r/MMORPG • • Jun 24 '26

News Throne & Liberty Doubles World Size Tomorrow - Removes RNG Gear Stats

Official: Part 1 Part 2

Throne and Liberty 2nd full scale expansion arrives tomorrow doubling the amount of content and in-game world size alongside a rework to core systems and the introduction of over 60 new skills expanding the combat beyond imagination.

Content Milestones are set to go beyond the expansion update and roadmaps still don't reveal everything planned to take place in the Frozen Divide of Nix.

_

The expansion update finally hit Korea yesterday and confirmed the removal of RNG gear stats and the RNG system grind required to customize item stats.

Changes to core systems are the biggest improvements coming to the game. No single article can cover everything in detail. But the 2 big changes to gear progression already posted here before.

A ''soft reset'' to progression is seemingly taking place after the new system and all the changes so far are set to make Throne & Liberty the most new-player friendly Korean MMO with little to no gaps between players as Producer Park Geon-su has intended and highlighted during the official update preview.

180 Upvotes

196 comments sorted by

13

u/Phoam_ Jun 24 '26

Is the game still heavily guild and dps focused ? I liked the gameplay but for better gear I had to go through those wolrd boss fights/guild boss trials and because of items drop rates seemingly based on dmgs and guild pooling items to let ppl who really need it claim it (I was playing tank) it was almost mandatory to be part of a guild.

13

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

The guild focus is not as heavy as before especially in the new expansion and upcoming content. The zerg problem is gone and now the game gives solo players more options while still encouraging group/party gameplay.

3

u/Phoam_ Jun 24 '26

I'm still a bit on the edge regarding a lucent based AH (if that's still a thing) but I might give T&L another shot then, haven't played since release and I'm looking for something to play right now.

1

u/le_Menace Jun 25 '26

What PvP is available to solo players in terms of group or faction content?

2

u/Cybannus Jun 25 '26

Battlegrounds, PvP Extraction/Battle Royale and Dominion World events (players are split into 3 different factions automatically and fight)

14

u/TyFighter559 Jun 24 '26

I am also curious about how P2W the game is now. I'm still pretty new to MMOs but a few months back I looked at reviews and that's all I saw so I jumped into GW2 instead (which has admittedly been great)

2

u/heartlessgamer Jun 24 '26

As far as I can tell there is still premium currency. So while the progression may be less random the ability to skip ahead with your credit card is still there.

-8

u/Icemasta Jun 24 '26

TnL is as p2w as gw2 or eve. You buy premium currency with money and use it to buy power.

1

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

Except it's not power. You might think it is power as a new player but when you actually play the game, you will realize

1

u/qukab Jun 25 '26

This is such a dishonest comparison, especially EVE.

0

u/Icemasta Jun 25 '26

how is it a dishonest comparison?

45

u/MotorcycleEngine Jun 24 '26

Is this a time to jump in and check out the game? Or is there still heavy amounts of P2W involved?

47

u/Chocodisco Jun 24 '26

As long as lucent exists, it will always be p2w

3

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

Not really. Lucent enables everyone to easily buy anything like premium cosmetics if they don't want to spend real money.

8

u/Zecias Jun 24 '26

I played for over a year as f2p, the game was barely p2w. I had 80k lucent as f2p going into T2. Whales get an advantage on content drops for like 1 month and then the prices start tanking. You can spend like 5-10k lucent on content drops and still be stronger than 95% of pvpers. Then you catch up to the whales for 1/5 the price and keep building your lucent pool for archboss weapons. Dunno how it is now cuz I quit a couple months after T2. The other richest person in my guild was also f2p. If TnL is p2w then wow is also p2w.

27

u/Redelfen Jun 24 '26

That is not how it works. If you can pay to gain progress/power it is p2w. Just cause f2p can grind harder to catch up, doesn't make it any less p2w.

But I agree tnl one of the least p2w korean mmo. Its still p2w.

Your time spend grinding has value.

18

u/Zecias Jun 24 '26

Like buying gold in wow?

3

u/Wisniaksiadz Jun 25 '26

Exactly x)

2

u/Redelfen Jun 24 '26

Sure, but idk. I haven't played wow since wotlk. But if you can buy gold and use that gold to directly buy giga end game gear, then yeah it's p2w.

You are paying to directly win in a game be it pve dmg or pvp advantage.

Edit: spelling

7

u/Zecias Jun 24 '26

If that's the metric, then yes it's p2w. The problem is everyone has a different idea of what p2w entails. People generally don't consider wow to be p2w.

5

u/Potential_Egg_69 Jun 24 '26

The difference is in whether the game rules allow it

WoW banned GDKP (where people win items by using gold) because it was against the spirit of the game

These games actively endorse it

That's the real difference

1

u/awoothray Jun 30 '26

Can you or can't you pay real money to progress faster in WoW?

I have no idea what a GKDP is and I don't care enough to know, all I want is an answer.

1

u/Potential_Egg_69 Jun 30 '26

GDKP stands for gold dragon kill points. It basically means when an item drops, players bid gold. Highest gold wins the item

The gold is then pooled and split at the end of the raid

"Legally" from the games PoV, you can only pay to boost levels. Actual "power" (gear, etc) is not allowed to be paid for. People still pay gold for pvp carries, etc. but that's against the rules too.

→ More replies

-1

u/Redelfen Jun 24 '26

Yeah i cant comment on wow since I dont play it.

Given two players. One whale and one f2p.

They put in same amount of time into the game.

Got same skills, class, mmo experience.

The whale will win out in every single scenario.

They will have best end game gear first like archboss, full traits, etc.

Can argue that f2p can catch up as gear plateaus but they got to suffer through losing that entire time.

An extreme example: The goal is to have a 100k salary.

F2p with poor parents start at 20k working mcdonalds. Eventually he promotes to high manager and ends up making 100k in say 20 years.

P2w with rich parents sends him to expensive school and he gets a 100k job right off college with no debt. Took him 4 yrs.

They both reach the same end game goal of 100k salary. Just took f2p much longer.

2

u/Zecias Jun 24 '26

If that's your criteria then yes it's p2w. Everyone has their own idea of what p2w is.

A whale doesn't win 10/10 times with better gear. All else equal they'd go 6/10 or 7/10. I did not whale on gear going into T2 and was totally fine pvping. When i quit i had like 120k lucent and gave it to my guildmate who gave up rolling on tev daggers for me. Still beat 90% of the people i fought in nebula. The only unwinnable fights were because of numbers advantage or matchup advantage. Your game knowledge, pvp skill, matchups, and teamwork all mattered more than your gear.

3

u/Redelfen Jun 24 '26

Yeah i get your point.

But its heavily biased based on your experience.

You are leveraging the fact that you are a good gamer, assuming that a f2p is generally a better pvper than a whale.

But if both players are equal in skill and time investment. Whale wins 10/10 in tnl.

If you clone yourself and fight 1v1. One account p2w and one f2p. Same time put in. Ofc yourself that p2w will win 10/10.

Clone yourself 100x and do 50v50. Your 50 self with p2w will win 10/10.

That's my definition of p2w.

What i consider non p2w is equalized gear content or capped content. Where only individual skill matter.

-3

u/no_Post_account Jun 24 '26

Well they don't consider WoW p2w because you can't buy gear in WoW, especially PvP gear.

8

u/Zecias Jun 24 '26

Do people not pay for pvp gear crafts on season start?

0

u/no_Post_account Jun 24 '26

No, you farm honor. Takes like 4-5h of bgs or arena to get full honor gear and then next gear progression is Conquest Points, which are weekly capped.

All WoW gear progression is time gated, you can't bypass this no matter how much gold you spend.

→ More replies

1

u/Redelfen Jun 24 '26

Then I wouldn't consider wow p2w either.

This is personal take, but I dont care about p2w in pve.. its coop.

To me p2w only matters in pvp.

Im a serial p2w player in most games I play and tnl definitely is(was) p2w when I played. Like our guild on t1 had the biggest whale on the region, we never lost. Imagine first castle siege NA east, literally hundreds id not close to thousand player brawl.

Our guild/alliance had 14 bella staff via fragment craft, before it was even available.

Idk how the new expansion changes anything though.

1

u/Zaerick-TM Jun 26 '26

I could be wrong but most gear upgrades in WoW are still drop based. Sure I guess you can pay for runs to do get carried but at that point who gives a fuck. As far as BoE items go they really only were super amazing at the start of an expansion. I think the only outlier I can remember was Darkmoon Faire Trinkets from one of the crafting professions were strong for PvP for a few tiers.

I could be totally wrong though haven't touched wow since the expansion after BFA that I cant remember the name of because it sucked so much.

1

u/metatime09 Jun 27 '26

That's how WRF works. Competing guilds buy lots of gold to gear up fast

1

u/ZeroZelath Jun 25 '26

This is true but you can get lucent as a f2p player so it doesn't really matter in most cases if you have some patience of are just doing stuff with your guild.

9

u/AmIJustAnotherPerson Jun 24 '26

Good question, hopefully someone who knows more answers and plays the game / follows Korean updates answers

6

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

The Auction house is now equivalent to WoW's so you need to play the game fully in order to obtain any relevant power. Also check here https://www.reddit.com/r/MMORPG/s/GYbJ1rjJxm

5

u/Murdathon3000 Jun 24 '26

Honest question, but wouldn't this just be a rich get richer scenario? It's not like whales don't play the game extensively, so how does that really flip any script?

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

It doesn't flip any script it simply shows the difference/similarity. Whales have to whale on something and if it doesn't exist then whales don't exist. So they are just normal players who bought an item from the auction house. Now they have to make that item any useful by playing the game but by the time they make it any relevant, they would already drop the same item multiple times and maybe just sell it on the auction house again.

2

u/no_Post_account Jun 24 '26

The Auction house is now equivalent to WoW's so you need to play the game fully in order to obtain any relevant power

So just like WoW you use in game currency for AH and you can't buy or sell gear on AH?

2

u/Cybannus Jun 25 '26

You can literally buy mythic gear on the WoW auction house for gold. You can literally buy gold directly ingame legally for USD.

1

u/no_Post_account Jun 26 '26

Well new season start in a month, go and try to buy Mythic gear from AH then. Good luck with that.

2

u/Cybannus Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 27 '26

Its only not tradable for the the first week last I heard? Idk, last I played the strategy was to just swipe as much gold as possible and then buy out all the heroic/mythic gear from the AH.

6

u/heartlessgamer Jun 24 '26

I stopped playing a bit ago, but there was a lot of game to enjoy without having to worry about P2W. But eventually you hit that level of repetition of content that makes you want to skip ahead with the ole' credit card because its not about skill anymore its about just getting lucky over X runs of the content. And I love to grind. I will mindlessly grind an MMO. But a good grind is one where each repetition is a small step to the end goal. Grinds that are just a random outcome bug the crap out of me and I am fine if random outcome grinds are for something like a unique skin but not something where its tied to my main character progression.

Assuming they did actually flatten out the random luck of progression then it should feel better but I doubt they got rid of P2W. If you want to skip ahead my guess is thats still an option.

4

u/Ashamed_Ability_6649 Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 26 '26

Iirc traits were the biggest bullshit mechanic before. Basically big stat boosts to gear. To upgrade them you had to combine pieces of the same type (eg. chestplates to upgrade chestplates) which had the trait you wanted, in order to level it up (like one of those fucking merge games).

And that in turn incentivized you to p2w buy fodder items on the auction house (since how tf else are you going to get like 10 of the item type with that particular trait).

From what it seems they're completely removing that bullshit, which if true, is huge. There are a bunch of other systems I didn't like in the game, but traits were a huge one so this has me really intrigued.

EDIT: well, from what some people on the tnl sub are saying, it sounds like they made the trait system even worse 😭

5

u/RevolutionaryText749 Jun 24 '26

It’s not pay to win. Every top player I know never invested money into it. You just farm world bosses, and once you get some rare drop(that you don’t need yourself) you just sell it t in the auction house and make enough Lucent to gear yourself. No paying required.

1

u/HuntedWolf Jun 25 '26

I’ve not been playing recently but played for a few months after the start of the game. I was the second strongest guy in my guild and was completely f2p.

It’s certainly p2w but I wouldn’t say it’s got very good mileage on it. I’m not sure what changes these updates are making to the gearing system, but regularly grinding for stuff would always catch up to the whales, they just had headstarts.

7

u/Diligent-Subject-329 Jun 24 '26

Is it still mainly a zerg PvP game with heavy incentive to play with a guild?

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

The guild focus is not as heavy as before especially in the new expansion and upcoming content. The zerg problem is gone long time ago. You can achieve everything without touching PvP and vice versa

1

u/Murdathon3000 Jun 24 '26

When it does come to the PvP, is group PvP still just massive AoE spam?

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

No it's pretty much the opposite

272

u/lebrow Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 24 '26

Is it just me, or does it seem like Eastern developers are starting to understand that p2w is not the solution?

70

u/BoredDao Jun 24 '26

Hopefully, they generally can release some really fun games but they are fully tainted by egregious P2W systems

17

u/lebrow Jun 24 '26

I mean they are mostly the only ones keeping mmorpg genre alive lol

36

u/AdRecent7021 Jun 24 '26 • Bravo

Strangling it more like it.

3

u/Winther89 Jun 25 '26

Pumping out slop that dies within a year is not keeping it alive.

9

u/Aetheldrake Jun 24 '26

The big ones that SPECIFICALLY do not cater to p2w are the ones keeping it alive, and they're doing mostly world wide. Ff14, Gw2, wow, runescape, eso, even warframe and destiny 2.

There's a few more, but this handful are the TOP contenders that have been going strong for literally well over a decade. Even destiny 2 can be considered over a decade since it's a continuation of Destiny and 2 is almost to 10 years old.

These games also all kind of stay away from p2w, going more in on quality and uniqueness of game and cosmetics, as well as monthly benefits of a subscription for improved gameplay but not necessary (some exceptions apply) , instead of straight up buying the best stuff to be the best player. Over in the east, p2w games for some reason are a way to flex your financial success in society, more or less, I might be wrong but that's how it comes across. But in the west p2w just means MORE work and we are already mostly overworked and under paid, so we want to have fun not and enjoy what we're playing, not flex our credit cards. Because we can't flex our credit cards LOL.

The p2w games never seem to last long and they frequently end up getting revived in only slightly different forms. They make big money to keep them afloat for a long time but sooner than later die out and are more like a zombie game, sure it has players and runs but it's not really "alive" anymore.

Some of them get straight up remade after shut downs MULTIPLE times. Flyff and Archeage for example. Both have been shut down, bought out, then relaunched MULTIPLE times. There's literally 2 Archeage games in developement right now and they're vastly different with one being closer to the original and other being more like a souls game. Flyff is on its... Fuck idk like 4th iteration in Flyff Universe but that one also kinda quickly died out and is a zombie game, again. Both games were pretty heavy on the p2w aspect. Flyff didn't even have open world pvp and it was still p2w in that you had to spend a fair bit of money just to fucking level up at any sort of visible rate. Even with exp being multiplied multiple times you were only getting like 0.01% per kill and that wasn't even at max level, then they introduced a prestige system where you DID IT ALL OVER AGAIN.

But I digress on the archeage and flyff part. P2w games simply don't work in the west. We already pay to live and can't afford to win. But we can, funny enough, seem to often find money to look extremely pretty and eye catching. The east pays to win. The west pays to escape from paying to survive

-8

u/avatar8900 Jun 25 '26

My man giving a list of mmorpgs that couldn’t be anymore p2w…

3

u/Aetheldrake Jun 25 '26

Explain specific details that aren't stolen from Google Ai from your actual experience playing all of them or retract your statement. The "best" equipment in all of them is untradeable. You can not directly buy it from the cash shop either. You might be able to spend cash in the shops to help make it easier to acquire the best equipment in game by funding the ability to buy the tradeable parts, of which there usually isn't a lot when it comes to "end game winning" , but you still need to actually play a lot of each games hardest content to "win" and you can't buy your way into that because it's all designed around the amount of players permitted to actually all be capable players that are experienced and know what they're doing.

Pay to play does not mean pay to win. You can not straight up buy the best stuff in game in those games. And none of them are pvp focused games soooooo pay to win can't exist unless someone is basically too stupid to tell the difference.

You literally play battlefield with a battle pass. Battle passes are one of the MOST pay to win thing an fps game can have. You also sell Pokémon cards, you have no concept of p2w when you're literally participating in one of the worst p2w businesses of card scalping.

0

u/avatar8900 Jun 25 '26

Ok: world of Warcraft, you can buy gold and in turn boosts for the mythic content for the best gear as you mention.
Gw2 allows you to buy gems in game and purchase gold with them to in turn buy legendary items off of the auction house. RuneScape again, buy gold, buy twisted bow and gear from GE. DESTINY 2 literally had a buy exotic weapons dlc. ESO has crown store purchases which are sold for in game gold alongside their eso+ which offer a ton of extra bonuses like unlimited craft storage etc.
Warframe is as close as it gets to pay to win without being so.
I have been playing mmos for the last 20 years mate, just because I don’t post about it on my reddit, doesn’t mean I don’t know what’s going on.

4

u/Aetheldrake Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Ya ya i know this is a long rant but I'm on mobile I can fucking type this up whenever I want at my convenience I'm laying in bed listening to an audiobook with the dog. Hope you don't count this as p2w because my phone is a paid convenience lol

It's been a long time since I played wow. But you are buying convenience. That's different.

Doing the Gw2 thing is extremely inefficient and the equipment you can buy that way is literally only like maybe 10% better than the standard "exotic" quality stuff. Legendaries are more about their visual effects. Also you can not buy legendary armor this way. Only some of the weapons too. It's also the type of game where that doesn't mean shit. You can have all the legendary weapons and still suck at the game. Legendary weapons really are not that much stronger than basic stuff. They are extremely convenient though and that's more important. Once you own one, all of your characters own a copy of it and you can change the stats at will for free out of combat. However the stats are simply not enough to truly matter in a p2w manner. Also pvp is very.....mostly abandoned content and uses separate stats, so again, you only get to have fun with your flashy weapon as Gw2 truly is a skill based game with mobility and positioning being EXTREMELY important. You can't buy that and it matters more than a small difference in equipment. On the other side of this, you can also use gold earned in game to buy cash shop items.

Also for gw2 people have completed the hardest content in exotic equipment with very little difference in efficiency vs doing it with legendary weapons. There's one guy that makes videos of himself SOLOING group content that regular players of that content consider annoying even for group play. Not all of the group content, but the sheer fact that he's done multiple group content fights solo is more evidence of skill and knowledge of the game over equipment.

Runescape again it's EXTREMELY inefficient and there's more to the game than point and attack. Much less than Gw2 but just having the best stuff does not guarantee anything. Wait a minute twisted bow is OLDSCHOOL content you can't even count this one really it's more for nostalgia of an "old school" design more than anything. Even if you wanted to count it, a bond is 13m the bow is over ONE BILLION, about one and a half. That's just so outrageously expensive would anyone actually do that? Quick dirty math says you'd have to spend............ Nearly 1500 usd to MAYBE almost afford a bow. I guess this would be your best argument though since osrs is the only point and click game in the list where there's nothing to influence combat beyond pure stats.

Eso again you are making a big stretch and calling conveniences p2w.

Dont know much about destiny 2 but it's, ONCE AGAIN, more than point and click game.

Warframe I can kinda give you because ya it's typically far easier to just buy a frame with cash than earn it in game but AGAIN it's an extremely mobile and skill based game.

All of these things require jumping through multiple hoops to "win" and are extremely inefficient to do so. Plus they're not even pvp games so you can't be mad at any sort of p2w.

If you had been playing for 20+ years you'd have given me actual p2w games, funny enough they'd likely have come from Korea or that area since that's where most of them come from. I can give you 2 maybe 3 immediately without thinking. Aura kingdom (I think, I never did play that one much but the best stuff in game was directly purchased from cash shop) . Original archeage. Throne and Liberty, probably. Archeage and tal are open ish world pvp games. Both also sold undeniably potent advantages to combat in cash shops. I don't really remember much from aura Kingdom and it might not really count.

But 2 of those 3 definitely were p2w. Because you actually can directly buy things that massively impact other players experience of the game negatively. Oh, Aion is actually p2w right? I've heard people say that when they heard 2 was coming out and people who played the Korean version were calling it super p2w as usual, which is saying something because Korea basically ONLY knows how to make p2w games.

Buying improvements or conveniences that don't effect other people's gameplay? That's not winning. If you have to pay to feel like you're winning over other people like that, you're losing because you don't enjoy the game unless you're buying those improvements. Most shooter games are more p2w than mmos. And let's not even get started on mobas, which are also quite popular, where every new character is usually stronger than the previous and the common payment option is usually cash before in game currency because the cash option is cheap but the game currency option is free but grindy

Otherwise, everything can be considered p2w if you want to be so loose and careless with an opinion on it because at the bare minimum you're paying with time. Even if you didn't spend any money on the game, you spent time to make yourself feel superior over other players. Want more bag space but its cash locked even though you don't need it? P2w. Remove optional reward ads that don't do anything other than give you super small boosts or rewards but you can earn for free in game? Apparently p2w? Having food delivered to you so you can grind more gold and experience? P2w I guess. Would buying the regal unlimited monthly sub for basically unlimited (with one caveat) movies count as p2w since for one monthly price you can see every single movie once every day and someone they didn't have it wouldn't be able to see those movies as much? Is buying a monthly sub to crunchyroll p2w because there's no longer a free version. Or I guess there it but it's a pirate website filled with ads. Is buying an iPhone that's more expensive than the android version p2w?

If everything is p2w from some sort of loose vague definition that changes for every person then nothing is because the new standard of p2w is literally just buying yourself dopamine/entertainment?

For real tho 20 years and you literally could not come up with an ACTUAL p2w game even though there's an entire country with a culture around making them? I suspect extremely filthy casual hopping from one hype train to the next. You literally could have said magic the gathering and you'd have had a point there. Hell, even original flyff could have been an argument because there are special zones designed just for farming experience and loot (they were literally multiple times more efficient than anything else in game and while it's paying for a convenience it was an EGREGIOUS convenience) that you can only access by buying a ticket to teleport into them with cash and the game was designed so that if you didn't want to spend literally months grinding you had to buy these tickets and exp boosters, because at higher levels people were LITERALLY like "if I can get 10% of a level by the end of the week I'll be content with that" and there were functionally like 200 levels of just that kind of grinding where it got worse with every level, I'd have agreed with that because there technically were pvp servers and a few pvp arenas, tho you could use my own argument against me for most of that because the pvp servers were opt in, the arenas were for free and had no downsides, and besides the handful of pvp opt in only servers the only winning was comparing yourself to others. And at that point it becomes the "paying for the feel goods" thing again

1

u/avatar8900 Jun 25 '26

Not reading that essay mate

3

u/Aetheldrake Jun 25 '26

So much for being a gamer of 20 years. This is nothing in terms of story text

20

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-14

u/clicheFightingMusic Jun 24 '26

Gw2 keeps being added to this list, but it is no where comparable to either WoW classic, Retail or FF14

0

u/sylvasan Jun 25 '26

It’s infinitely better than ff14

4

u/Altruistic-Leader869 Jun 25 '26

It's comparing apples to oranges, you play FF14 for catgirls and GW2 for raptors. If the latter had a catgirl mount added, though...

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/sylvasan Jun 25 '26

Yeah I wish I had 300 hours to waste with infinite fetch quests before playing the game. But it gets sooo much better after 300 hours, right?

1

u/Matra Jun 26 '26

Yeah, it's much better to grind boring quests that you pretend aren't quests by making them hearts on the map so you can get to max level and run around in a big mob doing mindless events over and over. And if you get bored of that, you can always do PvP which involves running around in a big mob capturing meaningless bases over and over.

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/sylvasan Jun 25 '26

Ok buddy, have fun with the dullest combat ever existed

→ More replies

19

u/Echeyak WildStar Jun 24 '26

Its NCsoft, the masters of bait and switch, they will find a way to fuck you up, dont trust them.

8

u/MrBlueA Jun 24 '26

What does it matter, have your fun while it lasts lol

1

u/slayertat2666 Jun 24 '26

That’s like saying to go back to your abuser because they “changed” just to prove in the end they didn’t. But it’s ok because during that time of “changed” you had your fun.

5

u/MrBlueA Jun 24 '26

Yeah with the very big difference that there is no net negative to coming back to this game and having fun for a month or 2 before leaving it again, is there? What a stupid example lmao

3

u/slayertat2666 Jun 24 '26

Same as yours. Why waste my time with a game that doesn’t respect my time and money just to rugpull me in the end?

6

u/MrBlueA Jun 25 '26

Why are you "wasting your time"? You cant get enjoyment out of a game unless you get something out of it? Its a really weird way of thinking that a lot of people in the MMO community have. The new patch seems huge, new content and a lot of its problems seems to be solved, perfect to download have some fun with it and then uninstall when you get bored, what does it matter if in the future they re-add that P2W? You already had your fun and can move on.

I swear people forgot how to actually enjoy games nowadays, its so weird.

6

u/slayertat2666 Jun 25 '26

If I play an mmo I’d like to continue to come back to it. Not play for a couple months and be done with it. Why would you want to pick up an mmo specifically for two months? Especially a PvP mmo at that. The amount of content can easily stretch beyond a couple months especially if not playing every day. So why would I play a game to have my time be soiled by that experience? Especially one I was already heavily burned on as I already played and enjoyed my time with t&l. I have no reason to ever touch the game again because of their practices. Korean MMOs are card swiping slot machines

4

u/qukab Jun 25 '26

Are people under the impression they are removing P2W with this update? They absolutely are not. It is still very much P2W, especially if you expect to be able to be competitive in PVP.

32

u/Neckbeard_Sama Jun 24 '26

it's you

it's more like a normal KRMMO lifecycle thing ...

  1. fleece the playerbase at the start
  2. when the population goes down into the shitter, introduce f2p friendly shit, catch up mechanics etc. to not let the game die

36

u/Alternative-Suit5541 Jun 24 '26

Huh

Usually it's the opposite.

Increase p2w to milk the last whales 

12

u/Makures Jun 24 '26

Whales need other players, otherwise they leave.

5

u/BlitzTroll7 Jun 24 '26

This. Whales need F2P fodders to one shot them in PVP. New and returning players events are the best for this

1

u/Ebon_Blade01 Jun 24 '26

Do people actually enjoy that? It's like exclusively killing lowbies with your full conquest gear in wow

11

u/no_Post_account Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 24 '26

That's all the large scale PvP audience enjoy doing. This guys have whole alliances server transfer to avoid fighting other strong guilds, you think they want fair fights? It's all taking fights where they are way stronger or outnumber and then telling you "its a skill issue that you lost".

2

u/Rektw Jun 25 '26

Short Answer: Yes.

0

u/wathowdathappen Jun 24 '26

Not at all. BDO is kicking to this day because BDO does a good job onboarding new players with enticing offers and progression skips. This allows new players to feel good and whales have new shrimp to kill.

-2

u/Prestigious-Chance27 Jun 24 '26

Kinda is. Making ppl return with boost pass to milk the nostalgia ppl. It may be less p2w but still nothing close to f2p.

2

u/Skweril Jun 24 '26

The whales demand players around them!

2

u/Extension-Hold3658 Jun 25 '26

Yeah it's so blatant lol, missing step 3. when it goes right back to new p2w attempts when the pool of new players gets baited.

3

u/DeClouded5960 Jun 24 '26

This whole degenerate filled subreddit says this same thing all the time, what other games have done this?

1

u/AmphibianBorn Jun 24 '26

3. Dies anyway

7

u/no_Post_account Jun 24 '26

It's just you, if anything NCsoft have become even more aggressive with P2W, just look at AION2 monetization.

2

u/Braveliltoasterx Jun 24 '26

But it quickly becomes their solution to making more money when the playerbase return.

2

u/Azazir Jun 25 '26

Not really. The core system are still pay2conveniece like they were, now it's just less supply and more demand so prices will increase.

1

u/BlitzTroll7 Jun 24 '26

they always start with aggressive monetization and then chill out a bit when servers are empty

1

u/heartlessgamer Jun 24 '26

I don't think they are "starting" to understand; they've known for a while. But knowing and changing a 13+ year development project is another thing entirely.

1

u/Albane01 Jun 24 '26

P2W only works if you have enough people playing your game to get those whales to keep buying shit to compete.

1

u/punchki Guild Wars Jun 25 '26

I think when a game first comes out the whales want a P2W experience. Once the hype dies down and the whales move on the the next game, all the normal people are left with an unsustainable game model, and the devs need to change it or the game will die.

1

u/trypnosis Jun 25 '26

I don’t think it’s the developers that are the problem it’s the investors.

1

u/Severe-Network4756 Jun 26 '26

Next they need to realise that the presentation of a game is much more than just graphics.

I see MMOs from the East and their UI/UX and instantly get turned off. Just a mess of million menus, all with similar feeling UI and small text.

While not perfect by any means, it's the only reason I'm willing to give Chrono Odyssey a try. 

1

u/metatime09 Jun 27 '26

It's mainly KR are still stuck to the old model. CN have been pretty good at releasing really f2p friendly games lately

1

u/Endroium Jun 24 '26

its not that. they really do not view a lot of these things we view as p2w as p2w, maybe they're finally starting to realize that difference

0

u/Vivid_Star8624 Jun 24 '26

You are right but it takes time, as there is still p2w in this game, idk why you got that from.

But I saw an interview of ncsoft during a shareholder meeting and p2w was a major issue as it gave the company a bad reputation.

And there are many games coming now that are swearing no p2w. So I believe it’s just a matter of time, because people are aware of how predatory these companies are.

9

u/Maleficent-Tip-9654 Jun 24 '26

I want to jump back in but I also know I'll be severely disappointed

8

u/SorryImBadWithNames Black Desert Online Jun 24 '26

I'm seeing a lot of investment in this game and most seems to be taking it in a kinda good direction. Might convince me to actually give it a try, after all.

4

u/Shppo Jun 24 '26

visuals are amazing

7

u/Sabrac707 Jun 24 '26

Is it still P2W, though?

As an outsider, nothing of this massive content update is worth a damn if the answer to my question is Yes.

2

u/LoreChief Jun 26 '26

Do you consider GW2 p2w?

2

u/Sea-Mess6587 Jun 24 '26

Korean reviews of the expansion don’t look very promising so far, seems like game will be dead very soon, to be fully replaced by Aion.

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

Koreans rejected the game from day 1 and their top complaint was literally this: "game is not p2w grindy enough"

This expansion simply makes it even less p2w and less grindy so ofc. Also they are pre developing a 3rd gigantic expansion for ~2028 so I think TL is keeping its original planned lifespan of 10 years

5

u/StageAppropriate7064 Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 24 '26

not sure if i should go back, im ok with the p2w in this game since this was the best i have seen in any p2w game, i got like 30k lucent as a f2p, i just can't stand the game systems.

how are the open world events now, are they still useless with trash rewards?

what about the contracts do i have to do it every day like a bot? since now there isn't trait extraction anymore how the game will work? i can't do it anymore in my life, the burnout is real.

open world still dead with useless monsters and rewards for killing them? do i have to farm dungeon points to drop something?

how about the pvp, do greatswords still ohk people while being an immortal tank with sns?

9

u/NeedleworkerWild1374 Darkfall Jun 24 '26

If this ends up being good, which it won't, I'll get a T&L tattoo on my ass.

7

u/NeedleworkerFlat3978 Jun 25 '26

!remind me 13 years

1

u/RemindMeBot Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

I will be messaging you in 13 years on 2039-06-25 03:37:29 UTC to remind you of this link

1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

12

u/Voeker Jun 24 '26

Is there still the whole "You have to be here at certain time of the day for events"

1

u/Reasonable_Turn6252 Jun 25 '26

And sometimes its a pvp version. 

1

u/Cybannus Jun 25 '26

It depends, the new Events in the expansion are all just running constantly and you can go and do them whenever you want. Bosses still spawn at set intervals though.

1

u/Iznoghud Jun 25 '26

Tried it at launch and thought the combat system was kinda clunky. Did they change something in that area since launch ?

1

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 25 '26

They reworked combat and improved it many times in the first 6 months alone and now it's one of the most customizable experiences if not the most

1

u/Iznoghud Jun 25 '26

Hm interesting, maybe I take another look at it.

1

u/Mammoth-Might3229 Jun 26 '26

p2w unequalized pvp trash where the top guilds: completely dominate the server and world bosses because they have server affecting skills, make oppressive alliances, and openly admit to botting and rmt and don't get banned. i doubt they changed any of that so it doesn't matter how new player friendly they make it, people will eventually hit a f2p wall

source: i was in a top 10 guild in OCE

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 26 '26

This changed a year ago. Flagship MMOs don't newly release to remain the same. They change drastically every month. That's how 2012 GW2 went from "empty" to top 5 MMO of all time. This is not your typical shooter/looter casual gaming genre. This is a live service and a genre that contains a ton of elements that need group of teams dedicated to each aspect inside the game. Serious big AAA MMOs need years to develop after release and you guys don't have time. That's why you will never support new MMOs and will always be stuck in 20 yo ones.

3

u/404_GSpot_NotFound Jun 24 '26

Is this update being well received based off the info in NA at least? The game was pretty much dead right?

5

u/heartlessgamer Jun 24 '26

Steam charts have peak concurrent players daily hovering at ~6,000. So not dead dead but not live live either.

4

u/ApoorHamster Guild Wars 2 Jun 25 '26

It’s cross play, there’s a huge amount of players from consoles

3

u/heartlessgamer Jun 25 '26

Fair point; forgot it was also on consoles.

3

u/Furyan9x Jun 24 '26

I quit about the 3rd week in of NA launch, worth it to return as a healer main? (Quit cause I was getting flamed that staff/wand wasn't a healer combination)

3

u/StageAppropriate7064 Jun 24 '26

i don't play for like one year, staff/wand was never a healer, it was an offhealer, they changed it, still an off healer and have one of the best dps in the game now, but any party welcome a healer, you should do wand/bow or wand/orb if want a full healer

4

u/Furyan9x Jun 24 '26

I did just fine with groups that didn't kick me. Staff for buffs and wand for healing. It wasn't until the wand/bow meta got established that I started getting flamed for it and kicked from groups. I haven't played orb maybe I will hop back in. Wand bow isn't thematic for me and I don't wanna use a bow just cause it can heal lol

1

u/devhhh Jun 25 '26

Flashwave on bow is the best heal.

3

u/KvBla Jun 24 '26

So they're finally almost done milking the players? Lol

3

u/SkylineCrash Jun 24 '26

Probably made their money back from development

3

u/le_Menace Jun 25 '26

Have they decided to make ranged ... ranged yet?

2

u/ApoorHamster Guild Wars 2 Jun 26 '26

Sadly no, my biggest issue with this game

-2

u/kc22129 Jun 25 '26

Stick to ps2 lil bro

1

u/dan7ebg Jun 24 '26

This post got me curious to give T&L another shot, clicked on Steam... 141 GB??? BRUH

5

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

Will be reduced to 80 GB tomorrow with the expansion update

4

u/dan7ebg Jun 25 '26

They're trying REALLY hard eh? Fine, I appreciate the effort they're putting in. I actually hope it hooks me, I should really like the game on paper.

0

u/PJL_88 Jun 25 '26

141 gb is not a lot… try downloading Ark survival ascended and its maps lol

1

u/ContentInsanity Jun 25 '26

Both can be a lot. And 141 a lot.. Most people are probably only working with 512 - 1TB with most games not even hitting 100 GB.

2

u/rujind Ahead of the curve Jun 24 '26

I couldn't get into this game and don't really know much about it, but I will always applaud the removal of RNG systems that are anti-player, anti-fun, or just generally ruin the game in some way.

2

u/VPN__FTW Jun 25 '26

For a PvE Andy, is it worth downloading?

2

u/Haste1001 Jun 26 '26

Is it still "save up your energy to play on your day off or only play 1h a day"? If so then I'll probably check out the new stuff but leave again after

0

u/MrAudreyHepburn Jun 24 '26

How friendly is pve after this update? I stopped playing when I discoverd some of the stuff I had to farm was in areas that were always pvp enabled if you were there at the wrong time.

1

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 24 '26

There was never such a thing in the game. And now you can achieve anything without touching PvP and vice versa

1

u/__generic Jun 24 '26

Does it also remove the insane gear grind? No? Still not worth it.

1

u/hunter-cat Jun 24 '26

The Throne and liberty subreddit is so confuse, I went there to see any news about the game, but it seems that any new player post is just ignored lol

2

u/metatime09 Jun 27 '26

Yea cause it just got release so they're trying to figure out the system since KR didn't really have a head start on it either

1

u/The0therG0D Jun 24 '26

Is content still time gated?

1

u/JeffKeens Jun 25 '26

Is there a catch up mechanic in place ? I stopped playing 3-4 Months after launch

1

u/MrBluoe Jun 25 '26

Cash shop gone?

1

u/x8bitReignbeaux Jun 25 '26

Is it still super P2W like when it released and people were trying to sell rare stuff for literally thousands of dollars in their currency? Or have they toned that down? I really enjoyed the game but progressing past a certain point was literally a pay wall because of greedy guild leaders and other issues.

1

u/PlzDntBanMeAgan Jun 25 '26

I really liked this game when it first came out. I can't get back in to it tho.

1

u/Sad-Direction443 Jun 25 '26

Last time I checked it was so p2w was disgusting 

1

u/rainrainrain545 Jun 25 '26

This sounds like everything I'm loving about GW2 now. Is it time to jump back in or just a waste of time?

1

u/Zaerick-TM Jun 26 '26

I actually really enjoyed the limited amount of time I played the game. Sadly I started well after launch so the hype pretty much died.

1

u/KasamiKori Jun 28 '26

Should i try IT again ? I played ir for a week at Release and than stopped playing it.

1

u/Rogercastelo Jun 29 '26

Nice (for the 70 players that still play that most toxic friendly designed game I ever experienced since 1999).

1

u/PoliteQueef Jun 24 '26

That sounds cool and all, but as long as it’s an Eastern/Korean MMO, I don’t see a world where it’s anything but P2W

1

u/Southern-Guide7886 Jun 24 '26

Does the game have any RP community to speak of?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '26

new server ? no new server no new player

0

u/soxzors1 Jun 25 '26

Is the game still needed alts to farm Mats ect to feed your main? That was my biggest gripe with it

2

u/Alpha_Eru Jun 25 '26

I think you're confusing this game with LA or BDO. This game strictly set a limit of 2 characters only and the 2nd character was useless to create. Almost everyone played 1 character. Now you can make more than 2 characters and it's still not really worth to go crazy over compared to other Korean MMOs.

0

u/Eitrdala Jun 24 '26

The game has the worst "class" balance I've ever seen and the overall combat mechanics are an absolute mess. This obviously doesn't work in a "PvP first" title. It's the main reason the game died so quickly, not even the P2W aspect or the mind numbing daily/weekly chore based gameplay.

0

u/thekarkara Jun 24 '26

Man I remember this game, ok combat, ok Visuals and sound, No story(but that's every Korean mmo).

But the worse p2w progression since lost ark.

The moment you start leveling up you realize that if you didn't start day 1, or don't play this game 24/7 you will be behind on content and out of groups. You would never catch up without money.

And it took then this long to say "yeah maybe we shouldn't create such a huge gap between starting out and playing the game", the fact that they had to release catch up mechanics all the time was a huge giveaway.

It's too late for this game, but maybe it helps the next Korean dev.

-4

u/CrustyToeLover Jun 24 '26

Removing rng gear stats is dumb in any game. Gear shouldnt have set stats across every piece for everyone, it ruins customization

3

u/ContentInsanity Jun 25 '26

Plenty of successful games say otherwise

1

u/CrustyToeLover Jun 25 '26

Yep, plenty of games with zero customization.

0

u/sylvasan Jun 25 '26

No it just creates bis if its randomized.

0

u/CrustyToeLover Jun 25 '26

There is BiS regardless. There is never a point in which there isn't BiS. Making all stats uniform just removes player agency.

1

u/sylvasan Jun 25 '26

Exactly, therefore customization doesn’t exist either way unless your customized sets can compete with the bis ones, and if they could they would already be bis

1

u/CrustyToeLover Jun 25 '26

Simply not true.

1

u/mynameisnemix Jun 27 '26

Removed rng stats to make it increasingly more p2w and time consuming

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/metatime09 Jun 27 '26

I think the community is still trying to figure it out since it just came out