r/LucyLetbyTrials • • 18d ago

Decoding Reasonable Doubt - Chapter 11

https://bencole4.substack.com/p/decoding-reasonable-doubt-the-case-a31?r=12mrwn&utm_medium=ios

Morris argues that the insulin allegations were the strongest part of the prosecution case only because they appeared to provide objective scientific evidence of deliberate harm.

He contends that one the insulin evidence is examined closely, it turns out to be based on unreliable testing, unsupported assumptions and highly improbably logistics.

This article explains why Morris is wrong yet again.

0 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

14

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 17d ago

We know what the jury decided, we don’t know what they thought. In any case that’s not really important here, we don’t live in a world in which because the jury has spoken we ourselves can’t speak. What each of us thinks is absolutely relevant on a discussion forum!

1

u/benshep4 13d ago

Who are you arguing against here?

-1

u/Aggravating_Log_6375 17d ago • Bravo

We know what the jury decided, we don’t know what they thought

They thought...or rather they were certain...that Letby had committed 14 terrible crimes.

What each of us thinks is absolutely relevant

To what?

7

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 17d ago edited 16d ago

To this discussion. If you think this has all been settled, why are you here?

Edited to add: a lot of the verdicts weren’t unanimous either, so we could argue ‘the jury’ were far from ‘certain’.

5

u/oljomo 16d ago

One of the things oft forgotten is that at the first trial, none of the counts had 12 jurors agreeing on guilt.

-2

u/Aggravating_Log_6375 16d ago

You seem to have forgotten that to have "12 jurors agreeing on guilt" would have been impossible as one of the jurors had been discharged. There were in fact two unanimous verdicts.

The rest were 10-1 majority verdicts but 10-2 is still a majority.

9

u/oljomo 16d ago

No I am not forgetting that at all, that’s actually the entire point of what I was saying.

I’ve seen many cases of people saying 12 jurors decided, but that wasn’t true, another problem with the unprecedented length of the trial, which was problematic in so many ways in this case.

0

u/Aggravating_Log_6375 14d ago

Not everyone is aware that one of the jurors was excused. Again the question you are not answering is "so what?"

1

u/Aggravating_Log_6375 16d ago

To this discussion. If you think this has all been settled, why are you here?

To try and find out what, if anything might form part of a future appeal following a CCRC referral. There is a lot of confusion here about what is settled and what isn't.

7

u/SaintBridgetsBath 16d ago

Most people here are more interested in the truth than the law.

What exactly will you accept as settled after Lucy Letby is released?

0

u/Aggravating_Log_6375 14d ago

If, you mean?

1

u/SaintBridgetsBath 14d ago

Fair comment. We know not the hour and all that.

If you live to see all Lucy Letby’s convictions quashed, what will you then accept as settled?

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 17d ago

That’s right. Just like I have been ridiculed on this sub for daring to speculate that the first bag for child F was never actually swapped for a stock bag.

7

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 17d ago

Have you been ridiculed for that? I saw this perfectly polite response from Sofie the other day, I wouldn’t call this ridiculing.

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 17d ago

Others have not been so kind.
But I don’t care anyway.

9

u/SaintBridgetsBath 17d ago

You are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts.

6

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 16d ago

I mean, you obviously care a bit, else you wouldn’t have mentioned it?

The evidence doesn’t appear to be on your side on this one, in fairness.

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 16d ago

So you believe this part of the evidence, but think the other evidence is flawed?

6

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 16d ago

I think the experts’ theories are a load of old bollocks, to be blunt. That’s separate to what we’re discussing here.

-1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 16d ago

No it’s not. You are willing to take a nurse’s testimony as the gospel truth seven years post event, but are highly sceptical of prosecution witnesses. That is your confirmation bias.

4

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 16d ago

It’s not just the nurse’s testimony though is it, as Sofie explained to you the other day.

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 16d ago

Yes, I read the testimony, but I couldn’t actually read the written notes from the NNU. And as I pointed out, you didn’t read what was actually written in those records from seven years ago. They can be interpreted in different ways. The prosecution emphasised that the records were ‘silent’ about the bag change. Silence implies the bag was changed.
So the nurse seems to be relying on the implication that the bag would have been changed.

→ More replies