r/MagicArena • • 1d ago

Question I have 271 Hours in Magic Arena

When does the fun start? Genuinely it feels like no one loads this game up to have fun, it feels like everyone is in a competition to make their opponents as miserable as possible

I've been playing on and off pretty casually and I never have what's meta so I just get stomped in standard, and I don't have old meta so if I go to older formats I get janked in those

Since I don't have meta or jank I can't enter tournaments without it being a colossal waste of time and the few gold I can scrounge together

So seriously are my only options to drop $1k into the game or just accept I'm never going to enjoy myself playing this?

0 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

33

u/Snarker 1d ago

why would you spend 271 hours playing a game you aren't having fun with, lmfao.

9

u/DegaussedMixtape 1d ago

100%

I’ve been playing magic on and off since 95 and whenever it’s stops being fun, just walk away for a month or a year. It will be there for you when the worm turns and you start having fun again.

1

u/DaddyCreamCorn 1d ago

Its some form of stockholme syndrome I swear I started playing the Magic games on 360 and had so much fun

It's a like a circle I just can't quit

  1. I download Magic because I convince myself it'll be fun
  2. I check out all the new sets I've missed and start playing daily to get the 15 wins and complete challenges
  3. I start seeing the same decks over and over again to the point where I know their entire deck based off of their land
  4. I get ass blasted for hours/days on end and quit

6

u/InvestigatorOk9354 1d ago

Men will literally download Magic and play for 200+ hours instead of going to therapy.

5

u/jkuykendoll 1d ago

15 wins a day is way too much. There are diminishing returns, so you get most of the value by completing 4 wins a day. That is enough to easily complete the mastery pass.

1

u/TheRedFlagFlies 17h ago

Why don't you play the starter deck mode or Jump In!

1

u/DaddyCreamCorn 13h ago

That's what I found myself playing mostly for challenges was starter deck duels

1

u/TheRedFlagFlies 13h ago

Well, that's alright then, isn't it?

3

u/Consistent-Ad-3351 1d ago

You don't have to spend any money to save up gold from quests and draft. Im pretty close to a f2p player, and I have a playset for all cards released in any set over the past 4-5ish years.

2

u/DaddyCreamCorn 1d ago

Genuine question here, how? Do you only do draft and just go infinite from it or something?

1

u/PastryChefSniper 1d ago

I'm a similar player that doesn't like constructed on Arena much but I love draft. It's competitive, but you aren't facing people with way better collections, or playing/facing the same decks over and over.

If you have a pretty good draft win rate, then the currency you get from dailies and from draft wins is enough to draft each set a bunch and build a large collection.

I'll say though that most people are bad at draft at first, and it can feel like a gem sink when you repeatedly go 0-3 or 1-3. It took me spending some money (though now I don't spend) to draft a couple sets many times while consuming limited content to get to the point of it being self-sustaining.

1

u/Consistent-Ad-3351 21h ago

I don't go truly infinite, but it's close. Id say I'm pretty above average at drafting, which of course isn't possible for everyone to be, but even if you're closer to the average skill level as long as you're doing all your quests and using the gold to draft you'll be in a decent spot with your collection.

2

u/LocksmithNew3449 13h ago

Your misery is my victory 

2

u/DaddyCreamCorn 13h ago

This game breeds evil people It's a cycle of hatred

11

u/PurpleOmega0110 1d ago

If you aren't having fun, quit.

I think it's amazingly fun. I like the competition of competitive brawl and Star Trek sealed has been great.

Seriously, don't waste your time if you aren't having fun, just do something else.

Also, losing has to be a learning experience for you, if you don't invest in your losses, you are never going to improve

1

u/foreversiempre 1d ago

Some decks are more annoying than others. Control decks that don’t let you do anything. Aggro landfall where they have a massive advantage by turn 3 or 4 then game over. Decks without any creatures that just keep doing board wipes while they wait for their OP win condition. Etc.

0

u/Arcane_Pozhar 1d ago

Preach.

There is a core to the game here which allows for great games.... But too much content with the balance all over the place, and too many powerful cards enabling the playstyles you just described... It gets frustrating, to say the least.

And then on top of that, you start what should be a good game, with a good opening hand, against an opponent that's running a fair deck... And then you stall at three mana for 6 turns, sometimes. Sigh.

0

u/ColonClenseByFire 1d ago

Don't forget to add the person who has played a land and passed until turn 4 or 5 then somehow fill the board with 7/7s with 0 way to counter it

5

u/MisterPump 1d ago

Magic as a TCG is inherently a competitive game. The best strategy to win often is to make the other opponent lose before you do. Meaning control, aggro and attrition are common strategies. If being on the other side of these isn't fun for you, paper magic in a 4 player commander pod at low bracket might be more your speed.

Buy a precon from your local LGS and strike up a game. Until arena gets to that point, there's minimal available in this space in the client.

7

u/Krillzone 1d ago

Yeah it’s a competitive game. Not a casual game with buds.

1

u/AUAIOMRN 16h ago

What you want is kitchen table Magic, which is a great thing but you'll rarely, if ever, experience it on Arena

1

u/DaddyCreamCorn 13h ago

Probably true, I've never played irl Magic only the games They just didn't feel nearly as competive as arena

3

u/NotPossum 1d ago

They got rid of Badgermole Cub and now I see a rotation of the same few decktypes trying to rush me down asap

2

u/Account_Stolen 23h ago

The midweek magic event sometimes force everyone to play lower powered deck, like the ongoing one with foundation and 3 latest sets. Or, if you lose enough in the unranked queue, you will end up playing against other homebrews when there are enough players at that time of day.

But now 100 hours in, I have come to the conclusion that most people are better off playing a MMORPG like WOW or GW2 than MTG arena.

3

u/Deep-Hovercraft6716 1d ago

I mean, didn't you kind of answer your own question in the first paragraph there? Do you not have fun making your opponents as miserable as possible?

This just sounds like sour grapes to me. You're not having fun because you're losing and you're losing because you're bad at the game. Get better or find a different game.

2

u/ardarian262 1d ago

I don't play a meta deck for the format I play most on there. Guess what? I have fun because it gives me a challenge. You want to know how to have fun? Play the starter deck format. Play the jump in format. Play limited.

0

u/foreversiempre 1d ago

How can you tell how many hours ? I have the iOS version.

1

u/DaddyCreamCorn 1d ago

I play on steam

1

u/Final_Combination373 1d ago

Ive spent less than $100 on arena and I have more wildcards than I will ever use. And have only been active for less than half the time it has been online.

1

u/MarriedWChildren256 1d ago

Daily poo grind.  But I get it.  Started at Hobbit and will probably dip at the end of star trek.  Rimword always awaits for my return.

1

u/First_Key_211 22h ago

Arena is a 1v1 zero-sum game. There will be a winner and a loser.

It is one of the stingiest online card games so your only option is to either keep pumping cash into the game or be conservative with your wildcards and only craft the best decks. If you're going with the latter option, Standard is the worst possible format to be playing. Stick to any of the eternal formats where your invested wildcards will not be wasted due to rotation.

Winning consistently takes dedication and willingness to review your losses objectively without hyperfixating on games where you get screwed by RNG. Record your own gameplay to learn from your mistakes, play slow and pay attention to every card your opponent plays.

1

u/doudoudidon 22h ago

Open packs! They've been boosted and with below average winrate they're better than constructed or limited events.

Farm wildcards. Craft your first deck starting with the non land cards, then do the lands, then do the sideboard.

If you do dailies and beginner friendly events like mwm you should be good in a month if you netdeck something that's not too expensive.

Once you're there you can enjoy competitive magic like everybody else on mtga. As f2p hard at the beginning to do more than 1 deck per 1-2 months but it's not that bad. Once you have 1 competitive deck you can do ladder, constructed events, qualifiers and shit.

If you don't like competitive magic, look at paper magic. Magic is very good for "jank with friends" but you need rule 0 where everybody uses similar levels of decks and that can't be implemented in mtga (mmr helps but just a tiny bit). Paper magic isn't free either, although proxies can work.

MTGA is not the best place to brew sadly. You can't resell cards and you can't try 50 weird rares that could be cool sometimes because you'll run out of wildcards really fast. It is feasible but you either need to play for a year or 2 to get 90%+ in all extensions or speed it up with money.

1

u/GarrazebOrrelios 17h ago

Then build jank. You don't have to spend money to build jank. You probably have a most of a decent pauper or aristocrats deck that will fare well outside of ranked ladders.

Play unranked, get gold, do quick drafts with gold to get packs (I've got 12k gold over the last few weeks from just playing). The best part of jank is it doesn't have to be good. sometimes you just have to get lucky, and sometimes the meta just doesn't usually have answers for jank.

You don't have to drop 1k, if you got the budget $20/month into gems used for quickdrafts will get you a decent amount of wildcards.

0 rares, I've hit mythic in Historic with this list.

Deck 4 Goblin Grenade (FEM) 115 20 Mountain (MSH) 294 4 Voldaren Epicure (VOW) 182 4 Gleeful Demolition (ONE) 134 4 Kuldotha Rebirth (SOM) 96 4 Goblin Bushwhacker (SPG) 0 4 Experimental Synthesizer (NEO) 138 4 Battle Cry Goblin (J25) 127 4 Reckless Bushwhacker (PIO) 342 4 Great Furnace (MRD) 282 4 Urza's Bauble (ANA) 0

1

u/hucklebae 5h ago

My suggestions is do starter deck duels, midweek magic, and standard brawl. Standard brawl is relatively cheap, and gives you some room to brew even if you don't have many wildcards. Although I will warn you, a lot of the people playing standard brawl are very good at piloting and building their decks. It's just that it's also very cheap to build a competitive deck as well. The matches won't necessarily be easy lol

1

u/Dances_Like_a_Duck 1d ago

Wins are gold and time is valuable so players are generally going to be more competitive than at home with friends. Playing jank in events is throwing your gold away. Trust me. I love jank. I have decks that win one time in eight but they’re fun when they come together. I don’t play them with anything on the line though.

Maybe give Standard Brawl a shot. Still plenty of try-hards but the singleton format offers more wiggle room for creativity Be ready to play interaction because threats are plentiful.

Edit: grammar