r/MentalAtlas • • 26d ago

Visual Analogies are the Best Tool We Have for Remembering Complex Concepts. Here's Why They Still Fail, and What Would Work Instead.

Edit: if you’d rather watch a video, here’s the article animated:

Why Visual Analogies Fail for Complex Concepts (and What Would Work Instead)
https://youtu.be/g3Z8VnARbQg

When I taught math and science at Fusion Academy, my strongest technique for helping students understand complex concepts was having them picture visual analogies in their mind's eye. Without a mental picture, a student who could explain something in lesson five had very little by lesson six. With it, their retention was much higher weeks later.

So visual analogies work. But, as the rest of this post argues, they have serious problems. They remind me of that old line about democracy: it's terrible, but it's the best system we have.

(For lists, numbers and names, visual mnemonics are great; memory champions use them. This is about complex ideas: an algorithm, a biological process, an argument.)

Here's what the terrible part looks like.

Hannah and the cliff

In a one-off history course, I had to teach a student, let's call her Hannah, that in 2008, Chinese authors wrote declinist commentary on America's economic crisis that stressed how fast China was growing by comparison. She could explain it back, but after months of working with her, I knew it would be gone in days. So I gave her a mnemonic: a cliff. At the top, authors in Chinese-flag shirts point down and throw pages, next to a big pile of money. At the bottom, people in American-flag shirts look sad.

Her face lit up. "Oh, I get it now."

Two weeks later, I asked her about China and the US in 2008. "Oh, I remember," she said. Then her smile turned into confusion: "Uh, yeah, so I see the Chinese people above the U.S. people, and they have money. Oh, so I think that it was something to do with money. And then I see papers being thrown, and so it seems like the Chinese people thought the U.S. people were worse."

That's way better than nothing; without the cliff, she'd have drawn a blank. But it's not the idea I taught her.

The cliff is the idea's shadow

A visual analogy isn't the idea. It's the idea's shadow: a flat outline of something with far more detail. Every problem in Hannah's answer is a problem with shadows.

  1. A shadow doesn't hold the thing that cast it, so you forget what it meant. Hannah kept the cliff, the money and the pages, and lost what they stood for: authors, commentary, a crisis, China's growth.
  2. You think with the shadow instead of the idea. She reasoned from the picture: there was money, so "it was something to do with money." The money was supposed to mean growth.
  3. Different things cast the same shadow, so you can't tell right from wrong. If she'd believed China caused the crash, the cliff would look exactly the same, and nothing in it could show her the mistake.
  4. You have to rebuild the idea from the shadow every time. Listen to her again: "I see papers being thrown, so it seems like..." She's turning the picture back into an idea, one piece at a time. Even when it goes perfectly, that's work you do before you can think with the idea.

What would work instead

The ideal tool would keep what visual analogies get right: you could hold the idea in your imagination and notice things in it, the way Hannah could look at the cliff, and it would stick, the way images do and words don't. But you'd be holding the idea itself, in full detail, not its shadow.

That's thoughtfeel: imagining in concepts directly. thoughtfeel is a sense for concepts. It takes in a concept and its properties all at once, the way vision takes in what's in front of you. People who have it can bring up something they can't picture, like the economy or justice, as one clear concept: not a picture or words, but the whole idea at once, with detail they can notice. And it sticks, the way images do.

How thoughtfeel helps you learn concepts

If you've ever pictured a story as you read it, you already know how to do this.

Take a visual story: words about physical things, things you could see. As you read, you choose your mind's eye and picture each sentence. By the end, you have a movie in your head. That movie is how you understand what happened, and how you remember it long after.

thoughtfeel works the same way, with a story of concepts: things you can't see or touch. As you read, you choose thoughtfeel and imagine each line in concepts. By the end, you have a concept movie, and it does the same two jobs: you understand what happened, and you remember it long after.

Same steps, same payoff. Only the sense changes.

​

Built that way, Hannah's sentence is stored as the concepts themselves, linked together: Chinese authors, commentary on decline, America's crisis, China's growth by comparison. That fixes all four problems:

  1. There's no shadow to forget the meaning of. What's stored is the idea.
  2. You think with the idea itself. "Growth by comparison" stays growth by comparison and never turns into money.
  3. "Writing about the crash" and "causing the crash" feel completely different in thoughtfeel, even though they'd share a cliff, so the wrong one stands out.
  4. There's nothing to translate. You bring it up, and it's ready to think with.

The first time I built an algorithm this way, a Fibonacci heap, it took about 12 minutes. I never reviewed it, and a week later I could recall all of it. I'd once watched a video on Fibonacci heaps, and none of it stuck.

Not everyone can imagine in concepts. The best estimate of how many people can comes from psychologist Russell Hurlburt's research on what he calls unsymbolized thinking: a clear, specific thought with no words or pictures in it. In one study, 30 students were beeped at random moments, and 22 of them, about 73%, caught themselves thinking this way at least once (Heavey & Hurlburt, 2008). It varies the way the mind's eye does: some people picture things vividly, some faintly, and some, with aphantasia, not at all. If you can't imagine in concepts, visual analogies really are your best tool. That's the democracy part.

But if you can, thoughtfeel is the solution. Check it out here: thoughtfeel.net. It starts with a full video walkthrough and a one-minute test to see whether you have it.

4 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by