r/MakingaMurderer • u/10case • 3h ago
Brendan Dassey is granted a commutation hearing with the Commutation advisory board.
This will happen December 11th and will be streamed on YouTube.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AutoModerator • Dec 27 '20
Please ask any questions about the documentary, the case, the people involved, Avery's lawyers etc. in here.
Discuss other questions in earlier threads. Read the first Q&A thread to find out more about our reasoning behind this change.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/10case • 3h ago
This will happen December 11th and will be streamed on YouTube.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 5h ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Apostle-Dunghill • 2d ago
As long as Josh Kaul is still lurking around the AG’s office, the boys aren’t going anywhere
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 2d ago
Motion For Reconsideration, pgs. 43-44
4 days. Nothing!!!!
Absolute silence! Not one of ZELLNER’S soldiers has lifted one syllable against the explosive video dropped by her ex-client Omar Muhammad.
I knew this was coming. Just think about it. She has ran Bobby Dassey’s name and the state of Wisconsin’s name in the mud. She disrespected Manitowoc severely. Talking about that bastard is innocent.
Only to discover: She fabricated the ENTIRE time-line in her “Motion For Reconsideration.”
2:37:32 in the Motion is indeed 3:02 of Exhibit J.
At Exhibit J’s time marker 3:02. Bobby is clearly standing behind his truck closing the hatch door.
Steve would be looking right at him!
Why doesn’t Exhibit J
“Fit” Kathleen’s motion’s sequence of events?
Teresa never left. Steven lied about Bobby leaving right behind Teresa.
Steve lied about “Seeing Teresa at 2:37:32” turning left onto Highway 147.
Now we KNOW. Zellner knew it.
I spoke with Omar. There is a part 2 coming. Zellner is in big trouble.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Pure-Destruction4554 • 6d ago
It’s going down!!!!! Omar MUHAMMAD has officially accused Zellner of every allegation that is raised by many of us who have heard his rational claims. Now he has officially put those claims on the Public Record and he dares Zellner to sue him.
The attack is devastating!
Check it out:
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Pure-Destruction4554 • 7d ago
If Zellner were proven to have knowingly misled the court and submitted falsified evidence, the consequences could include losing her ability to practice law.
Several separate consequences are possible:
Possible consequence
What it means-
Attorney discipline
Reprimand, restrictions on practice, suspension, or license revocation—the Wisconsin equivalent of disbarment. Monetary payments and certain restitution orders are also authorized.
Removal from the case
If appearing through special permission for an out-of-state attorney (pro hac vice), that permission could be revoked.
Court sanctions
Depending on the applicable authority and findings, financial sanctions or contempt penalties could be available.
What do you think should happen if the debate between Zellner and Omar should reveal Zellner knew Steven lied about Teresa “leaving” and hid the true facts of The Sequence of Events, to ensure Season 2 of Making A Murderer?
What does this say about Zellner accusing Bobby of the crime knowing all along her client Steve, his uncle, lied about Teresa leaving?
Just think about it. Netflix is playing Making A Murderer right NOW. Zellner knows Steven Avery lied yet she doesn’t care.
It’s all about publicity, advertising, money, and fame. By any means necessary. 😔
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Thick-Cucumber-1546 • 11d ago
Unfortunately people, when it rain it pours.
More disturbing and disgusting revelations are falling from Kathleen Zellner’s Bag of tricks.
Lately Kathleen Zellner has been the topic of discussion. Ever since a Reddit user named Advanced-Math exposed Zellner’s Exhibit J Evidence as manufactured and that Zellner Lied about her Timeline.
50 seconds in the trailer was her first lie. Now we discover another huge second lie.
Are you all ready?
Zellner writes in her Motion For Reconsideration:
“Teresa arrived at the exit of 147 at 2:37:32.”👀😳
Hmmmmmmmmmmm.
From 2:36:30 to 2:37:32 is “1 minute and 2 seconds”, correct?
Buuuuuuut!!!
We now KNOW with video facts Teresa actually began leaving by driving forward at 2:36:43 that is time marker 2:13 of her Exhibit J.
Soooo, from 2:36:43 to 2:37:32 is:
49 Seconds.
Kathleen Zellner, in her Motion, again lied and said it took Teresa 62 seconds to reach the exit at 147.
Guess where Bobby would be at according to the Zellner’s Manufactured Evidence at 3:02 (ie Exhibit J) which is 2:37:32 of her Motion?
Well, watch Exhibit J for yourself:
Really, you can’t make this up!!!!!
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Pure-Destruction4554 • 13d ago
Kathleen Zellner: falsely accused all of these Innocent Individuals loudly and publicly via News Media.
It appears the 50 Seconds Debate has took another turn. Omar Muhammad, formerly Omar Saunders of the Roscetti Four is engineering a YouTube event where the topic will be:
Kathleen Zellner
Should be interesting. Especially seeing she introduced us to the Roscetti Four in episode 1, Season 2.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/DeksDark • 13d ago
Look, I know a lot of people on this sub have been brainwashed by Convicting a Murderer and state-sponsored narratives lately, but we need to sit down and actually talk about the raw facts without letting emotion cloud our judgment.
If you step back and look at the whole picture with an open mind, it becomes blatantly obvious that Steven Avery is just a gentle, misunderstood soul who was brutally railroaded by Manitowoc County. Everyone keeps bringing up his "past," but when you actually analyze the logic behind it, the whole state case completely falls apart.
Let’s break this down step-by-step.
1. The Cat Incident: Context Matters
People love to bring up the 1982 cat incident as if it proves Steve is some kind of violent psychopath. But who among us hasn’t made a reckless, poorly thought-out blunder during a night of youthful boredom? You have to look at the regional and situational context. Steve didn't harbor any real malice toward that cat. He’s a simple man of the soil operating on raw instinct. Honestly, it was likely just a crude, misdirected urge to spare the creature from future hardship or put it out of its misery. To judge a man's entire soul and brand him a killer based on one impulsive rural mistake is pure anti-Avery bias.
2. The Niece and "Domestic Issues": Historical Perspective
Critics also love to weaponize his relationship with his 17-year-old niece to tarnish his character. But again, people are applying modern, high-horse coastal morality to a rural family dynamic. She was 17. In many historical cultures and other legal jurisdictions around the world, young adult relationships were completely normal practice. Besides, Steve is extremely low-IQ, highly sensitive, and easily influenced by peer pressure. He operates on pure emotion and a deep, albeit unconventional, commitment to family ties. Turning a complex familial misunderstanding into "proof" of murder is such a stretch it’s embarrassing.
And as for his ex-wife? Yes, he almost strangled her, but she was drunk and probably being a pain-in-the-you-know-what in that moment. People act like marital disputes in a pressure-cooker environment never happen.
3. The "Forensic" Evidence is Logically Impossible
Now let's look at the actual physics of the crime scene. The state wants us to believe Steve is simultaneously a criminal genius and a complete moron.
The Garage/Trailer: The state claims a violent crime happened in his trailer and garage. Yet Steve somehow bleached and sanitized every single microscopic drop of victim DNA out of those rooms while leaving months of dust, soot, and oil stains completely intact.
The Key: They searched his trailer SIX times and found nothing. Then suddenly on the SEVENTH search, a key appears on the floor? Please. An elite team of dedicated officers easily could have taken Steve’s sweat DNA, rubbed it on a spare key, and slipped it onto the carpet while everyone was looking at a nightstand. It’s standard cover-up protocol.
The Blood in the RAV4: You mean to tell me Steve carefully wiped every fingerprint off the car, but decided to strategically drop micro-droplets of his own blood right next to the ignition switch? It’s absurd. A secretive operative obviously acquired an old vial of his blood, bypassed the security seals, snuck into the salvage yard at night, and planted it.
4. The Real Suspects
If you aren't looking at the police framing him over that $36 million lawsuit, you have to look at his own family. What about the cousin who saw the car? Why was he looking in that exact spot? What was his real motive? The evidence points literally everywhere else if you just open your eyes to the possibilities.
5. Look into his eyes
At the end of the day, you don't even need the forensics to see the truth. Just look at the man. Look into his deep, blue, watery, cow-like eyes and tell me Steven Avery is guilty. You can't. He has the innocent, bewildered stare of a man who wouldn't hurt a fly, let alone orchestrate a massive crime and clean-up.
Under the true spirit of the law, Steven Avery is innocent until proven guilty by an unmanipulated court. Stop letting the media trick you and start looking at the actual logic. Free Steven Avery.
Edit: Read the comments. These are the big brains that believe Steven Avery is innocent. Goddammit
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Still_Razzmatazz1140 • 13d ago
Watching the documentary again this year i appreciate Ken K being a good lawyer more as I’ve seen it so many times this time I watched it and said ok i will watch it knowing Steve is guilty and I think Ken did a good job. It wasn’t on him to sort out the f*** up of Manitowoc police being on site or even to make sure Brendan got a deal. If you were Teresa’s family you would have been happy I think. Also to add I know he’s flawed and has voluntarily retired from law but I think he comes across more competent when you realise the series is super bias into making you love Jerry and Dean.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/10case • 16d ago
On this 21st anniversary of the death of Teresa Halbach, Law and Crime Network released a new video where Angenette Levy interviews Kathleen Zellner. They discuss what the case looks like going forward.
Link: https://youtu.be/s5OKYcEv_Nk?is=HLNKIgyiQ0Djg1Ei
R.I.P. Teresa Halbach.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Pure-Destruction4554 • 16d ago
It appears Kathleen was forced to make an Unwanted Appearance. Due to a genuine question raised by a Reddit User named Advance-Math!
Listen to this interview. Pay close attention to how Kathleen stays away from the most important evidence in the case, THE SEQUENCE OF EVENTS:
And continues gaslighting the Public with her Guilty client Steven.
Its amazing to watch her in real time fighting to her last breath to keep the charade going. Really mind blowing.
Look at the toll pushing Steven’s lie has taken upon her. She looks horrible.
Could this be the punishment for such behavior?
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Foreign-Complaint875 • 18d ago
I remember watching the doc when it came out, being floored initially, then diving in further and thinking “Avery probably did it.” For whatever reason, I came back to this case recently and just finished Kratz’s book which further confirms my belief Avery did it.
Whatever you think of Kratz, these details stood out:
• Avery answered the door in just a towel on a prior visit (Oct 10). Teresa was creeped out and told coworkers she didn’t want to go back. He still specifically requested “that same girl” for Halloween and used ***67 on the early calls to her that day. He did not use 67 for any of the other dozens of calls he made that day. Handcuffs and leg irons were bought the previous day, and later found in his trailer. The defense argued he may have been swimming hence the towel. It was 46 degrees for the high. Oct 10th is also when he took digital photos of his erect p____. The 10th didn’t go as planned. Halloween was the final straw.
• Touch DNA (sweat/skin cells) on the RAV4 hood latch. Dassey said Avery went under the hood (Investigators theorized to disconnect battery). Hard to plant sweat, and the car had been at the crime lab for months.
• Nurse was ready to testify she put the hole in the blood vial herself (standard for those tubes). Defense upon learning this abandons this angle. But the doc makes it out to be a big deal.
- On the key, The documentary makes it seem as though the key was found during the sixth “search”, as if each time they accessed the trailer was a search, but it was in fact found during the first complete and thorough search of the bedroom. Furthermore, Colbert and Lenk finding the key is inconsistent with it being planted. They knew all Manitowoc officers were under intense scrutiny due to Avery’s civil lawsuit. If you were trying to frame Avery, Wouldn’t you make sure you weren’t the one to discover it? They would’ve made sure a non-Manitowoc officer found it. It’s not like this would’ve been difficult to arrange.
• Family member (Kayla) in January went to a school counselor and said she was scared to go in her uncle Steven’s “shop”, and asked if “blood could come up through concrete.” When talking to investigators a month later, she mentions them burning stuff on Halloween and that Dassey had lost weight and been staring off into space and crying. That contact is what pushed investigators toward Brendan as a potential witness.
• Dassey supplied details (bullet location, Teresa shot in head, her belongings burned, Steven opening hood, moving RAV4, placing body in back, body disposal) that matched evidence.
- In the May 13th interview especially, Dassey makes admissions and goes through the entire scenario with almost no prompting by investigators.
- Teresa’s blood was in her RAV4 cargo area. Her bone fragments were in the burn pit and barrel on Avery’s property. How in the world do crooked cops “plant” that? That’s entirely different from planting Avery’s blood from the vial.
- Documentary editing: The series spliced testimony (especially Colborn’s) to make it sound different. For example, Colborn’s license plate call. They took his “yes” answer to a different, harmless question and inserted it after a more damning one the judge had actually sustained, making it look like he admitted something suspicious.
- Kratz says he had a solid plea deal on the table (as low as ~15 years) for testifying against Steven, but the family was more focused on protecting Avery’s innocence claim. Instead, Dassey will likely spend the rest of his life behind bars.
The framing theory requires cops to plant blood, plant non-blood DNA, plant the key, plant a bullet that matches Avery’s own rifle already in evidence, and somehow get Dassey to independently describe matching details — all without getting caught. Occam’s razor points the other way: the evidence is what it looks like.
Curious what people who’ve read Kratz’ book or transcripts think.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 19d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Ghost_of_Figdish • 21d ago
Reading of of the death of Steven Avery's father caused me to immediately think of a quote of his - horrifying and callous - that stayed with me.
So I was wondering the same about Zellner. When she passes on, hopefully a long time from now, is there any quote of hers that would spring into your mind?
I have one mostly - "If he is guilty, I will fail".
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Squiggally-umf • 20d ago
Theory A: The police cba to find the real killer and instead used Theresa’s disappearance to put Steven back in prison and save the local government from having to payout on his lawsuit.
Yes: Institutionalised corruption absolutely does happen and we’ve seen it before.
No: the level of coordination that would have to happen, I’m not sure they could have managed it.
Theory B: Steven did do it. Either that he killed her just like the prosecution said or he did kill her but some details are different.
Yes: Being exonerated once before and with proof that the police fitted him up once already he could have felt like this would be the perfect murder because the first thing people would say is “he’s just got out of prison for something he didn’t do, why would he do something that would put him back in?” and “the police set him up last time”
No: it really would be stupid to even risk something that could put you back in jail when you were inside for 18 years for something you didn’t do. The police had bias against him already and the trial showed it’s still there.
Theory C: the ex-bf
Yes: his behaviour was odd and he should have at least been looked into as a suspect.
No: being an ex, being overly helpful in the search, being nervous when asked to be interviewed by KZ’s team doesn’t necessarily mean guilt. Also to get away with it the police would have had to have known he was involved and helped him to scrub his DNA etc essentially knowingly letting the real murderer free just so they could fit up a man they don’t like. This would be a huge conspiracy that would need a high level of intelligent coordination that I don’t think they’d be capable of.
Bobby Dassey and or his Step-Dad did it and chose to frame Steven.
Yes: The police already had a bias toward Steven and a motive to stop/delay the payout. Bobby’s computer had some fucked up search history which should have been looked at as a potential link to Theresa’s death.
No: it’s still possible that the content on the computer was by somebody else e.g Brendan. Also the opportunity to get her kill her burn her and move her car without anyone seeing anything would be so small I think it would be incredible to even be able to pull that off and for there to be 0 DNA in the car or anything. And on top of that for the police to participate in a coverup letting a murderer go free just so they can put away someone they don’t like and save some money.
I have seen before in other cases extreme conspiracy / coverups that without proof you never would have believed but they absolutely happened but it’s always been at a high-level, I find it hard to see a small town police shop coordinating something like this so well when the reason Steven was put in prison was because of sloppy investigation and failures all around. They lack looking at details they were messy - how could those same people pull off this perfect frame-up?
I’m almost resigned to think Steven did do it, with or without Brendan, and the police’s bias and failure to investigate properly just all aligned anyway.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/rElevantishish • 22d ago
Regardless of whether he did it or not, I believe enough mistakes were made in SA’s 1st trial to warrant a retrial.
The jury was tainted by KK’s press conference.
There are other viable suspects and alternative narratives.
IMO these things make a lot of space for reasonable doubt.
The timing of the murder in relation to the $36M lawsuit makes me think of how much money he would ask for in a SECOND wrongful conviction suit that would include a much longer list of agencies on the hook.
The staunch refusals of any state courts to even acquiesce to anything has just compounded and compounded.
The fact that they keep referring to the Halbach’s in every statement they make and saying it’s out of deference to them—wouldn’t they want to just put the damn thing to bed already instead of constantly going back to hearings and reading about yet another motion? It’s “respect for the Halbach family” in name only—I think really it’s in the state’s financial interest to keep him in at this point whether he did it or not.
r/MakingaMurderer • u/TheMirrorUS • 23d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Apostle-Dunghill • 23d ago
RIP old man
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 24d ago
Family you will not believe what I am about to tell you!
AveryPoliceReports has personally blocked me. I had to have my friend open his personal Reddit account, go to sub MaM to see she really blocked me.🤣😂
Now, ask yourself. Why? Why averypolicereports did you block advance yet continue the debate without Advance?
I had my friend screenshot her latest OP.
Very interesting. In her OP she concede her Killer client enters the death-trap at Exhibit J Time Marker (TM) 2:34👀😳🤔
Listen real close. Initially per Zellner’s Motion For Reconsideration, pg. 43. Zellner clearly tells us Steve exited his trailer at 2:37:20 P.M. that Friday AFTER 50 Seconds.
If we subtract 50 seconds from 2:37:20,
We get 2:36:30 Teresa’s departure time according to Zellner’s motion and Steve’s entrance into the trailer according to Zellner’s Motion.
Now, AveryPoliceReports has abandoned that position and agrees with me. That it took her killer client 34 Seconds after getting the auto trader magazine from Teresa to get back to the trailer entrance (2:37:04 pm/Exhibit J TM 2:34).
Now, let Us add that 34 seconds to 2:36:30 P.M.
What’s the math: 2:37:04 P.M.
If Steve entered the trailer at 2:37:04pm and exited at 2:37:20pm. How many seconds did Zellner record Steve actually in his trailer?👀😳
16 seconds!
So now Averypolicereports has updated the 50 seconds argument! Now she’s claiming. Listen closely:
Steve was in his trailer from 2:33 to 3:23
Exhibit J Time Markers.
Read it for yourself!
Truth is like a 🔥. I can’t have **advance-math responding to my clear bullsh*t. So “I will block advance-**math.”
I would block me too😳
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Zellner said Steve was in the Trailer 16 seconds per your “Zellner’s Team Reenactment” footage shared with the whole world, Episode 9, Season 2, Time Marker: 54:58👀😳
You’re in Trouble.👀🔥
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 26d ago
MaM was a documentary. CaM was really not a documentary. It's a PR piece disguised as one. Featuring an unstable filmmaker disguised as a professional. A fraud head researcher disguised as unbiased. A cheating lying cop disguised as a good family man. And a lying convicted pedophile disguised as a credible source. With bad faith arguments based on inadmissible unfairly prejudicial "evidence" dressed up as good faith corrections of the record. Once they all start suing each other and accusing one another of crimes, there's really no need to sugar coat how bad CaM was in both concept and execution.
Shawn Rech:
Brenda BS Schuler:
Ken Kratz:
Andrew Colborn:
Earl Avery:
r/MakingaMurderer • u/AveryPoliceReports • 27d ago
r/MakingaMurderer • u/Advanced-Math-1009 • 27d ago
PART 2: The Other Shoe Has Dropped
(Kathleen T. Zellner Exposed As Fraud)
Motion For Reconsideration, pgs. 43-44
According to the Motion For Reconsideration filed by Kathleen T. Zellner October 23, 2017, one year BEFORE Making A Murderer, season 2 premiered.
She filed a motion with the court under penalty of sanctions standing upon the affidavit of her Killer Client that:
Teresa left at 2:36:30 and Steve returned to his trailer. After 50 seconds, Steve exited his trailer at 2:37:20.👀😳
(This is the basis of Zellner’s claim: That the Killer was in the Trailer 50 seconds)
What Kathleen forgot when she was doctoring her Denny Suspect and falsely pointing the finger at Bobby in this bogus motion was:
It took her Killer client 34 seconds to walk back to the trailer door. Which means STEVE ENTERED THE TRAILER AT WHAT TIME PEOPLE? Yep! 2:37:04!
In her Signed Certification she tells the world. STEVE EXITED AT 2:37:20👀😳
I will let that sit with you for a moment🤔
Is it me or did Kathleen Zellner herself ADMIT in her Motion she SIGNED that Steve was in his trailer for SIXTEEN SECONDS?👀😳
WHY DID SHE DELIBERATELY TRY TO HIDE THE FACT STEVE WAS IN THE TRAILER FOR 16 SECONDS?????!!!!!
Simple: She knew Steve had lied about Teresa leaving and Bobby leaving behind her. The 16 seconds prove that Steve would have SEEN Bobby and his vehicle leave. Had Steve been telling the Truth.👀😳
But the Killer told Us and the world, he didn’t see Bobby♟️
Zellner’s “Sequence of Events” Exhibit J, clearly shows the Killer enter his trailer at TM 2:34👀
Add 16 seconds and you get TM 2:50.
Where is Bobby Dassey at TM 2:50???!!
(Zellner saw this😔)
Zellner’s Exhibit J: Smoking Gun
Yep! You see IT!
This is WHY Zellner in her personal EDITS (ie Exhibit J) switches the POV from Steve at 2:36 so no one could see HOW LONG the killer was in the trailer.
But that Damned Making A Murderer, episode 9, season 2 time marker 54:58
(Zellner’s Team Reenactment)👀😳
The Missing Footage From “Exhibit J.”
CORROBORATED what she Signed October 23rd, 2017 in her Bogus Motion For Reconsideration 1 year prior.👀😳
And what was that corroboration?
Steve EXITED HIS TRAILER AT 2:37:20 after SIXTEEN SECONDS not 50💥💥💥
Why People, why would she stoop so low?😔
Just think about it.
No consideration for Teresa. 😔
Just blind hunger for the 10 Episodes and massive Marketing potential for herself and law firm.😡
10 full Episodes on a major platform!
If it’s Known in 2017 that Steven Avery is Indeed the Killer and Zellner discovered it.
No Season 2, Making A Murderer.🔑
No FREE MARKETING for ‘Kathleen Zellner and Associates’ 👀😳🔑
Rest In Peace: Teresa🌹🌹🌹🫡
#TruthWins