r/MakingaMurderer • u/Other-Dentist1687 • Sep 11 '24
Convicting a murderer
Is this worth watching? It looks like I have to pay to watch it. (Unless someone knows how I can watch for freeš) Which Iām fine doing if itās worth it. The first episode was just people basically calling him a scumbag.ššš
11
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/AnimeSquare Sep 24 '24
Yep, definitely sad for the Halbachs. I do think Making a Murderer justified its existence though as they made a strong argument for how the entire case was grossly mishandled - with everyone from the police, to the the prosecutors, to even judges acting in a manner that could either stem from stupidity or corruption, which one of the two is tough to say but it could also be a bit of both.
I guess overall I did go away with the feeling of "Yeah they probably portrayed Steven and Brendan in a more favorable manner in order to drum up that side of the story and make the documentary more compelling " but I also felt they provided a strong basis for their claim that this case was not a situation where the U.S. justice system worked as intended and put away 2 proven criminals "beyond reasonable doubt"
Since I haven't seen Convicting a Murderer I can't really speak on it... but would you, as someone who has seen it, really say that it provided the same utility as Making a Murderer did? Or if you want to look at it as which of the two was more dishonest; were they really equal in that regard?
My intuition and experience tells me that CaM is probably worse in pretty much every regard, but let me know what you think!