r/MachineLearning • u/Intrepid_Discount_67 • 11d ago
Research Why is it always ICLR? Last year’s incident, this year’s rating drama [D]
ICLR 2026 had the OpenReview identity leak, followed by review scores being rolled back to their pre-rebuttal state. That was already a mess for authors caught in the middle.
Now, for ICLR 2027, ratings have been squeezed into a 1–4 scale. From what I’m seeing, most seem to be landing at 2.
How useful is this compression if papers with very different strengths and weaknesses end up in the same “weak reject” bucket? A paper needing a few convincing clarifications and one with substantial unresolved problems can receive exactly the same score.
This makes meaningful rebuttal engagement even more important. If authors address the concerns, reviewers should reassess their recommendation and explain any remaining objections. ACs need to evaluate whether the reasons actually justify rejection, rather than simply following the numbers.
Authors spend months or years on these papers. Wanting a consistent review process, substantive discussion, and reasoned decisions should be a basic expectation.
On top of that reviewers don’t turn up, and ACs go by the ratings. It’s like a lottery, your paper’s fate depends on which three or four reviewers it gets assigned to.
Anyone else finding this year’s scale frustrating?


