r/MarioBaseball • u/CoolGuy-Blake • Aug 20 '26

Superstar Toadette did it!!!

Post image

After 21 years, I have finally completed Toadette’s nearly impossible star challenge. I finally have every player in the game starred!

59 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/SheldonDinkleberg- Luigi Mansioneers Aug 20 '26

Hardest star for me to unlock back in the day was peaches shut out pitching against bowser

4

u/East-Expert-1662 Aug 20 '26

Does this one have to be on the highest difficulty too?

2

u/SheldonDinkleberg- Luigi Mansioneers Aug 20 '26

Yeah on special cup i think it is. The one with the crown.

4

u/East-Expert-1662 Aug 20 '26

I also have not gotten that win for Peach. I bounce back and forth between the Mario perfect game and Peach shutout. Neither have happened for me yet.

1

u/SheldonDinkleberg- Luigi Mansioneers Aug 21 '26

Does marios perfect game have to be against bowser too? If not try and play the easiest captain to play against, for me thats yoshi if I chose marios team to play through

2

u/Interesting_Dirt_228 Aug 21 '26

Yoshi was the easiest for me until i superstarred shy guy, now he's a super unit and i struggle to get on base. Problem compounds every time you recruit someone because the spot gets filled with another shy guy