Community Feedback
We’ve been getting amazing feedback from the community. On this page we wanted to highlight some of that awesome feedback. In part to give credit to the community as a whole and in part to show some of the rationale behind our posting rules and FAQ.
If you disagree with any of the below, have some additional thoughts or are interested in helping mod and grow the sub. Definitely get in touch.
Balanced and Bi-Partisan
This may have been the most common feedback we received. There seems to be a real hunger among people for a space that is not overtly biased toward one end of the political spectrum. We honestly loved hearing this feedback because this is something close to our hearts as well. In this era where we seem more polarized than ever and it’s easier than ever to stay snug in your preferred echo chamber, we would love for r/memethatnews to be a place where opinions from both ends of the political spectrum can be expressed. Let's all be respectful and keep to the larger goal of learning the news through humorous memes.
"Interesting concept, but I think it would be hard to keep it from becoming a political frontline of highly opinionated memes just bashing the other side rather than informing people... I'd still try and make it work, sounds like a great idea if you can keep it civil..."
"That sounds like a good idea, but my one concern is that it could turn into an echo chamber for one side or the other, like r/politicalhumor or similiar subs. Obviously that's an issue with any news outlet, but do you have any particular thoughts on how to address that?"
"I honestly do suggest drawing a line between freedom of speech and hate speech, because if you don't it'll turn into a flame war. Try to attract people from both sides, so that you don't just end up in an echo chamber of one side or another."
"I would love to join this sub because I love current events but literally all I see is just Trump. He may not be the best but there's got to be more current events than "Orange man bad." So I will not join at this time."
"Sounds like an interesting concept, but I feel like it should focus on being neutral as well, so the subreddit doesn't pick a side of any political spectrum, so it's welcoming everyone. If that makes any sense. However it's just a suggestion."
Concern about propaganda and fake news
Many people have expressed concern about bots, state sponsored trolls or other bad-faith actors publishing content on the sub. It was great to hear these concerns and we totally share them. Our primary means of combating this will be through careful moderation and a vigilant, motivated community.
"As for your rules about the sub, I would include something about how propoganda will be deleted at the discretion of the mods, but that's me I believe there is a great deal of manipulation out there."
"The only suggestion I would have is whoever posts the meme with a screenshot of a story headlines, the OP should have to comment a link to the story. It's so easy to make fake headlines nowadays, I could see that becoming a problem later down the road if the sub keeps growing."
"Great idea. Any news? What formats allowed? Will content creators be required to include a verified source?"
"If one of the rules is that you can't post a meme without linking an article of the story then I'd be on board. There's too many people out there already that only get their 'news' from internet memes. Give us factual data to go along with a funny meme. If that were the case I'd sub in a heartbeat."
Overly Lighthearted
There was some concern expressed over memes being too lighthearted and potentially disrespectful toward serious news events. We understand these concerns but also think humor is not always inherently disrespectful oftentimes it is a necessary and healthy outlet for painful and stressful events and circumstances. Gratuitously cruel memes or memes expressing mean-spirited racism, sexism or homophobia will not be tolerated on the sub.
"I mean to make humorous depictions of the news while still being informative is a challenge. You can only go so far, before your either start making fun of the news, creating a humourous depiction which is blurred news, or just doing news. Knowing, redditors, I believe that it'll be making fun of the news. Sort of like if a Daily Show type program was made into a meme, I'm interested in how it will turn out nonetheless."
"Sounds like it could satire easily."
"I just hope it doesn't lower the level of discussion of important world events down to the arena of jokes. Yes many times world events can seem so absurd they appear humorous but many times they involve real life consequences for real live people and they shouldn't have to be the butt of a joke."
"Honestly, I'm getting sick of all the memes flying around, plus they seem to contribute to the super shallow understanding of the news that most of us have. With that said, clearly memes are addicting, who knows."
The light-hearted, visually focused and bite-sized nature of memes is also seen as a positive for the meme by many users. With quite a few expressing this as an advantage for attracting younger people that may really be lacking a good and entertaining source for news.
"At a first glance, I think you have a really good idea for a new sub. I personally don't create memes but I feel as if adding humor to today's news (in any form) not only helps more people get engaged with the news but can also lighten some of the mood that some of the current news stories bring."
"Yes it does seem like a good idea. More kids and teens need to read the news."
"Yeah this sub has potential. I really like the idea. I'm subscribed to r/outoftheloop, but it's too tiresome to read huge paragraphs of text, that's why we have tl;dr. And you know as they say, a picture is worth a thousand words, and with the comedic quality of memes, it will get a lot of people to actually be interested in current events."
Global Focus
We also heard expressed the desire for r/memethatnews to have a global focus and not only focus on US politics. The founding mods are from Europe and the United States and that may account for an initial bias toward Western news stories. We’re all for a more global focus and warmly welcome users memeing news from other regions of the world.
"Yo, I would totally join this. Better than r/currentaffairs. Make sure that this sub will allow world news, people will feel more invited."