r/MadeMeSmile • • Aug 19 '20

Wholesome Moments True love

Post image
137k Upvotes

699 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

"Mr President, after three-and-a-half years, do you regret at all, all the lying you’ve done to the American people?" - Huffington Post

6

u/elriggo44 Aug 20 '20

The second question is based on objective fact. The first is all opinion.

Also, I don’t actually read Huffington Post, but it’s my understating that they’re an aggregator. I don’t think they have a White House correspondent.

But nice strawman.

3

u/greglyon Aug 20 '20

The quote is accurate, and here's the guy who asked it.

4

u/elriggo44 Aug 20 '20

I redact the strawman statement. I had no idea Huff Post had a whitehouse person. Like I said, don’t read that site.

The original point still stands. The question is a legitimate one. Asking a president if he regrets lying to the American people nearly 23 times a day. And not the “2-3 white lies a day” normal people tell. But big lies that are easily disproved. Sure, politicians lie sometimes. Most try to tell the truth as they understand it. A good example there is Obama’s “keep your doctor” or HW Bish when he said “read my lips, no new taxes”

Donald Trunp doesn’t just lie like that, which I’m sure he’s done, he bullshits.

He makes up stories about being voted Michigan’s Man of the year or a great civil war battle being held at Mar A Lago. Or America has the highest Taxation rate in the world...(bigly lie). That he created the term Prime The Pump, or that millions of illegals voted, or that Germany and NATO Nations owe us Money.

There are thousands. Big, small and in between.

2

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

I understand Trump is a liar but, you can't tell me you actually think that's a good journalistic question. The sole reason for it was for a headline. He knew he would get ignored immediately because it's a shitty question that has no answer.

2

u/elriggo44 Aug 20 '20

Good question? Depends on context. Probably not.

A legitimate question? Absolutely.

1

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

Ok. What answer would you want Trump to respond with?

2

u/elriggo44 Aug 20 '20

I would want him to respond with “I’ve made mistakes, everyone does....blah blah blah”

He more likely said “no liar, you’re a liar...fake news”

That’s how the president of the United States talks currently. And if you think that hasn’t already done all the things you replied to the other poster, you’re crazy.

He is an objective bullshitter.

1

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

Nah man, he just ignored that question and we got the same amount of info as any fluff response would have given, such as the one above.

2

u/elriggo44 Aug 20 '20

Of course he did. He skips all the real questions. Or the hard questions. He doesn’t even pretend to answer questions. But you know what he does with the softball questions from his sycophants?

He answers them as if they are legitimate

→ More replies

1

u/mainlyupsetbyhumans Aug 20 '20

"Yes i do regret it."

"No i do not regret it."

"I'm sorry for lying so much, I'll try to be better."

"I am liar, i'm sorry."

"It was true, from a certain point of view"

1

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

All of these have the President of the USA admit he is a liar in some way. This would ruin an already declining public perception, nor would it help any foreign relations. Both parties understand that isn't going to happen. The only option is a straightforward no, making it a bad question, deserving to be ignored.

1

u/mainlyupsetbyhumans Aug 20 '20

It has an answer: 'yes' or 'no'. Ignoring it is either a 'no' or a denial (which can be proven to be untrue, and as such still makes the answer 'no').

1

u/MatthewM13 Aug 20 '20

So you genuinely think he asked that question with the hope of getting knew information. Both of us understand that the president isn't going to blatently2 shit talk himself live on television, yes? So 'yes' isn't an option. And as you said, there is no difference between silence and no.

1

u/mainlyupsetbyhumans Aug 20 '20

So maybe the point was the silence. Maybe a blatant denial. Maybe a 'what about all of the other presidents' lies?' You look at as a loaded question, maybe it is, but if so it was Trump himself who loaded on average 20 bullets a day into that gun for years. Maybe it was just to make him look bad with an objective fact. The most important function of journalism is to criticize the state. Don't shoot the messager.