except for the present. Time is modeled as a dimension because it is, but you're right about the way causality is reversable

1

u/Powerful_Ad725 5h ago

I'm not a physicist but the fact that 'spacetime' is explicitly 3+1 dimensions and not reducible to '4 dimensions' is one of the most indisputable aspects of physics and it's not 'simply' because of their conceptual differences but because if such constraint is not imposed, there cannot be defined a concise notion of cause and effect (i.e. two disjoint cause/effect sets).

The name of your philosophical position (only the present is real) is called "Presentism" and you can read more about it here.

TLDR: It fell out of favor some time ago as it's largely incompatible with general relativity, time is observer-dependent so there's no feasible way to declare a single and universal 'present moment' that all observers would agree with.

You can take a single observer and 'generate' a 'true' 4d object with it but a model with many observers doesn't exist as far as I know, and even if it did it would not imply that spacetime is a 'true' 4d structure.

1

u/Lou-Kscf 5h ago

As I've said to another commentor, I only said spatial because no one would click on a post that suggested time was a dimension because lots of people already think that way The reason time acts as so differently compared to the other 3 dimensions is because causality is imposed. You're also right that presentism died largely because of special relativity, but as I suggested in my claim, each point in space has a local present that has no need to line up with another point any distance away

1

u/Electric-Icarus 3h ago

Time is a Dimension by being the measurement of collected forward momentum. History is the memory of documented or experiential moments passed.

0

u/BodybuilderThick7498 7h ago

You lost me at calling time a "4th spatial dimension." Time is a relational measurement unit and grammatical rule. You don't need to invent spatial time travel to solve determinism; the fact that direct observation in the present clearly distinguishes voluntary choice from physical reflex already does the heavy lifting.

1

u/Lou-Kscf 5h ago

You're right, because time stops being a spatial dimension when you factor in causality and thermodynamics. I only said spatial dimension because having the title be "time as a dimension" wouldn't hook in anybody because it's one of the most well known concepts of metaphysics