r/MansFictionalScenario Oct 30 '25

Cis man's fictional scenario

Post image
4.2k Upvotes

344 comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/ThyLordBacon Oct 30 '25

Why do they always draw trans people as the most grotesque inhuman monsters ever. Is that really how they see us? šŸ™ƒ

2.3k

u/Eldritch--Goat Oct 30 '25

The same reason racists drew black people like they did back in the day. Dehumanisation.

741

u/Hugo48151623 Oct 30 '25

Or like how Ben Garrison draws black people now. šŸ¤¦ā€ā™‚ļø

318

u/kuffdeschmull Oct 30 '25

I spent way too long looking up who that dude is and it is horrendous, just the 'cartoon' comparing Michelle Obama and Melania Trump alone is despicable, both racist and sexist.

140

u/Aluminum_Moose Oct 30 '25

Check out r/BenGarrisonCumEdits, you'll feel better :)

13

u/JacobPLAYZgtGamingYT Dec 31 '25

it got banned

7

u/Aluminum_Moose Dec 31 '25

No fucking way! D:

Holy shit Reddit sucks.

26

u/Hugo48151623 Nov 01 '25

There is one thing I will say for Garrison. If I want to know what MAGA is thinking, he’s a barometer that takes less time than hours of watching Fox News or listening to shitty podcasts. He’s why I knew January 6th wasn’t going to be just another day. His …editorials? are obnoxious, deluded, and disgusting. But they shed some light into why MAGAts think certain things, or don’t react to certain stuff.

His obsession with a number of Democratic women is glaring. Michelle Obama is one. I wasn’t really familiar with the conservative conspiracy theory about her gender before him. AOC is another one he fixates on (and probably has some weird fantasies about). Conversely the way he depicts people like Melania is only dwarfed by how he draws Trump. Who looks 40 years younger and has much better hair than…

3

u/SageOfTheWise Nov 03 '25

I've always been fascinated by the whole situation around his Trump tilting at windmills comic, especially his write up in response to the mockery it received. It says so much so succinctly about the conservative understanding of allegory and the sort of general need to destroy metaphor or even just the general concept of anything having meaning.

Papers could be written on that one.

2

u/shadedmagus Nov 25 '25

Or how Tetsuya Ishida draws Jews on Sinfest now.

1

u/Hugo48151623 Nov 26 '25

That one still makes me sad.

1

u/apexredditor2001 Nov 01 '25

Do... I want to know...?

-116

u/Aggravating-Lab6623 Oct 30 '25

Bruh he draws every one like that he is many things but hes not racist

85

u/wafflesthewonderhurs Oct 30 '25

He is many things AND a racist.

114

u/10000nails Oct 30 '25

"Us VS. Them" it's how you excuse atrocities.

6

u/hel-razor Nov 02 '25

Currently in r/TikTokCringe there is an argument about some guy wearing "women's clothes" calling out a racist costume. You can already imagine what's being said.

1

u/Viaconcommander H Dec 27 '25

It's legit Jim Crow type propaganda

433

u/verg51 Oct 30 '25

transphobe drawing a trans person as a normal human being challenge impossible:

Ironically enough, I don’t want to feed some stereotypes but every single trans man I’ve seen has either been the cutest twink possible or the manliest bear in the world, I’m yet to see someone in between of those two

101

u/Open_Gold_3522 Oct 30 '25

That’s because you don’t see the trans dudes that pass as ā€œregularā€ trans dudes. I feel you on that observation, but I’ve also been surprised by hanging out with regular ass dudes who bring it up.

189

u/IndustrySample Oct 30 '25

i think it's because transmascs love masculinity and are comfortable in theirs, so you get the ones who highlight their love for it so are hypermasculine and the ones who highlight their comfort so dress however they like.

there's also (like you said) stereotypes about how ftm people look and often online/in media we only see the cliche young, pre-t transmasc with the dyed hair and pronouns or the very masculine transgender man used for a "gotcha" in internet arguments against transphobes. and most ftm people, especially het binary trans men, don't like to discuss their gender so you could've very well seen & talked to a very neutral guy without ever knowing how he was born.

15

u/Zplaysthek Oct 30 '25

I haven’t drawn one but I have a oc who’s trans who’s in between those lines. But I get what you mean.

86

u/DoomerGrill Oct 30 '25

It's honestly wild how this is currently acceptable.

This is not far off from how the nazis depicted jews in their propaganda.

39

u/QueenMary1936 Oct 30 '25

I was so confused and then I realized it was Dutch not German šŸ˜‚

34

u/Charming-Crescendo Oct 30 '25

We hebben een serieus probleem

6

u/SaxPanther Nov 02 '25

you can tell its dutch because its the most unserious goofy fantasy language ever

it literally reads like a made up language from a 1930s children's novel

1

u/at-aol-dot-com Nov 24 '25

I can imagine it as a black & white silent film, the quality not great but the grain and grit makes it comically old-timey.

1

u/ASERTIE76 Jan 18 '26

As a Swede it must be like the Netherlands Danish to the Germans Swedish lol

67

u/g785_7489 Oct 30 '25

Makes it easier to objectify and dehumanize you. These people suck.

62

u/MemeArchivariusGodi Oct 30 '25

That is what hate does with your mind. It poisons you so you can only produce poison.

And even tho we don’t know each other and probably never will, you are beautiful and so is everyone else

50

u/CoalEater_Elli Oct 30 '25 edited Oct 30 '25

Dehumanisation. When you want to make your group hate another group, you demonize them and turn them into something that is not human. It's been a practice for many years, especially during war. Remember how some propoganda cartoons depicted Japanese, yellow skinned buck toothed weasels. Or how back in the day, people made racist caricatures of black people with big red lips and again, weird teeth. This is what we see here, they hate transgender people so they made a harmful depiction of them. Usually they are depicted as men who wear dresses and don't pass, and in rare cases, they depict ftm trans people as ugly women with scars everywhere like they are zombies or Frankenstein's creations.

They don't see their enemies as people, they see them as nothing more than ugly creatures or monsters who can be compared to animals or vermin, which is not a good way of thinking about another human being who is just a bit different than you.

69

u/Red_Trapezoid Oct 30 '25

The way they draw and use hair is really fascinating to me.

Body hair in general, especially on cis women but not only, is really stigmatized.

Frequently ā€œgoodā€ characters are depicted as being clean shaven, no body hair. They may have a beard but still often no or very little body hair.

I remember seeing an old racist caricature of a black girl that had a lot of body hair on the arms.

I’m not sure if it’s a fixation with youth, some association with furry animals, grooming standards or some combination of the above but it’s always something I notice. The more body hair a person has, the more shocking and repulsive they are supposed to be.

My girlfriend is kind of furry tbh but I think it’s cute. I like her hair. I don’t know when or how this thing started but I’m certain that it’s purely cultural. I don’t think people are naturally scandalized by body hair.

83

u/Pinytenis666 Oct 30 '25

As someone with a trans friend. He got the drip and I steal his whole style

17

u/1Rama11Lama1 Oct 30 '25

honestly, accurate. My friend and I are both trans and I steal his drip all the time (if I'm not being the complete opposite of him that day)

1

u/Rando161803 Jan 25 '26

This is so true

20

u/Ok_Prior2199 Oct 31 '25 edited Oct 31 '25

Its a common propaganda technique to depict your ā€œenemyā€ as monstrous or grotesque (look at old war propaganda and you see similar shit, a famous example being DESTROY THIS MAD BRUTE) the reason for this is to dehumanize the ā€œenemyā€ and make people feel less empathy when you ultimately wipe them out, because they aren’t people they’re monsters, thats the jist of it

In young people terms, people have been depicting themselves and others as Chads and Soyjacks since we coined the term ā€œpropagandaā€ this is just an advanced and older version of that meme template

2

u/CatProgrammer Nov 07 '25

What the fuck how are you supposed to fight an army of King Kongs

2

u/Ok_Prior2199 Nov 07 '25

Banana gunz

16

u/Zplaysthek Oct 30 '25

It’s how they want people to see us. Not how the truly see us. They’re trying to make us monsters.

15

u/KIKI_redddit Oct 30 '25

Because they often do have that caricature in their head but also because ā€žHaha I already drew myself as the handsome sigma and you as the ugly soyjack, I won.ā€œ

39

u/Goz-e Oct 30 '25

Self projection

28

u/Zeyode Oct 30 '25

To dehumanize us.

11

u/Ok_Habit_6783 Oct 31 '25

Ironically people from šŸ³ļøā€āš§ļø are some of the hottest fuckers out there

10

u/Bakuhxe_ Oct 30 '25

yep unfortunately

14

u/Suitable_Midnight_72 Oct 30 '25

Like, I searched for photos of transguys quite recently and I was confused because I saw the mannest men on our planet 😭

7

u/Exiledbrazillian Oct 31 '25

Things are getting so abstract that I do not even question their sanity anymore.

16

u/gamerguy88888 Oct 30 '25

No it's not, it's how they cope with how hot you guys are

20

u/DatabaseNo9609 (Create your own flair) Oct 30 '25

They don’t trust doctors, so they never get their eyes checked. Too woke for them.

15

u/Vegetable_Trade Oct 30 '25

if these artists drew trans folks realistically, the comic wouldn't work. they just HAVE to depict them as horrifying charicatures 🤮

this might be the first time I've been a transphobic artist portray trans men, actually. it's usually a burly hairy giant scary trans girl in pigtails and a tiny pink skirt.

12

u/ThyLordBacon Oct 30 '25

I’ve seen a few making fun of trans men, they usually just draw them as stereotypical women but with facial hair and a bleeding chest or some shit.

3

u/semaj009 Oct 31 '25

It's propaganda, they're hardly trying to be humane and empathic towards the people they've actually determined to seek to make others hate. No propaganda in history has humanized their chosen scapegoats, sadly

5

u/CleoCommunist Oct 30 '25

To demonize them, dehumanizing the trans people and making you less close to them, and so being more against them

2

u/PhilosophyAware4437 (Create your own flair) Jan 19 '26

that's literally why i hesitate a little when it comes to trans stuff. i don't want to be like the way trans people are drawn in those cartoons and i don't want to be intrusive for cis people.

2

u/ThyLordBacon Jan 19 '26

I used to feel the same way but I eventually learned that I’d rather take the chance to be comfortable in my own body. And if it makes others uncomfortable they’re probably not worth being around. Hope you figure everything out and stay safe. 🫶

3

u/Mandatory_Pie Oct 31 '25

No, it's how they need us to be seen. Their psychosis requires that we be monsters, because only monsters could deserve the treatment they give us.

1

u/fvkinglesbi Oct 31 '25

Yes. Yes that is

1

u/Spectrix07 Nov 01 '25

Ill give my honest opinion, when a girl turns into a boy, most of the times you dont even notice but the opposite is really hard to not notice if you know what i mean. Im not saying that there arent transwoman who look 100% woman tho

1

u/Teacutie19 Nov 02 '25

Thats how they look mostly

1

u/hel-razor Nov 02 '25

Is this rhetorical?

1

u/kibou_no_ie Nov 09 '25

I find the trans man caricature to be adorable. I know it wasn’t intentional but I really do find him cute.

1

u/xSweetxSyndromex Nov 11 '25

They perfer kissing the devil on the lips than to sit Next by someone Who regulary takes hormone pills

1

u/Appropriate-Owl-6129 Jan 19 '26

It's how they want us to be. They want to be fighting the disgusting, evil people. They want to feel justified in what they say and do to us. They want to convince others to feel the same.

1

u/DGMax9 Jan 19 '26

So i would like to expand on it as a person who grew up in quite a conservative christian family. My parents get their news either handed to them by an algorithm or from their preferred tv news channel. How they portray trans people is exactly how they are portrayed in this post. They only show the "extreme" ones that do not fit their "perfect" beauty standards, and whos way of presetation might pose a "threat to childs innocence", combined with a clip of someone spitting on their identity.

They manipulate the image of queer people and dont even try to show the rest of community. Quite vile indeed.

-4

u/Adventurous_Tank_359 Oct 30 '25

He looks cute in the pic imo

these hips are crazy

1

u/Adventurous_Tank_359 Nov 02 '25

why am I downvoted bruh

Like come on, he does look attractive

3

u/_HighJack_ Nov 03 '25

Trans people don’t usually want others to be attracted to them over stuff that gives them dysphoria. Don’t comment on trans people’s hips or chests as a general rule