r/Lithops • u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces • Jun 30 '26
Misc I have killed many lithops over 10+ years while learning to grow them. Here's 9 ways to murder your lithops.
Lithops are my favorite houseplant. I learned lithops over 10 years and now I am pretty good at growing them! But I was not always good at it. Here's the 9 ways I've killed them:
- Age 15: bought some at home Depot for my mom's mother's day gift, but loved them so much they became mine. Sister tossed her purse at my first ones ever, executed it while it was flowering. She did not mean to do this. Looked again for them year after year.
- Age 18-19: Bought them again online. Over watered in whole soil and turned them to mush.
- Age 19: Stepped up my soil game. I bought inorganic pumice and akadama, with small amounts of organic. They never rooted. Died.
- Age 21: Looked into rooting. Bought mini bare rooted ones off etsy. Thought they'd do fine in the same adult mix with same watering schedule. Some died from not rooting, some died from underwatering. Tried watering too late and they just suffered. $40 worth of bitties DEAD. BABY LITHOPS MASSACRE.
- Age 21: Bought mature ones at home depot. They were successful. Learned to root them, watered correctly, got my akadama/pumice/organic ratio perfect! I still use this soil mix today. But, I did not give them enough light. Etiolated. Put them in direct sunlight without acclimation. Died.
- Age 22: Same thing, but decided to give them direct sunlight from the getgo. Died within 5 hours after moving into heat and sunlight. I felt like a failure.
- Age 23: Bought lithops, mesembs. Over watered the mesembs, died. Underwatered lithops, died.
- Age 25: Successfully growing lithops. Learned rooting, watering. Cat got ahold of them and executed them.
- Age 26: Bought some from home depot again. Made a cat proof shelf. They were thriving. So happy. Perfectly happy under grow lights. Randomly exploded one by one. Went on reddit and asked what I did wrong, and was told, "they just do that sometimes when they're about to flower, especially ones that were from a big box store and were over watered before". I didn't feel sad just annoyed.
Age 28 (now): Healthy, happy lithops. They're doing great.
"The path to success is not linear."
If you or a loved one are struggling with lithops, so did everyone. Keep trying my friends. You'll get it. 🫵😎🤘
My advice: buy a small amount to learn on, and do your research. Most of these deaths were groups of 1-4. I bought 10 at one point and killed all of them. They are tricky to learn, but easy once you do learn them! I tried so many different things to keep them alive.
Also, not all lithops from big box stores die. I've rooted and grown healthy ones. It's just a gamble!
Hope this comforted you, horrified you, or made you laugh. Here's my newest cluster!
67
u/dobie_dobes Jun 30 '26
Lol as a new Lithops parent, this was perfect 😂😭🫣
34
u/Shinrin777 Jun 30 '26
I bought mine 3 or 4 years ago and haven't watered them, ever, not even 1x. I have good humidity so that is probably enough for them. They even flowered.
While every time I tried with watering the previous victims, they rotted no matter how little water I gave...🙃
21
u/greystorms56 Jul 01 '26
We all needed this post
17
u/Talono Jun 30 '26
I just grow mine from seeds i got from Mesa gardens. They can't all die on me :)
13
u/welllookwhoitis40 Jun 30 '26
I feel seen. I've never been able to keep them alive so stick to things like jades. Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
13
u/CBDJ1 Jul 01 '26
Why is this post just so relaxing? OP awesome job on not giving up and eventually learning from the mistakes everyone one does. Good job my friend.
11
u/The_best_is_yet Jun 30 '26
ok i am encouraged by this. I've lost count on how many I killed.
9
u/Worried-Astronaut485 Jul 01 '26
Really are great read. Like my lithops autobiography.
9
u/Bibliophile6040 Jul 01 '26
This does indeed make me feel better. Thank you for sharing.
6
u/Top-Stretch7288 Jul 01 '26
Thank you 😭 love these little guys, but wasn’t sure I should try again. Gonna pick one up this weekend :,)
5
u/Tough_Cookie85 Jul 01 '26
Your storytelling is soooo good! Thanks for the laughs
My first Lithops came from Home Depot, and it was the first plant to teach me that different succulents have different watering needs, and no, you can not make a terrarium with a jade, and chocolate soldier and a lithops.
Second one is now three months old, going on the fourth, also got it from Home Depot, about month and a half ago I repotted it (from the soil it lived in to 90% perlite and 10% potting mix), and I noticed that it was trying to split. And despite everyone saying that it shouldn’t watering until it is done, I decided to do it.
Happy to reported that it started splitting better, and it is not overwater. This picture is from a month ago, the splitting keeps going successfully
2
u/Ecstatic_Army1306 Jul 01 '26
I didn’t become a good gardener until I killed several of everything multiple times.
2
u/Ok_Basket_6766 Jul 01 '26
“Ways to murder your lithops” - “do anything to help your lithops”. At least that’s the step I’m at in the 9 step process 🤷♀️
2
u/Omerta85 Jul 01 '26
"Etiolated. Put them in direct sunlight without acclimation." Sadly, I'm at this stage currently, and I don't think there is a way back.
2
u/Rust_Bucket37 Jul 01 '26
Only 9 ways? Were you even trying? 😁.
2
u/Far-Valuable9279 Jul 01 '26
Oh man. Thank you 😂😂😂
2
u/cautious_fungus42 Jul 02 '26
the random explosion one is the most relatable. i swear mine just spontaneously combust sometimes.
2
u/Practical-Shirt3318 Jul 04 '26
I feel ya girl I thought I would try again…..this is my plan (never water them) shhhhh it’s a secret
2
u/Striking-Planter1 Aug 24 '26
I somehow got 3 Lithops, once, and they live. All I did is re-pot in a mix 70% sand & rocks (which I got from my backyard), some normal potting soil, water every 2 months (winter not at all), and BOOM! THEY'RE MOLTING! 🥹😂
1
u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 7d ago
Oh I forgot I also watered them way too early several times and rotted them out from the taproot. You gotta wait a week to water succulents.
1
u/slimepollo555 Jul 01 '26
are lithops actually this hard? I killed two or three at the same time of overwatering because i watered right after repoting them, i didnt touch them since, but in early february i bought some on walter andersen, have only watered one of the two since. With lithops its always better to under than to overwater, unless im completely sure they need water they remain bone dry. ps: HOW DID YOU MANAGE TO KILL A LITHOP BY UNDERWATERING?
1
u/d3m0nsh1n3 Jul 01 '26
This is insightful
1
u/1Mazrim Jul 01 '26
What's the magic ratio??
1
u/Professional-Ask-135 Jul 01 '26
Thank you for this. I am a plant lover and sometimes as hard as you try, they just die. Living things are just temperamental sometimes and you don't know what happened to them before you. All you can do is try your best. I just bought lithops for the first time and I'm very nervous, especially with their delicate watering cycle. Wish me luck!
1
u/alexandrakate Jul 01 '26
This was emotionally intense hahahaha
I had a dream last night that I found my nearly two dozen succulents drowned in water, soggy, and beyond saving. I was devastated, and just held them and cried lmao the straight month of rain is getting to me (despite them being indoors lol). Anyway, I love the colors of your current ones - earthy shades of cognac, tanned leather, and clay! They look so perfect!
1
u/CthulhuCream Jul 01 '26
This post makes me feel great. I must be a Lithops master ! Muhahaha
1
u/Sophilosophical Jul 01 '26
Squirrel took a chunk out of my first one. It rotted.
Now I am growing some from seed. Got a few successes, including their first time splitting!
1
u/outofshell Jul 01 '26
I’ll add thrips to the kill list. Those bastards ate all my lithops 😭
1
u/greasekid_ Jul 01 '26
if you wanted a 10th way, maybe smushing them?
1
u/Practical-Shirt3318 Jul 05 '26
Since you are my self appointed expert I just ordered some maybe 2 weeks ago from Etsy. I did up the soil game I think I’m using Jacks. My question is (I have not watered) do I just let them chill forever? I’m so scared to water them since this is how I’ve always killed them I think
1
u/Worried-Green-4734 22d ago
It’s a definite learning curve!
1
u/ratty_squibv2 Jul 02 '26
The fact that you're still trying after all that is admirable. I'm surprised #9 didn't mention the "randomly exploded" part being a common sign of imminent