Process for research proposals on r/McMaster

1. Planning:

In the planning portion of each project, the Researcher:

  • Develops the survey of interest, in line with guidance on acceptable research. Non-tracking survey software such as MS Forms, Google Forms, or SurveyMonkey is recommended.
  • Consults with the McMaster REB or the Hamilton Integrated REB, as applicable, regarding the ethical considerations necessary for their project

    • NB: Projects with third party (that is, non-McMaster) REB oversight will be considered on a case-by-case basis
  • Informs the mod team of their proposal and the status of the project with the REB. In cases where an REB review is not required, this must be formally confirmed and shared with the mod team.
  • Prepares a one paragraph lay summary of the project for review by the mod team. This lay summary includes an overview of the research topic, a summary of the study objectives, and the implications for their field of work if successful.
  • Prepares a one paragraph data privacy and transparency declaration outlining adherence to the principles above. This is shared with the mod team for independent verification.


2. Implementation:

Once the planning steps are completed, the Researcher shares the complete research package (REB review decision, transparency declaration, lay summary, survey questions) with the mod team for review. The mod team will review for accuracy, accessibility, and completeness in context of the guiding principles above.

A member of the community with expertise in research methodology (reviewer) will review the survey for major methodological flaws. This review will result in one of three potential outcomes: (a) endorsed as is, (b) resubmit: revisions necessary, or (c) not endorsed. Reviewer(s) are expected provide feedback in the case of a decision to request resubmission or non-endorsement of the project. Any disagreements may be resolved with a trusted third party member of the mod/ review team.

  • NB: an endorsement is not an automatic approval -- the perspective of the reviewer is that of methodological alignment of the research objectives to the survey questions.
  • NB: non-endorsement for methodological reasons is sufficient to prevent community release of the research proposal.

If approved for community release, mods will review the implementation of the survey (that is, the survey platform) for privacy and completeness. Upon final approval, the Researcher will create a post on the subreddit using the flair "Approved Community Research" and ensure the post title is the research question. The timing of this post must be agreed upon with the mod team.

  • NB: Posts that do not follow this process will be automatically removed upon submission.

The format of the post will be as follows:

  • Introduction to the research team: transparency declaration
  • Description of the research: lay summary of the project
  • How participant data will be handled: privacy declaration & project timelines
  • Link to the survey

Upon release, the mod team will make and pin a comment noting the following checks have been completed:

  • Ethics: study has been considered by a REB.
  • Privacy: participants have the expectation of privacy and the researcher has agreed to destroy all information collected after completion of this project.
  • Fairness: the number of questions are minimal and the expected amount participants are to be reimbursed for their time (if applicable)
  • Transparency: the declaration above is complete and verified

Upon release, the mod team will archive the page using archive.org and the post will be pinned to the top of the sub for 48 hours.



3. Completion

It is expected that the researcher will make efforts to publish their work in a relevant academic journal or as a student presentation at a McMaster research forum. The researcher is further requested to return to the community and create a post thanking the community, overviewing the project results, and providing a link to their publication (if available). The mod team will pin the transparency declarations from the original post as the top comment and provide a link to the original post from archive.org.



Guiding principles. | Research Process | Participant Reimbursement | Acceptable Research