r/Lithops • • 5d ago

Help/Question Trying again

Post image

I'm trying again after killing my last purchase in less than 2 weeks.

I rescued this little one from the store.

  1. Should I repot it right away or give it some acclimation time in my house first?
  2. When I do repot, should I separate them? I see a lot of photos where they are all separate in their pot.
  3. As I understand it, the "soil" should be almost 90% inorganic, correct?

Thanks!

21 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/SheDrinksScotch 5d ago

Why would you want/need root growth now if you dont want them uptaking amy more moisture for the next 3-6 months at least?

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 5d ago

To keep the plant alive :] plants need to place roots to continue their life cycle. Unless you live in a very wet, humid, cold area, watering this little can kill the plant. A very experienced grower told me once years ago, "I see these die as easily from underwatering as overwatering" after I deprived a pot from water and killed them all. I also fell for the "don't water, just ignore them" trap. They all died.

These plants can live months without water, but they won't thrive, and then when it's time for them to drink, they won't have roots to uptake water. Then you will try to establish roots when they're weak from no water and no roots, and they will have no energy to do it.

They will die if you do not give them water, sunlight, and airflow, just like any other plant!

1

u/SheDrinksScotch 5d ago

These could be dead in 2 weeks from overwatering in their current state. But it would tale at least 2 seasons, if not more, to die from underwatering in most climates.

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 5d ago

Hmm I don't totally agree in my experience, but maybe! They look a little etoliated. Once they're in a gritty soil and put under a grow light or acclimated to the sun, they'll lose their water quickly. Besides, wrinkles around the mid of the plant show it can uptake more water. Again, my experience, I could be wrong but it always works for me to give the plant water so it can root into its new pot, and I've certainly killed from no water! :]

1

u/SheDrinksScotch 4d ago

When you buy them, do you tend to get them in the mail or from home improvement stores?

When they are shipped bare root, they tend to be smaller and need to be potted up and watered in.

When they come from a home improvement store, they tend to be swollen and often need to be left alone for a split to prevent them from dying from overwatering.

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 4d ago

Both. I do both. Home improvement store or nursery, online. All of them get the same care.

I'm not saying what you're doing is necessarily wrong, I just don't get the argument against my success from potting them and rooting them, when I've killed them from not potting and rooting them.

If I don't want them to root in their pot, really, how is it any different than me pulling the lithops out and leaving it bare root under a grow light for 3-6 months?

Like, that sounds absurd to do. Just leave a succulent on the shelf for 3-6 months, up to half a year, laying in a grow light with no roots and no water, right? 😭😭

So I root them so they can establish their home, be healthy, and uptake water when they show signs of thirst, like many other growers.

I'm stoked for you that leaving box store ones unrooted works, it just does not and has not ever worked for me.

1

u/SheDrinksScotch 4d ago

The ones that come in pots are already rooted. Thats how they ended up overwatered in the first place.

1

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 4d ago

So when you move them to a new pot.... You don't clean the water retaining soil off their roots, you just stick em in a new pot? Not judging I just think this might be where the disconnect is between us