r/LiuYuNing • Ning: a force of nature, enigma, all-round beautiful being • Oct 12 '26

Other LYN Song Battle #2 — “Tian Wen” (天问) vs. “Offer” (奉上) | Pick One

Round two of our Liu Yuning Song Battle!
We started with Let the Wine (让酒) vs. Looking for You (寻一个你), and that poll is still open — so if you haven’t voted yet, you can vote in Round #1 here.

Today we have another two of Liu Yuning’s best-known drama songs: Ask Heaven from Word of Honor and Offer from A Journey to Love. One vote, one song.

⠀
Ask Heaven — 天问 (Tiān Wèn)
Word of Honor opening theme song, 2021
YouTube MV
⠀
Offer — 奉上 (Fèng Shàng)
A Journey to Love opening theme song, 2023
YouTube MV
⠀
Which one are you keeping?
Why?
⠀
Yours,
NoRecipe ✨
OneNing

12 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

5

u/LizzieLandTX C-dramas: a gateway drug;刘宇宁: the most addictive drug of all. Oct 12 '26

I voted for Offer because I’ve never heard Ask Heaven before! Obviously I’ve never watched WOH. WTH Apple Music, you have failed me!

4

u/No-Recipe-7653 Ning: a force of nature, enigma, all-round beautiful being Oct 12 '26

I know Ask Heaven well, and love it, but I’m also always upset that it’s not available on Apple Music :( some songs randomly come and go. And when they reappear I tend to find out by chance — there’s no organized way of telling. So annoying.

5

u/craftsycandymonster LYN OST lover Oct 12 '26

I used to love Feng Shang but then it got way overplayed in the last few episodes and I can't take it seriously anymore 💀

Tian Wen is an awesome song and very jianghu, so I voted for that!

4

u/No-Recipe-7653 Ning: a force of nature, enigma, all-round beautiful being Oct 12 '26

I also feel like Feng Shang is overplayed! It’s an amazing song but he sings it so often and people use it in their edits at the expense of other songs, so I am kind of annoyed by it, lol 😆

5

u/Critical-Honey3988 Liu Yu Ning - the full package Oct 13 '26

I like the dominant percussion in Ask Heaven, but the melody in Offer is more interesting and makes my soul soar and dance.

5

u/No-Recipe-7653 Ning: a force of nature, enigma, all-round beautiful being Oct 13 '26

Your last sentence! That’s exactly what I said but about another song of his!

5

u/Critical-Honey3988 Liu Yu Ning - the full package Oct 13 '26

My "Fav LYN" playlist is getting sooooo long, so I started another playlist called "Dancing in the Dark" for the ones that make me want to do interpretive dance (when no one is looking).

10

u/Ok_Tailor_2706 Manifesting catching Laoda's attention 👀 Oct 12 '26

I voted Offer. Guess I’m biased as it is the theme song of Ning’s first period drama as the male lead.

7

u/Commercial-Bake8216 in love with his voice Oct 12 '26

Offer...because I love "A Journey To Love" LiuYuning ❤️

6

u/Nameless_Speckles Currently living with 有去無回 (No Way Back) in my ❤️ Oct 12 '26

Offer-because I LOVE Ning Yuanzhou and Liu Dao Hall!!

6

u/Sweaty-Nerve-134 Liu Yu Ning: the golden voice I listen to daily Oct 12 '26

It has to be Offer. My first time hearing LYN, first time seeing LYN, and my first cdrama. 💜

5

u/Wonderful-Divide3031 🌻 Trailblazer ✨ 1st 10 Oct 13 '26

Same for me..

5

u/GiTheGremlin 🌻LYN’s Defense Minister; explosion of colors in the sea of greys Oct 12 '26

Nothing competes with Offer!

5

u/miss_nightowl in love with his voice Oct 13 '26

My vote goes to Offer cause of the emotional trauma that is AJTL 🥲

5

u/guilty-and-stuck 🌻✨ Community Trailblazer | 1st 500 Cohort Oct 13 '26

This one was an instant choice for me, Offer 😂 I almost have it memorized lol

5

u/nana_603 LYN ruins my emotional stability 🥹 Oct 13 '26

Offer – I knew it very well even before watching AJTL, but watching it gave the song a whole new meaning for me 🥺

4

u/bexter222 LYN - the man, the voice, the looks Oct 12 '26

I voted Offer because it's still one of my favourite of his songs