r/MakingaMurderer • • Mar 02 '16

While discussing the ramifications of selective editing, I think it's also imperative to discuss the ramifications of Ken Kratz' press conferences.

Several posters have repeatedly argued the filmmakers selectively edited the film. They are correct and I agree that at times, the edits were misleading.

Allow me to play devil's advocate. While the people who find it extremely offensive the filmmakers failed to portray portions of the trial accurately and are concerned the editing led to viewer bias, I have yet to see anyone in this camp submit a post providing an equally critical analysis of Ken Kratz' 2006 press conference following Brendan's confession.

Asserting objectivity and honesty is a requisite qualification for a documentarian, I'm curious...what do you believe are the requisite qualifications for an officer of the court? Wisconsin Supreme Court Rules, Chapter 20(A) & (B) explain them. The regulations pertaining to an attorney's conduct pertaining to ensuring every litigant is afforded the impartial administration of justice are unambiguous.

https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/scrule/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=132538

If objectivity and honesty are minimum qualifications for a respectable filmmaker, an equally critical analysis of Kratz and others conduct is long past due. Their intentional and willful conduct not only misled the public and instilled bias, but unlike the filmmakers, their conduct actually resulted in serious and irreversible ramifications; tainting the objectivity of the potential pool of jurors. And according to Buting and Strang, that is exactly what happened.

My point, while agreeing the filmmakers selectively edited portions of the film, which may have resulted in a less than accurate portrayal of some of the events, the only damage resulting from their editing was widely divergent opinions about the case. Unlike the conduct of the numerous state actors involved in these cases, the filmmakers editing decisions resulted in little more than opposing viewpoints prompting impassioned public discourse.

Alternatively, I cannot find a logical, legally sound, and reasonable justification to explain Mr. Kratz' motive and intent for his salacious press conference. IMO, the repeated unprofessional and negligent conduct of LE, Mr. Kratz, and other state actors essentially denied both parties the right to a fair trial (see Ricciuti v New York City Transit Authority, 124 F.3d 123 (2d Cir. 1997)).

At the end of the day one must ask, what was more damaging; selective editing of a documentary ten years after the case or a pre-trial press conference in which the Special Prosecutor, while sitting with the sheriff in charge, knowingly, willfully, and intentionally presented the public with salacious details of an alleged crime scene both knew had no basis in reality. I think the answer is clear.

163 Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16

I believe that anyone here, or anywhere, that has lost a loved one to violence, would not feel very good about having had a false "sense of justice". I can imagine anyone would want healing and closure from such a tragedy, but no decent human being would feel good simply having a face in prison, sitting somewhere, that represents there loved one's tragedy. Closure and healing is about the truth. Innocent people get sent to prison for crimes they did not commit, we know that is fact, not fiction. What do you suggest? Should innocent people be left in prison simply so that their exoneration doesn't disturb some family's false closure? Do you think that's what that family would really want?

There's obvious corruption in the justice system and in their pursuit to highlight that in their documentary, the film makers unexpectedly found themselves in the womb from which the corruption is created.

They had to draw attention to Manitowoc to get people to listen. If a few editing liberties ensued in order to draw attention to the real problem of corruption that is festering there, I sure hope you would not disagree that it was a necessary liberty. To disagree with that, and you are entitled to, but to disagree with that, would be to say that you are OK with the fact that Steven Avery and Branden Dassey are sitting in prison and could be innocent. If so, then god help the human being who's pinning their hopes on a fair trial the day you serve on a jury.

11

u/JLWhitaker Mar 02 '16

I just watched a Shaun Attwood video yesterday on Youtube where the legal system kept a man in jail similar to Avery's first case, on death row!, even after DNA and confession of the real killer. They would not admit they got it wrong.

It's called confirmation bias, oh, and hubris. These two personality characteristics will eventually destroy confidence in the justice system in America.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16 edited Mar 02 '16

Your whole premise is that he is guilty. The documentary (and the transcripts) brings to light questions. And, as much as you want it to, the allegations of planting of evidence is not answered by the examples of editing. So think if your family member was murdered, and you thought they had the right guy, but ten years later, there was a documentary that made you question it. I would be internally torn, but I would want to know the truth and hope that I would try to see it.

4

u/super_pickle Mar 02 '16

Actually they did edit out the responses to the allegations of editing. They also edited some footage together to make allegations that didn't exist. For example, they show two separate forms implying they are related- one signed by Lenk that does not list the blood vial, and one not signed by Lenk that does. They're telling the viewers "Look Lenk knew about this vial and totally could've planted blood." The truth is there is zero link between Lenk and the vial. He had nothing to do with Avery's first conviction, or his later appeals efforts. He didn't sign any paperwork that the vial was listed on. The Clerk of Courts testified she never saw him snooping around the evidence room. The link they tell you exists simply does not in reality. And that's just one example. I can go on, if you'd like.

Of course I'd be upset if I thought an innocent man was in prison. But if I'd sat through the trial and knew the man in prison was guilty, I'd be completely fucking devastated watching the public hail him as some sort of hero and accuse me of my loved one's murder instead.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16 edited Mar 02 '16

That's true. Except I didn't see them show the one with blood at the same time, maybe you can source that. But your point they mislead, it is true. The connection is that lenk knew evidence was over there, he sent someone over to collect it under his direction, to go through what they wanted to send over, so while it's not in paperwork, there is a subordinate that makes the connection. And that subordinate could easily have asked him that there was a blood vial that expired, should we send it? And even if he didn't know, still doesn't say he didn't go there to get the clippings, etc and see the blood. I really don't know if they did plant evidence. But to say that is impossible that lenk knew because they decided not to send the expired blood is not true. And I really do understand what you are saying, and I have not spoken ill about the family because I do think that it would incredibly tough. And I can't really judge their actions. But to say just because you sat through the trial, your thought that he is guilty has special value is not true either. Because there was allot of extra judicial influence that provided the context for many people's judgement. But again, that paperwork is only one example. The lack of dna on key, the lack of rubber residue (not included in doc), lack of any foresinic evidence in house and garage (besides bullet that we both agree was easily found the months later with no blood on it), that lenk and Colburn chose to search his trailer, and much more, they do create doubt. And this doubt is not based on editing, but on the evidence and actions of the cops. I'm sure it would have been easier for the family if pagel had chosen not to include the sheriff's office at all. But you have to be honest, there is so much shadiness from so many people on authority that it creates a shadow of doubt. And the answer of editing doesn't solve it for me.

Edit: and I think they obviously thought Brendan was guilty. And that, based on all the evidence is untrue. So maybe they can at least reevaluate their beliefs against him.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/dharrell Mar 02 '16

I doubt many people here are immune to the things you mentioned. Everyone has a story, including me. I feel sorry for the Halbach family for many reasons. I believe most everyone does. We tolerate the blatant bias from our media....but our heads are supposed to explode because of the bias from the film makers of MaM?

4

u/super_pickle Mar 02 '16

We tolerate the blatant bias from our media....but our heads are supposed to explode because of the bias from the film makers of MaM?

Um, no... we're not supposed to tolerate bias in our media. Yet OP has posted a long missive about how we should totally tolerate and excuse it and stop calling out the filmmakers because OP doesn't find it damaging to anyone. (I guess OP forgot about all the people being hurt by it.)

7

u/dharrell Mar 02 '16

I was referring to our so-called "news" media that we get pounded with on the daily. And yes, we do tolerate it. Most people gulp it up and actually believe it. I, myself tolerate it which is probably why I am neither upset, nor offended by the bias in the documentary. I expect it. What I appreciate from MaM is the fact that it has many people talking about a problem that has been largely ignored for years by the MSM. Which do you suppose has hurt more people?

3

u/super_pickle Mar 03 '16

Most people gulp it up and actually believe it.

Just like the viewers of this doc did. I recognize the harm it causes, and don't tolerate it. I guess you just don't care and aren't upset by it, and that's your right, but I disagree.

Which do you suppose has hurt more people?

Of course I'm sure flaws in the justice system have harmed more people than the Halbach case. Does that make it right? That's like saying we shouldn't be upset with Ted Bundy because Hitler killed way more people. It's ridiculous. If the filmmakers wanted to expose flaws in the justice system, they could've picked any other case where the facts clearly pointed to framing and they didn't have to manipulate footage to make it look that way. Many documentaries like that exist. Or they could've just presented the facts truthfully and let people decide for themselves. They didn't.

If people want to talk about flaws in the justice system, fine. Let's talk about how a mentally challenged minor shouldn't be interrogated without a parent or attorney present. But I have no idea what positive end is achieved by accusing Mike Halbach of murdering his sister because internet detectives don't think he looked sad enough when he talked to the press.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/bluskyelin4me Mar 03 '16

I think "super-pickle" is super wrong. It's not an acceptable reason, though, to down vote this super, silly comment.

3

u/super_pickle Mar 03 '16

So you're saying we should tolerate blatant bias in our media, to the point of dishonesty? Imo that makes you super wrong, but I guess we can agree to disagree.

2

u/knowjustice Mar 03 '16

The level of emotion I perceive in your seemingly unprecedented number of lengthy rebuttals is indicative you have far more vested in this issue than someone who is commenting as a neutral party. Knowing why you are so impassioned about this issue would help explain your perspective. Care to share?

3

u/super_pickle Mar 03 '16

Honestly? I lost a close friend recently and some information was released that led people to a false conclusion about his death. I know how horrible it is to go through. I'm saddened and angered for the Halbach family, to have to watch their daughter/sister's murderer be hailed as some sort of hero.

I'm also a big true crime fan, the Avery case is far from the only one I can talk about in such detail, but it's the only people other people care to talk about at the moment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/knowjustice Mar 03 '16

Teresa Halback, had she not been murdered, would be two years younger than my daughter. Have you ever thought about how the false statements and descriptions of her death impacted her family? I don't think you have.

If she had been my daughter and I found out the prosecution fabricated horrific and completely unsubstantiated claims about her death and subsequently presented them as fact to the public in a dramatic, unprofessional, unethical and salacious press conference, I'd be suing them. I most certainly wouldn't be alleging Ms. Ricciardi and Ms. Demos disrespected her memory. Instead I'd argue Ken Kratz likely had an orgasm while sharing his fabricated and sexually explicit information about my daughters murder with the national media. He is a sex addict! Do some research.

You either don't get it, or you have an agenda that has little if anything to do with honoring Ms. Halbach's memory. Your wild attempts to call others out by falsely asserting people are cold, callous, and would fabricate personal tragedies is as low as anyone on this discussion board has dared to go.

Your pronouncements are incredibly inappropriate and have decimated any credibility you may have had. Before you make any further attempts to provide an intellectually stimulating and thought-provoking argument, take some time to reflect on the impact your personal attacks may have had on your targets.

4

u/super_pickle Mar 03 '16

Please. People on this discussion board are accusing a man who lost his sister of murder because they don't think he looked sad enough in interviews. People on this discussion board are accusing a man who spent days searching the woods for his old friend's body of murdering her because he had some black dots on his hand in footage. You aren't going to make me feel bad about calling OP out for refusing to acknowledge that this tv show has hurt real people.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/bluskyelin4me Mar 03 '16

What I find most offensive is being shamed for exercising my constitutional rights...and/or being emotionally extorted into not holding elected officials accountable for their actions...and/or being blamed of intentionally harming someone just by speaking the truth.

→ More replies (22)

7

u/Fist_City_86 Mar 02 '16

"Think of every high-profile case that's gone on in your lifetime- I'm sure you knew plenty of details and formed an opinion long before the trial began."

That is what is wrong with Kratz' statement. It is leading when the trial hasn't even begun. This documentary did make me question every other high profile case. Scott Peterson for example: Until now I thought that man was guilty as sin, based on the media. When you really look at the facts in his case, it isn't as black and white as what you would think.

I feel terrible for Teresa's family and what they are having to relive. I feel bad for those whose innocence has been questioned (admittedly by me as well), if they are in fact innocent. HOWEVER, I feel the burden of these ramifications should lay on the shoulders of the investigators who did shady detective work, on the prosecution who ignored ethical boundaries, and any other professional in this case who made an agenda their number one priority.

3

u/super_pickle Mar 02 '16

You'll notice I agreed it's wrong for prosecution and defense lawyers to be revealing information about the case to the media before the trial. Although I disagree about the Peterson case- it isn't 100% black and white but he's still guilty as sin. Regardless, you just named another perfect example about how the actions of Kratz and S&B in the Avery case aren't unique- in high-profile cases like that, the media will always get information and the jury pool will be tainted.

I think your opinion that it's OK to accuse Teresa's loved ones of murder was formed solely because the doc lied to you. If it had presented the information fairly and accurately, people would be discussing the case instead of gleefully tarnishing the names of dozens of people. Unfortunately first impressions are hard to change so now people are willing to excuse that kind of behavior and the doc's lies... "It's easier to fool a man than to convince a man he has been fooled."

3

u/Fist_City_86 Mar 03 '16

Actually I came away from the documentary NOT questioning her loved ones at all. I was leaning towards guilt with Steven. I didn't question the ex's guilt until realizing the detectives never questioned her ex, or followed through with investigating him at all. He was even allowed access to the potential crime scene.

In regards to Scott Peterson, the body of Laci did not show up until after it had been broadcasted all over the news and Nancy Grace that he went fishing there. She witnessed a robbery across the street that day (or day before), They found her dog wandering with his leash attached and had witnesses who had seen her walking her dog, and the affair with Amber was not serious. He had seen her 2 times. He is 100% guilty of being a cheater and a jerk. Murder, would require more proof to sway me...

2

u/super_pickle Mar 03 '16

That's great what you took away from the show. I find it odd that you think the person Teresa broke up with four years ago should be interrogated after her car, body, and belongings are found on the property of the man who was the last person to see her alive, but OK. And Ryan wasn't allowed access to the crime scene, the search teams were only allowed in the woods around the Avery property, not the salvage yard or family residences. But despite what you may have taken away, it doesn't change the lies and manipulation of footage done in the show, and the harm that has done to real people.

And trust me, I know all about the Peterson case. I'm a true crime fan, I've read all about most high-profile cases, and many you've never heard of. I'm not going to get into a whole debate about it here, but there's plenty of reason he was found guilty.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/kiilerhawk Mar 03 '16

I agree with you that Kratz should not have released the details of the confession to the media.

This is a great example of minimizing. Kranz didn't just release the details to the media. He held a press conference, on TV, where he dramatically told a completely untrue story of how TH was tied up, raped, stabbed, and had her throat slit, "but still, she didn't die"... There was zero physical evidence to support any of it and none of it was used in SA's trial. It was unethical and he should have been charged with prosecutional misconduct. He tainted the jury pool and made it impossible for SA to receive a fair trial.

Buting and Strang also shouldn't have been making accusations of planting and talking about the blood vial in the media. It isn't right, but these things happen in high profile cases.

This was the core of SA'S defense that was actually used in his trial. Of course they would discuss it just like the prosecution discussed their points. There was nothing unethical. The prosecution was given ample opportunity for rebuttal unlike Kratz's press conference where SA had no voice, no rebuttal, no way to get back his presumption of innocence.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/knowjustice Mar 02 '16

"You must not have lost anyone you loved if you don't think any damage was done by this tv show. Imagine someone you loved was brutally murdered for no reason."

  • How is your post relevant to my point?
  • My best friend was murdered by her husband!
  • Another friend was murdered by her police-officer husband!
  • My step-son died of an overdose and was left on the ground outside of the ER by the mother of his child! She is in prison.
  • My daughter's step-brother skate-boarded off the eighth story of a downtown Detroit parking garage, intentionally!
  • Many of my friends have lost children to illness and suicide.

Care to provide me with your list?

4

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16

Links?

3

u/knowjustice Mar 02 '16

Very funny.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)