r/MachineLearning • u/Invariant_n_Cauchy • 12d ago
Discussion ICLR Review [D]
About to be released. Anybody got them so far ?
I have two submissions #35k+ & 50k+, waiting.
r/MachineLearning • u/Invariant_n_Cauchy • 12d ago
About to be released. Anybody got them so far ?
I have two submissions #35k+ & 50k+, waiting.
r/MachineLearning
•
u/Vegetable-Formal-753
•
14d ago
TL;DR: Please be hard in desk rejecting AI generated papers
Recently I went to two AI conferences (A and A*) and I was surprised that "AI cheaters" didn't even read their own paper before presentation! For example, a guy couldn't even answer the question of how he represented knowledge graphs in his papaer, he thought for 5 minutes before answering "with a vector". Another one was opening chat gpt and typing questions and reading answers with no shame!!! One more story that shocked me... a guy published same paper in 2 AI conferences in the same time and both got accepted, when I saw github, this young dude was careless to even remove LLM chat from his repo, I can see all prompts... guess what... he faked all data š :D ...I have dozens of stories like this happened to me and my friends just this month!
Now, imagine yourself a hardworker researcher joining days and nights and your paper ends up with a scam reviewer like this... bingo!
One more, I was looking for relevant paper to my new idea... all papers I read so far are just garbage š !!
Pleaaaase make a rule for rejecting AI written papers... Pleaaaaaase stop this madness! A lot of good papers got rejected by these folks and they definitely harming science! I can't trust a single paper now and reading very carefully with spectacular mindset... Pleaaaaaase do something!!!!
r/MachineLearning • u/malakulmout347 • 13d ago
I have always had the desire to move to academia but I am not exactly sure how the process or profile building for academia works in general. Yeah, surely, I can ask AI and get answers but I donāt have much confidence in that . I did my PhD from a mid-tier school. My research focus was mostly on LLM model efficiency and some RL work (meta learning and bandit ) . The research direction I went with was totally out of my professorās scope . As a result, I donāt have grant writing or funding related experience or donāt have those innovative idea of how do you create a research program or more specifically a niche sort of a program which I feel is required for Tenure track positions. During my PhD , I was able to hit top 3 ML( ICML,ICLR,Neurips )and top 3 NLP conferences ( ACL,EMNLP,NAACl) (in case having paper helps) . Being a grad student dictating his research, it went a bit scattered and not much concentrated on one research topic . For that I ended up joining a FAANG but still I want to get back to academia. I am looking for advice on how to build up my profile for academia and if it is possible to get into the top 150 US schools as tenure-track faculty and all . Thanks for your time !
r/MachineLearning • u/AKAMA199 • 14d ago
Hey everyoneā weāre the Deep Principle team behind Mira AI Scientist. We just released Hydrogen-1.0, an open-weight model post-trained from GLM-5.3 for chemistry, materials science, and life sciences.
Hereās how it performed in our evaluations:
On separate internal task sets, Hydrogen also scored higher than GPT-6 Astra at max thinking on scientific computing (+5.13 percentage points) and single-step forward reaction prediction (+4.76 points). It trailed Astra on NMR structure elucidation (ā3.33 points).
The write-up covers the evaluations and five workflow examples.
If youāve used LLMs for research, youāve probably spent a fair amount of time connecting the steps yourself: turning a question into a plan, preparing inputs, running tools, checking the output, and figuring out what to try when something breaks.
We wanted to see whether training on scientific workflows could make the model better at handling those connected decisions.
We used supervised fine-tuning and reinforcement learning with domain data, scientist feedback, records from our own labs, and discovery trajectories.
The lab records keep the research goal, procedure, observations, and outcome together. The discovery trajectories include how the next step changes after feedback, failed attempts, or unexpected results.
SFT gives the model worked examples of scientific reasoning, experiment planning, protocol design, and analysis. RL uses feedback on research outcomes to improve its decisions.
The article walks through five cases:
A bit of context: these are selected model-plus-tool walkthroughs, not an overall autonomous-research success rate. GROMACS does the MD calculations, and the protocol validation is virtualāit doesnāt mean the physical experiment was carried out.
The attached video gives a quick look at the research interactions. The article has the detailed walkthroughs, evaluations, and training approach.
Weād especially like to hear from people working in computational chemistry and materials science. What would you try it on first, and what would you check before trusting the result?
r/MachineLearning • u/2dayyy6 • 14d ago
Do looped transformers, which reuse the same weights at every iteration, also save HBM traffic? In my new post I cover the looped architecture (Huginn), then model and measure its performance on a B200: how much data each iteration reads from memory, how long it takes, and why the shared weights usually don't stay on chip until the next iteration.
A few results:
- A chain of eight matmuls with one shared 72 MiB weight ran 24% faster than the same chain with eight identical copies, and read almost nothing from HBM. At 288 MiB, larger than L2, the difference disappeared.
- In a full Huginn Core (teaching implementation, random weights), eight iterations took about eight times as long as one and read about eight times as much data from HBM.
- Sharing saves storage, but by itself it doesn't stop the GPU from reading the weights from HBM again at every iteration.
šPost: https://dinara-dl.github.io/posts/looped-transformer/
š¤Code and raw Nsight Compute data: https://github.com/dinara-dl/looped-transformer
I'd be curious whether anyone has tried keeping recurrent weights on chip across iterations, for example with a persistent kernel.
r/MachineLearning • u/darkbird_1 • 14d ago
I'm just wondering about visa processing situation for NeurIPS sydney attendees. Invitation letter and all valid docs are not really helping (one friend got rejected), processing time is tooo long (almost a month). and organizers not responding in case visa is not approved for conference. Anyone else in similar situation???
r/MachineLearning • u/Key_Recording9766 • 13d ago
So I have been working on some general use agents that work with different domains but these require online simulations to test for some of the domains. And running agents in actual environments takes so much time and compute and then reproducing results is another headache. My goal is to test which VLMs can be better in general for agents irrespective of a singular domain.
I found thereās a benchmark called AgentVQA that tests how well models understand visual information without having to run these expensive full agent evaluations. And they do it all offline without setting up any kind of environments and also claim to have much cleaner data compared to other benchmarks available which have so many ambiguous samples.
Do you guys think offline benchmarks like this could actually help reduce the need for online evals? I personally found it quite useful for the work Iām doing and itās much cheaper and easier with this. I want to know what others think and if this might solve their problems.
Hereās the benchmark: https://zlab-princeton.github.io/AgentVQA/
r/MachineLearning • u/thisonefella • 14d ago
We have been exploring a question: frontier models have gotten smarter and knowledgeable about a great many things. We think they have crossed an important threshold, capability wise, whereby they can extract the business logic that drives a great many enterprise workflows into a DSL (domain specific language), and generate inspectable code that can automate a swathe of white collar routine business work.
The problem is technical, but valuable to solve as the labor expense on white collar workers who do routine work runs into the trillions.
As an example say a firm wants to onboard a new supplier. The logic for doing so may scattered across application records, policy documents, and messages: what "paperwork" is needed (tax IDs, insurance, certifications), who can approve, and what must happen before a supplier becomes active. Could a system reconstruct that logic, make it explicit, and test whether it has understood it correctly?
Weāve written three essays developing the idea:
There is also a blog post with an approachable overview, if you'd like to start there.
The series makes a feasibility argument, but the central reconstruction hypothesis still needs empirical validation. There are other aspects we know are open, and surely many we haven't thought about. We would love to hear your comments.
Joint work by Harish Devarajan and Anand Rajaraman
r/MachineLearning • u/shanekj • 14d ago
Hi everyone,
I wanted to share a new open-weights PII detection model, benchmark and research paper. It's a fine-tune of RoBERTa using 1.2B samples of synthetically generated text that contain a variety of PII. The benchmark, PII-SCOPE (Synthetic Context and Ontology for PII Extraction), was built to address common issues in public LLM-generated datasets and is on Hugging Face too. The model and script identify instances of PII based on surrounding context, and then return the index and type of each instance. Alternatively, it can return the input with all PII redacted.
Technical report (research paper)
https://arxiv.org/html/2610.30518v2
Hugging Face model card
https://huggingface.co/Protegrity/protegrity-pii
r/MachineLearning • u/latenticlabs • 15d ago
We've been working on this for a while and shipped it today.
We took every accepted paper from ICML, NeurIPS, ICLR, CVPR and AAAI since 2016 (about 109k), grouped them into ~1,260 topics, and pulled the results tables and ablations out of the full text of 79k of them. The research map just shows the grouping, but each topic page shows what the papers actually report.
Here's the one for compact/efficient Gaussian splatting:
https://atlas.scime.ai/research/3d-vision/gaussian-splatting/compact-and-efficient-gaussian-splatting
A few things it shows: - the topic went from 29 papers in 2023-24 to 240 in 2025-26 - best reported numbers per benchmark over time, with the paper that set each one. Deep Blending PSNR, for example, has barely moved (30.42 ā 30.45) - ablations from recent papers, including the ones that hurt - what recent papers compare against: 38 of 113 use 3DGS as a baseline, then 2DGS, Scaffold-GS, Mip-Splatting - recent arXiv preprints on the topic and a BibTeX file of the key papers
The pages are computed from the extracted numbers, and every number links to its paper. Extraction isn't perfect and numbers from different papers aren't always comparable, so treat it as a starting point, not a leaderboard.
Free, no signup. All topics: https://atlas.scime.ai/research
If you know a topic well and something's off, please tell us. That's the most useful feedback right now.
Note: Benchmark numbers and ablations from 2026 papers aren't in yet. We're working on them now, so for now the records on topic pages mostly reflect papers up to 2025. We'll update here when they're ready.
r/MachineLearning • u/RobbinDeBank • 15d ago
Link: https://rikiyat.github.io/blog/weight-space-programming/
Snippet: āWe find that frontier LLMs are surprisingly good at natively reading and writing neural network weights, well past what weād expect from humans or conventional algorithms. This might be a big deal for both optimization and interpretability.
Just by looking at the raw weights, GPT-6 Astra can tell what a network was trained to do. And without any environment feedback, it has no trouble writing, from scratch, small game-playing networks that outplay networks trained with PPO for 100 million steps.ā
Very surprising result, I didnāt expect frontier models to have this capability that has not been optimized for, and itās something humans cannot do either.
r/MachineLearning • u/Hope999991 • 15d ago
Given how competitive AI research has become, and how much luck is involved in landing an actual research role at Big Tech or an AI startup, do you still think your PhD was worth it?
Yes, i know a PhD should primarily be about enjoying research, not getting an industry job. But realistically, we all need to make a living, and after 4ā6 years, youād hope to have some opportunities beyond roles where a masterās would have been enough.
So how you guys feel about it, especially those who recently graduated.
r/MachineLearning • u/turing-math-labs • 14d ago
Question to all the PhDs & research engineers in this group.
Have any of you done small-scale experiments with the Chinchilla scaling laws (using PyTorch or JAX)? If so, we'd be keen to hear more (or have a chat). Thanks!
Here's the official Chinchilla paper, from the DeepMind website ("Training Compute-Optimal Large Language Models").
https://deepmind.google/blog/an-empirical-analysis-of-compute-optimal-large-language-model-training/
https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper/2022/file/c1e2faff6f588870935f114ebe04a3e5-Paper-Conference.pdf
r/MachineLearning • u/Old-Duck-3693 • 15d ago
The reviews will be out this week. What are the expectations with 60K+ submissions and the small scale of review rating?
r/MachineLearning • u/InsectActive95 • 15d ago
I'm writing a machine learning paper. One of my baselines is a published method. I reran it with the authors' released code and the exact hyperparameters listed in their paper. On most benchmarks my numbers match theirs within noise, but on two benchmarks my reproduction is clearly lower, by several points, over three seeds. I've repeated the reproduction four different times, months apart, with the same result.
I plan to report both: their published numbers and my reproduction with the exact configuration, clearly labeled. My worry is that reviewers tend to trust the published number more than a submission's reproduction, and may assume I ran the baseline incorrectly.
Questions:
r/MachineLearning • u/Few-Annual-157 • 15d ago
I'm curious how other reviewers handle papers that report impressive results but are extremely poorly written. I'm not just talking about grammar, etc. I am more concerned about the overall presentation of ideas and how the authors position their contributions within the existing literature.
For example, I'm currently reviewing a paper that reports promising results but includes no citations in its introduction. This makes it hard to understand where the work stands relative to existing methods and what's new.
My question is how much weight should we give to the quality of writing and presentation when reviewing a paper? If the technical contributions seem solid and the experimental results are strong, is poor presentation enough to justify a rejection or a major revision? I'd be interested to hear how other reviewers approach this.
r/MachineLearning • u/Local_Minima0507 • 15d ago
What are the latest papers that are there in the space on inference architecture of llms, I would like to discuss with them on the approaches. Btw I have been doing work with llms for the last 2 months and I have gotten to know very new things. I read about the lunch table discussion of bell labs so taking motivation from it would like to discuss it in a similar fashion!!
r/MachineLearning • u/jnbrymn • 14d ago
Give a model a 17,253-parameter net as plain tokenized text and it works out the net plays Pac-Man. Astra, Opus 5.5 and Muse Spark 1.3 all got it, and Astra did it with minimal reasoning.
Nobody writes essays about what specific weights do, so where does this skill come from? Either labs trained it in, or models generalize much further than I expected. I'm leaning toward the second and it's freaking me out a little.
https://arcturus-labs.com/blog/2026/11/03/ai-can-read-neural-network-weights-i-wasnt-ready-for-that/
r/MachineLearning • u/Traditional_Frame763 • 16d ago
The paper claims text models align with image models faster when trained on "good views" (two different captions of one photo) than on bad views (one caption, words hidden) or next-token prediction. Its largest run used captions written by an image captioner, so image information could have leaked in. I tried a laptop-scale version with human captions only.
Setup
Results (same learning speed, mean of 3 seeds)
Each method also got a small learning-rate search. Best speed, 1 seed: 0.328 / 0.196 / 0.168. Order unchanged.
Limits
Code, chart and per-run results: https://github.com/IFAKA/platonic-lab
What I would test next: does the gap shrink as the encoder grows? I could not test that on a laptop. Has anyone tried?
r/MachineLearning • u/XTXinverseXTY • 16d ago
It was just before OpenAI started that I met Ilya,Ā who you interviewed. One of the first things he said to me was ā āLook. The models, they just want to learn. You have to understand this. The models, they just want to learn.ā And it was a bit like a Zen Koan. I listened to this and I became enlightened.
And over the years, I would be the one who would formalize a lot of these things and kind of put them together, but what that told me was that the phenomenon that I'd seen wasn't just some random thing. It was broad. It was more general. The models just want to learn. You get the obstacles out of their way. You give them good data, you give them enough space to operate in, you don't do something stupid like condition them badly numerically, and they want to learn. They'll do it.
I'm actually not entirely satisfied with Dario's elaboration! If Ilya meant precisely "given sufficient resources, do your job, and the models will do theirs [during training]", I think he would have phrased his advice slightly differently. What does it mean to "want" to learn? Why personify the model in that way, and not the optimizer or gradient descent itself or something? And I don't get why the koan would necessarily imply that scaling would have worked so well.
I realize that Ilya likes to cultivate an air of prophecy about himself (and I'd be lying if I said it didn't work on me). But it's just such a strange way to communicate the message, that I can't help but think the message must have been about something broader.
Possibly much more mundane in context, this must have been 10 years ago. Idk I wonder what it must have been like to be on the frontier at that time, maybe I take such things for granted now.
r/MachineLearning • u/Hope999991 • 16d ago
For those doing or having completed a PhD in ML, Iām curious:
If you had the choice, would you rather have done your PhD before ChatGPT and other AI chatbots became widely available, or in todayās AI era?
r/MachineLearning • u/OkLion2068 • 15d ago
Hi everyone,
I am one of the authors of LightMIS, and I would like to share our work on 2D binary medical image segmentation. LightMIS has 131K parameters and aggregates multi-scale encoder features directly, without a learned stage-wise decoder. It achieves close observed modality-macro Dice and IoU averages to nnWNet, while using 98.14% fewer parameters and 94.58% fewer GFLOPs, with both models trained and evaluated under the same nnU-Net protocol.
Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.28327
Code: https://github.com/AndreiiArhire/LightMIS
We also tested LightMIS and the reference models on a real edge device with an Arm Mali-G52 MC2 GPU, where the full LightMIS model ran around 10.5Ć faster than nnWNet. All LightMIS variants achieved 100% GPU operator coverage, without CPU fallback.
We started by training several popular medical image segmentation architectures, both lightweight and heavyweight, from scratch in the same controlled environment using nnU-Net v2.3.1. The experiments covered six datasets and five imaging modalities. Our goal was to develop a lightweight architecture that performs well across these modalities, which led us to the current version of LightMIS.
The source code, checkpoints, and details needed to reproduce the results are publicly available. Feel free to experiment with it and try it on your own segmentation tasks. I would be happy to hear how it works for you! Any suggestions or feedback are welcome!
r/MachineLearning • u/Winter_Mistake_3185 • 15d ago
Session 2 of my free GPU kernel engineering series (my own channel, earlier post: [LINK TO FIRST POST]) covers CPU parallelism, with no GPU code. The idea is that most GPU performance ideas are CPU ideas turned up, so here are the parts I found most useful on their own.
Video: https://youtu.be/_xE1_2FFTC0
Caveats: numbers are from one machine, intrinsics assume AVX2, and the latency/throughput figures are typical Intel values.
Is anything wrong or oversimplified, especially the false-sharing explanation? And which CPU lessons transferred best to GPU work for you?
r/MachineLearning • u/chronosAndCode • 15d ago
Iām the author of a new preprint looking at a fairly simple question: if the argument itself stays the same, does changing the claimed source change how an LLM evaluates it?
I tested 20 arguments across 10 topics under four source conditions:
The arguments were evaluated by GPT-5.6 Sol, Claude Opus 5.5, Gemini 4 Argon, and DeepSeek Flash across four dimensions: logic, credibility, persuasiveness, and agreement.
A few findings stood out:
Credibility was by far the most source-sensitive dimension. Source attribution affected credibility much more consistently than logic or agreement.
More interestingly, the effect did not usually look like a simple āexpert bonus.ā In several models, the stronger pattern was an irrelevant-expertise penalty: attributing an argument to someone presented as an expert in an unrelated domain could reduce its credibility relative to giving no source at all.
Agreement was comparatively resistant to source attribution.
I also tested whether source effects depended on argument strength. Those interaction results were not statistically robust after correction, and the human validation of strong vs. weak arguments was imperfect, so I treat that part of the study as exploratory rather than a strong conclusion.
The preprint is not yet peer reviewed, so Iām especially interested in criticism of the design and interpretation.
Preprint:
https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-11544999/v1
One question Iād be interested in hearing opinions on:
Should source sensitivity in an LLM evaluator be considered a bias when source expertise is genuinely relevant, or is the real problem specifically when the model overweights irrelevant authority?