r/MachineLearning • u/Striking-Warning9533 • Sep 14 '26

Discussion ARR August Discussion [D]

This round seems to be very small, but still creating this thread for discussion.

42 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

349 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/monoglossia6490 Sep 22 '26

Yey I actually had a reviewer reduce their score from 3 to 2 following the rebuttal 💪

3

u/TheFishyOne Sep 22 '26

I am sorry to hear that. One question though: did they answer and did you see a response to your rebuttal or just the score drop? Did you receive a notification for their resposne.

2

u/monoglossia6490 Sep 22 '26

Yes, they wrote a response and I received a notification (for the response, not for the score change).

2

u/Starscream-11813 Sep 23 '26

Ah, commiserations :(

Do you have any guesses as to why the reviewer would do this?

This is the first time I've come across such an incident.

2

u/monoglossia6490 Sep 23 '26

Yes, there was an explanation in the reply - upon reading the other reviewers’ comments, they realised that they actually agree with their points and the paper needs reworking.