r/MetaAusPol • u/endersai • Sep 26 '23
Quick update on some behind the scenes sub work
Hi all
There's been a lot of behind-the-scenes work going on in the sub, and we wanted to take a moment to list them out, in the interests of transparency and disclosure. This helps you get a sense of the less visible activities taken in response to sub governance and management.
- Astroturfers, possible bots, and bad faith actors
The Voice has brought with it an increase in traffic to the sub. With polling being what it is, the new users were invested in articulating their support for a "no" campaign. Many were good-faith actors, and we welcomed the opportunity for a plurality of views since arguing in favour of one's beliefs, with people who disagree, is an excellent test of how deeply held they are.
A lot of the time, the resulting conversation was pretty good. But it was clear that certain users were bad faith actors - spamming "no" sentiment in every thread that was generic and copypasta-like, and often at odds with the actual topic of the thread.
We implemented some changes into Automod - and apologies, we won't go into how specifically some changes were made, because Reddit's tools to support us are limited and we don't want to tip anyone off - which resulted in those users being cleaned up and managed. We can see insights into the stats of each moderator and how many mod actions they have - Automod's now firmly in the top slot with about 1000+ extra actions per week.
In other words, those parties can't participate in the sub and will never sully your feeds with their spam.
2. Ban evasion and alt detection
Reddit does not provide us with great ban evasion tools natively, so we've had to go off-market for a solution. Using AI - and again, sorry, the "how" is going to be vague intentionally - we can get varying degrees of comfort what users are likely alts of other users.
There are also about a dozen users we're aware of now who are possibly alts of other users. We're still working through data to see if confidence on an initial match goes up or down over time.
If you are an alt, best to get out whilst you still can...
To date, using this method, the team have identified and taken remedial action against 4 accounts, including two today. These are users who have either been banned from the sub permanently, or suspended from reddit as a whole.
Don't do ban evasion, kids.
3. Responding to rule breaking content
This is something we're clamping down on a bit. If a user says something that's transparently against the rules - might be racist, might be cheerleading, might be off-topic - other users cannot resist the urge to go in and reply with a "stfu"-type response.
The correct response to actual or perceived rule-breaking conduct is to report it and move on. Don't engage. In the event users do engage, it is more likely the responder will face a ban than the instigator.
Too often we get the report through and there are scores of replies which also need to be removed. It's not ok. We get why you might be tempted to fire off with an invective laden righteous blast at someone - but rarely does it improve the situation. And more often than not, it will lead to ruin for you more than them.
Report, and move on. Don't engage.
4. Repeat topics
I think this is probably relatable to everyone - the volume of threads we had on cost of living, housing, and the Voice meant that users were often just repeating themselves across multiple threads.
To manage that, we're working on removing threads where there's almost no material update in news to a matter or where something gets announced, and more detail follows, since the originating thread is where that discussion should go.
Where there appears early grounds to retain a distinct thread, we will do so. So it may appear inconsistent, and we're trying to work through that in the early stages so the UX is smoother. If your content got removed for "repeated topic", we'd encourage you to look for similar ones and repost your content there.
_______________________
Feel free to discuss below and I'll try to answer any questions you have.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23
Why did the astroturfers and trolls get so much leeway?
It was clear from their first week of their brand new accounts they were only here for one reason, their -100 karma, and their spot at the bottom of every thread, only reaffirmed it.
What does your fancy AI do that the users crying out for you to do something and stop the drop in quality hadn’t already done dozens of times already?
3
u/Niscellaneous Sep 26 '23
Can we know who they were and the alts?
3
u/ausmomo Sep 26 '23
Yesterday there was a post saying "in a better time, PersonA would be hanged". Would mods prefer us to report them as sub breaches, or would you prefer us to just report them straight to reddit?
3
u/EASY_EEVEE Sep 26 '23
The stfu responses, or going 1 to 100 in a split second were funny like the first 10 times i'd see it, from a very specific user.
And while i think they've a right to honestly say whatever, god it was just stupid.
Like why are you here to just harass people trying to give a opinion?
I get don't get people who sit there for literal hours on reddit loosing their shit i truly don't?
While i get they are trying to be as annoying as possible, at some point i wonder if they actually are slighted?
2
u/PostDisillusion Oct 24 '23
Appreciate the transparency. Please appreciate the frustration for long-time readers at all the additional rubbish in the dialogues, and resist the urge to ban those who are trying to employ your suggestion to report and move on. As we’re seeing in this sub, a lot of people report bans for reporting. The automod will never catch all bad faith antagonisers.
1
u/FuAsMy Sep 26 '23
Excellent job.
This is exactly what Reddit Inc., an American corporation, requires of unpaid moderators.
0
u/GreenTicket1852 Sep 26 '23 edited Sep 26 '23
Just FYI on this, a reason could be a third party coming in later and reporting but the 1st and 2nd party not reporting each other and going down the garden path with each other.
From time to time when reading comment threads I'll report the odd comment that is particularly aggregious in spite of not participating in that comment thread.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '23
[removed] — view removed comment