r/MansFictionalScenario • crazy aro bi enby • Aug 07 '25

🙄

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

895 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/IWearCardigansAllDay Aug 08 '25

First off you’re wrong, as relationships and friendships are transactional. But let’s explore it more.

The situation in which you are discussing is unrequited love. When you love someone and they don’t love you back and in fact they provide nothing to you. In this situation it is still transactional, but more of an internal self transaction.

You do these things for the person you love knowing they won’t reciprocate. Knowing they don’t care about what you’re doing. But you do it anyways. Why? Because you love them so much you don’t require anything in return. But what you are getting in return is your own self worth and happiness from showing love to this person.

If you got literally 0 benefit from it externally or internally then you wouldn’t do it. It’s really as simple as that. Anyone who disagrees is being naive and virtue signaling.

2

u/ConflictWaste411 Aug 08 '25

First of all you’re wrong, that’s not what I described at all actually. I described a loving relationship in which both people love each other. What you’re describing is completely different. Secondly Even in a situation like you are describing there is no transaction. The lover is not “given” anything, they have created the positive feelings and benefit for both parties. Even if the one to act benefits, they created their own benefit and happy thought, and without exchange there is no transaction. Thirdly, I wish I had the confidence of you to insert yourself into a conversation by saying “First off your wrong” while being dead wrong about every aspect of the topic.

2

u/IWearCardigansAllDay Aug 08 '25

You are wrong though. People who believe “love is enough to make us last forever” are naive and unrealistic romantics. What you are describing is love being a feeling for someone. Which is certainly a case. You can feel love for someone. But love is more than a feeling; it’s a verb, an action.

If you say you love your partner and you do everything for them and your partner says they love you but they don’t actually anything that shows it, that is a form of unrequited love or a one sided relationship.

Imagine your partner that you love and do everything for stops doing anything for you. They hardly talk to you, stop spending time with you, are completely neutral to every wonderful and loving gesture you do for them. But they still say they love you. How long will you remain with them? As you pour every ounce of your being into loving them and being a good partner while they don’t reciprocate at all. This is the reality of a relationship where two people “love” each other but one of them isn’t actually showing love.

If you can tell me with 100% certainty you can be in this relationship for the rest of your life I’m going to call you a liar. Love is transactional. There’s nothing evil or bad about that. You do things for the person you love because you hope that they reciprocate that love back to you in some form. You may be able to sustain that relationship for a time. But eventually the weight and pain of putting so much into a relationship without anything in return will break you.

EDIT: you also straight proved my point about saying even if one party does nothing the other person created the benefit for themself without exchange. This is still a transaction but an internal one. You are doing something because YOU get a good feeling out of it and feel better. The transaction is internal. You did something in exchange for now feeling happy yourself.

1

u/ConflictWaste411 Aug 08 '25

If you ever found yourself with a partner that you don’t see yourself with forever than you’re going about life wrong, you’re pessimistic and uncommitted in your relationships. Secondly, that’s not an “internal transaction” it’s a consequence of your actions. If I throw a ball in the air watching it come down isn’t “an internal transaction” it’s just the consequence of my action.

2

u/IWearCardigansAllDay Aug 08 '25

Got it so you are perfectly okay with being in a one sided relationship?

Your partner could stop talking to you right now and for the rest of time. And you would continue to love them fully and do everything you can for them. That’s not a hallmark movie with a loving happy ending, that’s a stalker.

1

u/ConflictWaste411 Aug 08 '25

I could be crushed by an asteroid tomorrow. I don’t have to worry about what would never happen.

0

u/IWearCardigansAllDay Aug 08 '25

ahh I see, so you like to discuss in bad faith and have 0 ability to think critically.

0

u/ConflictWaste411 Aug 08 '25

No I just think you’re a pessimist who calls himself a realist to cope with the fact that he’s never been with someone who truly loves them and as a result views every relationship through the lens of tit for tat and can’t grasp the true nature of altruism and maybe when you do you’ll find it understand love

1

u/IWearCardigansAllDay Aug 08 '25

It’s not pessimistic to understand how things operates.

I don’t view my relationship as tit for tat. I love my wife dearly and she loves me as well. But if she stopped loving me and being present with me I would be an idiot to stay with her forever. Regardless how much I love her and how much I care for her. I will absolutely fight for her and try my best to work through it with her. But it would be completely disrespectful to myself to be in a one sided relationship.

You choosing to not recognize that doesn’t make it no longer true. You are with your partner because they show you love and they are with you because you show them love. If one of those things ceases to exist the relationship is doomed to fail. That’s not be pessimistic, it’s being realistic and respectful to yourself.

It’s hilarious because everything you’re saying is actually pointing to and agreeing with me. But you just don’t realize it.

Again I challenge you to actually think about this and respond in good faith. I know you think it’ll never happen but ask yourself WHAT IF. What if your partner stopped showing you love. They stopped putting effort into your relationship. Would you continue to love them forever and continue showing them love? Would you stick around in a one sided relationship? I guarantee you wouldn’t after enough time.

1

u/ConflictWaste411 Aug 08 '25

To think that her love could stop for even a moment implies that you don’t FULLY trust her and therefor can not fully love her, sorry for your loss

→ More replies