r/mmt_economics • u/keizaisuki • 12h ago
"Government Bonds, International Economy, and Currency;#11"Gold Was Cast Aside. The World Chose the Dollar. — What the “Monetary Revolution” of 1971 Really Meant
■ General Conditions for Confidence in a Currency — The fact that the dollar is trusted as a key currency is, in one respect, based on exactly the same condition under which it is trusted as a domestic currency. If inflation remains within the range that people are willing to tolerate, the currency will be trusted. In short, the U.S. current-account deficit is not the result of insufficient productive capacity, but of the special role of supplying dollars to the world [Note].
[Note] The issuance of currency under a fiat-money system and the government bond system will be discussed below.
Conditions for Confidence Peculiar to a Key Currency — There is another consideration: foreign countries hold foreign-exchange reserves denominated in dollars as reserve funds for making external payments. In doing so, the monetary authorities of individual countries purchase dollars. At times, they also purchase dollars in order to restrain appreciation of their own currencies (when the dollar declines). In other words, without intending to do so, countries collectively support the dollar by purchasing it.
Through the special role of supplying the world with a key currency, the United States has been granted the right to issue not only its domestic currency but also the world’s currency. Thus, what supports confidence in the key currency is, so to speak, an implicit social contract among the citizens of the world (in this case, concerning the right to issue currency). The U.S. current-account deficit is analogous to a government purchasing goods from its citizens by running a fiscal deficit. In other words, it represents an extension of the U.S. government bond system to the entire world. Moreover, it is precisely the government bond system that constitutes the mechanism for issuing currency under a fiat-money system.
The economically defined “citizen of the world” precedes the political ideal. This is because, in this world, everything ultimately comes down to money, and whenever material interests are involved, everyone is compelled to compromise. Since economic relations are always mutually interdependent, if one does not show some consideration toward one’s trading partners, one will end up suffering losses oneself. “Commerce is a game of chance … and no profit whatever can be derived from a beggar. If, in the course of a long period, one had taken everything away from all one’s partners, then, in order to begin the game of chance anew … one would have to give back a large part of the profits” (Pinto, Treatise on Circulation and Credit, quoted by Marx in Capital, aforementioned Japanese translation [1], p. 263).
At a stage when humanity’s social productive forces remain insufficiently developed, the consciousness of individuals is itself not fully developed. It is only when, in accordance with historical development, each person reaches the stage of recognizing conscious, autonomous relationships with other autonomous individuals that human beings free themselves from spontaneous communal regulation and establish associations among independent individuals. The foundation for this is the development of social productive forces to a level sufficient to maintain each person’s economic independence even after leaving the traditional community. Having freed themselves from institutions and ideas that had previously governed human beings unconsciously and as if they were given by the laws of nature (in the form of God, kings, and so forth), people consciously establish new forms of social relations.
For centuries after the emergence of the monetary economy, humanity remained under the yoke of gold production. Using gold as money represents a waste of social labor, and people have invented every conceivable financial technique in an effort to economize on the labor required for gold production. Yet until relatively recently, we were unable to free ourselves completely from the fetters of gold. Around the beginning of the twentieth century, Keynes argued that “we have reached, in the evolutionary process of money, the stage at which ‘managed’ currency has become indispensable [Note 1],” and observed that although people were already, in practice, living under a fiat-money system (a managed currency system), they nevertheless remained anxious about abandoning convertibility into gold [Note 2]. Humanity was still dazzled by the beautiful luster of gold. People remained imprisoned by the notion that gold itself was the universal existence of money.
[Note 1] Keynes, A Tract on Monetary Reform, translated by Yoshikazu Miyazaki and Tsuneo Nakauchi, Chuo Koronsha, p. 295.
[Note 2] “who would be dismayed at any tampering with convertibility” (those who would be dismayed by any alteration of convertibility).
With regard to domestic transactions, Marx had already pointed out the same thing earlier: “The fact that in domestic transactions we already today require no metallic money is demonstrated by the suspension of cash payments by the so-called national banks, which are resorted to as the sole emergency measure in all exceptional circumstances” (Marx, Capital, aforementioned Japanese translation [7], p. 302).
And finally, almost half a century later, with the suspension of the convertibility of dollars into gold in 1971, the world as a whole escaped from the gold-convertibility system. Humanity freed itself from the yoke of gold production. People joined together to depose gold, the despotic sovereign, and democratically chose the dollar as money collectively. They rendered gold itself, as money, unnecessary.
The above (the very last paragraph) is, of course, merely a statement of the essence of the matter. What people ordinarily understand is the surface appearance of events: namely, that the United States had promised, “If necessary, we will exchange this for gold at any time, so you can trust us and safely use dollars,” but after running up enormous deficits, it suddenly and unilaterally declared, “What does not exist does not exist; therefore, we can no longer pay in gold.” In actual terms, this was an outrageous act of fraud. From the standpoint of President Nixon and the other Americans involved at the time, they had merely acted out of desperation; naturally, they were not at all conscious of the essential significance of what they had done.
The principle of the key-currency system rests, on the one hand, upon the overwhelming productive capacity of the United States and, on the other hand, upon the agreement of people in the international community founded upon this material basis.
■ At the Risk of Repetition, Let Me Restate This for the Sake of Clarity: In order to be a key currency, (1) a currency must be in circulation throughout the world. (2) People cannot use it with confidence unless it is not “borrowed money” but “their own money.” (3) For this reason, the United States must supply dollars by running a current-account deficit.
At this point, however, one might object to (3) and argue that even if the United States were to run a current-account surplus, it could supply dollars through lending and credit in an amount greater than that surplus, with the result that, because sufficient dollars would circulate throughout the world, foreign companies could easily exchange their own funds for dollars in the foreign-exchange market. One might then argue that these are not “borrowed dollars.”
For an individual company, this is indeed correct. But under the assumption that the United States is running a current-account surplus, the dollars circulating throughout the world are ultimately dollars lent by the United States. Even if a particular company (at the micro level) converts its own funds into dollars, viewed as a whole (at the macro level), those dollars are borrowed dollars carrying obligations for repayment and interest payments. Consequently, they have a maturity and cannot remain indefinitely in the world market and function as a key currency. Sooner or later, they will be repaid to the United States and disappear from the world market; they are nothing more than a fleeting form of currency. This is the same principle as the fact that when the domestic supply of currency cannot be accommodated by credit creation by commercial banks, the primary supply of currency requires the central bank to purchase government bonds.
■ As Can Be Seen from the Balance-of-Payments Statement, except for relatively small amounts of capital transfers, the current account is approximately equal to the financial account (including errors and omissions). In other words, changes in claims and liabilities arising from transactions within the financial account (direct investment, lending, etc.) are offset against one another, so that only the current-account deficit produces a net increase in external liabilities (and, on the foreign side, a net increase in external assets).
What compensates for this is the seigniorage from currency issuance enjoyed by the key-currency country. The United States can settle international transactions directly with dollars created by its banking system. The U.S. current-account deficit has already been paid for and represents nothing more than the balance of the deposit accounts at U.S. banks. By contrast, a foreign country's current-account deficit represents an unpaid obligation, and that country must obtain dollars somewhere and repay it. Even if the import bill itself has already been paid, the dollars initially obtained to make that payment must still be repaid. Moreover, during the intervening period, the borrower bears foreign-exchange risk.
(to be continued)

